">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
FACT CHECK: GOP joins murky math on stimulus jobs
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Search
Search:
FACT CHECK: GOP joins murky math on stimulus jobs
By MATT APUZZO,Associated Press Writer AP - Saturday, July 11
WASHINGTON - House Republicans on Friday declared the nation's economic stimulus efforts a "dismal failure." But the convoluted math they used to disparage the recovery is as murky and meaningless as the White House formula championing the stimulus.
ADVERTISEMENT
Led by the senior Republican on the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, Rep. John Mica, R-Fla., committee members argued simultaneously that the government was spending too much money and not spending it fast enough.
They argued that projects are mired in red tape, that the slow pace of transportation spending is to blame for rising unemployment, and that the stimulus was not targeted to areas that needed jobs the most.
A look at their claims:
___
MICA SAID: Transportation money is slow to get out because of "red tape" slowing things down.
THE FACTS: Republicans are correct that only a small percentage of the $48 billion in transportation money has been spent. But red tape is a red herring. In fact, stimulus projects have to be ready to begin quickly. Projects that have yet to clear permitting, environmental review or other bureaucratic hurdles won't get funded because they won't meet the law's deadlines.
Rep. John Duncan, R-Tenn., said "doing away with all the environmental restrictions" would speed up stimulus spending. That mischaracterizes both the stimulus and the environmental review process.
Since 1970, federally funded projects have required reviews to ensure they don't harm the environment, public health or safety. It's not just about saving endangered species. Environmental restrictions prohibit developers from building highways in areas that would pollute drinking water or send water flooding into nearby basements.
Eliminating those restrictions would eliminate the public's right to review and object to projects before they're built.
Even if those requirements were waived for stimulus projects, however, it likely would not matter. A May report by the White House Council on Environmental Quality found that no stimulus projects have been substantially slowed by environmental reviews.
Mica is correct that the stimulus added some new bureaucratic requirements, but those are primarily oversight rules that require states to report where the money is going and how many jobs are being created.
The fact is, Washington is releasing transportation money at an unprecedented clip. Why haven't states spent it already? First, contractors have to bid on the project, to ensure politicians aren't steering money to their cronies. Also states don't typically spend all their money until a project is completed, even though people are already working.
Mica pointed to the collapsed Interstate 35 bridge in Minnesota, which was replaced in less than a year, as evidence that Congress can speed up transportation projects when it wants to. But that's a mischaracterization. Minnesota received no federal environmental waivers. Minnesota kept the new bridge the same as the old bridge, so new environmental effects were deemed to be minimal.
The real reason the bridge went up quickly? Contractors worked around the clock and through the coldest stretch of winter to finish the $234 million job, spurred on by a $25 million bonus for finishing early.
___
REP. MARIO DIAZ-BALART, R-FLA., SAID: "There is a new definition for dismal failure: Stimulus. This stimulus."
THE FACTS: The argument is based on the idea that unemployment keeps going up despite the transportation spending. That's a non-sequitur. The $48 billion in transportation money represents just 6 percent of the total stimulus. A far greater share of stimulus money, $288 billion, was spent on tax cuts, and conservatives would never accept the argument that rising unemployment proves that tax cuts don't work.
The fact is, Republicans don't need to create mathematical head-scratchers to criticize the stimulus. Since President Barack Obama signed the stimulus into effect in February, the nation has lost more than 2 million jobs and unemployment has climbed ever higher. The administration's claims that the law has created or saved 150,000 jobs is based on a misused formula and the number cannot be verified.
Whether it's today or in 2012, voters can judge the Obama administration on real job numbers, not rosy White House estimates or gloomy Republican numbers.
___
REP. CANDICE MILLER, R-MICH., SAID: Transportation money is not going to areas that need it most because spending was based on an antiquated formula.
THE FACTS: She is correct. Because states have to spend the money quickly, they are steering money to projects that are ready to go. Often that means projects in wealthier areas that can afford planning. So, counties with high unemployment are not favored when money is spent.
Changing the formula to favor needy communities would have solved this, but it would not have been easy and would have slowed down the process even more.
___
Associated Press writers Dina Cappiello in Washington and Martiga Lohn in St. Paul, Minn., contributed to this report.
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: World
Honduras rivals agree more talks to pursue solutionReuters - Saturday, July 11
Obama acclaimed on landmark African visitAFP - 2 hours 37 minutes ago
Protests as Honduras crisis talks end with no dealAFP - Saturday, July 11
Africa aid must be matched by good governance - ObamaReuters - 2 hours 51 minutes ago
British PM's Afghanistan warning as death toll surpasses IraqAFP - Saturday, July 11
Most Popular – World
Viewed
Miniskirts, cleavage upset male SKoreans: survey
Pushy French are world's worst tourists: study
Jackson 'best father' ever, daughter tells the world
Jackson mother relieved of estate on funeral eve
German mother gives birth to identical triplets
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Saturday, 11 July 2009 Taliban losing, says Britain as troop toll rises
British PM's Afghanistan warning as death toll surpasses Iraq
Six security personnel killed in Pakistan: officials
Israel must keep much of Golan
West Bank should not be 'Judenrein': Israel PM
Worst violence since US pullback hits Iraq
Bombs kill 50 in Iraq as violence flares
Hundreds protest in Iran, defying crackdown vow
Bomb attacks kill 52 in Iraq
Afghan truck bomb kills 25: police
France ends search for Brazil flight box signals
China raises Xinjiang death toll to 184
| International
|
US-TECH Summary
Reborn GM vows to rev up as new company
Honduras rivals agree more talks to pursue solution
| International
|
Medvedev backs away from joint WTO bid
North Korea army behind South web attack: report
Eight British troops killed in Afghanistan
| International
|
Father jailed in Germany for pimping daughter
Shrinking US trade gap seen as positive for economy
U.S. drone strike kills 5 militants in Pakistan
| International
|
Low-cost online computer gaming surges in US
Spaniard gored to death in Pamplona bull run
Canada examines cancer risks of diabetes drug
Rosetta Stone sues Google over trademark
Pushy French are world's worst tourists: study
Australia presses China on detained Rio exec
| International
|
Pamplona bull gores man to death
Hundreds hurt, homes destroyed in China quake: reports
Publishers deny British tabloid celebrity phone-hacking claims
North Korea army behind South web attack: report
| International
|
Russia operator denies plan to rename Lenin station
Miner Anglo American chooses new chairman: reports
Power.com countersues Facebook in user data dispute
Obama uses G8 debut to issue warning to Iran
| International
|
China claims to have proof against Rio Tinto staff
French paper goes global, risks ridicule with translation
German exports perk up in May on month: statistics
Medvedev threatens U.S. over missile shield
| International
|
Google CEO to discuss his role on Apple's board
Hundreds injured in south China quake
| International
|
Iraq denies U.S. policy shift brought Iranians' release
| International
|
German chipmaker Infineon unveils major capital increase
US fund Apollo to invest in Germany's Infineon: report
Fuel rods to be checked at German nuclear plant
Publishers deny British tabloid celebrity phone-hacking claims
Chavez contacted US over Honduras: official
British police probe tabloid phone-hacking claims
Obama arrives in Ghana to red carpet welcome
Obama arrives in Ghana for maiden trip to sub-Saharan Africa
LA wants reports on Jackson memorial cost, revenue
Big media seek 21st century business models
| Technology
|
SC gov hangs on to office, 2 weeks after scandal
Text of Obama's news conference on Friday
North Korea army behind South web attack: report
| Technology
|
Obesity a risk factor in swine flu?
China raises Xinjiang death toll to 184
Power.com countersues Facebook over user data
| Technology
|
GM exits bankruptcy; CEO vows better performance
Australia concerned over Rio executive detention
Obama Gets Warm Welcome In Ghana
Google CEO to discuss his role on Apple's board
| Technology
|
Weather To Get Final Vote On Saturday Shuttle Launch
Idaho board game lets players live 'Truckin' life
North Korea army seen behind South web attack
India gay sex ruling
Anti-Rejection Drug May Extend Human Life
England cricket bowlers flayed by Aussie media
Camel Climbs Mount Washington
AOL reviewing assets, but will likely keep Bebo
| Technology
|
US lawmakers rally behind Uighur leader
Australian shot dead at US mine in Indonesia: police
Bloggers test boundaries in Saudi Arabia
| Technology
|
4-Month-Old Found Dead At Day Care Center Of Apparent Heart Trouble
Three Sought In Murders Of Couple With 12 Adopted Children
News Corp won't buy Twitter, won't sell MySpace
| Technology
|
Continental Airlines Gets A Nod From DOT To Join Star Alliance
Evans has a go at Tour de France
Ericsson to manage Sprint network in $4.5-$5billion deal
| Technology
|
Australian shot dead near Freeport Papua mine
GM Emerges From Bankruptcy As Slimmer, Faster Firm
Recalls Continue of Milk Products Linked To Salmonella
Update: G8 Commits $20 Billion To Food Security; Obama Says Economic Recovery Still Underway
Clinton hopes NKorea grants amnesty to US reporters
Paris Hilton insists she plugged sorority movie
Zooey Deschanel destined for "Highness"
Turkmenistan prepared to supply Nabucco
"Old Christine" is new to Lifetime
Turkmenstan prepared to supply Nabucco
India's Infosys Q1 profit up 17.2 pct, beats forecasts
Malkovich to take serial killer opera around Europe
Clooney to shoot film in Italian earthquake city
Hollywood sends 3D home -- in videogames
Still no EU green light for SKorea trade deal: diplomats
China property prices post first on-year rise in six months
Jesse James Hollywood convicted of murder, kidnap
Pakistan's 2008/09 remittances at record $7.8 bln
Fate of fans' flowers, cards for Jackson undecided
India's Infosys says quarterly profit up 1.6 pct
Ryan Reynolds cast as Green Lantern
| Entertainment
|
China exports down 21.4% year on year in June
Court clears Indonesian official in activist death
Jackson's dad suspects foul play in death
| Entertainment
|
Wary Christmas looms for music retailers
Taiwan's Cathay Fin posts weak Q2 net profit
3 'Idol' alumni target holiday season for debuts
| Entertainment
|
Megawati rejects Indonesian presidential poll
Ryan Reynolds cast as "Green Lantern"
Taiwan dollar weakens on fund outflows, insurers
Austrians say outrageous Bruno ist pretty funny
| Entertainment
|
Harry Potter stars felt pressure to ace kiss
| Entertainment
|
CORRECTION: Jeremy Renner looks for success, finds "Hurt Locker"
Re-election raises hope of bold Indonesian govt
China to build own Neverland as Michael Jackson tribute
| Entertainment
|
Obama artist admits to 3 Boston vandalism charges
Wary Christmas looms for music retailers
| Entertainment
|
McCartney returns to Ed Sullivan Theater
Indonesia poised for growth after Yudhoyono 'landslide'
Ryan Seacrest nears new megadeal
| Entertainment
|
Son of late Grammy nominee to take over NYC church
Early results show Indonesian president winning
Jeremy Renner looks for success, finds Hurt Locker
| Entertainment
|
British tabloid denies it hacked celebrities
Bono says Ghana rebranding Africa
| Entertainment
|
Jason Priestley and wife welcome a baby boy in LA
Carrey to be a grandfather; his daughter expecting
Dozens line up for Jackson Ind. hometown memorial
Two Malaysian men charged with human trafficking: report
NKorea's parliamentary head leaves for Egypt
U.S. drone strike kills 5 militants in Pakistan
Pakistani c.bank sells 16.5 bln rupees of T-bills
Vietnam could sack doctors revealing foetal sex: media
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
3 'Idol' alumni target holiday season for debuts
Carrie Underwood to entertain Fort Campbell troops
Paris Hilton insists she plugged sorority movie
Obama: Africa aid must be matched by good governance
| International
|
London's Big Ben clocks up 150 years
Iran plays down G8 concern at protests, nuke standoff
Canada warns pregnant women about swine flu risks
Iran prepares package to offer West
CORRECTED
Pakistan to put Mumbai attack suspects on trial
| International
|
Iran prepares package to offer West: minister
| International
|
Car bomb in northern Iraq's Mosul kills 4
| International
|
Zimbabwe's Mugabe criticizes West for conditional aid
| International
|
Somali troops clash with insurgents, 20 killed
| International
|
Greying Asia faces pensions time bomb: ADB study
Australia presses China on Rio Tinto arrest
China scales back homeless number after quake
Weather worries cloud Endeavour launch attempt
McDonald warns Celtic of Roar's 'Old Firm'
SKorea spy agency 'hunts NKorean' for cyber attack
US govt review questions effectiveness of wiretaps
Indonesia find 15 Afghan migrants: police
Analysis: Obama suggests sanctions for Iran
FACT CHECK: GOP joins murky math on stimulus jobs
Obama admin: No grounds to probe Afghan war crimes
GM Considering eBay Partnership To Sell Vehicles
Couple in astronaut assault case plan to marry
WA teen who mistook hiker for bear gets 30 days
One week delay in Jackson guardianship case
Jackson's hometown holds memorial for pop icon
Island Records stars pay tribute at Montreux Jazz Festival
| Entertainment
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights