InfoAnda - Terror trials differ in civilian, military courts

Pakistanis angry over detentions in Times Sq. case
Monday, May 24, 2010
ISLAMABAD – Relatives of three men detained by Pakistan for alleged links to the suspect in the attempted Times Square bombing say the men are innocent.
They

Taiwan denies boycotting Australian film festival
Thursday, August 6, 2009

AFP - Thursday, August 6TAIPEI (AFP) - - Taiwan's Beijing-friendly government on Wednesday denied boycotting an Australian film festival amid a row over the e

Merkel's support dips, regional ally resigns International
Thursday, September 3, 2009

By Sarah Marsh and Noah Barkin

BERLIN (Reuters) - Chancellor Angela Merkel suffered a double blow on Thursday as a senior party ally in east German

Minister seeks closure of anti-Berlusconi websites
Wednesday, December 16, 2009
ROME (AFP) - – The Italian government moved Tuesday to close down Internet sites encouraging further violence against Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, who

Asian markets mixed after Wall Street rally
Wednesday, March 18, 2009

By ELAINE KURTENBACH,AP Business Writer AP - Wednesday, March 18SHANGHAI - Asia's stock market rally seemed to be running out of steam Wednesday, despite an

Ryan Couture suffers upset loss at Strikeforce Challangers | 25 June 2011
Putin should not run in 2012 vote: Medvedev aide | | 22 October 2010
S.Korean star found dead in apparent suicide | 30 June 2010

U.S. Ad Spending Hits $63 Billion In First Half Of 2010 | 14 September 2010

Forum Views () Forum Replies ()

Read more with google mobile : Terror trials differ in civilian, military courts

Yahoo! My Yahoo! Mail More Yahoo! Services Account Options New User? Sign Up Sign In Help Yahoo! Search web search Home Singapore Asia Pacific World Business Entertainment Sports Technology Africa Europe Latin America Middle East North America Terror trials differ in civilian, military courts By MARK SHERMAN,Associated Press Writer - Sunday, November 22 Send IM Story Print WASHINGTON – The federal courts and military tribunals that will prosecute suspected terrorists vary sharply in their independence, public stature and use of evidence. But the Obama administration has so far offered no clear-cut rationale for how it chooses which system will try a detainee. The fuzzy line drawn by the administration has made it easier for critics on both the left and right to assert that no firm legal principle is guiding the choices. The administration has said similarly situated suspects can be tried in either system, while others may still be held without trial because there is insufficient evidence for either proceeding, but they are considered too dangerous to release. "I think the Obama administration is trying to straddle this debate between whether we should approach al-Qaida as a problem of massive-scale criminality or as a problem of war," said Matthew Waxman, a former Bush administration State Department and Pentagon official now at Columbia University law school. Indeed, on Capitol Hill last Wednesday, Attorney General Eric Holder testified, "The 9/11 attacks were both an act of war and a violation of our federal criminal law, and they could have been prosecuted in either federal courts or military commissions." The administration is sending professed Sept. 11 mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and four alleged henchmen to a civilian trial in New York, while a suspect in the USS Cole bombing in 2000 and four other terror suspects will be tried by military commissions. The major differences between the systems are the federal judiciary's independence, rooted in the Constitution and lifetime appointments of judges, and the relaxed rules for admitting evidence in military tribunals. Federal courts bar evidence obtained by coercion. And the new law regarding military commissions that President Barack Obama signed last month forbids evidence derived from torture and other harsh interrogation techniques. But the commissions still have rules that allow greater use of hearsay testimony and, in some instances, could permit the introduction of coerced testimony. Military judges ultimately will decide what evidence can be admitted, but the new law allows statements made by defendants to be used even if they are not given voluntarily in certain circumstances, including in combat situations. Written witness statements, rather than live testimony that is subject to cross-examination, also can be admitted by military judges. The larger issue, for some civil libertarians, is what the American Civil Liberties Union's Jonathan Hafetz called a "legitimacy deficit." The commissions set up under President George W. Bush to try terrorism detainees have been revised several times based on Supreme Court decisions and acts of Congress that moved their rules and procedures closer to federal courts. "But they just don't have the credibility and never will have the credibility that federal courts have," Hafetz said. Joanne Mariner, director of the terrorism and counterterrorism program at Human Rights Watch, said another indication of the reduced stature of the commissions is that, by law, they can never be used to try U.S. citizens. "The federal courts are a co-equal branch of government and judges are constitutionally protected from interference. That is really important in politically charged and high-profile cases," Mariner said. "Military commission judges and prosecutors have no such protection." On the other hand, supporters of the military tribunals say they provide sufficient protections for accused terrorists. Moreover, they say, the Sept. 11 attack is a classic war crime _ the mass murder of civilians _ for which military tribunals have traditionally been used. "Other things being equal, you would think that targeting civilians makes the crime more grave," said Gregory G. Katsas, a Bush Justice Department official. "If you don't try Khalid Sheikh Mohammed by military commission, I don't know who you try." A host of leading Republicans, including Bush's last attorney general, Michael Mukasey, and former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani, have said the 9/11 defendants should be tried by military tribunal. The administration appears to have made pragmatic and political choices after determining that it is likely to win convictions in a civilian trial of the alleged Sept. 11 plotters, but seems less sure of its prospects if suspects from other attacks were tried in federal court. Holder hinted at this balancing act in his Senate Judiciary Committee testimony. "I am a prosecutor, and as a prosecutor my top priority was simply to select the venue where the government will have the greatest opportunity to present the strongest case in the best forum," he said, while rejecting senators' assertions that convictions are easier in military commissions. But he also said those who attacked a civilian target on U.S. soil were being sent to a civilian federal court and those who attacked or plotted against military targets abroad were going before tribunals. Holder's formulation puts the U.S. in the position of distinguishing between American interests based on which government agency was attacked. The attack on a Navy warship, the Cole, is to be handled by military commission, while the bombings of U.S. embassies in Africa in 1998 have been prosecuted by successive administrations in federal court. Waxman said that it is unlikely al-Qaida makes that distinction. "We're talking about a transnational terrorist network whose criminality extends across borders," he said. "The scene of the crime is global." The lack of a clear explanation of the administration's choice has led some legal experts to conclude federal courts will be used when convictions seem assured and commissions will handle cases where evidence is weaker or more difficult to get past a federal judge. "It somewhat supports the idea that if we can't make the case, we'll send them to a second-class system, which is the military commission," said Laura Olson, senior counsel at The Constitution Project, which objects to using military tribunals. This two-tiered system may not entirely satisfy civil libertarians who want the administration to abandon the commissions or the Republican-led opposition in Congress that objects to giving Mohammed and the others their day in federal court. But it could prove a viable approach that both avoids the credibility problems of using commissions for the highest visibility cases and the risk of acquittals if less devastating attacks were tried in civilian courts, said University of Chicago law professor Eric Posner. "This moderate view that avoids the two extremes may be very appealing to people in the long run," Posner said. Recommend Send IM Story Print Related Articles Italian police arrest 2 linked to Mumbai attacks AP - Sunday, November 22 NC man gets life in prison for woman's fatal scare AP - Sunday, November 22 McCain links political correctness to shootings AP - Sunday, November 22 Mental health cases tax police, emergency workers AP - Sunday, November 22 59 and counting: Health care bill nears test vote AP - 1 hour 40 minutes ago News Search Top Stories Obama health drive faces critical vote Putin backs Medvedev's call for Russia modernisation First Air France A380 reaches New York CERN atom-smasher restarts after 14-month hiatus: official Crisis fallout still in 'first half': forum More Top Stories » ADVERTISEMENT Most Popular Most Viewed Most Recommended First Air France A380 reaches New York CERN atom-smasher restarts after 14-month hiatus: official Dubai growing at five percent pace: economy tsar Crisis fallout still in 'first half': forum Giant atom-smasher poised for restart: CERN More Most Viewed » Alcohol helps cut heart disease risk for men: study More Most Recommended » Elsewhere on Yahoo! Financial news on Yahoo! Finance Stars and latest movies Best travel destinations More on Yahoo! News Home Singapore Asia Pacific World Business Entertainment Sports Technology Subscribe to our news feeds Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS » More news feeds | What are news feeds? Also on Yahoo Answers Groups Mail Messenger Mobile Travel Finance Movies Sports Games » All Yahoo! Services Site Highlights Singapore Full Coverage Most Popular Asia Entertainment Photos Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved. Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Community | Intellectual Property Rights Policy | Help

Other News on Sunday, 22 November 2009
Iran to hold war games to protect nuclear sites
Putin backs Medvedev's call for Russia modernisation
Obama health drive faces critical vote
Iraq parliament struggles over elusive vote deal
Sri Lanka to open refugee camps ahead of polls | International |
Sri Lanka to release 136,000 Tamil war refugees
EPA: Uranium from polluted mine in Nev. wells
Rocket hits outside luxury hotel in Afghan capital
NC man gets life in prison for woman's fatal scare
Australia issues 'catastrophic' alerts as fires rage
59 and counting: Health care bill nears test vote
Afghan road builder's dream thwarted by violence
Chicago losing glitz when Winfrey goes off the air
China says 42 dead, 66 trapped in mine explosion
Hawaii anxiously watching year-end tuna supply
Atlantis astronauts take 2nd spacewalk of mission
Security forces: Blast near Kabul's Serena Hotel
AP reporter caught up in Stalin family's agony
3 men blow themselves up in Pakistani Kashmir
Italy arrests Pakistanis suspected of Mumbai links
Terror trials differ in civilian, military courts
Elderly US couple pleads guilty in Cuba spy case
Twilight sequel sets new opening-day record | Entertainment |
Singer Robbie Williams to court investors: report | Entertainment |
Singer Robbie Williams to court investors: report
"Twilight" sequel sets new opening-day record
Losing Winfrey would be big blow for Second City
German auction house pulls disputed painting
Michael Jackson glove among items at music auction
Israel-Palestinian conflict kills 8,900 in 20yrs: NGO
EU recession over, but sharp contrasts in east
Iran to hold war games to protect nuclear facilities | International |
American Express takes aim at PayPal with Revolution
Israeli aircraft strike tunnels, arms factories
Swine flu vaccine effective despite mutations: experts
Anglican leader, pope meet amid tensions
China mine explosion death toll reaches 87 | International |
Austrian sets up online cattle auctions
US 'helps build anti-Taliban militias' in Afghanistan
Colombia's Uribe seeks to ease Venezuela tensions | International |
Belgian ex-premier meets party chiefs as hunt begins for new PM
Israeli planes strike targets in Gaza
W.Sahara activist refuses Madrid offer of refugee status
Israeli planes strike targets in Gaza | International |
Iran to hold war games to protect nuclear facilities
Pressure for progress at talks on rebel Karabakh | International |
Rhodes Scholars named for 2010
Atheist student groups flower on college campuses
2nd autopsy for Malaysian opposition aide: lawyer
Indonesian ferry with over 200 people sinks: police
UC Santa Cruz protesters still occupy building
Biden says Senate handed Obama a big victory
Death toll in China mine disaster rises to 87: media
Groth to play tennis for Australia after citizenship
Passenger charged in fatal stabbing on NYC subway
N.Korean leader inspects security forces
Healthcare bill passes first U.S. Senate test
Korean death row inmate dies after suicide attempt
Obama health drive clears key Senate hurdle
Motown caps 50th anniversary with hometown gala
Mumbai still vulnerable 1 year after terror attack
4 injured in San Francisco cable car accident
Malaysian activist's body exhumed for 2nd autopsy
Separated twins beat the odds
Japanese temple resorts to manga to woo visitors
Top S.Korea think-tank sees 2010 GDP at 8-yr high
South Koreans to get Apple's iPhone this week
IPhone to go on sale in South Korea
Jackson's glove sells for $350,000 at auction | Entertainment |
Crisis forcing hard-up Spaniards to sell their hair
Desperate retailers seek holiday season rescue
Motown caps 50th anniversary with hometown gala
International Emmys to honor David Frost
Botswana tries spicy solution to keep elephants at bay
Developing: Senate Democrats Secure Votes To Prevent Republican Healthcare Filibuster
Jacko 'moonwalk' glove sells for 350,000 dollars
Mobile Home Fire Kills 5 In Central Florida
Sarandon gets lifetime achievement award at Stockholm film fest
Smiling on Facebook costs Canadian her insurance
French designer wolfs down US doggy rags
Pope in landmark meeting with artists in Sistine Chapel
Anesthetic Spray Seen As Cure For Premature Ejaculation
U.S. Customs Agents Arrest Man With 15 Lizards Strapped To Body
Thousands Of Bongs Seized in Los Angeles
Georgia Plans To Lay Bulldog Mascot To Rest
Albinos In Africa Being Hunted For Their Human Body Parts To Be Used In Witchraft Concoctions
Iran releases ex-official on bail in mass trial
Crisis forcing hard-up Spaniards to sell their hair
Israeli president plays down settlement work | International |
Iranian reformer freed on $700,000 bail
Iraqi parliament fails to reach election deal | International |
Former Iran VP released on bail
Overloaded Indonesian ferry sinks; 4 dead, most survive | International |
Iranian reformer freed on $700,000 bail: report | International |
Ahmadinejad heads to nuclear-backers Brazil, Venezuela
Alleged Iraq bombers offer confessions
Pirates hijack Greek-owned bulk carrier off Yemen | International |
Bomb blasts kill six, wound 40 in India's northeast | International |
Israeli president to Egypt for talks with Mubarak
Militants could be invited to Afghan Jirga | International |
Ahmadinejad leaves for tour including Brazil, Venezuela
Khmer Rouge prison chief anxious as trial ends
Indonesian ferry sinks; 9 dead, some 230 rescued
CORRECTS RI Bishop-Kennedy
AP NewsAlert
Overloaded Indonesian ferry sinks; 4 dead, most survive
South Korea mass murderer hangs himself in cell
Police identify gunman in deadly Saipan rampage
2 bomb blasts leave 7 dead, 52 wounded in India
Indonesian passenger ferry sinks with 242 aboard
Bomb blasts kill six, wound 40 in India's northeast
Suspected pirates kidnap 3 crewmen in Philippines
Afghan official: 5 border security guards killed
India's Reliance announces bid for LyondellBasell
China could grow 10 pct in fourth quarter: report
AirAsia to tap Southeast Asian capital market
Report: Indonesian passenger ferry sinks with 228
Beirut sets out to woo back shoppers
Pistols, Tasers, assault rifles sell fast at US show
Jackson's glove sells for $350,000 at auction
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
UC Students Protest Tuition Hike
Taliban suffocate Pakistan Buddhist heritage
Man Stabbed To Death After Argument Over NYC Subway Seat
Senior U.S. Special Operations Commander Makes Security Visit To Bangladesh
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights

USD EUR - 1 year graph		BlogMeter 1.01