Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Pandora founder pursues bigger piece of radio pie
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (0)
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
Tired Gay succumbs to Dix in 200 meters
03 Jul 2010
North Korea shrugs off ship and calls for nuclear talks
09 Jul 2010
U.S. judge slashes penalty in music download case
09 Jul 2010
German fans want revenge grilling of oracle octopus
08 Jul 2010
Cat burglar takes shine to washing-line underwear
08 Jul 2010
BP could start cap switch on Saturday: Coast Guard
09 Jul 2010
California transit cop verdict sparks looting
09 Jul 2010
BP set to install bigger cap on leaking Gulf well
09 Jul 2010
Weaker economic view, stronger 3-year sale
09 Jul 2010
Viagra-popping seniors lead the pack for STDs
06 Jul 2010
Tired Gay succumbs to Dix in 200 meters
03 Jul 2010
German fans want revenge grilling of oracle octopus
08 Jul 2010
Google's Schmidt undaunted by Apple or Facebook
09 Jul 2010
Cat burglar takes shine to washing-line underwear
08 Jul 2010
BP could start cap switch on Saturday: Coast Guard
09 Jul 2010
Investors flocking to group organizing sites
08 Jul 2010
Viagra-popping seniors lead the pack for STDs
06 Jul 2010
Fresh economic worries trigger rush into gold
17 Jun 2010
SEC pushes tighter market-making rules: sources
09 Jul 2010
Soldier charged over leaked video of attack
06 Jul 2010
Pandora founder pursues bigger piece of radio pie
Digg This
Tweet This
Share on LinkedIn
Share on Facebook
Related News
Special Report: Guy Hands, Citigroup and the fight for EMI
Fri, Jun 11 2010
Related Topics
Fashion »
Entertainment »
Technology »
ipad »
Music »
Media »
By Antony Bruno
Fri Jul 9, 2010 10:39pm EDT
DENVER (Billboard) - During a recent taping of the Comedy Central show "The Colbert Report," host Stephen Colbert took Pandora founder Tim Westergren to task for the name of his Internet radio service.
"Why Pandora?" Colbert asked, reminding him that Pandora's box from Greek mythology released evil into the world. "Is that what the Internet is? You click open the box and evil comes out your speakers?"
"Surprises come out," Westergren responded, "and at the bottom of that box was hope."
To be sure, Pandora is full of surprises and hope. For almost 10 years, Pandora operated on the verge of collapse. In the early years, while it labored to build the Music Genome Project that powers its music recommendation engine, Pandora struggled to find both a business model and funding, to the point where it had to ask employees to work without pay for almost two years.
Then came the infamous March 2007 Copyright Royalty Board (CRB) decision that raised the performance royalty rates for Internet radio to a degree that Westergren said would put Pandora out of business. It led to a two-year fight to reduce those rates, culminating in a compromise reached last July.
Today, Pandora is for the first time on solid footing. It's about to reach the milestone of 60 million registered users and reported its first profitable quarter at the end of last year. At any given time, there are 500 simultaneous targeted advertising campaigns on Pandora, with 45 of the nation's top 50 advertisers spending money on the site. And the company is now expanding into automobiles and TV sets in an effort to turn Internet radio from the redheaded stepchild of the radio industry into a legitimate competitor.
SEEKING RADIO DOLLARS
"In the last year, I feel like we've finally cracked the nut on how to effectively monetize a streaming radio service," Westergren says. "Our intention is to build a radio business that looks a lot like the traditional radio business, with a scalable mechanism for selling national and local advertising so we can do everything from big, branded national campaigns to local pizza joint specials. They can be delivered as graphic ads, as audio ads, as video ads. We're pitching big ad agencies who have historically bought broadcast radio and pitching them to shift that money to the Web."
This isn't mere bravado. Westergren, 44, may be the poster boy for the laid-back startup executive, but he's a passionate believer that Pandora will one day change the way the world thinks about radio. His town hall meetings with users nationwide typically draw hundreds of fans whom he quickly charms with his down-to-earth casualness and genuine enthusiasm. Yet as the CRB copyright dispute proved, he's not afraid of a fight. Taking on the terrestrial radio establishment may seem like tilting at windmills, but Westergren's fervor -- which president/CEO Joe Kennedy molds into a business plan -- has helped build a growing team of believers.
Pandora hired 70 of its 190 employees last year and plans to hire another 70 this year, 80 percent to 90 percent of whom will be in ad sales or sales support. Its largest office outside its home base in Oakland, California, is in New York, where a staff of 25 focus exclusively on sales and support, with additional offices in Chicago, Dallas, Los Angeles and other cities. For the first time in the company's history, its ad sales team outnumbers the music analysts that keep the Music Genome Project database up to date.
REVENUE VS. ROYALTIES
Despite all this momentum, it's not enough to sustain the kind of growth Westergren hopes to achieve. Pandora raked in $50 million in revenue in 2009, which the company hopes to double by the end of the year. Of that, it paid $30 million in royalties to the music industry as agreed to in the CRB rate settlement with performance rights organization SoundExchange.
That agreement calls for Pandora to pay either a per-stream rate for each song it plays or 25 percent of all revenue, whichever is greater. Pandora needs to generate 8 cents per user per hour to shift the royalty burden to the revenue-share model. Currently, it's bringing in only 2 cents per user per hour.
"Pandora can't survive on network advertising," Westergren says. "The site's too expensive to run because of the licensing. We have to command premium rates."
To do that, Pandora has to rely on more than its sheer numbers, which, while impressive when compared with other digital music services, pale in comparison to traditional radio. Web measurement firm comScore says 13 million unique users interact with Pandora every month, which Westergren says increases to 20 million when taking into account the mobile users that comScore doesn't track. That's only about 1 percent of the audience that traditional radio commands.
Instead, Pandora is relying on its unique position as a source of music discovery. Pandora users enter the name of an artist or song they like, and Pandora's technology builds a custom radio station around that "seed." Users can further fine-tune the stream by voting on each song the service recommends (selecting either "thumbs up" or "thumbs down"). In addition to driving engagement (the company claims users interact with the service seven to eight times per hour) this activity generates user data that can be enormously useful to both artists and advertisers: age, gender, music preference and -- when paired with information compiled during the registration process -- zip code.
ARTIST ENGAGEMENT
Pandora's strategy is to work more directly with artists, convincing them to provide exclusive content to the site that Pandora hosts and sells to sponsors at premium rates. The first iteration of this came last year with the Dave Matthews Band, which hosted a listening party on Pandora, sponsored by Brita. Pandora streamed the group's "Big Whiskey and the Groogrux King" album for a week before its release date from a special landing page on Pandora. It also sent a message to all users who either seeded or voted positively for a DMB song, alerting them of the stream.
According to the band's manager, Bruce Flohr at Red Light Management, the promotion resulted in more than half a million streams, with 8,000 linking through to buy the album on iTunes. The band later teamed with Pandora again to drive awareness of its tour, filming interviews with Matthews discussing his green touring initiative. All told, the entire campaign resulted in more than 21 million impressions.
"It was designed to make sure our fans heard the record in an environment where they were getting turned on to music," Flohr says. "It's harder and harder to find things that move the needle in this business. If done correctly, Pandora moves that needle."
More artist managers and label executives have begun to share that point of view. Last December, Pandora posted several video interviews with John Mayer discussing his musical influences, along with a customized playlist of his favorite songs. Pandora brought in AT&T as a sponsor, and the campaign generated 81 million impressions between the two, according to Mick Management founder Michael McDonald.
"There was more exposure from this than any of (Mayer's) other campaigns," he says. "In a world where things are fragmented, it's difficult to find people. So their targeting works. These new models and new ways of reaching people are the ways we're going to survive going forward."
Pandora now has close to 20 similar campaigns either completed, active or in the works for this year, featuring such acts as Jack Johnson, Jewel, Miley Cyrus, Switchfoot, Miranda Lambert, the Walkmen, Mason Jennings and Rogue Wave. The campaigns can include any combination of a prerelease listening party, a series of video interviews or a custom mixtape.
Participating brands, it seems, couldn't be happier. Brita, for example, has since transitioned its involvement with the Dave Matthews Band from Pandora to participating directly as a sponsor of the group's tour.
That's an important shift because at least for now, artists and labels don't make any extra money if they participate in these sponsored campaigns, other than their cut of the CRB royalty payments Pandora makes to SoundExchange.
LEVELING THE FIELD
The $30 million in performance royalties paid by Pandora last year represents 60 percent of its revenue. Compare that with satellite radio, which pays 15 percent of royalties for the same content, and terrestrial radio, which pays nothing.
"For the first time, artists are going to get to participate in the radio advertising revenue business," Westergren says. "It's a huge business that has been walled off for musicians."
Westergren has emerged as a vocal supporter of the Performance Royalty Act, which would force terrestrial radio broadcasters to pay performance royalties for the first time. While beneficial for labels and artists, such a requirement would also help put Pandora and traditional radio on more equal footing.
To achieve the kind of scale that Westergren envisions would require expansion to new platforms, particularly to TV and the automobile. Most of Pandora's daily traffic -- about 60 percent -- still comes from computers, according to the company. Of the other 40 percent, the majority comes from mobile phones (3 percent comes through its early forays into Internet-connected TVs).
The biggest potential rests in the car. Pandora has the opportunity to change the way people perceive radio much like DVRs changed the way people view their TV. Once users discover the ability to skip a song they don't like on Pandora while driving, the model could be permanently altered.
Pandora already has a deal with Ford to include the service in cars carrying its Sync entertainment system and has deals to make Pandora-capable after-market car stereos from Pioneer and Alpine.
Fashion
Entertainment
Technology
ipad
Music
Media
Add a Comment
*We welcome comments that advance the story directly or with relevant tangential information. We try to block comments that use offensive language or appear to be spam and review comments frequently to ensure they meet our standards. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters.
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Reader Feedback
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts
Venture Capital Journal
International Financing Review
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
FindLaw
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Saturday, 10 July 2010 Iran appears to back down on woman's stoning
Balkan leaders discuss EU integration
Google to resume taking 'Street View' photos next week
Naomi Campbell to testify at Taylor war crimes trial
US, Russia stage Cold War airport spy swap
U.S. man in N. Korean prison attempts suicide: KCNA
|
Blizzard drops plan to require real names on forums
Cavendish wins Tour sixth stage, Cancellara in yellow
US-TECH Summary
Scandal-hit Sarkozy schedules French TV appearance
Taliban commander captured as NATO ramps up raids
Taliban commander captured as NATO raids intensify
Betancourt sues Colombia for $6.8 mln over kidnap
|
Online protest on Egyptian's death draws hundreds
More than 565,000 AFP pictures downloaded at World Cup
British diplomat Valerie Amos to be new U.N. aid chief
|
NTP files patent suits against technology giants
Japan's Fujitsu sets sights on cloud computing
South Lebanon people wary of French peacekeepers
|
Twitter forbidden for Japanese campaigns
Last call for virtual flowers, Facebook closing Gift Shop
Online news site leads charge in French scandal
NTP files patent suits against technology giants
Russia, U.S. swap 14 in Cold War-style spy exchange
UN condemns sinking of South Korean warship
Laos plans first US visit since war: diplomats
NKorea proposes talks with US over ship sinking
Japan's Imperial couple tuned in to World Cup
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Myanmar democracy activists allowed to form new party
Jennifer Lopez cancels Cyprus gig after outcry
U.S. general named to lead Iraq and Afghan war theatre
Naked Mickey Mouse swastika art stirs controversy in Poland
Suspected Russian agents want to plead guilty
Bucharest exhibition debunks Dracula myth
Online protest on Egyptian's death draws hundreds
|
New York lights fire under city's smokers
Keeping up with self-made star Kim Kardashian
Strike over at Honda plant in China
India's Bharti Airtel to invest $150 mln in Kenya
Philippines raises growth targets
Britney Spears getting a Glee-full makeover
|
Jennifer Lopez cancels Cyprus gig after outcry
|
Afghan president 'resists' US village defence plan
British fugitive kills himself in dramatic armed siege
U.N. council deplores attacks on troops in S.Lebanon
Death toll from Pakistan bomb attack reaches 102
|
Fugitive British gunman dead: source
Even absent, Apple's Jobs a big player at Sun Valley
Explosion hits NATO convoy in eastern Afghanistan
North Korea shrugs off ship and calls for nuclear talks
|
Russian spies leave US without a trace
NTP files patent suits against technology giants
Slow, deadly road to peace for U.S. troops in Kandahar
|
Iran says woman's stoning sentence 'under revision'
Scandal-hit Sarkozy schedules French TV appearance
Obama, Abbas discuss path to Mideast direct talks
Stray NATO artillery kills six Afghan civilians
|
Australian soldier killed by blast in Afghanistan
NATO accepts blame for killing 6 Afghan civilians
NTP files patent suits against technology giants
U.N. council condemns attack on South Korean ship
|
Springboks, All Blacks ready for 'ultimate Test'
Anti-Chavez media mogul seeks international justice
Even absent, Apple's Jobs a big player at Sun Valley
|
U.S. says began mulling spy swap as early as June 11
Pakistan bomb attacks claim 102 lives
Pandora founder pursues bigger piece of radio pie
Pandora founder pursues bigger piece of radio pie
|
Angry protesters eye sentencing in transit killing
S.Lankan protest drags on despite appeal from UN chief
IRS keeping close eye on musicians' tour dollars
Duck boat, 2 bodies pulled from Philadelphia river
Lady Antebellum leads album sales for 1st-half 2010
Pakistan attack toll mounts to 102: official
U.S. judge slashes penalty in music download case
|
Minimum and maximum temperatures in Celsius
Adrien Brody flexes muscles in "Predators"
Australia stands by Afghan war despite 17th death
Tom Jones gets back to basics with gospel album
China's exports soar despite Euro-US malaise
N.Korea willing to talk after escaping UN blame
Talent Agency WME drops Mel Gibson
Japan, Russia agree to build gas plant: report
Three years on, Red Mosque legacy bites
Charlie Sheen case delayed again
North Korea shrugs off ship and calls for nuclear talks
China says exports up 35 percent in June
New "Mad Men" season threatened by AT&T cable dispute
Democrats face test on eve of Japanese election
U.S. judge slashes penalty in music download case
Google wins permission to keep website in China
Adrien Brody flexes muscles in Predators
|
IRS keeping close eye on musicians' tour dollars
|
Pandora founder pursues bigger piece of radio pie
|
Lady Antebellum leads album sales for 1st-half 2010
|
Charlie Sheen case delayed again
|
Tom Jones gets back to basics with gospel album
|
New Mad Men season threatened by AT&T cable dispute
|
NATO says 'errant rounds' killed six Afghan civilians
NATO says 'errant rounds' kills six Afghan civilians
Japan PM's party at risk of setback in Sunday vote
|
Painting of dead Mandela draws outrage in S.Africa
Body remains found on wheels of plane in Riyadh
British envoy says regrets offence over cleric blog
|
Iran reviewing woman's stoning death sentence
Sri Lankan president ends minister's anti-U.N. fast
|
NATO: 5 coalition troops killed in Afghanistan
Bomb in Kandahar city kills at least 1
Ukraine's Yanukovich fails in move to strengthen powers
|
Australian soldier killed by blast in Afghanistan
Large blast in Afghanistan's Kandahar city
Sudan to mull north-south confederation after vote
|
11 Shia die in Afghan attack; 2 NATO convoys hit
Fini ally warns Berlusconi as confidence votes loom
|
Greenpeace marks 1985 Rainbow Warrior bombing
6.2-magnitude quake shakes Pacific near Guam: USGS
Australian Aboriginal warrior buried after 170 years
Value of oil skimming Gulf flotilla is uncertain
New Myanmar party says vote could herald change
Google gets nod from China to keep search page
|
Death toll from Pakistan bomb attack reaches 102
Bangladeshi mum in Australia to meet separated twins
China court accepts 'Avatar' plagiarism case
Harley-Davidson opens first Indian dealership
Saudi probes 11-year oil smuggling operation: report
China says exports up 35 percent in June
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights