Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Arab Israeli's Auschwitz visit raises criticism
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Arab Israeli's Auschwitz visit raises criticism
By DIAA HADID,Associated Press Writer -
Wednesday, January 27
Send
IM Story
Print
JERUSALEM – An Israeli Arab lawmaker's plan to attend a Holocaust memorial ceremony at Auschwitz on Wednesday has drawn fierce criticism from both Arabs and some Jews, underscoring the deep divisions between the two sides over the legacy of the Nazi genocide.
The uproar of Mohammed Barakeh's visit highlights the deep reluctance among many Arabs to acknowledge the Holocaust for fear of diminishing their own narrative of suffering at Israel's hands.
Barakeh has come under criticism from Israeli Arabs who say his visit is inappropriate at a time of heightened Israeli-Palestinian tensions _ particularly amid Israel's blockade of the Gaza Strip.
The lawmaker's visit is a rare Arab commemoration of the Holocaust, a step Israel has long encouraged. But Barakeh also says he intends to condemn Israel's policies toward Palestinians during the visit to Poland, striking a profoundly sensitive chord. Many Jews say any attempt to equate the Palestinians' plight to the genocide is offensive.
Barakeh is a member of an Israeli delegation, led by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, attending a ceremony Wednesday marking the 65th anniversary of the liberation of the Auschwitz and Birkenau camps in Nazi-occupied Poland. More than 1 million of the 6 million Jews killed by the Nazis and their collaborators during World War II died at the two camps.
Barakeh frequently calls on his Arab brethren to recognize the Holocaust and understand its importance to Jews. Still, he is also deeply critical of Israel.
"The Jews, who are the victims of the Nazis, are now practicing oppression against the Palestinians," Barakeh told The Associated Press. "I want to tell them: You must learn the real lesson, you must fight oppression and repression in all places and times."
Israel's Arabs minority has an often tense relationship with the Jewish majority. Arabs make up about one-fifth of Israel's 7 million citizens, and there are 13 Arab legislators in the 120-seat parliament.
Despite holding citizenship, Israeli Arabs face widespread discrimination and identify strongly with their Palestinian brethren in the neighboring West Bank and Gaza Strip.
The conflict over the Holocaust dates back to the founding of Israel in 1948.
About 200,000 Holocaust survivors live in Israel among hundreds of thousands of their children and grandchildren. Israel provided a new home for the survivors and a measure of insurance that no future attempt to wipe out the Jewish people would succeed.
But in the war surrounding Israel's creation, about 700,000 Palestinians fled or were driven from their homes, leading to a widespread feeling that they were forced to pay the price of the Nazis' persecution of the Jews in Europe.
That perception makes many Arabs in Israel and the territories hesitate to acknowledge the genocide, fearing it gives justification for their own suffering.
Palestinian officials in the West Bank shut down a children's orchestra and banished its conductor in March after they performed for elderly Holocaust survivors. In August, Palestinian officials in Gaza angrily reacted against U.N. officials who suggested including information about the Holocaust at their schools.
Views toward the Holocaust among Palestinians _ and around the Arab world _ range from outright denial to diminishing the full extent of the genocide.
Two right-wing Israeli Jewish parliamentarians have demanded Barakeh withdraw from the trip.
"I am sure he will use this visit to attack Israel," said legislator Dany Danon. "The fact that he is making (an) analogy between the Jewish Holocaust and the Palestinians is outrageous."
Amnon Beeri-Sulitzeanu _ co-director of the Abraham Fund, a Jewish-Arab organization that tries to promote coexistence _ acknowledges the sensitivities over drawing parallels.
But, he says he hopes the visit will "encourage Jewish leaders in Israel ... to at least understand and learn more about Palestinian history. Obviously there is no comparison or parallel, but I believe it's an important step to trust building between Jews and Arabs in Israel."
Few, if any, prominent Arabs from Mideast nations have made publicized visits to Auschwitz _ but Israel's Arab community is an exception. Two other Arab-Israeli lawmakers previously visited the camp in an effort to build bridges, as did a group of about 100 Arab-Israeli writers and clerics in 2003.
Barakeh is the most prominent public figure yet to do so. He comes from a family forced to flee their village during the 1948 Mideast war, and his parliament speeches often sharply criticize Israel's treatment of the Palestinians. He belongs to Hadash, Israel's communist party, which traditionally gathers both Arab and Jewish voters.
For the past two weeks, Barakeh's visit has prompted unusually heated debate in the Arab-Israeli press.
His detractors argue that Israel's blockade of the Gaza Strip, which is meant to punish Gaza's Hamas rulers but has created severe hardships for its 1.5 million residents, make his visit inappropriate.
"There's a contradiction in morality between continuing the siege on Gaza and this visit. The Knesset members going to Auschwitz are the ones who demand this siege continue," said Abdel-Hakim Mufid of the radical Northern Islamic Movement.
Prominent Arab writer Zuhair Andraous called it "a slap in the face."
Adding to anger is that members of Netanyahu's coalition have tried _ so far unsuccessfully _ to criminalize commemorations of the "nakba" that Arabs hold every year to mourn the consequences of their defeat in 1948 war.
"We cannot participate in an Israeli formal delegation that includes right-wing legislators who are trying pass laws preventing us from commemorating our own catastrophe," Andraous said.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
79-year-old jewel thief facing new charge in CA AP - 1 hour 55 minutes ago
US redefines Yemen strategy AP - 1 hour 56 minutes ago
IRS requires firms to report iffy tax breaks AP - 1 hour 59 minutes ago
Classmates march in support of beaten Pa. student AP - Wednesday, January 27
Scientist: Alien life could already be on Earth AP - 2 hours 5 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
GM announces deal to sell Saab to Spyker
IMF sees stronger but still fragile global recovery
UN panel defends climate change evidence
British economy crawls free of record recession
Obama seeks freeze on discretionary spending
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
New York woman falls, rips Picasso painting
Haitian police shoot scavengers indiscriminately
Ericsson cuts 1,500 more jobs, profit plunges
US existing-home sales dive in December
British economy crawls free of record recession
More Most Viewed »
Woman who saved Anne Frank's diary dead at 100
Scientists praise Obama as Doomsday clock reset
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Wednesday, 27 January 2010 Germany boosts Afghan efforts ahead of conference
French report calls for burqa ban
Obama to take questions via YouTube, answer them online
IMF sees stronger but still fragile global recovery
Israel says Turkish leader fueling anti-Semitism
Siemens denies giving Iran censorship technology
Search for victims, answers in Lebanon plane crash
UN panel defends climate change evidence
Minister: Israel rejects UN Gaza war probe call
Arab Israeli's Auschwitz visit raises criticism
US-TECH Summary
U.S. urges Kurds to settle disputes with Baghdad
|
EBay to stop, change listing fees for some sellers
Damaged Picasso Painting To Be Repaired
Nokia drops music package from flagship X6 model
Shifting Ground Forces Evacuation Of San Antonio Homes
U.S. concerned about arms flowing to South Sudan
|
China's Baidu wins court case against music groups
Facebook Page Prompts School Officials To Suspend Student, Issue Detention To Others
Internet companies voice alarm over Italian law
Kremlin urges Caucasus leaders to back new envoy
|
Suicide bomb injures nine near US base in Kabul
U.N. arms forum seen stuck on bomb-making material
|
Sarkozy beats Star Wars in bid to reassure France
|
Nokia drops music package from flagship X6 model
Clinton: Critics of US Haiti relief misguided
IRS requires firms to report iffy tax breaks
NASA ends effort to free rover from Martian sand
PROMISES, PROMISES: Skepticism on Obama tax credit
EBay to stop, change listing fees for some sellers
|
Judge OKs Alaska diocese plan for abuse victims
China issues warning over US arms sales to Taiwan
Correction: Obit-Stovitz story
Hong Kong lawmakers seek 'referendum' on democracy
NYC mayor denies White House ambitions for 2012
Sri Lanka war victors vie in presidential poll
Lawyer seeks FBI probe in Pa. arts student beating
Britain the best? Chinese ambassador not so sure
FCC seeks info on early mobile termination fees
|
Feds end probe of W.Va. congressman; no charges
Internet companies voice alarm over Italian law
|
Troops to 'help' Thai police face protesters
N.Korea declares 'no sail' zone: Seoul
Abortion doc case focuses on slaying, not debate
Nokia drops music package from flagship X6 model
|
Corruption watchdog slams Indonesian president
China's Baidu wins court case against music groups
|
Opium farming surges in northern Myanmar: group
China sentences four more to death for Urumqi riot
Car bomb wounds 6 near US base in Afghan capital
Argentina courts Chinese investors for mining sector
'Precious' aims to extend Sundance's Oscar glory
Malaysia likely emerged from recession: think-tank
Japan rejects economic project offer on disputed islets
LG books 4th-qtr net profit amid higher sales
China, Taiwan hold talks on trade pact
US truck, bus drivers banned from texting while driving
Sundance films turn cameras on the paparazzi
|
'World's best restaurant' El Bulli to shut for two years: chef
For Neil Sedaka, breaking up a career is hard to do
For Neil Sedaka, breaking up a career is hard to do
|
China court sides with Baidu in music piracy case
Ashley Judd to release memoir at age 41
|
'Precious' aims to extend Sundance's Oscar glory
Rosie lets kids do talking in TV film on families
|
Vienna Opera Ball to pay tribute to Chopin
Poet wins Costa book award for tribute to late wife
|
Somali-born hip-hop star to feature at World Cup
Asian voices make themselves heard at music industry fest
Sundance loves rock 'n' roll with Jett, 'Runaways'
Rosie lets kids do talking in TV film on families
Iraq militants using new tactics to foil security
World powers mull Yemen after foiled US jet 'attack'
Afghanistan wins $1.6 billion in debt relief: IMF
|
Haiti queues for aid amid fresh aftershocks
Sri Lanka president wins re-election: report
|
China says won't limit Google's Android mobile platform
Cold weather claims more lives in Europe
North Korea fires more artillery: report
|
GM clinches last-minute deal to sell Saab to Spyker
Study: Holocaust survivors battle depression
Mexicans Say U.S. Drug Crackdown Feeds Violence
Man rescued from rubble 14 days after Haiti quake
|
Suicide bomb injures nine near US base in Kabul
Facebook may "lock in" its Internet dominance
Mars Rover In Sand Trap, Becomes Stationary Lab
London meeting to bolster Yemen in al Qaeda fight
|
Zelaya to exit Honduras in win for coup leaders
|
eHarmony settles lawsuit over same-sex matching
U.S. Posts First Rise In Teen Pregnancy Since 1990s, Abortion Rate Also Up
Apple tablet can't save print on its own: analysts
FDA: Nipro Corp. Recalling 2M Medical Needles
Israel to shun UN call for Gaza probe: minister
posts best quarter of Bartz era
Buzz builds for Apple's tablet launch
New technology gives 3-D views of arteries
FCC seeks info on early mobile termination fees
Google Voice slips past Apple onto iPhone
Apple tablet can't save print on its own: analysts
|
Facebook may lock in its Internet dominance
|
China says won't limit Google's Android mobile platform
|
Two Koreas trade fire; North warns of more
Sri Lanka: Initial results show president leads
eHarmony settles lawsuit over same-sex matching
|
NKorea says it will continue firing artillery
Planes get too close on approach to LAX
Australia to protest death sentence for guard in Kabul
Obama approved secret operations in Yemen
US redefines Yemen strategy
China-Tibet talks resume amid bitter climate
China says no curb on Google mobile technology
|
Bangladesh upholds execution for ex-president's killers
CBO: Federal deficit projected at $1.35T
Land mine blast wounds 7 Philippine army soldiers
Chinese tennis finally comes of age
Early Ore. vote results come gushing in
Al-Qaeda seeks WMD, US unprepared: reports
Dalai Lama envoys hope to revisit autonomy plan
4 men accused of scheme with La. senator's phones
LA gold trader to stand trial in wife's stabbing
Pig heads left at Malaysian mosques amid tensions
Ex-Guatemalan leader arrested after US request
Dems lack workable plan and retreat on health care
Athens woos Beijing for massive bonds sale: report
Russia's UC Rusal slides in Hong Kong debut
Quincy Jones, John Mayer to headline LA music expo
Samsung executive commits suicide: police
SKorea's current account surplus hits record high
Japan's exports grow for first time in 15 months
S.Korea c/a surplus triples; outlook weak
China says no limits on use of Google's Android
PAKISTAN
IMF, World Bank announce debt relief for Afghanistan
Avatar becomes highest-grossing movie
|
Julianne Moore, Matt Dillon on TV pilot wish lists
|
Japan Airlines gets new president
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Clint Eastwood voted favorite movie star
|
Quincy Jones, John Mayer to headline LA music expo
Quincy Jones, John Mayer to headline LA music expo
|
NBC, Conan O'Brien back in business
|
Cage's former Vegas home sells for nearly $5M
Memo to Sundance filmmakers: Be distinct
|
Sam Worthington takes on "Dracula Year Zero"
"Frozen" could have been a killer chiller
Thin comedy "Extra Man" may disappoint
Frozen could have been a killer chiller
|
Sam Worthington takes on Dracula Year Zero
|
Football legend Cantona scores in Paris theatre debut
Thin comedy Extra Man may disappoint
|
Lyric Opera of Chicago announces 2010-11 season
Jessica Simpson working to send shoes to Haiti
Anne Hathaway set to announce Oscar nominations
Attacker hits Israeli chief justice with sneaker
Russian parliament ratifies European Court reform
China says no curb on Google mobile technology
Yemen pledges urgent reforms to tackle al Qaeda
|
Iranian pilgrims attacked in Iraqi capital
Five Taliban officials removed from sanctions list: UN
London meeting marks sea-change in Afghan approach
|
Israel slams Iran as world recalls Holocaust
|
Iran official: German diplomats involved in riots
|
Haiti quake raises fears of child-eating spirits
|
Economic woes cloud first Obama State of the Union
Bomb kills 3 children in NW Pakistan, say police
Malaysia arrests 10 suspects in anti-terror swoop
Clinton to press China FM on Internet issue
|
Google's older sister in China urges it to stay
|
Coalition standoff unnerves Thai markets
Officials fear another whooping crane die-off
Witness says gay marriage would help children
U.S. technology distributors on track to recovery
|
Police: Bomb kills 3 children in NW Pakistan
Hong Kong lawmakers condemn attack on democracy push
Obama's goal: Get agenda moving, people believing
Myanmar court postpones verdict on American
Backroom health care deals fuel voter anger
Analysis: Another goal pared back: Mideast peace
Walkout blocks speeches by Hong Kong democrats
Falungong says China blocked Hong Kong dance shows
Australian sentenced to death in Afghanistan
Taiwan trade talks off to a 'good start': China
Toyota halts US car sales over safety
China: Theaters must meet domestic movie quota
Pakistani o/n rates higher; rupee flat; stocks down
Swedish rapper testifies in LA murder trial
Canon's 4Q profit surges on brisk camera sales
Japan's exports rebound on strong Chinese demand
Taiwan to keep China bank investments ban: report
S.Korea won up on exporters; N.Korea risks weigh
Seoul shares hit 7-week closing low; LG Elec down
Seoul shares post lowest close in 7 weeks
Pete Doherty fined for carrying heroin in court
|
Bin Laden's ex-driver in the spotlight at Sundance
After Mamma Mia!, fans can sing along with ABBA
|
Next Harry Potter movies coming in 3D
|
Spain seeks EU-wide lifeline for battered women
Toyota Suspends Sales Of Selected Vehicles Previously Recalled
Spanish star is latest chef to chuck in apron
Florida Teen Found Guilty Of Attempting To Kidnap Child
Poet Reid surprise winner of Costa Book of the Year
Jersey Shore cast closer to deal
|
Civil Rights Group Settles 50-Year-Old Lawsuit
Would-be Gaza migrants face endless hurdles
ACORN Videographer, 3 Others Charged With Plot To Tamper Senator's Phones
Brown Seeks Help Of Hillary Clinton To Save Stormont Power-Sharing Deal
"Jersey Shore" cast closer to deal
China: Theaters must meet domestic movie quota
Bhutto, an icon and martyr, remembered at Sundance
'Avatar' soars to new box office record
Julianne Moore, Matt Dillon on TV pilot wish lists
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights