Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Mecca goes upmarket but commercialism unnerves some
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Mecca goes upmarket but commercialism unnerves some
Reuters - Saturday, November 13
Send
IM Story
Print
By Ulf Laessing
MECCA, Saudi Arabia - Sitting in the marble lobby of a luxury hotel in Mecca, Moroccan bank director Mohammad Hamdosh gets a breather from the cacophony of pilgrims bustling around the Grand Mosque in Islam's holiest city.
Millions have flocked to the city in Saudi Arabia for the annual haj pilgrimage, a duty for every able-bodied Muslim who can afford it. But some can afford more than others, and a controversial construction boom is catering to their needs.
"Every pilgrim comes according to his means. God gave me money, so why shouldn't I stay in this hotel?" says Hamdosh, on a trip that has cost him 12,000 Euros . "Haj is tiring so it's good to have a room to rest."
Inside the mosque, all pilgrims are equal as they circle the black stone known as the Kaaba towards which Muslims around the world turn in prayer every day.
But outside an array of towering five-star hotels have sprung up where the wealthy can bask in a 24-hour view of the Kaaba. The high-rises dwarf the mosque and the surrounding town, nestled in the mountains in the hinterland of the port city Jeddah.
It is part of a wider project to expand the mosque and bring more Muslims to the holy city for salvation, according to the writs of Islam -- something Saudi Arabia sees as its duty.
Mecca has just inaugurated the world's largest clockface perched Big Ben-style on the front of a high-rise hotel facing the Kaaba, while some 20 cranes next to the mosque herald more luxury accommodation.
The spending spree in Mecca and the second holy city Medina is valued at some $120 billion over the next decade and at present there are $20 billion of projects underway in Mecca alone, according to Banque Saudi Fransi. A square metre land in Mecca costs some 50,000 riyals .
"If people are in a good position they should stay close to the mosque," said Farhad Yaftali, a 25-year-old pilgrim from an five-strong Afghani business family in Dubai who paid $15,000 each. "It's good to have a room to rest and do wudu ," he said, sipping tea in the cafe of the same five-star hotel.
The Saudi government is proud of the development, made possible by the country's vast wealth accrued from its oil resources. The work is the latest stage in mosque expansions to accommodate pilgrims that stretch back decades.
"In the past 10 years, we've seen a big rise in pilgrims. This year the number of pilgrims will rise by 20 percent," Interior Minister Prince Nayef bin Abdulaziz told a news conference in Mecca this week.
"Work to further improve the level of services to pilgrims of the House of God is continuing," he said. Hoteliers say they expect more than three million pilgrims, maybe even four.
MECCANS ANGRY, POWERLESS
Many Saudi intellectuals, mainly from the Mecca region, are disturbed by the government's plans, which diplomats in Riyadh say have been approved only by senior clerics away from public scrutiny.
Saudi newspapers and Islamist blogs have engaged in some debate about the building frenzy, but no criticism comes from the top Saudi scholars who are allies to the Saudi royal family in governing the kingdom -- which has no elected parliament.
"One cannot help but feel sad seeing al-Kaaba so dot-small between all those glass and iron giants," said novelist Raja Alem, whose recent novel Tawq al-Hamam exposes destruction of historic areas, corruption and abuse.
"Long before Islam, Arabs didn't dare live in the circle of what we call 'al-haram', meaning the sacred area ," she said. "They spent their days in the holy city and moved out with nightfall. They thought their human activities defile God's home."
The rites of pilgrimage reinforce this sense of humility before God. Men wear two simple pieces of white cloth and women avoid perfumes.
Hoteliers say the government bans some displays of luxury such as swimming pools -- yet the new Makkah Clock Royal Tower Hotel will boast two top-notch spas .
"The notion of filling Mecca's sky line with modern skyscrapers is not only undermining the Kaaba, it is a clear material symbol of a massive cultural and social deletion the city has experienced," said Saudi columnist Mahmoud Sabbagh.
"The replacement of the old city has taken with it centuries-long preserved traditions in academic, social, and cultural systems and mechanisms. The whole cultural paradigm has been damaged," he said.
In recent decades many old houses have been torn down in Mecca to allow better access to the haram, making way for malls, hotels and huge underground parking areas. Locals are compensated for houses they lose.
Irfan al-Alawi, an Islamic theology professor based in London, said the Vatican would never sanction such work in its own sacred precinct.
The government should use space outside the city to build hotels, he said: "Mecca doesn't have to look like Manhattan or New York."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Suicide car bomb targets foreign troops in Kabul AFP - 17 minutes ago
Mecca heaving with Muslim pilgrims ahead of hajj AFP - 28 minutes ago
Comatose Sharon moved to family farm AFP - 42 minutes ago
U.N. mission approves Ivory Coast poll results Reuters - 1 hour 43 minutes ago
UK-World Summary Reuters - 1 hour 43 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Asian Games open with China set to dominate
EU heavyweights move to calm bond markets
German economy slows slightly after record bounce
Boeing blames Dreamliner fire on faulty power panel
DNA test raises doubts over Texas man's execution
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
EU fines 11 airlines 800 million euros for air cargo cartel
DNA test raises doubts over Texas man's execution
Boeing blames Dreamliner fire on faulty power panel
Acrimony as EU budget negotiations collapse
Irish bond rates hit record highs, fanning debt crisis fears
More Most Viewed »
Alcohol more harmful than heroin, crack cocaine: study
Toddler survives seven-floor fall in France
Spectacular unknown species found in Amazon
EU fines 11 airlines 800 million euros for air cargo cartel
Be fit, have fewer colds: study
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Friday, 12 November 2010 Sunni bloc walks out as Iraq power-sharing deal frays
Russian journalists march against attacks on media
Activision says Black Ops first-day sales a record
Greek police find 143 immigrants crammed into road tanker
TB levels off with progress in China, India: WHO
Seven Russian police killed in Dagestan: reports
News
Suicide car bomb kills at least 15 in Karachi
|
Iraq's new government to include Sunni-backed bloc
Irish bond rates hit record highs, fanning debt crisis fears
Ground Broken on Earth's First Spaceship Factory
Six Russian police 'killed in Dagestan'
Pope calls for peace in letter to Ahmadinejad
Clinton, Netanyahu Dodge Questions Before Crucial Meeting
Kylie Minogue To Perform On Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade
Bomb explodes next to Yemen ruling party building
|
Motorola fires back against Microsoft in patent dispute
Special report
"Barefoot Bandit" Indicted On Crime Spree Charges
NASA Discovers 2 New Cracks On Shuttle Exterior Fuel Tank
Analysts' view
New York Museum To Return Tut Relics To Egypt
Gaza aid workers en route for Greece after dispute
|
Security increased in Kandahar before Eid
Senegal president's re-election bid is illegal: ally
|
Iran 'adulteress' stoning case focuses on murder charge
Rihanna And Drake Hit #1 On Billboard Hot 100 With "What's My Name?"
Hezbollah vows to block arrests over Hariri killing
|
Power-sharing deal clinched in Iraq: party officials
Middle Aged High Cholesterol Not Linked With Alzheimer's Risk
Haiti cholera toll at 800, worry for U.S.: CDC expert
|
Taiwan's jailed ex-leader asks to be set free
Russian double agent helped US crack spy ring: lawmaker
S.Lanka floods force up to 300,000 from their homes
South Korea and U.S. fail to resolve trade deal row
Ancient Rome's biggest temple reopens
London exhibition charts global love of drugs
Indian drug firm Ranbaxy triples profits
Australia pick Moore for England rugby Test
'Call of Duty: Black Ops' blows away sales records
South Korea, U.S. fail to resolve trade deal row
US missile salvo kills six in Pakistan: officials
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Pakistan's forex reserves fall to $16.95 bln
Obama tells North Korea to end "belligerence"
Harry Potter fans brave wind and rain for premiere
Pakistani stocks end down; rupee firms; o/n rates flat
Serbs grumble at new smoking curbs
Twitter links users to Apple music social network
|
Italian cinema legend De Laurentiis dies: family
Pakistan launches campaign to fight corruption
Indonesian president to be 'lead speaker' in G-20 development session
Microsoft's MSN in tie-up with China's Sina
Level 3 to be a primary Netflix CDN provider
|
Malaysia Airlines says EC drops competition probe
Mitsubishi Motors to recall 250,000 vehicles in Japan
Conan plays safe, gives viewers trusted TV routine
|
Prize-winning Canadian novel already a rare book
|
US-TECH Summary
35 hours of video a minute uploaded to YouTube
NY Times to publish e-book best-seller lists
Motorola fires back against Microsoft in patent dispute
Hezbollah vows to block arrests over Hariri killing
Clinton offers Netanyahu security pledge on peace talks
|
Yahoo says report of 20 percent in layoffs "misleading"
Boeing blames Dreamliner fire on faulty power panel
denies report it plans to slash 20 percent of staff
EU heavyweights say bond market jitters 'misplaced'
Taiwan ex-president gets 19 years in prison
|
2014 is the new date to watch in Afghanistan
DNA test raises doubts over Texas man's execution
Viacom to sell Harmonix
Five years comatose, Israel's Sharon moves home
|
News Corp. gadfly wins lunch with Rupert Murdoch
Haiti cholera toll at 800, U.S. risk seen low
|
Russia, Japan leaders to meet amid islands spat
|
Twitter links up with Apple's Ping
Inflation under-statement sparks row in China
|
Activision says Black Ops first-day sales a record
Chavez promotes general U.S. calls drug kingpin
|
Twitter links users to Apple music social network
Environmentalists urge action at tuna talks
Acrimony as EU budget negotiations collapse
Lengthy US-Israel talks fail to make Mideast headway
Yahoo says report of 20 percent in layoffs misleading
|
Haiti cholera toll at 800, U.S. risk seen low
Top Russian spy defects after betraying ring in U.S.
Tributes pour in for late Italian cinema legend De Laurentiis
N.Zealand's first Asian-origin MP quits over scandal
StanChart eyes organic growth, non-banking business
Taiwan strips ex-leader Chen of perks after convictions
Arnie the Barbarian hails Italian mentor De Laurentiis
Strong quake hits Indonesia, no tsunami alert
India industrial output growth halves to 4.4 percent
S.Korea won posts biggest daily pct loss in 5 mth
Beijing to melt snow to address water shortage
News
Argentine chef turns home into intimate haute cuisine
Hunt for missing seamen after ship sinks off Japan
Seoul shares end flat amid China fall, Irish debt woes
Russian, Japanese leaders to meet amid islands row
Camila and Juan Luis Guerra are top Latin Grammy winners
Michael Jackson duet with Akon set for release
|
Prize-winning Canadian novel already a rare book
N.Zealand man jailed over seal attack
Harry Potter fans brave wind and rain for premiere
|
News
China issues tougher rare earth export rules
Chinese vase sells for record 43 mln pounds in London
China stands firm as G20 wrangling goes to wire
The Pee-wee Herman Show -- Theater Review
|
'Wandering minds' make people unhappy: study
US 'very confident' of strong G20 deal
Arnie the Barbarian hails Italian mentor De Laurentiis
Camila and Juan Luis Guerra are top Latin Grammy winners
|
Legendary movie producer Dino De Laurentiis dies at 91
Several Chinese banks face extra reserve requirement
TV's "Simpsons" renewed for 23rd season
TV's Simpsons renewed for 23rd season
|
US 'encouraged' at rise of China's yuan
Prize-winning Canadian novel already a rare book
|
Miranda Lambert, Brad Paisley shine at the CMAs
|
FACTBOX-S.Korean policymakers' remarks on capital controls
Disney Channel brings new star in to fold
|
PAKISTAN
Consider smaller Afghan force: US panel
German economy slows slightly after record bounce
Russia's spies must learn from betrayal: Medvedev
|
Nigeria will report Iran if arms broke U.N. sanctions
Special Report: The two lives of Angela Merkel
|
EU's Ashton offers to meet Iran on December 5
Rumors swirl in Myanmar over Suu Kyi release
|
Mecca goes upmarket but commercialism unnerves some
Taliban, military attacks in deadly lockstep
|
Five years comatose, Israel's Sharon taken home
Will Japan be an upbeat end to Obama's Asia trip?
|
Attacks strain trust between US, Afghan forces
Convoy attacked in Afghan capital: report
|
Afghan officials: Kabul attack wounds 2 soldiers
Some 200,000 at risk of cholera in Haiti, U.N. says
|
Afghan police: Suicide car bomber hits Kabul
Nuclear information safe with us, IAEA tells Iran
|
NATO: 15 Afghan insurgents killed in the south
Tributes pour in for late cinema legend De Laurentiis
Iran FM holds talks in Nigeria after illegal arms shipment
China aims to put a stop to online smear campaigns
All quiet on the Thai-Burma border
Bomb kills girl as Laos hosts int'l meet on 'war bomb' clearance
Thailand's flood death toll reaches 206
In Japan's largest Chinatown, people avoid politics
Last bid to save language of Kenyan ex-cave dwellers
Trees mysteriously dying in Bangladesh capital
The Pee-wee Herman Show -- Theater Review
The games people play at Asian Games
James Murdoch says apps cannibalize newspapers
|
Key hearing for suspected serial killer in Mich.
Malaysian court fails to rule on child conversions to Islam
Murkowski camp cries foul in ballot count
Bomb stokes fears Islamists expanding in Pakistan
Japan mobile phone app takes photos, counts calories
|
Pakistani stocks, o/n rates end lower; rupee weakens
AP Exclusive: Suspect turns case against priest
Intel increases dividend by 15 percent
|
Japanese banks Mizuho, SMFG see profit soar
Cruise passengers endured stench, cold food
Nobel Peace laureates meet in atomic-bombed Hiroshima
Michael Jackson duet with Akon set for release
Texas Man's Execution In Question With New DNA Findings
Toyota offers cautious outlook on electric cars
Officials use Steeler-styled van to serve warrants
3 Killed, 1 Injured in Florida Twin Engine Plane Crash
AMC Shuts Down "Rubicon"
Starbucks to develop coffee farm in China
Minn.'s Pawlenty ups challenge to fed health law
Clinton, Netanyahu Reiterate Commitment To Middle East Peace Talks
Taiwan regulator: hot money measures working
Disappearance Of 4 People Leads To Ohio College Lockdown
Effects Of Alcohol Go Far Beyond Liver Damage
Philippines seeks removal from aviation blacklists
Visiting Netanyahu Hold Middle East Talks With Clinton In New York
Sherri Shepherd, Melanie Griffith Among Guest Stars For Hot In Cleveland
China shares see biggest fall in 14 months
Taylor Swift, Miley Cyrus Added To AMAs Line-Up
G20 leaders endorse sweeping reform of IMF
Robert De Niro To Receive Golden Globe Lifetime Achievement Honor
S.Korea MP puts in foreign tax bond revision bill
Deathly Hallows conjures up holiday movie season
|
Garfield creator apologizes for Veterans Day strip
|
Japan mobile phone app takes photos, counts calories
Obama administration to target Internet privacy: report
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights