Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Networks' use of luge video disturbs some
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Asia Pacific
World
Networks' use of luge video disturbs some
By DAVID BAUDER,AP Television Writer -
Sunday, February 14
Send
IM Story
Print
NEW YORK – NBC and other networks were criticized Saturday for broadcasting the disturbing video of a Georgian luger who died after flying off the track and slamming into a steel beam during an Olympic training run.
NBC said callers complained and Twitter was aflame with disgust. Much of the criticism centered on the network showing the footage at the beginning of its coverage of Friday's opening ceremony for the Vancouver Games, even though video of Nodar Kumaritashvili's death aired on the ABC, CBS and NBC evening news programs.
News organizations frequently weigh the imperative of depicting the reality of the world they cover with concerns about whether images would be too disturbing for the public. In this case, the networks warned viewers and used the video. NBC, in a departure from its usual policy of holding onto video because it is the U.S. Olympics rightsholder, let other networks use it.
"We owe folks a warning here," NBC News anchor Brian Williams said at the beginning of his network's coverage of the opening ceremony Friday. "These pictures are very tough for some people to watch."
Similar warnings were offered by Diane Sawyer and Maggie Rodriguez on the ABC and CBS newscasts. On the "CBS Evening News," the video was shown three times _the last in slow motion. Although NBC muffled the sound of the accident, elsewhere the thudding clank of Kumaritashvili hitting the steel beam was audible.
The warnings weren't enough for Matthew T. Sussman, sports editor of Blogcritics Magazine, who wrote, "so it's anyone's fault for feeling nauseous or traumatized by what they saw. And it really is a terrible clip."
Kim Hartman, a freelance writer from Charleston, W.Va., wrote on a CNN posting that NBC should be ashamed for airing it at the opening of the Olympics.
"I hope that young man's family and friends and countrymen and women and children survive the trauma that you chose to expose them to," Hartman wrote. "You have ruined my games by embedding that image into my mind as the first thing I will recall and perhaps the only thing I will recall that occurred in Vancouver at the 2010 Olympic Games."
The story "could have been told perfectly accurately and well without NBC's 'Faces of Death' moment," blogger Dana Pico wrote.
An NBC executive involved in the decision was not immediately available for comment.
The decisions to air the video, which also appeared on NBC's Olympics Web site and elsewhere online, were interesting in the context of caution elsewhere. Many TV networks, for instance, did not show images of people jumping from the World Trade Center on Sept. 11, 2001.
Journalists have been criticized by some for not conveying the realities of America's two wars. It became an issue last fall, for example, when The Associated Press distributed a still picture of a mortally wounded U.S. Marine in an Afghanistan battlefield and was criticized for it by the U.S. defense secretary.
Bob Steele, an expert on media ethics at DePauw University, said Saturday he hoped the networks gave careful thought to their decisions.
"Clearly it was a failure if they just said, 'Wow, look at that, let's put it up.' Or 'the other networks are using it, let's put it up,'" Steele said.
He was also concerned that distance was a factor: a TV network might be more willing to air such a video with the victim from the republic of Georgia, and less so if an American had been killed.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Lucille Clifton, award-winning poet, dies at 73 AP - Sunday, February 14
Stuntman and actor Bobby Hoy dies at 82 AP - Sunday, February 14
Networks' use of luge video disturbs some AP - Sunday, February 14
Madonna to appear on 'The Marriage Ref' AP - Sunday, February 14
Pickup hits bus carrying country singer's band AP - Sunday, February 14
News Search
Top Stories
Troubled Winter Olympics gets into medal mode
Dutch tourist shot in Carnival mugging in Rio: police
US approves American Airlines, 'oneworld' alliance expansion
Greek crisis could force change in EU economy pact
Campaigning kicks off in Sudan presidential poll
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Spain fails to shake off recession
Mountain lynx makes another appearance
Toyota faces new woes with Tacoma truck recall
British fashion designer Alexander McQueen found dead
Penguin future looks perkier with marine zone: study
More Most Viewed »
Pitt, Jolie sue British paper over split claims
Fury heats up after new AIG bonuses
Sugary soft drinks linked to pancreatic cancer: study
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Sunday, 14 February 2010 Israel general doubts power to hit Iran atom sites
|
Spanish police arrest ETA car-bombing suspect
|
Yemeni Shi'ite rebels deny assassination attempt
|
Ukraine's Tymoshenko vows to fight rival's election
|
At Rio Carnival, a pressing problem
|
Scorsese eyes new film project with Robert De Niro
|
Clinton seeks more Arab pressure on Iran
Greek crisis could force change in EU economy pact
India says few clues to bomb, denies intelligence failure
|
IT revolution an achilles heel for Swiss bank secrecy
Dutch tourist shot in Carnival mugging in Rio: police
Heavy rainfalls hit Mecca amid holiday
Former US officials in cyberattack simulation
Afghan flag-raising in NATO offensive draws gunfire
|
Ban forces rivals of Iraqi PM to halt campaign
Rome police uncover 500,000 tonnes of fake goods
String of Iraq bomb attacks target poll candidates
|
US approves American Airlines, 'oneworld' alliance expansion
Suspended animation coming to life: researcher
Israel general doubts power to hit Iran atom sites
Indians get particular about online marriage
Recovery 'fragile' for eurozone: Bank of Italy chief
Bashir starts Sudan election campaign with a jig
|
Volkswagen recalls 20,000 cars in Mexico
Campaigning kicks off in Sudan presidential poll
Critics of Jordan's U.S. ties charged with sedition
America's Cup showcases latest sailing technology
Polish PM condemns Belarus crackdown on Polish minority
Iraq election officials confirm Sunni candidate ban
Microsoft co-founder Gates tackling climate change
Heavy rainfalls hit Mecca amid holiday
|
Eurozone recovery stalls amid Greek rescue doubts
Major Afghan assault claims first Taliban casualties
Games open in Canada's wintry indoor paradise
Obama calls for new spending cuts
Probe slams Eurostar over badly prepared trains
Afghan, US troops meet Marjah resistance: official
Europe's economic recovery stalls: data
Google mulls stand-alone version of Buzz
Google Buzz tweaked amid privacy complaints
Assault on Taliban in southern Afghanistan begins: NATO
Fashion icon McQueen found dead in apparent suicide
Google founder Brin wants way to work with China
Qaeda threatens to stop Iraq vote, as campaign opens
America's Cup showcases latest sailing technology
McQueen: beloved bad boy of British fashion
Euro slumps to lowest point vs dollar since May
Motorola to split into two publicly traded companies in 2011
Clinton wants Saudis to prod China on Iran sanctions
Ford says will file his 1st NY resident tax return
Feds deny BART $70M for Oakland airport connector
Police: Sheriff's sergeant kills 2 women and self
Judge finds grounds to sanction Arizona sheriff
Obama getting briefed on Afghanistan operation
India says few clues to bomb, denies intelligence failure
Summary Box: Anthem to delay insurance rate hike
Freed Suu Kyi deputy calls for Myanmar dialogue
Plans advance for Golden Gate Bridge suicide nets
Pakistan flung into fresh turmoil
Anthem to delay insurance rate hike amid criticism
Bombs, booby-traps slow US advance in Afghan town
Obama nuke plant loan reflects new energy strategy
Apparent bomb kills 8 in Indian bakery, 42 injured
Bombs slow US advance in Afghan town
Crash could force Japan's Fujimori out
Zvonareva, Tamarine power to Pattaya final
UN envoy to probe human rights in Myanmar
Eight killed in India terror attack
China's economic rise has silver lining for Japan
10,000 Chinese visit Taiwan on Lunar New Year's Day
Toyota finds no problem with electronics: reports
Preservation campaigners cover Hollywood sign
Pork-flavored doughnuts? A Chinese market beckons
Live or Memorex? `Avatar' raises Oscar question
Report: Toyota chief visits dealership, apologizes
India's Bharti makes bid for Kuwait's Zain assets
Pakistani c.bank buys 107.95 bln rupees of govt paper
Japan's Shinsei, Aozora banks halt merger: reports
Toyota suspends production of Lexus, Sai hybrids
Intel teams up with China's investment fund
Lucille Clifton, award-winning poet, dies at 73
Stuntman and actor Bobby Hoy dies at 82
After somber start, color punctuates New York runways
Poet urges fellow Haitians to ride out their misery
Guggenheim artists fill 'void' with ideas
Sri Lanka's legendary doorman turns 90
Networks' use of luge video disturbs some
Madonna to appear on 'The Marriage Ref'
Pickup hits bus carrying country singer's band
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Make life a game and save the world
Netanyahu to lobby in Russia for Iran sanctions
EU takes Greek economy under its wing
Yemen rebels to hand over Saudi soldiers
India says investigating blast, Pakistan talks on
|
Troubled Winter Olympics gets into medal mode
Pope to meet Irish bishops on child abuse scandal
|
Yemeni rebels to hand over Saudi soldiers: report
|
Lebanon 'March 14' supporters rally for slain Hariri
Yanukovich wins Ukraine presidency: election body
|
Dalai Lama urges Tibetans not to celebrate New Year
|
Immigrants riot in Milan after Egyptian killed
|
Bashir starts Sudan election campaign with a jig
Pakistani PM plays down crisis over judges
|
String of Iraq bomb attacks target poll candidates
Netanyahu to lobby in Russia for Iran sanctions
|
West African cocaine use rises along smuggling routes
|
Start obesity prevention in the cradle, study urges
Accused Alabama Campus Shooter Killed Brother 24 Years Ago
Florida Shooting Rampage Suspect Arrested
Amber Alert Called Off For Abducted California Kids
For roving US Army unit, Strykers are their homes
US missile raid 'kills seven' militants in Pakistan
Toyota Announces Inspection Recall Of 8,000 Tacoma Trucks
Tibetans shun New Year celebrations for 2nd year
Accused Alabama prof shot, killed brother in 1986
U.S. drone kills five in northwest Pakistan
Russia wants Bulgaria explanation on US missile shield
Tongans pray as cyclone threatens direct hit
Walls of water overwhelm N. Calif. surfing contest
Pakistani PM plays down crisis, opposition pounces
Bomb explodes near Thai govt, 2nd found near court
Officials: US missiles kill 5 in NW Pakistan
Fireworks, prayers greet Year of the Tiger
Sri Lankan Buddhists: Release opposition leader
Struggling 'Czech Hollywood' pins hope on state aid
Chinese Coen brothers remake thrills Berlin festival
|
South African wins Mr Gay World pageant
Chinese remake of Coen brothers film screens in Berlin
China's young graduates live 'ant's' life
Baghdad battles to preserve its battered heritage
Africa's league of fashionable gentlemen 'sapeurs'
Struggling 'Czech Hollywood' pins hope on state aid
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights