Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Lawsuit tests use of private e-mail for public business
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Lawsuit tests use of private e-mail for public business
Reuters - Saturday, March 5
Send
IM Story
Print
NEW YORK, March 4 - A lawsuit filed against the mayor and city council of Austin will test whether public officials in Texas can use their private e-mail accounts to hide communication about government affairs from public scrutiny.
Rulings in similar cases in other states have generally found in favor of public disclosure.
The suit, filed on Tuesday in state District Court in Travis County by the Austin Bulldog, a local news website, alleges that members of the Austin City Council broke open-records laws by failing to release private e-mails, text and instant messages that relate to city business.
The plaintiffs argued that Texas law requires city employees and officials to turn over local government records even when they're written on personal devices. "We believe that technologies like e-mails, instant messaging have been misused, and record retention laws haven't been enforced," said Bill Aleshire, an attorney for the plaintiff and a partner at Riggs, Aleshire & Ray in Austin. "City employees and officials have been transacting government in the shadows by using their own personal equipment."
Austin city spokesman Doug Matthews declined to respond to specific allegations in the case, but said that Texas law is unclear on which electronic communications are subject to disclosure laws. He pointed to three related cases currently pending in the state. "We're not alone in this," said Matthews. "In fact, statewide it remains an open question because the state law doesn't address private text and e-mail messages."
The Austin Bulldog filed a public information request in January for copies of all written communication between Austin City Council members and the mayor in 2010. The city delivered some e-mails last week, but the Bulldog said the city did not release all communications, including those relating to city business from council members' personal phones and e-mail addresses.
The suit said city officials have used private e-mail and phone accounts to "keep substantive communications" away from public view. In one example cited in the suit, a council member asked a constituent to switch to the councillor's personal e-mail address to continue discussing tax subsidies for a shopping center.
It further alleged that the city's internal instant-messaging platform is a "secret messaging system established to avoid retention of certain public records." The complaint was based on the Texas Public Information Act and the Local Government Records Act, which prohibits destroying or intentionally withholding communications of public record. Most states have some form of open-record legislation that defines retention requirements and access procedures for public records.
In recent years, courts have ruled in favor of public disclosure, said Benjamin Wright, a Dallas-based attorney who specializes in data security law. He cited a 2007 case in which a Kentucky judge required the state government to turn over copies of e-mails between two state employees, and an Arizona case the same year in which that state's Supreme Court held that a trial judge must decide whether a county official's e-mails were private. He also pointed to a 2008 decision by the Ohio Supreme Court that deleted e-mails of county commissioners must be recovered.
This article first appeared on Westlaw News & Insight
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
US-TECH Summary Reuters - Saturday, March 5
Brazil at heart of Google's Latin America strategy Reuters - Saturday, March 5
Lawsuit tests use of private e-mail for public business Reuters - Saturday, March 5
CBS buys online video guide Clicker Media AFP - Saturday, March 5
AT&T CFO Lindner retiring, Stephens to replace him Reuters - Saturday, March 5
News Search
Top Stories
Fall in US unemployment sparks optimism
British minister says unrest can double oil prices
Charlie Sheen latest: 'I'm Jewish, off to Haiti'
African leaders urge end to I. Coast killing
EU conservatives want strong euro, open on Irish rates
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
World's sixth mass extinction may be underway: study
Young Mexican female police chief seeks US asylum
Libya: live report
NASA Earth observation satellite fails to reach orbit
World can handle choked oil supplies: Geithner
More Most Viewed »
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2011 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Saturday, 5 March 2011 Police clash with Kadhafi opponents in Tripoli
Internet titans to meet, advise G8: source
Libya: live report
Euro-socialists call for lower EU loan rates
N. Korea refuses repatriations in row with South
Iditarod Race goes high tech with GPS devices
Fall in US unemployment sparks optimism
Egypt's new PM in Tahrir Square
Libyan deputy minister says government accepts Chavez plan
|
NASA Earth observation satellite fails to reach orbit
Anti-Gaddafi rebels, government dispute oil town control
|
New Egypt PM shows popular touch in Tahrir Square
|
Grief-stricken Pakistani Christians bury slain minister
Samsung sees iPad 2 thinness, price as challenge
Protesters across Oman demand reform, jobs
|
Fire rages through Mumbai slum
Sony to appeal Netherlands PS3s seizure in LG dispute
Thousands flee Sudan's Abyei flashpoint: aid group
|
Libyan leader Gadhafi calls Sri Lankan president
Dispute stalls Dutch PlayStation 3 shipment
More Shi'ite protests in Saudi oil region
|
Myanmar democracy group slams military fund
EU drops Hollywood studios probe
U.S. contractor goes on trial in Cuba
Myanmar pro-democracy group slams govt's budget
Child star of Oscar-winning film faces deportation
Britney's single "leaks," some predict a club hit
CBS acquires Web video guide, hires the top exec
|
Dior puts Galliano behind it at emotional Paris show
Georgia in US dispute over Stalin's favourite wine
EU drops Hollywood studios probe
Pakistani stocks end up; rupee firms; o/n rates down
Sony PlayStation 3 consoles held in Netherlands
Fashion pack turn out in support of Dior
EU exec closes antitrust probe into Hollywood studios
Monk in Bhutan jailed for having tobacco
Philippine blogger stirs a fashion revolution
Orange denies Tunisia corruption allegations
US-TECH Summary
CBS acquires Web video guide, hires the top exec
FT exec urges publishers to charge for web content
Samsung sees iPad 2 thinness, price as challenge
Character actor, director Frank Alesia dies
|
China prepares 4G mobile network: state media
Layoffs expected after AOL's Huff Post buy
Jeff Beck, Rod Stewart eye radical blues album
|
Grilled cheese, meatballs bid for Next Great Restaurant
|
SirusXM to launch station devoted to Charlie Sheen
|
Sony to appeal Netherlands PS3s seizure in LG dispute
Dispute stalls Dutch PlayStation 3 shipment
British minister says unrest can double oil prices
EU conservatives want strong euro, open on Irish rates
Rebels 'hold' key refinery town as many killed
Lawsuit tests use of private e-mail for public business
Georgia criticises Russia for not agreeing against force
Gaddafi forces surge in west Libya, rebels gain in east
|
Charlie Sheen latest: 'I'm Jewish, off to Haiti'
New Egypt PM shows popular touch in Tahrir Square
Japan to launch 'Hayabusa' bullet train
African leaders urge end to I. Coast killing
Libyan Internet service cut again: monitors
U.S., Sweden to push U.N. rights body to act on Iran
China internal security spending jumps past army budget
|
Bomb kills NATO service member in Afghanistan
North Korea heir formally invited to China
Aid contractor Gross goes on trial in Cuba
|
Thousands of Iraqis defy curbs to protest
New Egypt PM shows popular touch in Tahrir Square
|
Ivory Coast pays government workers as AU mediators stall
|
N.Korea heir formally invited to China
China state media warn against protest calls in capital
U.S. and Sweden to push U.N. rights body to act on Iran
|
Vote counting starts after Samoa election
Thousands expected for Sydney Gay Mardi Gras
U.S. aid contractor Gross goes on trial in Cuba
China says it will tackle inflation, boost incomes
American goes on trial in Cuba on spy charges
Sydney's Mardi Gras hits on same-sex marriage
Nepal's former Prime Minister Bhattarai dies at 87
Manigat seeks to stop influx of criminals to Haiti
Taiwan executes 5 murderers
Hong Kong picks Foster for $2.8 billion arts hub
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Accused Arizona shooter Loughner charged in new indictment
"For Colored Girls", Perry win big at Image Awards
Japan launches 'Hayabusa' bullet train
Bali observes Day of Silence for Hindu new year
Cary Elwes joins "Wonder Woman" pilot
Brazil at heart of Google's Latin America strategy
|
"Spider-Man" slapped with new safety violations
Twitter share auction suggests $7.7 billion valuation
|
Doobie Brothers are takin' it to country's streets
RIM to find new marketing chief to revive its brand
|
Lawsuit tests use of private e-mail for public business
|
AT&T CFO Lindner retiring, Stephens to replace him
|
Brazil at heart of Google's Latin America strategy
CBS buys online video guide Clicker Media
AT&T CFO Lindner retiring, Stephens to replace him
For Colored Girls, Perry win big at Image Awards
|
David Arquette hurt but okay after car crash
|
Charlie Sheen to get animated special on Spike TV
|
Spider-Man slapped with new safety violations
|
Doobie Brothers are takin' it to country's streets
|
Cary Elwes joins Wonder Woman pilot
|
Nostalgic Russians venerate Stalin on anniversary
Egypt ex-interior minister denies criminal charges
Berlusconi to attend all hearings in his trials
Trial opens of Egypt ex-interior minister
Saudi Arabia says won't tolerate protests
|
Yemen President reiterates to stay in power until 2013
|
U.N. force in Ivory Coast to be reinforced: official
|
State security building torched in Cairo: sources
|
Human Rights Watch slams journalists' arrests in Turkey
|
Japan foreign minister says won't quit
Leader of Russia's Chechnya gets new 5-year term
|
Key India coalition ally withdraws from government
|
Spokesman: China's military budget rise 'no threat'
Asean to hold roadshow in the US
Myanmar pilots among 6 dead in Russia crash
|
1,000 Thais missing in Libya
Philippine rebels burn bus drivers to death: police
Pakistan aims to keep deficit at 5 pct of GDP -finmin
Sony PlayStation 3 consoles held in Netherlands
Travellers shun capsule hotel
Tibetans swamp markets ahead of new year
Bali falls silent as Hindus mark Day of Silence
Taiwan executes five death row inmates
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights