InfoAnda - Special Report: Can Malaysia reform and discriminate? |

Pakistanis angry over detentions in Times Sq. case
Monday, May 24, 2010
ISLAMABAD – Relatives of three men detained by Pakistan for alleged links to the suspect in the attempted Times Square bombing say the men are innocent.
They

Taiwan denies boycotting Australian film festival
Thursday, August 6, 2009

AFP - Thursday, August 6TAIPEI (AFP) - - Taiwan's Beijing-friendly government on Wednesday denied boycotting an Australian film festival amid a row over the e

Merkel's support dips, regional ally resigns International
Thursday, September 3, 2009

By Sarah Marsh and Noah Barkin

BERLIN (Reuters) - Chancellor Angela Merkel suffered a double blow on Thursday as a senior party ally in east German

Minister seeks closure of anti-Berlusconi websites
Wednesday, December 16, 2009
ROME (AFP) - – The Italian government moved Tuesday to close down Internet sites encouraging further violence against Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, who

Asian markets mixed after Wall Street rally
Wednesday, March 18, 2009

By ELAINE KURTENBACH,AP Business Writer AP - Wednesday, March 18SHANGHAI - Asia's stock market rally seemed to be running out of steam Wednesday, despite an

Iran needs up to 15 nuclear plants: foreign minister | | 12 December 2009
Japan's Samurai art on show in New York | 20 October 2009
Microsoft shakes up game and mobile device division | 26 May 2010

Like never before, US voters plug into power of the Internet | 1 November 2008

Forum Views () Forum Replies ()

Read more with google mobile : Special Report: Can Malaysia reform and discriminate? |

Edition: U.S. Article Comments (0) Full Focus Editor's choice A selection of our top photos from the past 24 hours. Full Article Follow Reuters Facebook Twitter RSS YouTube Read Casey Anthony will be released from jail July 17 | 07 Jul 2011 Suspect in 7 murders kills himself, hostages safe 12:45am EDT Texas fight with EPA grows with power-plant rule 07 Jul 2011 Internet providers to act against online pirates 07 Jul 2011 China warns U.S. officials not to meet Dalai Lama 07 Jul 2011 Discussed 210 Minnesota government shutdown begins after talks fail 132 Obama: ending tax breaks required to cut deficit 99 Jury resumes deliberations in Casey Anthony murder trial Watched Mobile harbor delivers the goods for container ships at sea Wed, Jul 6 2011 A Tokyo-Paris flight in under three hours on the horizon Fri, Jun 24 2011 Casey Anthony sentenced to four years Thu, Jul 7 2011 Special Report: Can Malaysia reform and discriminate? Tweet Share this Email Print Related News Exclusive: AirAsia plans to boost Airbus deal Wed, Jul 6 2011 Stunning Thai election win brings hope of stability Mon, Jul 4 2011 Greek lawmakers back reforms, clear way for more aid Thu, Jun 30 2011 Analysis: A "Thaksinomics" renaissance in Thailand Thu, Jun 30 2011 Greece backs first austerity package, violence worsens Wed, Jun 29 2011 Analysis & Opinion Financial engineering as a career: Part 2 America’s missing trillions Related Topics World » By Bill Tarrant PUTRAJAYA, Malaysia | Thu Jul 7, 2011 11:53pm EDT PUTRAJAYA, Malaysia (Reuters) - Dr. Mahathir Mohamad sits at a vast desk cluttered with work, hands clasped before him and looking at his visitors with a slight smile. Dr. M, as he is popularly known, was prime minister of Malaysia from 1981 to 2003, the first commoner to ever hold the post in a land with nine sultans. His demeanor suggests the country physician he once was, ready with a frank diagnosis -- and in his first interview with the foreign media in five years, he doles out prescriptions for what ails his nation. The man who made Malaysia part of the "East Asia Miracle" with a massive inflow of foreign direct investment doesn't think much of it today. The former miracle economy, now a muddle, needs a new policy direction, he says in his office in Putrajaya, the administrative capital he built on old plantation land in the 1990s. "We should not be too dependent on FDI anymore," says Mahathir. "We've come to the stage when locals can invest. They have now the capital. They have the technology. They know the market. And I think they can manage big industries." His thinking is at odds with government policy. But it gets to the heart of a debate over the future of Malaysia, a former emerging market star now in danger of becoming an also-ran, stuck in the dreaded "middle income trap." Foreign investment has been dwindling since the onset of the 1997-1998 Asian financial crisis. Capital outflows have even exceeded inflows in four of the past five years. This has been accompanied by an alarming "brain drain" of emigres voting with their feet against Malaysia's prospects. Malaysia is counting on foreign investment to provide a quarter of the investments needed to fund projects under its "Economic Transformation Programme," which aims to turn the country of 28 million into a fully developed nation by 2020. That comes to an average of more than $11 billion a year, compared with an average of $3.1 billion since 1997 -- by any measure an ambitious target. The challenge is vastly more complicated by the exodus of talent that hits directly at Malaysia's aspiration to become a high-income nation focused on knowledge-based industries. "For Malaysia to stand success in its journey to high income, it will need to develop, attract and retain talent," the World Bank said in a March report. "Brain drain does not appear to square with this objective: Malaysia needs talent, but talent seems to be leaving." The rise of China and India in the region has overshadowed the export-dependent "Tiger Cub" economies of Southeast Asia, all struggling with their own reforms. Thailand has been at a dangerous political impasse for six years. Indonesia is consistently ranked as among the world's most corrupt countries. The Philippines is battling long-running insurgencies. Yet Malaysia does not compare well with its peers in the eyes of investors. A March report by Bank of America Merrill Lynch ranked Malaysia the second least popular market after Colombia among global emerging market fund managers and tied with India for least favorite among Asia-Pacific managers. A chief difficulty is the nation's balky affirmative action program. Ethnic Chinese account for most of the brain drain. The reason 60 percent of them gave for why they moved out of the motherland was "social injustice," a World Bank survey says. They are referring to the "Bumiputra" (sons of the soil) policy that discriminates against Chinese and Indians, who account for a third of the population, in favor of majority Malays for all kinds of things -- places in universities, jobs, shares in companies, home mortgages, government contracts. The government acknowledges the policy has been widely abused, with Malay front men offering their names to Chinese businesses to obtain government contracts, an arrangement known as "Ali Baba," after the character in Arabian Nights who gains entrance to the treasure cave of the 40 thieves with the magic words "Open Sesame." Prime Minister Najib Razak has launched a new edition of the policy called the New Economic Model that is meant to correct the inequities, mainly by making preferences need-based and not race-based. But as the World Bank report noted, "limited headway has been made on this front." It is certainly not popular with the rank and file Malays in Najib's UMNO party. Making significant reforms to the system is crucial to Malaysia's aspirations, but any rollback of privileges for the majority is a big political risk for any government that tries it. It is the Malaysian dilemma. THE IMPOSSIBLE GAME Idris Jala, the minister in charge of greatly boosting investment and wooing back emigres under the Economic Transformation Programme (ETP), calls it the impossible game. He is an unlikely character in the Malaysian Cabinet, a Christian from the Kelabit tribe in Sarawak on Malaysian Borneo who spent most of his career running companies, including the Malaysian unit of Royal Dutch Shell and Malaysia Airlines. "I am a true believer that real transformation goes hand in hand with the game of the impossible," Idris says in an e-mail interview. He sets impossible targets, is "very directive" and pushes his team constantly "to do the right things, but differently" until they are finally "one step ahead of you." "When you do transformation, you cannot achieve big results by democracy," he notes. The ETP aims to attract 1.4 trillion ringgit ($466 billion) by 2020 in a dozen broad industries. Only 8 percent of that will come from the government, which has long dominated the economy, either directly or through government-linked firms. Idris disclosed to Reuters that foreign investment will account for 27 percent of the total. He wants to climb the value ladder in the targeted industries. Take birds' nests, for example. Nests made with the saliva of swifts have been collected for centuries from huge limestone caves in Idris' home state of Sarawak to make the most expensive soup on earth. Processing them would give Malaysia a bigger chunk of a global market worth $3.3 billion, he said. Foreign investment will also provide many of the 3.3 million jobs that will be created under the ETP, whose over-arching goal is to raise per capita income to $15,000 from $6,700 in 2009. A challenge will be to upgrade skills in a labor force long geared to basic manufacturing and plantations, attract foreign talent, and try to reverse some of the "brain drain." About 700,000 Malaysians work abroad. A new agency called "Talent Corporation" has been given this task, offering tax breaks for Malaysians to return home and easing visa restrictions for foreigners. But the shift from low-cost manufacturing and plantations to more knowledge intensive work needs to take place in an environment where creativity and freedom of inquiry can flourish to draw talent and investment. The Malaysian model of ethnic preferences has not been conducive to that. MEGA-PROJECTS Mahathir remains a towering figure. In public forums and in his blog, he is a scourge to the government of the day, influential, for instance, in forcing the early retirement of his anointed successor, Abdullah Badawi. But while he's a critic of his successors, he is a strong defender of the Malaysian system he built. Mahathir came to office as the foremost champion of Malay privileges. Under his administration, the "Bumiputra rules" led to a mingling of politics and business that largely benefited a coterie of Malay and Chinese businessmen. Huge government building projects kept the contracts flowing and the political machine running. Mahathir says as much in the interview, citing the slowdown in big projects as the reason for the steady attrition of Chinese support for his successors in office. "What is happening is the Chinese feel that in the economic area, the business area, they are not receiving the kind of benefits they got during previous times," he said. "The moment I stepped down, all the projects were stopped ... When you stop big government projects, a lot of people -- well, their businesses will go down." In March, Mahathir published an 809-page autobiography, "A Doctor in the House." His main motivation in writing it was "to make corrections of the opinions and the accusations that were leveled at me" -- especially that he systematically undermined the judiciary. It is the biggest stain on his record. He authorized the arrest of his deputy and heir apparent, Anwar Ibrahim, on sodomy and corruption charges after the two men fell out over how to handle the Asian financial crisis. The trial was denounced in and out of Malaysia as a farce that called into question the rule of law. The financial crisis and Anwar's conviction marked a watershed. Foreign investors became wary about Malaysia, and a country once a haven for foreign investment was shunned. "Ten-twenty years ago, Malaysia was it," said a regional president of a European-based distribution company. "But then came 1997 and the rule of law was exposed for what it was. We once looked at Malaysia for a regional headquarters but rule of law and the bumi policy made us choose Singapore instead." Mahathir retired in 2003, but Malaysia has yet to inspire confidence again. Economic growth has fallen along with investment, averaging 4.6 percent in the decade that ended in 2010 from an average 7.2 percent in the 1990s. FIELD OF CYBER DREAMS Putrajaya is a monument to Muslim Malay culture. Graceful minarets and gleaming blue domes dominate the skyline and a bridge across an artificial lake was inspired by the famous one in Isfahan, Iran. More than 90 percent of the residents are Bumiputras. Across Putrajaya lake from Mahathir's office is a curious community of knowledge workers called Cyberjaya. The town is a place where the contentious "bum rules" do not apply. Cyberjaya (cyber success) is home to about 500 IT companies and two universities. It has a daytime population of 41,000 but only 14,000 fulltime residents sleep there overnight. This town is filled with futuristic-looking buildings but has few residential neighborhoods and little in the way of amenities, not yet anyway. Cyberjaya was one of Mahathir's last big projects. It was to be Malaysia's answer to California's Silicon Valley, the key difference being this one would be a ready-made town, built on old plantation land, in hopes technology innovators would come. Cyberjaya offers foreign investors a waiver of the "Bumiputra" rules that require equity stakes and employment for ethnic Malays. It also guaranteed the Internet would not be censored, in a country that kept the media on a tight leash. Cyberjaya was part of a grand plan to avoid the emerging market middle income trap Malaysia was falling into because it could no longer compete for manufacturing jobs, especially with China. Then the financial crisis hit and Mahathir's response spooked potential investors. Blaming Jewish conspirators for the crisis, he imposed capital controls to stop short-selling of the ringgit. Anwar was arrested the day after that. Some $30 billion in portfolio investment fled Malaysia in 1997; most of it has yet to return. Key foreign investors scrapped plans for Cyberjaya and for years Malaysia struggled to woo them back. The effort now appears to be bearing fruit. Last October, Hewlett Packard launched a multi-purpose client servicing center in Cyberjaya, the single biggest investment by a technology multinational in Malaysia. HP said it would provide 4,000 jobs. It joins Dell, DHL, IBM, Fujitsu, Nokia and DoCoMo among others in the 29-square-kilometre town. Since 2009, Cyberjaya has attracted 7.12 billion ringgit ($2.37 billion) in investment, compared with a total of 4.62 billion ringgit in the previous 11 years. Success has given Hafidz Hashim, managing director of Cyberview Sdn Bhd, the town's developer, a new problem. "Entertainment," Hafiz said when asked what his "citizens" want the most. He is known as "the mayor of Cyberjaya because his company acts as both builder and city manager. More than half the projected investment over the next three years will be for residential property, Hafidz said in an interview. Cyberview has already built a community center and clubhouse and plans to build a huge entertainment complex, along with more shops and restaurants. It is far from Malaysia's answer to Silicon Valley, though. Cyberjaya is home to server farms, data storage facilities and client service centers, the low end of the Internet economy. There is little in the way of R&D underway. Arvin Singh, 22, has just quit his job at the HP plant because he was "constantly doing the same thing over and over again" and not growing on the job. Most of his co-workers were content to remain in this "comfort zone," he said. "But one must constantly work to expand one's knowledge," Singh says, adding he plans to study overseas to get further qualified. Hafidz said one of his biggest challenges is meeting the skills companies in Cyberjaya need, and which Malaysia's education system is not providing. He has set up a "Knowledge Workers Development Institute" where companies can send workers for training, and on-the-job training programs. Cyberjaya's success after a sputtering start has inspired similar projects in the country. The most ambitious is one emerging just north of Singapore called Iskandar Malaysia. It will eventually be a metropolis three times the size of Singapore with theme parks, international schools and colleges, hotels and hospitals, a movie studio, a financial center and luxury homes. It has attracted $23 billion in promised investments, nearly half from overseas. Iskandar is one of five "economic growth corridors" Malaysia is developing with incentives to foreign investors. They are, in effect, investment zones ring-fenced from the mainstream economy where business and politics have long entwined. FEAR FOR FUTURE Months after Mahathir took power in 1981, a Malaysian Chinese banker packed up his family in the southern city of Johor Bahru and moved to Singapore. He had grown uneasy about the future as Mahathir took an increasingly interventionist approach to the economy and ramped up the affirmative action policy. Those uncertainties have only increased for a Chinese community that abandoned the ruling National Front coalition in the 2008 general election and are now deserting the country in ever mounting numbers. The World Bank said the Malaysian diaspora has quadrupled over the past three decades. "People are unhappy about the way the (policy) has been exploited, the way it has degenerated into some kind of apartheid policy," said the banker, who requested only his surname, Lee, be used. "They say come back, we'll give you tax breaks. But when you move back, you're not talking just about your career, but your children's future. And it's this perception of uncertainty that holds them back. They feel the society they have moved to is more assuring that the one they came from." Lee's son, a medical doctor, said the overseas Malaysian Chinese community has now become anxious about the growing force of political Islam. Last year, 10 churches and two mosques were desecrated after a Malaysian high court ruled Christians could use the word Allah for God in their literature. "A lot of people are now worried about a hyper-religious government taking power, and then all that they worked so hard for goes up in smoke." Kalimullah Hassan, former Group Editor of Malaysia's pro-government New Straits Times publications, understands their anxiety. A Bumiputra himself, Kalimullah worries about the emergence of right-wing politicians trying to win back Malays, nearly half of whom voted for a multi-ethnic opposition coalition headed by Anwar Ibrahim in 2008. "To unite the Malays, they raise the bogeyman - other races, specifically the Chinese and foreigners who are supposedly out to displace the Malays in their own homeland - and in doing so, they've upped the ante in race relations," Kalimullah says. The politics of patronage is no longer working because there isn't enough largesse to spread around in a country whose population has nearly tripled since 1970 and with capital inflows and growth slowing, Kalimullah says. What Malaysia needs now more than ever is the meritocracy Prime Minister Najib has proposed in his New Economic Model. Otherwise its human capital will be stunted, he says. "In the mid-to-long term, Malaysia is going to be left further behind by a world which has already realised that human capital is its greatest asset." (Additional reporting by Razak Ahmad; Editing by Mike Williams and Neil Fullick) World Related Quotes and News Company Price Related News Tweet this Link this Share this Digg this Email Reprints We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/ Comments (0) Be the first to comment on reuters.com. Add yours using the box above. Social Stream (What's this?) © Copyright 2011 Thomson Reuters Editorial Editions: Africa Arabic Argentina Brazil Canada China France Germany India Italy Japan Latin America Mexico Russia Spain United Kingdom United States Reuters Contact Us Advertise With Us Help Journalism Handbook Archive Site Index Video Index Reader Feedback Mobile Newsletters RSS Podcasts Widgets Your View Analyst Research Thomson Reuters Copyright Disclaimer Privacy Professional Products Professional Products Support Financial Products About Thomson Reuters Careers Online Products Acquisitions Monthly Buyouts Venture Capital Journal International Financing Review Project Finance International PEhub.com PE Week FindLaw Super Lawyers Attorney Rating Service Reuters on Facebook Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests. NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.

Other News on Friday, 8 July 2011
Venezuela's Chavez says surgery forces slower pace |
ADP payroll report: Private sector employers created 157,000 jobs in June
Any force deal with Iraq must address Iran: Mullen |
Ricky Martin hopes to add a daughter to his brood; see same-sex marriage legal in Puerto Rico
Congress considers “resetting” Russian relations
Microalgae could be Texas' next cashcrop
Lee Westwood grabs share of lead at Scottish Open
Iraqi PM Maliki criticises Sunni secession talk |
Staten Island mosquitoes found carrying West Nile virus
Israelis say U.N. report on Gaza flotilla to appear soon |
U.S. considers Palestinians’ statehood talks with U.N. a bad idea
Gwyneth Paltrow refuses to eat from canned foods
Cuba sets appeal hearing for jailed American |
Taiwan test fires submarine launched missile
Analysis: Protests punish Pinera, but Chile economy seen safe |
John Twomey and crew continue Irish qualification bid, sail in top 10 of IFDS Worlds
RIM says adds 1 million EMEA subscribers in 3 weeks |
Court OKs TerreStar's $1.38 billion sale to Dish |
Cell phones, devices biggest driving distractions |
ABC soap All My Children to live on, online |
Hack job! Murdoch axes paper to save deal |
Elizabeth Smart to join ABC on missing person stories |
Yemen's Saleh appears on TV, offers to share power |
China warns U.S. officials not to meet Dalai Lama |
Italy's Berlusconi exposes NATO rifts over Libya |
Roof collapse at FC Twente soccer stadium kills one, injures 16
Karachi's ethnic, political violence kills 70 in three days |
Syrian forces storm suburb; ambassador in Hama |
U.N. should stay in volatile parts of Sudan: U.S. |
As Egypt change drags on, some praise Mubarak |
Deron Williams to reportedly consider playing in Turkey
Mets star Jose Reyes placed in 15-day DL with injured hamstring
Analysis: Summer to test Japan resolve over nuclear power |
QB Kerry Collins calls it quits after 16 seasons
Special Report: Can Malaysia reform and discriminate? |
Yemeni president makes first public appearance since bomb attack
Colts Hall of Fame tight end John Mackey dead at 69
SEC charges JPMorgan with rigging municipal bond deals
NYSE Euronext stockholders approve merger with Deutsche Boerse
UCLA Health System Pays $865,000 to Settle Celebrity Privacy Allegations
Martha Stewart's New Series Premieres This Month
Google's Schmidt sees room for several social networks |
Twitter security lags some other sites: experts |
Proxy firm unimpressed by RIM promise about board |
Fans, stars, Hollywood say farewell to Harry Potter |
Murdoch axes paper, British PM's aide faces arrest |
Fifty-three feared dead in DR Congo plane crash |
Sudan recognizes independence of oil-rich south |
Free fishing events in Ontario to conclude this weekend
Egyptians rally to demand swifter reforms, justice |
Peeping Tom jailed for secretly taping 260 women
Lawsuits predicted as New York towns ponder whether to block fracking
Hugh Grant helps shutter News of the World tabloid
No quick fix to east Libya woes as war drags on |
Dead alligator goes for a ride
More urban poor depending on food subsidies
Beyond the euphoria of Southern independence
ABC says 'Children,' 'One Life' to live online
Ex-News of the World royal editor arrested |
Michigan murder suspect kills self
200 activists blocked from Israel flights: police |
Nature's fury takes 58 lives in Nepal since May 15
Google to cooperate in antitrust review: Schmidt |
Greenlight Capital sells Yahoo stake: source |
Baidu realigns business lines, senior exec to leave |
Chris Young retires hat, readies album and tour |
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights

USD EUR - 1 year graph		BlogMeter 1.01