Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
U.N. atom assembly rejects Arab move targeting Israel
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (8)
Email
Print
Reprints
Read
Obama seeks to curb ruling on gays in military
10:56am EDT
Pakistan vows to repatriate jailed scientist
9:45am EDT
U.S. Nuclear Weapons Have Been Compromised by Unidentified Aerial Objects
PR Newswire 15 Sep 2010
Gulliver lands in HSBC hot seat with a bump
7:34am EDT
UPDATE 1-1 in 5 gay, bisexual men in US cities has HIV
23 Sep 2010
Shared
U.S. Nuclear Weapons Have Been Compromised by Unidentified Aerial Objects
PR Newswire 15 Sep 2010
UPDATE 1-1 in 5 gay, bisexual men in US cities has HIV
23 Sep 2010
Talking to death: texts, phones kill 16,000: study
23 Sep 2010
Ahmadinejad tells U.N. most blame U.S. gov't for 9/11
|
23 Sep 2010
Obama seeks to curb ruling on gays in military
10:56am EDT
Watched
Spray-on haute couture
Tue, Sep 21 2010
US walks out on Ahmadinejad speech
Thu, Sep 23 2010
NASA unveils latest mars rover
Tue, Sep 21 2010
U.N. atom assembly rejects Arab move targeting Israel
Tweet This
Share on LinkedIn
Share on Facebook
Related News
Q+A: What is at stake in Israel row at UN atom body?
7:38am EDT
Analysis & Opinion
Tardy Obama plays second fiddle to Swiss at UN
Mideast peace veterans and handshake diplomacy
Related Topics
World »
International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Director General Yukiya Amano (C) attends a board of governors meeting at the UN headquarters in Vienna, September 13, 2010.
Credit: Reuters/Herwig Prammer
By Fredrik Dahl and Sylvia Westall
VIENNA |
Fri Sep 24, 2010 9:56am EDT
VIENNA (Reuters) - Member states of the U.N. nuclear watchdog narrowly rejected an Arab-sponsored resolution on Friday calling on Israel to join a global anti-atomic weapons treaty, a diplomatic victory for the United States.
Washington had urged countries to vote down the symbolically important although non-binding resolution, saying it could derail broader efforts to ban nuclear warheads in the Middle East and also damage fresh Israeli-Palestinian peace talks.
"The winner here is the peace process, the winner here is the opportunity to move forward with a zone free of weapons of mass destruction in the Middle East," Glyn Davies, the U.S. envoy to the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), said after a tense debate that highlighted deep divisions between largely Western countries and developing nations.
Israel is widely believed to hold the Middle East's only nuclear arsenal and is also the only country in the tinderbox region outside the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty.
Arab states backed by Iran say this poses a threat to peace and stability. They want Israel to subject all its atomic facilities to IAEA monitoring. Israel says it would only join the pact if there is a comprehensive Middle East peace.
Israel has never confirmed nor denied having atomic bombs, under a policy of ambiguity to deter its Arab and Islamic foes.
Forty-six delegations voted in favor of the resolution and 51 against. Other delegations in the general assembly of the 151-member IAEA either abstained or were absent.
It had approved a similar resolution expressing concern at "Israel's Nuclear Capabilities" in a close vote at last year's General Conference, as the annual IAEA gathering is known.
"The vote result is an important victory for the moral stand in the face of extremism and hypocrisy," Israeli Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman told Israel's Army Radio.
AVOIDING "FATAL BLOW?"
Several small countries, including some in Latin America such as Costa Rica and Panama, who were absent in 2009 voted against the measure this time. Like last year, Russia and China supported the text, showing big power differences on the issue.
If it signed the NPT, Israel would have to renounce nuclear weaponry. Arab states say there cannot be genuine peace in the Middle East until Israel abandons nuclear weapons.
"It is Israel that singles itself out by standing aloof from the consensus of all the other states in the region which have acceded to the NPT," a Sudanese diplomat told the assembly, speaking for the Arab group. "It stands alone in refusing to place its nuclear facilities under the agency safeguards."
Israel and the United States regard Iran as the Middle East's main proliferation threat, accusing it of seeking to develop atomic weapons in secret. Tehran denies the charge.
U.S. officials had warned that approval of the resolution would erase any chance of Israel attending an Egyptian-proposed conference in 2012 toward establishing a Middle East zone free of weapons of mass destruction.
1
2
Next
World
Comments
See All Comments (8) | Post Comment
Sep 24, 2010 8:01am EDT
Although I am not a Jew, I cannot believe that Israel submits to the bullying of the American State Department when its’ homeland is so vulnerable. I also cannot understand why so many Congressman and Senators, who are Jewish, are so silent?
hempstead1944
Report As Abusive
Sep 24, 2010 8:20am EDT
Neither the article nor the above comment, whose author doesn’t seem to have read the article very closely, is very enlightening. The State Department is backing Israel but that seems to go against its policy of pushing countries with nuclear bombs to join the nonproliferation treaty. Obviously, there is something more in this resolution, but it is impossible to tell from this breathless little report.
judex
Report As Abusive
Sep 24, 2010 8:25am EDT
By the way, the US is backing Israel here. Why do you call it bullying? The bigger question is this: what is the USA’s position on Israel nuclear capability. And how do we sell it to the Arabs? And is it -that Israel has the bomb, that Arabs are upset- even important? God, how I hate this kind of blurby information!
judex
Report As Abusive
Sep 24, 2010 10:36am EDT
The NPT is a voluntary treaty. It is not subject to the will of other countries, nor can it be. Every signatory signed that treaty, not because they were forced but because they wanted to.
If Israel doesn’t want to, it doesn’t have to. And since it has never signed it, it is under no obligation to submit to its mandate. Its not like it had signed it and then withdrawn, or reneged on its promises. It made no promise in the first place. In a way, Israel hold nuclear weapons for the same reason the US and Russia and France and Britain hold them. For deterrence. And that makes Iran irate.
Aleithia
Report As Abusive
Sep 24, 2010 10:37am EDT
the US aproves of its sister nation having the aims to protect itself, bar none.
wolf91101
Report As Abusive
Sep 24, 2010 10:54am EDT
Israel’s policy of not stating publicly of having nucleur weapons is doing what it is designed to do. Keep the nations that want to destroy the only democracy in the Middle East deeply concerned that if they do have the weapons, will they use them in retaliation for all out war with Iran ?
Abington
Report As Abusive
Sep 24, 2010 11:25am EDT
Claims that Israel is “the only democracy in the middle east” are spurious at best, (i recall that Iran had elections last year) and only designed as a smokescreen to divert attention from the blatant hypocrisy of the US support of the “principle” that SOME nuclear renegades are “more equal” than others
Angstworld
Report As Abusive
Sep 24, 2010 11:40am EDT
If by sister you mean usurper of US power, debaser of US morality, corrupter of US government and racist religious fanatics who see an entire population of indigenous Arabs as subhuman. If that is what you meant by sister country then Israel is our sister.
How can a ‘Jewish’ state not be religiously intolerant, racist and undemocratic? Some are more equal than others. The article also seems Orwellian in that the US talks about regional peace by allowing one country to violate the ban – it just seems lunatic. And the thug Russian bouncer talking about hypocrisy makes the hypocrisy meter explode. No neo-nut has been able to sufficiently explain the contradiction and hypocrisy of a democratic ‘Jewish’ state. The very concept of which is antithetical the very core of America’s soul. Israeli pluralism extends only to different types of Jews. The fact that the most corrupt congress ever ( 2 billion and counting) supports this atrocious government says more about America’s impending doom than it does about Israel’s legitimacy. I think everyone who unequivocally supports Zionism should admit to themselves they are racist and let the healing begin.
MHCO
Report As Abusive
Sep 24, 2010 11:46am EDT
This is the non proliferation treaty and does call for the total rejection of nuclear weapons – if the state possesses them.
It would show an act of good faith on the part of the Israeli’s to join it – otherwise they face the constant charge that they are hypocrites and liars for
demanding adherence to a treaty they never bothered to sign themselves.
The question at the last presidential debates was – would the US support Israel if it was attacked by Iran. The reverse of that question wasn’t asked.
paintcan
Report As Abusive
See All Comments (8)
Add a Comment
*We welcome comments that advance the story directly or with relevant tangential information. We try to block comments that use offensive language or appear to be spam and review comments frequently to ensure they meet our standards. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters.
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Reader Feedback
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Analyst Research
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts
Venture Capital Journal
International Financing Review
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
FindLaw
Reuters on Facebook
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Friday, 24 September 2010 Pakistani scientist sentenced to 86 years in US prison
France protests pension reform
Time Warner could deliver premium VOD in Q1
US-TECH Summary
Irish economic recovery fails in second quarter
Ahmadinejad tells U.N. most blame U.S. government for 9/11
|
Iran drops bid for seat on U.N. nuclear body's board
U.S. military eyes cyber defenses for banks, grid
France wants to hear Qaeda's hostage demands
US limits Avandia diabetes drug use, falls short of ban
Internet said to speed development for poor nations
Two new horned dinosaurs discovered in western US
Iran says nuclear talks can succeed only if fair
US jobless claims rise unexpectedly
South Sudan starts talks with renegade militia chief
YouTube wins piracy case against Spanish TV
Afghan president calls for release of journalists
FCC paves way for new mobile devices
German Catholic Church to compensate abuse victims
|
US: Dead in Afghan chopper crash were all American
Relatives of jailed Azerbaijani bloggers appeal to Obama
Indian phone networks compliant on BlackBerry: report
NGO sees renewed push in counterfeiting talks in Tokyo
Facebook CEO Zuckerberg to give $100 million to schools: report
Japanese quizzed in China as maritime dispute tensions rise
China will not buckle on national interests: premier
Obama tells Wen China must do more on currency
FCC paves way for new mobile devices
|
Myanmar must free prisoners before elections: Amnesty
Brazilian film about Lula to vie for Oscars
Obama, Wen meet, stress cooperation
Time Warner could deliver premium VOD in Q1
|
Bosnian to star in Angelina Jolie's first film
China says 4 Japanese suspected of illegal filming
W. Marsalis to tour Cuba with Lincoln Center group
N.Korean foreign delegate dismisses succession reports
Sayles: US-Philippine war has 'parallels' today
Internet said to speed development for poor nations
|
China bans mine bosses from sending assistants down shafts
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
China 'questions Japanese' for filming military zone
Website ranks most influential tweeters
|
Website ranks most influential tweeters
A Minute With: Tom Selleck talking "Blue Bloods"
Namibia court postpones China graft case again
Taiwan to loan art to China amid warming ties
NGO sees renewed push in counterfeiting talks in Tokyo
|
Europe's couch potatoes dished up local content TV diet
Chinese rom-com brings Bordeaux to big screen
Obama to visit Indonesia in November
New Harry Potter trailer promises dark times ahead
|
Website ranks most influential tweeters
|
Katy Perry dropped from Sesame Street
|
Mel Gibson's ex-lover launches PR battle
|
A Minute With: Tom Selleck talking Blue Bloods
|
CBS challenges NBC in Thursday comedy sweepstakes
|
Joaquin Phoenix thanks Letterman for his beat down
|
Bosnian actress nabs lead role in Jolie's movie
|
Owls of Ga'Hoole swoop into movie with Aussie accents
|
Stanley Kramer's Inherit the Wind still resonates
|
Pakistani scientist sentenced to 86 years in US prison
Soviet 1991 coup leader Yanayev dies at 73: reports
Japan to free China boat captain at center of row
|
Iran leader's September 11 speech sparks US fury
US reviewing ways to fight cyber attacks: general
Ahmadinejad tells U.N. most blame U.S. gov't for 9/11
|
Great white sharks no cold-blooded 'Jaws'
No parliamentary majority for Swedish PM: final count
Colombia kills top FARC rebel commander in raid
|
Facebook resolves service disruption issue
Afghan president calls for release of journalists
U.S. Sentences Pakistani Neuroscientist To 86 Years Imprisonment
Gunmen kill Mexican mayor near Monterrey
|
Putin says Arctic must remain 'zone of peace'
Lula to launch record Petrobras share sale
'Father of Iranian blogging' faces death penalty: watchdog
US state executes first woman in nearly 100 years
U.S. Afghan war review unlikely to prompt big changes
|
Netanyahu: U.N. Flotilla Raid Report Is "Biased"
U.S.: America Was Invited Into Afghanistan, Soviets Invaded
Japanese quizzed in China as maritime row escalates
A second day of technical troubles at Facebook
Tropical Storm Matthew heads for Central America
|
"Scott Pilgrim vs. The World" Coming To DVD, Blu-ray With Bonus Features And Updated Cover Art
Diabetes drug Avandia banned in Europe, restricted in US
Ahmadinejads U.N. Speech Prompts Diplomat Walkout
FCC frees up spectrum for super-fast wireless
Iran says nuclear talks can succeed only if fair
|
Obama says world must back Middle East peace bid
Seattle Grandmother Kills 3 Family Members, Herself
Special report: Dilma Rousseff, Brazil's automatic pilot
|
Talking to death: texts, phones kill 16,000: study
U.S. Stocks Continue Slump Over Rising Jobless Claims, Euro Debt
Another Man, Pictures Surface in Bishop Long's Sex Abuse Scandal
Colombia rebels briefly assault Cerrejon mine
|
Health Care Reform Provisions Take Effect Amid Controversy Over Costs
Buck Has Slim Lead In Colorado Senate Race
1st woman in 5 years executed in US amid outcry
Japan trade min hears China rare earth exports halted
Obama tells Iran door to diplomacy still open
Two Koreas set for more talks on family reunions
Families of jailed Azeri bloggers appeal to Obama
Japan to free China boat captain at centre of row
Japan 'to free' Chinese skipper at centre of row
Malaysia says JI militant handed over to Singapore
Japan traders say China blocking rare earths exports
Pools of the rich suspected in Philippine dengue outbreak
Talking to death: texts, phones kill 16,000: study
|
Great white sharks no cold-blooded 'Jaws': campaigners
"Leap of Faith's" long, hard road to Broadway
HK activists' trip to disputed islands derailed again
"Wall Street" sequel set to rally at box office
US, S.Korea to hold naval war games next week
Facebook resolves service disruption issue
|
"Blue Bloods" a welcome return for Tom Selleck
Eddie Fisher dies aged 82
Nancy Wilson and Cameron Crowe divorcing
Portia De Rossi changes name to DeGeneres
Joblessness may be pushing Americans to live in sin
Seoul shares end higher on auto rallies
Actor Ryan Reynolds buried on film but not by fame
S.Korean authorities buy dlrs to curb won -traders
Crosby, Ovechkin to square off in outdoor reality TV
S.Korea c.bank says drains 10.0 trln won via repos
PAKISTAN
Air New Zealand says confident 2011 earnings will improve
Obama tells Wen China must do more on currency
RPT-Seoul shares mixed, auto shares rally
S.Korea bonds rally on quantitative easing talk
Seoul shares open lower on poor U.S. data
Apple tops PetroChina in market capitalization
Eddie Fisher dies aged 82
|
Nancy Wilson and Cameron Crowe divorcing
|
Blue Bloods a welcome return for Tom Selleck
|
Wall Street sequel set to rally at box office
|
Actor Ryan Reynolds buried on film but not by fame
|
Leap of Faith's long, hard road to Broadway
|
Portia De Rossi changes name to DeGeneres
|
Israel plays down scope of future settler projects
U.N. atom assembly rejects Arab move targeting Israel
|
India, RIM working on glitches in email access: source
Arsenal post record profits
France has 'no plans to retrieve hostages by force'
Oracle's Ellison says microchip firms could be good fit
U.S. troops fight on despite end to combat in Iraq
|
NATO frees Al Jazeera staff
British monarch 'asked for heating handout'
Special report: BRIC breaking: Brazil's China syndrome
|
Nike 1Q Profits Up 9 Percent
Second Afghan journalist released by NATO
Suicide bombers attack NATO base in Afghan east
|
Justice Dept. Seeks To Stop "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" Injunction
Pakistan vows to repatriate jailed scientist
|
Virgina Executes First Woman in 100 Years
AP Interview: Hiker talks of year in Iran prison
"Jersey Shore" Star Pauly D Reportedly Gets Own Spin-Off Show
Report Claims Higher Booze Taxes Would Lower Deaths, Injuries
Detained Afghan journalist released by coalition
Athletes arrive for Games, but future in doubt
|
Stallone Voted Ultimate Action Hero
Afghan suicide bomber kills child, injures 28
French unions up stakes in new pension protest call
|
Harper Campaigns For UN Security Council Seat
Israel plays down scope of future settler projects
|
One Dead, Another Wounded In Stabbing In Boston School
Attention To Women's Health Issues Leads To Progress In Treatment
Belgian love triangle skydive murder trial begins
|
Japan to free Chinese skipper at centre of row
Suu Kyi entitled to vote in Myanmar poll
Athletes arrive as Delhi races against the clock
Pakistan return home after disastrous tour
Great white sharks no cold-blooded 'Jaws': campaigners
China panda keeper finalists begin training
China hints missiles targeting Taiwan 'could be axed'
Letterman felon to skip Emmys despite nomination
Oracle's Ellison says microchip firms could be good fit
|
India, RIM working on glitches in email access: source
|
Pakistani rupee at record low; stocks end higher
LinkedIn buys company, has talked to bankers: CEO
|
Obama to focus on China at ASEAN summit in New York
Facebook resolves service disruption issue
|
Cyber attack appears to target Iran: U.S. tech firm
|
Japan silent on intervention talk after sharp yen fall
Tokyo investors 'against cancelling lunch breaks'
Netflix signs expanded license agreement with NBC
|
Motorsports 'racing to cash in on Asia'
SKorea's KNOC clinches Dana Petroleum takeover
S.Korea's state oil firm claims control over UK's Dana
S.Korea pension fund to invest $300 mln in U.S. property
PREVIEW-Pakistani analysts divided about key policy rate
Wall Street insider looks into Money Never Sleeps
|
Male soprano stars in forgotten Italian opera
|
Letterman felon to skip Emmys despite nomination
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights