Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Conflict seen between 2 deals for 9/11 responders
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Conflict seen between 2 deals for 9/11 responders
By DAVID B. CARUSO,Associated Press Writer -
Friday, June 11
Send
IM Story
Print
NEW YORK – Thousands of 9/11 rescue and recovery workers suing New York City over their exposure to clouds of pulverized glass and cement at the World Trade Center site may have a tough choice between two deals in the weeks ahead.
Do they take a share of a new settlement worth up to $713 million, or hold out for a second, potentially more lucrative option _ a federal bill that could pay billions to people who die or become disabled because of illnesses caused by trade center ash?
That decision could be a difficult one for responders like former police officer Glen Klein, one of more than 10,000 cops, firefighters and construction workers with pending lawsuits.
"It is incredibly unfair to put people in this position," said Klein, who developed asthma and other health problems after working long hours in the rubble. "It's amazing, really, that it's even come to this, almost a decade after 9/11."
Lawyers who crafted the legal pact approved on Thursday urged plaintiffs to take the deal and not pin their hopes on a federal bill.
U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein, who endorsed the settlement, exhorted responders not to reject the settlement because of something Congress might or might not do.
"There is no better deal. This is the deal on the table," he said. "People can think, maybe Congress will do something. It's possible. But the old saw applies: The bird in the hand is better than two in the bush."
The two efforts to compensate sick ground zero workers are on a collision course because of a rule intended to prevent double dipping _ getting paid twice by the government for the same injury.
Congress is poised to consider legislation this summer that would reopen the 9/11 victim compensation fund and pay up to $8.2 billion to people whose health has been ruined by environmental damage caused by the attacks.
The bill, however, contains a tough restriction: It bars anyone from receiving a payment if they previously successfully had sued the city over their health.
Several lawyers involved in the case called on lawmakers to eliminate the potential conflict by changing the bill.
Marc Bern, a senior partner in the law firm representing most plaintiffs, said lawmakers could simply reduce any federal award by whatever amount a responder already had received in the settlement.
"Don't make the first responders gamble with a choice that is not a choice," said Nicholas Papain, whose firm represents about 640 firefighters. "I ask them to fix it, now that this settlement is real."
U.S. Rep. Carolyn Maloney, a leading sponsor of the bill, said Congress will not support a measure that allows responders to participate in both programs. Maloney, D-N.Y., said the changes suggested by the lawyers "would put the bill in serious jeopardy.
"Regretfully, it would be unprecedented to allow those who settle a case to go back and seek additional compensation for the same case," she said in an e-mail to The Associated Press. "Those deciding whether or not to agree to the revised settlement announced today should do so on the merits of the settlement itself and not on the promise of change to the legislation."
She added that the bill's supporters hope to have a decision in Congress by the anniversary of the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, which would give responders just enough time to decide which program was best for them.
The deadline to join the settlement is Sept. 30.
After years of inaction, a key House committee signed off on the measure last month, clearing the way for it to move to the House floor. But its success remains in doubt, in part because of its enormous cost. The proposal has yet to budge in the Senate.
The legal settlement faces a big hurdle, too. For it to take effect, 95 percent of the responders must opt in. If fewer than that say yes, the deal dies.
Kenneth Feinberg, the former special master of the federal 9/11 victim compensation fund, has urged Congress for years to reopen the program to cover people with new health ailments, but on Thursday he was among those urging people to accept the settlement now.
"What is the alternative? To wait? You're waiting for Godot. You've waited enough," he said.
Under the legal deal, individual payments are to be based on the severity of each person's illness, and the likelihood that it might have been cased by trade center dust.
Payments would range from a minimum of $3,250, for people who aren't sick but worry they could fall ill in the future, to as much as $1.5 million to people who have died. Nonsmokers disabled by severe asthma might get between $800,000 and $1 million.
Feinberg has been appointed to hear appeals of any awards responders believe are too low.
It is unclear whether the federal program would offer more. It contains far more money for claims but could also cover thousands more people who never joined the lawsuits.
The House bill would also authorize up to $5.1 billion to cover the future medical treatment of 9/11 responders. That part of the legislation would be open to all, regardless of whether they participate in the legal settlement.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Gunmen kill 19 at Mexican rehab center AFP - 40 minutes ago
Mandela uncertain on W.Cup opener after family tragedy AFP - Friday, June 11
Ethnic clashes in south Kyrgyzstan leave 37 dead AFP - 1 hour 50 minutes ago
Pope begs forgiveness for church sex scandal AFP - Saturday, June 12
Iran's Ahmadinejad says Israel is 'doomed' AFP - Saturday, June 12
News Search
Top Stories
Kyrgyzstan imposes emergency as clashes kill 37
Ahmadinejad blasts US, says Israel is 'doomed'
Obama has made 'big mistake' with Iran: Ahmadinejad
Pope begs forgiveness for 'abuse of the little ones'
Missing US yacht girl found safe in Indian Ocean
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Abu Dhabi to build 'world's largest' solar plant
Missing US yacht girl found safe in Indian Ocean
BP chairman summoned to Obama meeting over oil spill
On the brink of extinction, tigers need man as never before
US pressure on BP sends share price tumbling
More Most Viewed »
Hubble catches planet being devoured by its star
The point about pain: New study sheds light on acupuncture
Clashes as Israeli forces storm Gaza aid boat: Hamas TV
Egypt unearths tomb of pharaonic army chief
Physicists solve mystery of missing neutrinos
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
World Cup 2010
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Friday, 11 June 2010 Defiant Iran could downgrade ties with UN atomic watchdog
Putin visits France amid warship row
China gets tough on World Cup gambling
Ex-workmate slams Kerviel's 'stratospheric' trades
Google drops background images on homepage amid outcry
US trade gap widens as Chinese imports surge
Dozens of Chinese websites warned over porn: state media
Grisly Afghan attack claims 40 lives, raises fear
Abbas: Hope eroding for two-state Mideast solution
|
Serbians flock en masse to online rich list
Iraqi Shi'ite blocs announce merger
|
China reverses stance with Iran sanctions support
Swiss national Goeldi freed from Libya jail-lawyer
|
China wants more dialogue on Iran nuclear issue
Slums, displaced show challenges for Colombia leader
|
Japan fail to get boost after being held by Zimbabwe
China, Russia seek new Iran nuclear talks
US drone strike kills three in Pakistan: officials
US fears for Myanmar refugees ahead of polls
US official: Fair Myanmar vote a must for refugees
Kewell fit and "up for" German battle
Australia pull out of 2018 World Cup bid
China's currency policy dampening global reforms: US
Thai PM reopens probe into Thaksin's 'war on drugs'
Blatter joins Twitterati in time for World Cup
|
China trade surplus soars in May on export boom
Global markets surge on upbeat growth prospects
Nigerian villagers face child deaths for gold digging
Egypt to make Alexandria first smoke-free city
China's currency policy threatens global reforms: US
Mandela leads slew of big stars at World Cup opener
Shiseido sees rising labour costs in China
Red, La Cage lead tight race for Tony Awards
|
Report details suicide attempt by Larry King's wife
|
Edinburgh Fringe grows bigger than ever
|
Thousands rock Soweto at World Cup concert
|
Shawn Johnson tells court she feared accused stalker
|
Iran leader in China after about-face on sanctions
Iran defies sanctions as West plans harsher measures
|
Putin visits France amid warship row
Twitter launches own site for World Cup
Rescue under way for missing US sailor, 16
FBI opens probe into hack of AT&T website
BP chairman summoned to Obama meeting over oil spill
Kyrgyzstan says 17 killed, 201 wounded in riots
|
Katy Perry Earns Second #1 With "California Gurls"
US more than doubles oil leak estimate
Twitter buys Web analytics firm
Abbas: Hope eroding for two-state Mideast solution
|
Colombia's Santos has strong lead for runoff: poll
|
"Girl With The Dragon Tattoo" Coming To DVD
Obama Congratulates Aquino As New Philippine Leader
Japan PM warns of eventual default if debt not fixed
|
Guantanamo Prisoners Focus of Habeas Report Released By Former FBI Director
Army Secretary Axes Arlington Cemetery Officials Over Burial Anomalies
Heads dumped in Guatemala capital
|
Dell Announces Settlement Talks With SEC Over Intel Relationship
On the brink of extinction, tigers need man as never before
Mandela relative's death clouds Cup start
|
BREAKING NEWS: Indian Team Completes Access To Mumbai Terror Suspect David Headley
U.S. Markets Rise On Foreign Growth Prospects
Calderon demands probe of U.S. border deaths
|
"Glee" To Debut Clothing, Games, Books And More This Fall
U.S. Senate Threatens China With Economic Sanctions Over Trade Imbalance
Hope for two-state solution 'beginning to erode': Abbas
Obama urges support for Iranian 'freedom'
Mexican president demands US probe of teen's death
Rare photo of slave children found in NC attic
Missing US yacht girl found safe in Indian Ocean
Minimum and maximum temperatures in Celsius
US casino cheat knows all the tricks of the trade
China police bust huge counterfeit ring
FBI begins probe into AT&T iPad security breach
|
Chinese man convicted for selling son on Internet
Iran's Ahmadinejad blasts nuclear powers on China visit
U.S. industry eyes win in IT trade case versus EU
|
News
Honda says two China plants to resume production
Britain's Standard Chartered lists in Mumbai
'US drone strike kills 3 militants in Pakistan'
China's inflation outstrips government target
Taiwan court cuts ex president's jail term
Japan PM: 'risk of collapse' from debt mountain
New Japan govt's corporate tax cut plans: minister
North Korea eye toppling mighty Brazil
US: China currency policy threatens global reforms
Japanese minister to resign over postal reform
Fujitsu, Toshiba to merge mobile operations
Designer from Nepal who cracked New York
India April factory production jumps 17.6 percent
India April industrial production surged 17.6 pct
US casino cheating expert knows all the tricks of the trade
Designer from Nepal who cracked New York
And the winner is... Zulu sangoma reveals all
Scotland tops list for lifestyle health risks: study
Fourth Twilight film will be split in two
|
Rare exhibition of homosexual art opens in Warsaw
Obama Congratulates Aquino As New Philippine Leader
Taiwan pulls movies from Shanghai festival
How much does movie marketing matter?
|
U.S. Teen Sailor In Solo Circumnavigation Bid Lost At Sea
Special Report: Guy Hands, Citigroup and the fight for EMI
|
Army Secretary Axes Arlington Cemetery Officials Over Burial Anomalies
Oldest Leather Shoe Found In Armenia Is 5,500 Years Old
Katy Perry heats up U.S. singles chart
|
No Parking Sign Goes Up In Front Of Park Car Ticketed Driver To Dispute Fine In Court
Woman Having Sex On Picnic Table Charged With Adultery, Public Lewdness
World Cup poses a challenge for studios
|
Joan Rivers documentary provides laughs, poignancy
|
US Silent Films Come Home From New Zealand
Texas Principal Fired For Child Neglect
Karate Kid and A-Team updates duel at box office
|
Study: Personality Shown To Predict Fertility
Carpenters lead guitarist Tony Peluso dies
|
Files Released In Roethlisberger Sex Assault Investigation
Bomb kills 9 in Afghan south: provincial official
Pope begs forgiveness for 'abuse of the little ones'
Aborigines to view Japanese spacecraft on landing
2 US troops, 11 Afghan civilians killed in south
Iraq suicide bomb kills 2 U.S. soldiers, 3 Iraqis
|
Kyrgyzstan imposes emergency as clashes kill 37
Ahmadinejad calls UN resolution 'worthless paper'
Ahmadinejad blasts US, says Israel is 'doomed'
Katy Perry Earns Second #1 With "California Gurls"
Obama has made 'big mistake' with Iran: Ahmadinejad
Ahmadinejad calls resolution 'worthless paper'
Iran slams US after China about-face on sanctions
U.S., NATO urge patience with slow Afghan progress
|
9 Afghan civilians killed by mine blast in south
9 Afghan civilians killed in mine blast
Iceland passes gay marriage law in unanimous vote
|
Somali pirates free British-flagged ship
|
Iran says U.S. kidnaps, illegally detains Iranians
|
Pope begs forgiveness for sexual abuse scandal
|
Attack on military convoy injures 14 in east Turkey
|
China sentences school attacker to death
Sudanese killers of US envoy 'escape from prison'
Police in China's Xinjiang hold anti-riot exercise
Conflict seen between 2 deals for 9/11 responders
S.Korea, Russia probe rocket failure
Farm Worker Pleads Not Guilty To 12 Animal Abuse Counts
Interview: Bill Clinton to Dems, 'Never give up'
Actress Ashley Judd Invites Obama To Witness Rape Of Appalachia
Japanese minister resigns over vexed postal issue
CT Man Trapped Under Furnace Nearly Amputates Own Arm In Escape Bid
Botox Found To Ease Pain Of Nerve Disorder
Federal Agents Seize Imported Chinese Honey
Murder Trial Of Former BART Officer Begins
S.Korea to brief UN on ship sinking
Summit Officially Splits "Breaking Dawn" Into 2 Films
Wall Street rally pushes Asian markets higher
"Look Who's Talking" To Make Nick At Nite Debut
Motorola, RIM end licensing dispute
|
India's industrial output up 17.6 percent
Reliance Ind. pays $1B for India broadband winner
India to make Bollywood Hitler movie
Reliance Industries pays $1 billion for Infotel
UK hip-hop on verge of breaking U.S. :Diddy
|
Rapper Dr. Dre loses claims against former label
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights