">Forum Views () 
">Forum Replies ()  
 
 
Read more with google mobile :
California's video game law ruled unconstitutional  
 
 
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
  
 
  
Navigation
Primary Navigation
 
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
 
 
Search
 
 
Search:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
California's video game law ruled unconstitutional
 
 
 
 
 
 
 Reuters - Saturday, February 21
By Gina Keating
ADVERTISEMENT
  
LOS ANGELES - A U.S. appeals court ruled Friday that a California law restricting the sales and rental of violent video games to minors and imposing labeling requirements is too restrictive and violates free speech guarantees.
The Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals found that the labeling requirement unfairly forces video games to carry "the state's controversial opinion" about which games are violent.
The unanimous opinion by a three-judge panel could have a far-reaching impact on efforts by other states to establish mandatory video game labeling requirements.
The court upheld a lower court finding that California lawmakers failed to produce evidence that violent video games cause psychological or neurological harm to children.
"Even if it did, the Act is not narrowly tailored to prevent that harm and there remain less restrictive means of forwarding the state's purported interests," the court wrote.
Those alternative measures include the voluntary ratings system established by the Entertainment Software Rating Board, educational campaigns and parental controls, the court said.
State Sen. Leland Yee, the author of the legislation, said he will urge California Attorney General Jerry Brown to appeal the court's ruling to the U.S. Supreme Court.
"I've always contended that the ... law the governor signed was a good one for protecting children from the harm from playing these ultra-violent video games," Yee told Reuters. "I've always felt it would end up in the Supreme Court."
Bo Andersen, president and chief executive of the Entertainment Merchants Association, said the ruling vindicates his group's position that "ratings education, retailer ratings enforcement, and control of game play by parents are the appropriate responses to concerns about video game content."
Andersen and Michael Gallagher, president and CEO of the Entertainment Software Association, urged the state to abandon any further appeals of the case.
"This is a clear signal that in California and across the country, the reckless pursuit of anti-video game legislation like this is an exercise in wasting taxpayer money, government time and state resources," Gallagher said in a statement.
The 2005 law, which requires games described as violent to carry an "18" label, has been contested by video game publishers, distributors and sellers.
A lower court had barred the law from taking effect in 2006, and later invalidated it. The state appealed that case, titled Video Software Dealers Association v. Arnold Schwarzenegger , last October.
Entertainment Software Association members include Disney Interactive Studios, Electronic Arts, Microsoft Corp, THQ Inc, Sony Computer Entertainment America, and Take-Two Interactive Software.
 
 
 
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
 
 
   
Recommend this article
Average (0 votes)
Sign in to recommend this article »
Most Recommended Stories »
  
Related Articles: Technology
US protesters slam weak apology for monkey cartoonAFP - Saturday, February 21
US-TECH SummaryReuters - Saturday, February 21
Digital music services flunk college testReuters - Saturday, February 21
Apple's Woz waltzes back into the spotlightReuters - Saturday, February 21
Google shoots down 'Atlantis' picturesAFP - Saturday, February 21
 
 
 
 
Most Popular – Technology
 
 
 
 
 
 Viewed
 
 
 
 
Huge gamma-ray blast spotted in space
 
 
Malaria: Spoonful of sugar could save thousands of children
 
 
Seductive chemicals hidden in sloppy kisses
 
 
UBS plunges 10 pct amid widening US tax fraud probe
 
 
Trial offers hope for curing peanut allergies
 
 
View Complete List »
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy 
- Terms of Service 
- Community 
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy 
- Help
        
    
 
   
 
Other News on Saturday, 21 February 2009 Tamil Tiger aircraft attack Sri Lanka capital
| International
|  
U.S. secures Afghan supply route
| International
|  
Mexico tests remains for U.S. anti-kidnap expert
| International
|  
Rights may take second place on Clinton China visit
| International
|  
Latvian ruling coalition falls, PM resigns
| International
|  
Mugabe turns 85 with challenge in party, unity government
| International
|  
Court finds California video game law unconstitutional
| Technology
|  
U.S. lawmaker to push repeal of online gambling ban
| Technology
|  
Cable providers eye offering TV shows online: report
| Technology
|  
Ill, disabled Aussie kids get first online network
| Technology
|  
Recession Keeps Less Planes Flying, Making U.S. Neighborhoods Quieter  
School Board In Florida Sets Homework Guidelines  
China Internet users asked to probe custody death
| Technology
|  
Update: Obama Thanks Mayors For Their Work; Says Stimulus Must Be Spent With Accountability  
Amnesty International Asks Clinton To Retract Statement, Declare Human Rights Crucial To Chinese Relations  
Democratic Congressmen Decry Hostilities During 'Unsanctioned' Trip To Gaza  
Business Opportunities For Women, Minorities May Open If Chicago Wins 2016 Olympic Hosting Bid  
Bill Clinton Gives Obama A Grade For First Month In Office  
Cost Of Solar Installation Continues Drop  
Picture of bruised Rihanna sparks police probe
| Entertainment
|  
Leonard Cohen plays first U.S. concert in 15 years
| Entertainment
|  
Actors and studios end contract talks, hit new snag
| Entertainment
|  
Three foreign troops killed in Afghanistan  
China and U.S. can lead world to recovery: Clinton
| International
|  
20 nations offer to boost Afghan contributions: US  
"Lethal Weapon" Screenwriter Sued By Ex-Girlfriend Of Assault  
Netanyahu urges moderates to join broad government  
Israel says rocket from Lebanon wounds woman
| International
|  
'King of Pop' eyes concert comeback in London: reports  
U.S. secures Afghan supply route
| International
|  
Netanyahu asked to form Israel's next government  
Alleged fraudster's Antigua bank closes  
Rwandan army to start Congo withdrawal
| International
|  
Paintings of "Polish Kafka" revealed in Israel  
US gov't moves to dispel bank nationalization rumors  
Iran understates uranium stocks to IAEA: diplomats
| International
|  
Diplomats claim Iran understates uranium stocks to IAEA  
Swiss court blocks bank data sharing with US: report  
Australian author freed after Thai royal pardon
| International
|  
Stroke deaths soar in poorer nations, drop in rich: study  
Survey shows most Japanese want PM to quit
| International
|  
Eurovision Song Contest beloved and belittled  
EU auto sector drives into protectionism row  
U.S. set to refurbish planes for Taiwan
| International
|  
US annual inflation wiped out, deflation looms  
Cancan dancers, Lord of Misrule open Rio Carnival
| International
|  
Bank fears drag down world markets  
Clinton in China pushes environment, finance  
Clinton calls for deeper US-China partnership  
Guantanamo in line with Geneva rules: official  
US, allies 'can't delay' Iran worries: White House  
Schwarzenegger Signs $130 Billion California Budget  
San Francisco Highway Crash Kills 6  
US protesters slam weak apology for monkey cartoon  
Venezuela bans travel for Stanford bank execs  
U.S. Soldier Convicted For Executing Iraqi Prisoners  
US-TECH Summary  
Group Counters Stimulus Plan With TV Ad Featuring Jesus  
US military deaths in Afghanistan region at 581  
Digital music services flunk college test  
U.S. Concerned As Iran Expands Military Ties With Russia  
Apple's Woz waltzes back into the spotlight
| Technology
|  
US received Hamas letter for Obama: State Dept  
Apple's Woz waltzes back into the spotlight  
Feb 20 Highlights Of Low Points In U.S. Economy  
Digital music services flunk college test
| Technology
|  
US to prod Syrian envoy on terrorism, nukes  
Appeals Court: Sale, Rental Of Violent Video Games To Minors Unconstitutional  
Google shoots down 'Atlantis' pictures  
White House says world can't delay on Iran  
Small Business Administration Warns Of Scam Letter  
California's video game law ruled unconstitutional  
Price Of Consumer Goods Rose In January  
U.S. lawmaker to push repeal of online gambling ban  
Wall Street Rallies Late, But Still Closes Lower  
EU's eastern nations fear western protectionism  
Cable providers eye offering TV shows online: report  
Britain asked to wait on Qatada deportation  
China Internet users asked to probe custody death  
Nigeria to clamp down on e-waste imports  
Sri Lanka rebels call airstrike succes  
Japan's Ishikawa misses PGA cut but gains respect at Riviera  
Malaysian politician accused of giving away beef  
Oscar nods shine spotlight on short films
| Entertainment
|  
Obama broadens US targets in Pakistan: report  
Slumdog kids to walk Oscar red carpet
| Entertainment
|  
Clinton in China pushes environment, finance  
No sign of recession at pre-Oscar gift suites
| Entertainment
|  
"Slumdog" kids to walk Oscar red carpet  
Clinton believes China and U.S. can lead world to recovery  
Iran Praises Military Ties With Russia  
Pirate abduction in Malacca Strait after long lull  
Hollywood actors, producers talks end without deal  
Project Runway show features phantom finalists
| Entertainment
|  
Sri Lanka calls Tiger raid desperate bid to delay defeat  
Piracy sinking Lebanon cinema, music, cable industry  
Rebel planes raid Sri Lanka capital  
Japan's Sharp to make LCD panels in China: report  
Australian police probe Japanese whaling claims  
Mutual funds investing in China  
Prudential to take 9.9% stake in China Life  
Conan says bye to New York with some old friends  
Galicia's abandoned villages get new lives  
China's tax revenue growth slows in 2008: govt  
'Slumdog Millionaire,' Ledger lead Oscars betting  
Rihanna won't discuss Chris Brown, but thanks fans  
Vienna, one of the spy capitals of the world  
San Francisco man faces fallout from `Wife Swap'  
Attorney: Peter Falk's care is adequate  
No sign of recession at pre-Oscar gift suites  
'Slumdog' kids get ready for a trip to the Oscars  
Indonesia president hopeful unrepentant on rights abuse  
"Slumdog" kids to walk Oscar red carpet  
Iraq's Abu Ghraib prison renamed and reopens  
Violence flares on Israel-Lebanon border  
Iraqi Kurdish politician wants rights protected  
With new name and fresh paint, Abu Ghraib reopens  
2 rockets fired from Lebanon towards Israel  
Rocket from Lebanon wounds three Israelis: medics  
Sudan says 28 killed in clashes with Darfur rebels  
US, China to join forces on economy, climate change  
Clinton in China to push climate, finance  
US Senator Kerry meets Assad in Syria  
Syria, US explore improving ties as Kerry visits  
Obama urges control of mushrooming deficits  
Iran offered to end Iraq attacks for nuke deal: BBC  
Report: Edward Kennedy May Be Too Ill To Serve In Senate; Wife May Succeed Him  
Louisiana Governor Rejects Some Stimulus Funds  
Analysis: Even military split over Iraq pullout  
Arrest Near In Chandra Levy Murder Case In DC  
Spain denies arrest of top ETA leader  
Seoul singer breaks world marathon singing record  
Mum of kidnapped UN official pleads for help  
Pakistan: Mother of captive American issues appeal  
'Drunken antics' cost Japan minister his job: reports  
Thailand arrests alleged people smuggler  
India adds record 15.41 mobile million users in January  
Statuettes topple at Saint Laurent art show  
US, China to join forces on economy, climate change  
Pakistan Taliban agree "permanent ceasefire" in Swat  
'King of Pop' eyes London comeback concerts  
Asian finance ministers in Thailand to discuss global crisis  
Philippines: Fugitive arrested in lottery outlet  
'Slumdog Millionaire' poised for Oscars glory  
Tokyo Electric to build solar plant in California: report  
China tries to silence dissidents for Clinton visit  
Rio embarrassed by surge in Carnival crime against tourists  
Pakistani cenbank sells 24 bln rupees of T-bills  
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro  
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found  
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever  
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production  
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time  
AMD to Start Production of piledriver  
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs  
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia  
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air  
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch  
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent  
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up  
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform  
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis  
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets  
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights