">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Pirates were democrats, says scholar
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Search
Search:
Pirates were democrats, says scholar
AFP - Friday, June 19
WASHINGTON (AFP) - - Pirates have been long maligned and cursed as thieves and sea dogs, but according to one economist they formed vanguard capitalist democracies, with constitutions, elections and healthcare plans.
ADVERTISEMENT
With images of gun-toting Somali pirates recently aired on television screens across the world, Peter Leeson, has set himself the unenviable task of salvaging the reputations.
The economics professor at George Mason University outside the US capital, says he has found evidence that some 18th century pirates wrote down rules and principles which foreshadowed the US Constitution by decades.
"We have three or four surviving accounts of pirate constitutions," Leeson said.
Pirates had concluded through their rules that "we are going to use democracy to determine a lot of our decisions, we are going to split up the booty this way, we are going to establish a workers' compensation scheme, a system of social insurance," Leeson said.
One text, linked with Captain Bartholomew Roberts -- or "Black Bart," a Welsh pirate who prowled the Caribbean in the 18th century -- gives a clue into how structured pirate societies may have been.
"It has regulations on smoking, regulations on drinking, regulations on gambling, in addition to the sorts of normal rules that provide social order, such as prohibition on violence and theft and a means to enforce these things.
"It is different from other criminal organizations," he said pointing to the Sicilian Mafia's hierarchical power structure.
"On a pirate ship it is exactly the opposite. The leaders are only leaders by virtue of the fact that the guys on the bottom have selected them."
But if constitutionalism seems at odds with images of a grog-swilling life of high-seas pillage, then Leeson, in his book "The Invisible Hook," says economics -- and in particular Adam Smith's brand -- can explain a lot.
"They adopted those practices simply because it allowed them to profit," said Leeson.
"It does not take much thought to realize: 'Well, we are both thieves, you like stealing and I like stealing. We are both violent, so you like stabbing people and I like stabbing people.... We need some honor among thieves.'"
But true to violent stereotypes, punishments were severe -- lashings were common, although walking the plank was not, said Leeson.
"Marooning was also an important means of enforcement, as the pirates said 'to make someone the governor of his own island,' they would put you on an island with a pistol, one shot and a bottle of water. That was it," he said.
Pirates also employed a punishment known as "keel hauling," which would see an unfortunate soul dragged across the barnacled hull of a ship.
Still, along with proscriptive rules came sophisticated efforts to promote "good" behavior.
"In order to encourage their crew members to give it their all during battle... they need to incentivize people in some way, so they created a workers' compensation system.
"They would assign different values to different body parts. Each of these appendages would get a value according to how much they thought it was worth to them as a crew."
In one instance, injured or older crew members were even given a share of profits for as long as the group existed, despite being unable to take part in raids.
Unfortunately for today's ship owners, modern Somali pirates may be starting to replicate the system that made yesteryear's Caribbean pirates among the most successful criminals in history.
"They are starting to develop some private systems of governance that are similar to what early 18th century pirates had," said Leeson.
"They now have a traveling pirate court for example, they have created some rules to prevent theft and violence. You have enough members of the modern Somali pirate community to really make a society, an outlaw society."
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
1 user recommend
Enlarge Photo
Detained suspected pirates are seen aboard the Portuguese Frigate Corte Real off the coast of Somalia. Unfortunately for today's ship owners, modern Somali pirates may be starting to replicate the system that made yesteryear's Caribbean pirates among the most successful criminals in history.
Most Popular – Top Stories
Viewed
Clones of 9/11 hero dog unveiled in Los Angeles
Men's 'stiff upper lip' may explain cancer death rate
Obama signs note for girl who played hooky to see him
Climate change is happening 'here, now': US report
Airbus a big winner at Paris Air Show
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Thursday, 18 June 2009 Arabs largely silent on Iran unrest
Internet most popular information source: poll
Belfast racists force Romanians to hide in church
Iran accuses US of meddling after disputed vote
First-ever link between missing DNA and cancer: study
Google bows to pressure for German Street View
U.S., Israel seek clarity on settlement freeze
| International
|
Asia-US cable gateway ready by August: Philippine firm
Iran opposition presses protests despite crackdown
Time for 'new world order': Brazilian President
Jerusalem childrens' peace banner aiming for space
US cybersecurity chief warns of 'market' in malware
Tame US consumer prices dampen inflation concerns
Romanians flee Belfast homes after racist attacks
| International
|
Microsoft search still growing with Bing: comScore
More than 100,000 German students protest
| International
|
Iraq: suspect arrested in Sunni lawmaker's death
Energy bill advances in Senate
iPhone, iPod security flaws get 45 patches
| Technology
|
Sirius XM slated to launch iPhone app
| Technology
|
Internet most popular information source: poll
| Technology
|
NJ casino fined in brew-haha over mislabeled beer
4 charged in fatal NJ block party shooting
EPA Declares Public Health Emergency At Libby, MT Asbestos Site
Lee says North Korea must give up nukes
Obama Proposes Sweeping Regulatory Oversight Changes For Banks
Evacuations ordered in Texas train spill
Diplomats: Myanmar ready to host visit by UN chief
Four U.S. Banks Payback TARP, More To Follow
Shuttle launch delayed to July by hydrogen leak
Karzai defends VP pick criticized by rights groups
Medical Device Maker Synthes Indicted For Unapproved Trials Of Bone Cement
India says its ready to talk peace with Pakistan
Bid idled to draft Gov. Jindal for White House run
Missing PA Woman Found Unharmed In Trunk Of Her Car
Prison chief: Pol Pot ordered 4 Westerners killed
AP Sources: Better training urged in Afghan probe
Obama To Push Regulatory Reform; Sotomayor Meets With Senators
Taiwan's Ma denies China reunification drift
Judge Allows Republicans To Control New York Senate
AP Newsbreak: Mich. man says he may be missing boy
House Passes $106 Billion War Funding Bill
China, Russia say ties must flourish in economic crisis
NASA aims for unmanned moon rocket launch Thursday
North Korea Threatens "Merciless Military Strike" Against U.S.
Indonesia mine blast toll rises to 31: officials
Tame US consumer prices dampen inflation concerns
Obama To Provide Federal Benefits To Gay Couples
9/11 search dog cloned for former Canadian cop
Athletes come first for us, says Tokyo Olympic bid chairman
Tribesmen kill 28 Taliban militants in NW Pakistan
KFC plans China expansion as US sales fall
China's Wen says recovery at 'critical' stage: report
Japan economy has hit bottom: minister
Pakistani 6-mth T-bill cut-off yield at 12.4385 pct
Black Eyed Peas dominate U.S. charts
| Entertainment
|
Japan ups economic assessment
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Happy Together, again: rocker relives glory daze
| Entertainment
|
Happy Together, again: rocker relives glory daze
Chace Crawford is People's `hottest bachelor'
Sirius XM slated to launch iPhone app
| Entertainment
|
`Daily Show' correspondent Jones reports from Iran
Death toll from mine blast in Indonesia reaches 31
Judge halts Catcher in the Rye spin-off for now
| Entertainment
|
Recession turning Germans to sweets and snacks
Forty feared dead in Indonesia coal mine blast
South Africa tightens security around Confed stadiums
Sean Penn drops out of 'Cartel,' 'Three Stooges'
Unclear if Pakistan offensive serves US interests
Czech president wants vote on Ireland treaty guarantees
Iran set for day of mourning after protest deaths
| International
|
Toshiba to speed up system chip shrinkage
Rights groups: reformists seized in Iran crackdown
Clones of 9/11 hero dog unveiled in Los Angeles
EU ministers warn crisis-hit Ukraine
North Korea chemical weapons threaten region: report
| International
|
Cyber-sympathizers aid Iran protestors online
Summit set to back Barroso's bid for second term at EU helm
Iran set for day of mourning
Flyswatter-in-chief flexes his muscles in White House
U.S., Israel seek clarity on settlement freeze
| International
|
Microsoft downplays expectations for Bing
Schwarzenegger vows to veto California tax boost
Brazil, France deny rift over jet disaster probe
U.S. wireless providers debate about competition
Intel to rebrand some chips, phase out "Centrino"
Obama unveils key regulatory overhaul
Killing of US soldier casts light on Mosul police
Microsoft makes gains with Bing
Cuba is rolling museum of vintage U.S. cars
| International
|
Funding threatens US return to moon by 2020
AT&T lets more iPhone users upgrade for lower price
Myanmar rebels to abandon base, vow to fight on
| International
|
Big banks repay US for capital
Zimbabwe seeks tourism bonanza from World Cup
| International
|
Iraq makes arrests after Sunni leader's murder
World media turn to Twitter, email to defy Iran reporting ban
Ford is in 'really good shape': CEO
Key players in Iran's disputed election
Microsoft makes gains with Bing
| Technology
|
North Korea chemical weapons threaten region -report
Asia tennis stars strike blow for ages
AT&T lets more iPhone users upgrade for lower price
| Technology
|
Australian taser death sparks outcry
Obama: More benefits for gay workers only one step
Intel to rebrand some chips, phase out Centrino
| Technology
|
US seeks 'dramatic expansion' of India ties
U.S. wireless providers debate about competition
| Technology
|
Hillary Clinton fractures elbow in fall
Toshiba to speed up system chip shrinkage
| Technology
|
Mekong river dolphin near extinct: WWF
New financial rules: Major changes for big, small
Iranian athletes wear green in apparent protest
SKorea leader says won't accept nuclear North
7th victim of Mexico day care fire arrives in US
NYC man accused of threatening to kill prosecutor
Israel's Lieberman rejects settlement freeze
IAEA slams NKorean nuclear test
Ill. AG Madigan met with Obama, mulling Senate run
China Eastern Air to buy 20 Airbus A320 jets
Asia seen ready to take stronger leadership role
Pakistani c.bank buys 81.5 bln rupees of T-bills
NZ housing affordability improves in May-report
Billy Joel separates from third wife Katie Lee
| Entertainment
|
World Bank ups China 2009 growth forecast
Fallen Seinfeld star Richards a new man
| Entertainment
|
Pakistan's Karachi hit by power black-out
Reese Witherspoon proves a Pharm Girl' at heart
| Entertainment
|
Korea Hot Stocks
Walt Disney museum to focus on man behind brand
| Entertainment
|
Taiwan dollar slips in thin trade, eye on NDFs
S.Korea monitoring increase in household lending
Cannes-winning Philippine director shuns mainstream
Tom Cruise eyes new Mission: Impossible
| Entertainment
|
S.Korea government bonds gain on weak shares
Celebrity birthdays for the week of June 21-27
Andy Murray aims to follow in Perry's footsteps
The machines rise again in tedious Fallen
| Entertainment
|
Emmy Awards move over for MTV Video Music Awards
Kelis lays out support needs from Nas
Jane Fonda undergoes surgery to replace left knee
Baron Cohen's Bruno has military flair at premiere
Jimmy Choo designs collection for high-street's H&M
US publication of book delayed in Salinger dispute
Billy Joel separates from third wife Katie Lee
Ireland 'to get guarantees' at EU summit
T-Mobile USA to launch Dash smartphone in July
ElBaradei and Israel clash over Syria probe "bias"
Climate catastrophe getting closer, warn scientists
U.S. drones kill 9 in Waziristan: Pakistan officials
| International
|
Iran takes center stage at Twitter conference
Somali minister 'killed in suicide bombing'
Video clip raises Christian-Druze tension in Israel
Suicide bomber kills Somali security minister
| International
|
Pirates were democrats, says scholar
Another minister quits as British MPs' expenses published
Video views of democracy lauded online
Air France crash sparks black box debate
| International
|
Jerusalem launches debate on sharing holiest site
| International
|
Iraq forms committee after prisoner abuse reports
| International
|
ElBaradei, Israel clash over Syria probe bias
| International
|
Insurgent ambush kills 24 Algerian police: report
| International
|
Climate catastrophe getting closer, warn scientists
Activists defy Israel, to send Gaza cement
| International
|
Fla. city to workers: Wear underwear, deodorant
Former Vt. Gov. Dean backs public health choice
Malaysia's Anwar seeks to block sodomy charge
LG to produce monitor with virtualization technology
| Technology
|
Arms talks ahead of Obama visit "constructive"
Doh! Wrong turn? Homer gives driving directions
| Technology
|
Officials: Tajik ex-interior minister takes life
Tennis ace Sharapova unveils blinking phone dress
| Technology
|
China attacks Google over pornographic links
| Technology
|
Study: Pollution killing rare Irrawaddy dolphins
The Nation's Weather
T-Mobile USA to launch Dash smartphone in July
| Technology
|
Taiwan opposition to control members' China visits
Animal kills by federal agency more than double
White US Rep. in black Tenn. district faces fight
Mongolian president elect sworn in
Japan votes to lift ban on child organ transplants
Animal activists decry expanded elephant displays
Suspected US missile strikes in Pakistan kill 8
Suspected US missile strikes in Pakistan kill 5
Administration, lawmaker collide on highway bill
India state begins to reclaim "liberated" Maoist zone
AP NewsAlert
India's TCS opens new outsourcing center in Mexico
Paris Hilton brings her reality show to Dubai
WRAPUP 1-S.Korean officials play down rate hike in near term
World Bank raises China 2009 growth forecast
Taiwan port, shipping officials indicted for fraud
India enters deflation as economy slows
Asia seen ready to take stronger leadership role
Fallen Seinfeld star Richards a new man
| Entertainment
|
Malaysian manufacturing plunges 26.2 pct in April
Federal gay marriage challenge is a Hollywood tale
| Entertainment
|
Paris Hilton brings her reality show to Dubai
Scottish legends Proclaim political credentials
Woody Allen eyes Carla Bruni for film role
| Entertainment
|
Japan stocks fall on strong yen, economic worries
Bruno v Borat: Satirist pokes fun at former guise
En garde! Rival houses offer Picasso musketeers
| Entertainment
|
Heath Ledger's uncle to defend stealing charges
Billy Joel separates from third wife Katie Lee
| Entertainment
|
Boyle gently chides China for movie restrictions
Obama extends partial gay benefits
Electro generation grows up, takes kids raving
Boyle gently chides China for movie restrirctions
Fly: new album from a wholly trinity of jazz
Struggle for gay rights hits football in Turkey
Former St. Lucia Governor: Amy Winehouse Is A "Tattooed Reptile"
TV Bosses Approach Prine Harry's New Love Interest About Fighting His Ex On-Air
Queen Elizabeth's Gamekeeper Fined Over a Dead Badger
Sacha Baron Cohen: Britain's Prince Harry "A Total Slut"
Frozen Sharks Yield Ton Of Cocaine
Five Clones Of 9/11 K-9 Presented To Dog Handler
Arizona Town Settles Tied Election With High-Card Draw
5th Graders Create "Obaminoes" Mural To Celebrate History Making President
Missing PA Woman Found Unharmed In Trunk Of Her Car
Jada Pinkett Smith: Having Sex At A Friend's House Can Keep Relationships Alive
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights