Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Forgotten Stalin victims despair in Kazakh steppe
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Slideshow
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
"Clueless" star Brittany Murphy dead at 32
| Video
8:29am EST
Actress Brittany Murphy dies aged 32
20 Dec 2009
UPDATE 2-U.S. Northeast digs out of monster snowstorm
20 Dec 2009
Auschwitz sign thieves detained, not neo-Nazis
8:57am EST
U.S. health bill passes crucial Senate test
| Video
7:43am EST
Japanese man takes video game character as wife
20 Dec 2009
"Clueless" star Brittany Murphy dead at 32
| Video
8:29am EST
UPDATE 2-U.S. Northeast digs out of monster snowstorm
20 Dec 2009
Q+A: What does the Senate healthcare bill do?
7:43am EST
Protests mark funeral of dissident Iranian cleric
| Video
3:29am EST
Copenhagen Climate Change Conference
Is there a climate conference going on?
In Copenhagen, big companies from Siemens to Shell are making sure you know they care. Full Article | Full Coverage
Live from Copenhagen: Have your say
Reuters panel of climate experts address questions
Forgotten Stalin victims despair in Kazakh steppe
Maria Golovnina
DOLINKA, Kazakhstan
Mon Dec 21, 2009 10:19am EST
<
1 / 8
>
View Full Size
DOLINKA, Kazakhstan (Reuters) - Their only crime was to be German.
World | Russia
An icy wind lashing against his face, Viktor Fast gazed at rows of crumbling barracks in the snows of central Kazakhstan where his parents -- along with millions of other Russian Germans -- endured years of cruelty in Soviet labor camps.
"It was a bitter time," said Fast whose family members were accused of collaborating with the Nazis in the 1930s despite having lived in Russia for centuries as ordinary farmers.
"It was not a good time to be German," said Fast, 58. Now a resident of Frankfurt, he often comes to this remote spot to pay respect to those who died here as part of Stalin's purges.
Millions of people including ethnic Germans and Russian dissidents died between 1930 and 1960, unable to survive starvation and torture in a network of gulag camps scattered from Russia's Arctic tundra to the inhospitable Kazakh steppe.
Snow crunched under his feet as Fast toured Dolinka, a village at the center of the Kazakh gulag system. Only scraps of barbed wire and a scattering of crumbling barracks -- many converted into houses -- remind visitors of Dolinka's past.
Decades on, Stalin's Great Terror campaign is recognized globally as one of the biggest crimes against humanity. Yet survivors and campaigners lament what they see as Russia's reluctance to face up to the horrors of its past.
"People don't cherish their memories," said Fast, speaking Russian with a German accent. "Seventy years of Soviet policies have erased their memories."
As Moscow debates Stalin's role in its history, rights campaigners have accused Vladimir Putin's Russia of trying to whitewash the dictator's ruinous legacy, turning Stalin's purges into a forgotten chapter of Soviet history.
There is little debate about gulag camps in Russia where Stalin was voted Russia's third most popular figure in history in a nationwide poll last year.
An epigraph praising him was recently restored on the wall of a metro station in Moscow where communists laid wreaths on Monday to mark 130 years since Stalin's birth in Georgia.
"There is a creeping effort to vindicate Stalin and promote the benefits of strong-hand rule, and that is a big worry," said Yekaterina Kuznetsova, 71, a prominent gulag researcher. "But history is cunning. It tends to repeat itself."
MASS GRAVES
It is unclear exactly how many died in the Kazakh gulag camps, collectively known as Karlag. The overall gulag death toll also varies from 1.5 million to 20 million. Dolinka residents describe the surrounding steppe as one big mass grave.
One field is dotted with crosses, a place where hundreds of children -- "the offspring of the enemies of the people" -- were buried. It is known as Mamochkino -- or Mummy's -- cemetery.
A chilly 1943 note by the NKVD Soviet security service, a copy of which was seen by Reuters, states: "The death rate among prisoners has increased sharply in Karlag ... Having spent a work shift in the frost many are unable to warm up in the cold barracks ... and die without receiving any medical help."
Stalin's legacy hangs like a dark cloud over this part of Kazakhstan, a vast steppe nation deemed remote enough by Soviet rulers to test hundreds of nuclear bombs and lock up dissidents.
The nearby city of Karagandy, many of its imposing Stalin-era buildings constructed by gulag prisoners, is dominated by a big statue of Bolshevik leader Vladimir Lenin. A tiny marble memorial to gulag victims stands in a local park.
Twenty years since becoming independent, Kazakhstan itself is struggling to come to terms with its past, keen to maintain good relations with Russia -- its biggest trading partner.
Many are upset with their government's reluctance to skirt its Soviet legacy in a nation where over a million Kazakhs died in gulags and during a Soviet-inflicted famine in the 1930s.
Last week hundreds of people rallied in Almaty to accuse the government, which has retained a Soviet style of governance, of not doing enough to respect the past.
"It's a difficult topic. I would say it's a taboo," said Achim Schmillen, a researcher from Germany who traveled to Dolinka to visit a gulag memorial.
"Relations with Russia are very important. It's hard for them to get the right attitude and define their identity."
STALIN'S DEATH
Many former camps are now part of Kazakhstan's jail system. Some, like a row of abandoned barracks in Dolinka, are used as a waste dump. Wrapped tightly against the biting cold of -30 C (-22 F), villagers turn away as they walk past briskly.
A tiny village museum is packed with gulag items, its walls plastered with photos of prisoners' gaunt faces.
A journal kept by one prisoner lies on display, showing a hastily written entry dating back to March 1953. "Today there was an announcement ... that Stalin died ... I can't believe this."
Karlag was closed after Stalin's death. Often unable to find anywhere to go, many survivors and their wardens settled down in the same villages, forming an uneasy fusion of tragedies that were never discussed in public.
"After the Soviet collapse some of them were worried that they would be tried for crimes against humanity," said Kuznetsova, the researcher. "But of course no one came."
Russia denies accusations that it is whitewashing Stalin's totalitarian system. In October, President Dmitry Medvedev said the crimes of the past should not be forgiven.
Survivors think otherwise. Mikhail Shmulyov was jailed for not killing himself when captured by German troops in the 1940s. The 90-year-old feels bitter about Russia's stance on history.
"I was never a communist. But after this experience I became a true anti-Sovietchik (dissident)," he said in his wooden home in Almaty which he has elaborately decorated with Buddha statues, paintings and old black-and-white photographs.
"Today we see pictures of Lenin and Stalin everywhere again. I find it shocking. Communism must never be forgiven."
World
Russia
More from Reuters
Dubai World standstill seen in Jan, has $40 billion debt: source
DUBAI (Reuters) - Dubai World, faced with a $22 billion debt restructuring, told creditors it had $40 billion in total debts and will pitch a standstill proposal in mid-January, a banking source said on Monday.
U.S. health bill passes crucial Senate test
| Video
Copenhagen provides negotiation model for WTO: Lamy
Spyker shares soar as GM mulls new offer for Saab
Walgreen profit beats Street view, shares up
ConAgra profit beats Street
» More Top News
Health bill passes crucial test
A sweeping U.S. healthcare reform bill appears headed for passage in the Senate after surviving a middle-of-the-night test vote. Full Article | Video
Factbox: Details of the healthcare bill
Will the bill pass by Christmas?
Healthcare Reform
Let's make a deal
The battered M&A sector will make a tepid recovery in the coming year and three hot sectors will lead the way, according to a Thomson Reuters analysis. Full Article
JPMorgan tops ECM rankings
Hungry for deals after a forced diet
Fewer bankruptcies seen in 2010
Global Deals Review
© Copyright 2009 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts.com
Buyouts Europe:
Buyouts Conferences:
Venture Capital Journal
ECVJ
International Financing Review
International Securitisation Report
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Monday, 21 December 2009 Top Iran dissident cleric Montazeri dies at 87
Thousands hit in second day of Eurostar standstill
Sudan passes security bill despite protests
Cold snap causes holiday travel chaos in Europe
Yemen rebels say Saudi air raids kill 54
|
Iraq PM in Cairo to improve ties with Egypt
London Stock Exchange set to take over rival: reports
Dutch sports carmaker Spyker makes new bid for Saab
Suspected Turkish coup plotter kills self
Hariri sees new page in Lebanon ties with Syria
Colombia says faces external military threat
|
Mourners heap flowers by Mexican drug lord's coffin
|
UNDP calls on wealthy Arab states to help neighbors
|
Madagascar leader names colonel as prime minister
|
White House backs healthcare deal, sees victory
Despite aid, hunger still stalks Afghan children
Obama plan could limit records hidden from public
Karzai defends Cabinet picks
INSIDE WASHINGTON: An anti-whistleblower culture
Analysis: Hard reality as US pushes Pakistan
No praise sung for holly, ivy in Northwest forests
Astronauts geared for yuletide space adventure
US sends 12 Gitmo detainees to their home nations
China to try prominent dissident on Wednesday -l awyer
Storm crawls into New England, leaving mess behind
Airlines across East Coast dig out from big storm
White House urges compromise on health care reform
US decries Cambodia's deportation of Uighurs
Hyundai Motor announces China truck venture
Actress Brittany Murphy dead: report
|
Avatar earns $73 million in box office
|
Friend: Polanski finishing film under house arrest
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
`Avatar' blasts off with $232.2 million worldwide
Iran to punish unauthorised filmmakers: report
Some Iranians arrested on way to funeral
Christmas chaos as cold cripples Eurostar trains
China praises Cambodia as Uighurs deported
|
Russian railways enter modern age with new express
Iran's Mousavi in Qom for cleric's funeral
Google gets digital foothold in France
Thousands warned to flee Philippine volcano zone
Large turnout for Iran cleric's funeral: website
|
Sinn Fein chief Adams says father was child sex abuser
Polish police recover Auschwitz sign
|
BBC says Persian service being jammed
Missing Dutch sailor girl found on St. Martin
|
US actress Brittany Murphy dies at 32: police
Cold snap strands thousands of European travellers
Iran's opposition to mourn dissident cleric
Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood faces election rift
|
China gets Myanmar assurances on pipeline, border
|
Parents of captured Israeli soldier plead for his release
Chavez launches national police in violent Venezuela
|
Thousands head for Iran dissident cleric's funeral
Italy uses all channels to free Mauritania hostages
|
Iraq scores in oil well standoff, investment
Mexican drug lord buried quietly in family crypt
|
1 dead, 5 hurt in Coast Guard boat collision in CA
Ex-conjoined twins leave hospital on birthday eve
Health bill money for hospital sought by Dodd
US sent American to help Cuba's opposition: Castro
North Korea declares disputed waters 'firing zone'
21 militants killed in Afghan operations
White House presses for health care reform deal
Philippine volcano gets louder, could blow up soon
Protests greet top China negotiator on Taiwan visit
India-flagged cargo ship adrift in North Pacific
Thousands warned to flee Philippine volcano zone
Chavez: US spy plane violated Venezuela's airspace
Castro: Obama seeking to topple Cuban communism
Chinese envoy arrives in Taiwan for trade talks
Leading China dissident to be tried Wednesday
US sends home 12 Guantanamo detainees
AP Interview: US dad pins hopes on Brazil judge
Suu Kyi lawyers to appeal sentence
Escalator fire closes NYC's flagship Macy's store
China praises Cambodia as Uighurs deported
Seoul shares slip 0.2 pct after volatile trade
China sovereign fund to get fresh cash injection
Japan's exports fall at slowest pace in 14 months
Turkish cinema shrugs off cliches over Kurdish issue
Stiglitz warns US economy may contract next year
LG Display claims world's thinnest TV panel
BRIEF-Moody's: Korean banking system profile has been improving
NZ farmer confidence logs first gain in year-survey
Clueless star Brittany Murphy dead at 32
|
New movie trailers could boost Oscar ratings
|
PAKISTAN
S.Korea sees around $3.5 bln trade surplus in Dec
Seoul shares slip weighed by banks;techs rise
Valentino documentary kept afloat by credit cards
|
Rockers Def Leppard developing cartoon series
|
"Clueless" star Brittany Murphy dead at 32
Knightley picks unrewarding play for London debut
|
Papers on British palaces' upkeep could be released
Alvin and the Chipmunks sequel hits flat note
|
Natalie White wins 'Survivor,' collects $1M prize
"Alvin and the Chipmunks" sequel hits flat note
Turkish cinema shrugs off cliches over Kurdish issue
Knightley picks unrewarding play for London debut
Cuba boogies to Kool & the Gang
Valentino documentary kept afloat by credit cards
Jeff Daniels speaks at Univ. of Mich. graduation
Israel close to deciding on prisoner swap
Winter transport chaos grows in Europe
Protests mark funeral of dissident Iranian cleric
|
Missing Dutch teen sailor found in Caribbean
Japan logs trade surplus, boosted by China growth
Demjanjuk unmoved as Holocaust survivors testify
|
Clashes after Montazeri funeral in Iran
Afghan troops kill Taliban attackers, official says
|
Suicide attack kills local leader in northern Iraq
Netanyahu holds marathon talks on Israel-Hamas swap
|
Suicide attack kills local leader in northern Iraq
|
Eurostar halts trains, angry France demands answers
|
Sri Lanka says U.N. wants explanation on Tiger deaths
|
Bus carrying Syrians attacked in Lebanon, one dies
Pope visit to Rome synagogue under cloud
|
Forgotten Stalin victims despair in Kazakh steppe
|
China boosts Cambodia aid after Uighurs deported
Time running out for orangutans: conservationists
Tribunal charges Khmer Rouge "First Lady" with genocide
Barnes & Noble compensates buyers for late Nook
|
Philippine volcano gets louder, could erupt soon
Last Khmer Rouge defendant charged with genocide
Britain blames China over 'farcical' climate talks
President Obama meets with efficiency award winner
U.S. Repatriates 12 Guantanamo Detainees
The nation's weather
Sri Lankan navy seizes rebel arms smuggling ship
One Killed In Collision Between Coast Guard And Recreational Boat In San Diego
FL Governor To Return Money From Ponzi Scheme Bilker
Myanmar's court to review Suu Kyi house arrest
Federal Offices Closed In D.C. Due To Snow
Even after death, Roberts' hand to be felt at ORU
During Midnight Session, Senate Healthcare Bill Passes First Floor Vote
Senate Dems clear hurdle on health care
Mumps Outbreak Reported Among New York Jewish Community
FL Man Accused Of Smothering 83-Year-Old Father To Death With A Pillow
Airport Worker Falls 40 Feet To His Death
Record-breaking storm closes US federal government
Update: Snow Storm Continues To Cause Airport Delays
Who wins, who loses in Senate health bill
Snow Storm A Record Setter In Philly
Iraq initials oil deal with Petronas-Japex group
Pakistani o/n rates ease; rupee firms; stocks up
French firm to sign major deal to equip Chinese jet
Minister: China aims for 2010 GDP growth of 8 pct
Japan's ANA buying 10 Boeing planes
Hundreds gather for rebel's funeral in Papua
China banks need more capital in 2010: report
Japan's exports post slowest decline in 14 months
Jackson's death voted top 2009 entertainment story
Japan's Mizuho, Malaysia's Maybank in business tie-up
New movie trailers could boost Oscar ratings
Avatar leads box office, despite blizzard
|
Police Officers Draw Guns At DC Snowball Fight
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights