Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Detroit scare sparks debate on full-body scanners
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Detroit scare sparks debate on full-body scanners
Reuters - Wednesday, December 30
Send
IM Story
Print
By Ben Berkowitz
AMSTERDAM - Technology exists that might have detected explosives hidden in the underwear of a Nigerian man accused of trying to blow up a plane over Detroit, but cost and privacy worries have until now prevented its widespread use.
Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab, 23, is suspected of trying to ignite an explosive called PETN using a chemical-filled syringe as Northwest Flight 253 approached Detroit on Christmas morning.
He had passed through security checks in Lagos and Amsterdam, where standard metal detector archways failed to spot his weapon.
Amsterdam's Schiphol Airport has at least 15 full-body "millimeter wave" scanners that see underneath passengers' clothes to detect suspicious packages or weapons.
The problem: their use has been only voluntary because of concerns that the scans reveal passengers "naked" to the operators and anyone else passing by the machine's screen.
The costs are also substantial. Whereas a traditional archway metal detector runs up to $15,000, more intensive whole-body scanners cost about 10 times as much.
"I don't anticipate myself that there'll be a rush to buy new equipment because airport operators are strapped for cash at the moment and the equipment itself, whilst good, is not a solution to the problem," said Kevin Murphy, product manager of physical security for Qinetiq Group, a British-based defense and security technology group.
"Some passengers are reassured that there's new technology there and are prepared to give up some measure of their privacy for it, and others have been outraged by it."
Airport operators need effective security plans, behavioral modeling and hiring processes just as much as they need advanced hardware, he told Reuters. Qinetiq is focusing its efforts on "standoff screening" that scans passengers even before they reach security checkpoints.
SEEING UNDER CLOTHES
Both "millimeter wave" and "backscatter X-ray" scanners try to do roughly the same thing -- see under clothes and identify unusual objects by their different densities relative to the human body.
Industry experts say public fears about radiation from the X-ray machines are unwarranted. But stronger than the health concerns are the privacy fears, in the United States and especially in Europe.
Germany's interior ministry, which sets the standards for domestic airport security, declined to use body scanners last year after it decided they were an invasion of privacy, although their usefulness and safety are still being tested.
"They were rejected as going too far into the private sphere of travelers," said Verena Meyer, spokeswoman for the Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information, an independent parliamentary watchdog.
An interior ministry spokeswoman said on Tuesday that certain conditions had to be fulfilled, including masking people's intimate details and making explosives more easily recognizable.
In Britain, Home Secretary Alan Johnson said: "We intend to be at the cutting edge of all this new technology and to ensure that we put it in place as quickly as possible."
But progress until now has been slow. A spokesman for Manchester airport said it was running trials but had made no decision on implementation, while Heathrow operator BAA said it was not using body scanners at all.
The European Parliament has consistently opposed body scanners on privacy and health grounds and has asked for more studies in both these areas.
Nonetheless, "there are no EU rules preventing member states from using them if they want to," a spokesman for the Commission said on Tuesday.
NO GUARANTEES
Speculation about increased demand has boosted shares of scanner makers this week. Some smaller companies such as ICX Technologies and OSI Systems, worth only a few hundred million dollars to begin with, rose 10 percent or more on Monday.
Larger players like Smiths Group and L-3 Communications have also benefited, with their machinery already in trials in airports around the world.
Schiphol's chief operating officer and director of security said on Monday they intend to make millimeter wave scanners mandatory once they get EU approval. Schiphol officials rejected X-ray machines as too unsafe for the public for regular use.
They stressed repeatedly that no matter what technology they chose, they could not be certain last week's outcome would have been any different.
"There is no 100 percent guarantee we would have caught him," Schiphol Group COO Ad Rutten said of Abdulmutallab.
The industry was quick to praise Schiphol's decision but just as quick to add that it might not be enough.
"Absolutely without a shadow of doubt this is a good thing. But one solution will not address every vulnerability. It needs to be a set of solutions," said Jane's Aviation analyst Chris Yates.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Target Co was victim of hacker Albert Gonzalez Reuters - Wednesday, December 30
Google plans Android event in January AFP - Wednesday, December 30
Hacker pleads guilty in huge credit card theft case AFP - Wednesday, December 30
Google to hold Android event in early January Reuters - Wednesday, December 30
Nokia requests US inquiry against Apple AFP - Wednesday, December 30
News Search
Top Stories
Picasso painted little guitar found in Italian shoe box: reports
Lockheed to sell 24 F-16 fighter jets to Egypt
Fewer deaths in 2009 disasters: German re-insurer
US consumer confidence edges higher in December
London, Frankfurt stock markets hit 2009 peaks
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
China executes British national despite pleas
Obama: 'We will not rest' until air terror plotters caught
Dutch hero 'reacted on a bang' to subdue suspect
Van der Sar granted leave after wife collapses
Swiss bank secrecy emerges from 2009 with holes
More Most Viewed »
Tiger's wife Elin seeking divorce: reports
British priest defends urging people to shoplift
Century-old butter found in Scott's Antarctic hut
Brazilian confesses to sticking needles into two-year-old
Tiger Woods' girlfriend apologizes in TV interview
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Wednesday, 30 December 2009 Israel, Egypt discuss efforts to revive peace process
Fewer deaths in 2009 disasters: German re-insurer
US-TECH Summary
Court lets Palestinians use major Israeli highway
US consumer confidence stirs from doldrums
Yemen says may harbor up to 300 Qaeda suspects
|
Iran 'ready to swap enriched uranium abroad'
Gunmen kill Iraqi militia guards at checkpoint
Afghan soldier kills U.S. service member at army base
|
Iran opposition leaders face execution
Israel's nuclear whistleblower Vanunu detained
U.S. plane bomber wanted to study sharia in Yemen
|
Lebanese troops fire on Israeli jets over south
Three sentenced to death for June Iraq bombing
Israeli police arrest nuclear whistleblower Vanunu
Motorcycle chase reaches 140 mph on Ariz. highway
Yemen probes contacts, movements of bomb suspect
Nokia opens new front in Apple patent battle
|
Google to hold Android event in early January
|
NY Senate committee meets to decide senator's fate
Karzai, NATO clash over reports of civilian deaths
NKorea confirms it has detained an American
Afghan soldier shoots US, Italian troops: NATO
Virtual goods give Web firms new revenue in ad slump
|
China to lift Internet, phone bans in Xinjiang: state media
Sailor who survived USS Cole bombing dies in Fla.
Karzai sends team to probe Afghan civilian deaths
Home prices rise for 5th straight month in October
Japan minister bemoans deadlock in Russia islands row
3 people killed, 1 wounded after Detroit shooting
Patient cleared of defaming hospital in Indonesia
5.7-magnitude quake jolts parts of Bangladesh
Michael Jackson's death among 2009's major moments
|
The top 10 singles and albums on iTunes
Photographs unearthed of first Ellis Island immigrant: report
'Jersey Shore' town downplays linkage with show
Intel report: Iran seeking to smuggle raw uranium
Secret files show no-nonsense, whisky-loving Thatcher
Target Co was victim of hacker Albert Gonzalez
Picasso painted little guitar found in Italian shoe box: reports
North Korea pilfering nuclear reactor site: report
|
Iranian security forces intensify crackdown
Lockheed to sell 24 F-16 fighter jets to Egypt
Google plans Android event in January
U.S. eyeing more targeted sanctions against Iran
|
Afghan soldier shoots US, Italian troops: NATO
Spain raises terrorist alert level
Hacker pleads guilty in huge credit card theft case
Australian bushfires destroys almost 40 homes
|
US consumer confidence stirs from doldrums
Google to hold Android event in early January
Nokia requests US inquiry against Apple
Virtual goods give Web firms new revenue in ad slump
Detroit scare sparks debate on full-body scanners
North Korea New Year wish: tear down imaginary wall
|
Spain raises anti-terror alert ahead of possible attacks
|
Nokia requests US inquiry against Apple
US sets conditions for duty-free treatment of Bolivia
Bad moves thwart Washington truck heist
Wildfires destroy homes in Australia's west
Sri Lankan refugees leave Indonesia: official
UN seeks access to deported Hmong in Laos
Obama moves to curb number of classified records
Britain's Brown writes to Suu Kyi pledging support
San Francisco's famous sea lions have vanished
Militants kill 2 Filipino navy commandos in clash
Japan's mobile phone marvels go back to the future
Gold medal champ says manager stole $1.1 million
2 Koreas open new, updated military hot lines
Target Co was victim of hacker Albert Gonzalez
|
US military deaths in Afghanistan region at 861
Mystery surrounds Hong Kong acid attacker
ITC to probe charges RIM infringed patent
|
Security costs will top $75M in NYC terror trial
Australian wildfire destroys at least 20 homes
Drums probed as possible cause of NH anthrax case
Australia's 'Best Job' winner stung by jellyfish
Bomb threat closes Wisconsin Capitol
Attorney: PETA worker neglected snakes in his care
Seoul shares rise, post 50 pct gain in 2009
S.Korean won ends up, posts 8.2 pct gain on year
Blige, Latifah gear up for record-breaking People's Choice
RPT-Etisalat to pay Pakistan for telco firm stk-report
Taiwan stocks at 19-mth closing high, AU rises
S.Korea Q1 export outlook index eases -association
Japan aims for four million new jobs by 2020
PAKISTAN
Japan Airlines shares dive on bankruptcy fears
French trainee DJs put through their paces
US weighs duties on Chinese steel grating
Orwell's birthplace to be saved from decay
South Korea closes flash memory antitrust case
Protest at Mexican jail where Mel Gibson to film
Gibson film plan provokes protest outside Mexico prison
Transport Canada Bans Carry-on Bags For U.S.-Bound Flights
More Meth Labs Busted In 2009
Weinstein Co sees "Nine" losing ground at theaters
Letterman extortion suspect looks to Woods scandal
Former Bush Adviser Karl Rove Divorces Wife After 24 Years Of Marriage
Blige, Latifah gear up for record-breaking People's Choice
Blige, Latifah gear up for record-breaking People's Choice
|
Florida Man Advertises For Love; Gets Married
ABC evening news gets boost from Diane Sawyer
|
Top 20 prime-time TV programs
Google's Deal To Buy AdMob Has Consumer Groups Worried About Competition, Privacy Issues
Michael Jackson's death among 2009's major moments
North Korean State Media Confirms Detention Of American Intruder
Standard & Poor's/Case-Shiller Home Price Indices Show Economy Slowly Improving
Tropicana turns 70, feathers, dancing gals and all
Federal Court Limits Use Of Police Tasers
Three Congressional Panels To Hold Hearings On Failed Christmas Terror Plot
Father Charged With Child Abuse After Shooting Stepson With BB Gun
Weinstein Co sees Nine losing ground at theaters
|
Bombs kill more than 30 in Iraq
|
Bombs kill 23 in Iraq's western Anbar province
Tens of thousands at pro-government rallies in Iran
|
Bombs kill more than 30 in Iraq
Pakistan Taliban says carried out Karachi bombing
|
Iran police still holding 300 over Sunday protests
Afghans burn Obama effigy over civilian deaths
UK hostage released alive after 2007 Iraq capture
|
Yemen says forces clash with Qaeda, seize militant
|
10 killed, province governor hurt, in Iraq bombs
Hamas sees more prisoner swap talks with Israel
|
Afghans protest civilian deaths in foreign raid
|
Former Indonesian President Abdurrahman Wahid dies
|
The nation's weather
Sentencing for chief in celebrity surrogate case
Laos won't let UN visit repatriated Hmong yet
Gunman, other man dead at Calif casino office
Nokia's latest patent stike on Apple a risk, but may pay off
|
Pioneering Chinese editor announces new venture
Van slides over embankment in Grand Canyon park
Philippine politician wounded in another attack
Obama wants answers after botched terror attack
Chinese admiral floats idea of overseas naval bases
Bus, truck collide in China; 16 die, 11 injured
Analysis: Many question 'system worked' comment
16 dead in China road accident: state media
Mother Teresa, Gene Autry on upcoming US stamps
North Korea pilfering nuclear reactor site-report
Calif. man touts cooling shelter for farmworkers
Britain blasted as 'powerless' over China execution row
'Illegal' Vietnam Buddhists leave temple: abbot
Pakistani o/n rates flat; rupee weakens, stocks up
Creditors agree on debt scheme for S.Korea's Kumho
Taiwan seeks to limit fallout from US beef ban
Japan's sick finance minister back at work briefly
India's Ranbaxy shares weaken after China sale
JAL shares dive to record low on bankruptcy fears
Japan unveils growth plan for next decade
S.Korea upbeat on 2010, but Nov data disappoints
25 new titles added to National Film Registry
Actor Colin Farrell baptizes new son in Poland
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
ABC evening news gets boost from Diane Sawyer
Politically correct food on the menu in Britain
Two arrested in Bali over Japanese woman's murder
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights