Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
One-child policy debate reignited in China
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Australia
China
India
Indonesia
Japan
Malaysia
Philippines
Thailand
Vietnam
Search
Search:
One-child policy debate reignited in China
AFP - Friday, July 31
SHANGHAI (AFP) - - Analysts say recent media attention reflects a struggle between demographers alarmed by a shrinking workforce and ageing population and officials clinging to the mindset that China has too many people.
ADVERTISEMENT
Shanghai nurse Lu Ming wants a second baby but it is not China's one-child policy that is holding her back.
If anything, she is being encouraged to increase the size of her family as the city faces the challenge of providing for its ageing population.
Last week it reminded couples such as Lu and her husband -- both of whom are only children because of the policy -- that they are eligible to have a second child.
Comments by Shanghai family planning director Xie Lingli published on the front page of the government-run China Daily were initially seen as a signal that the controversial one-child policy was about to be relaxed after 30 years.
However, days later a report by China's official Xinhua news agency quoted Xie as saying she was simply stating rules that had been in place for years and that Shanghai never pursued measures that parted from national policies.
Yet for young university-educated mothers such as Lu, who said she was aware of the policy exceptions for having a second child, government officials' words alone mean little in the face of the rising costs of raising a bigger family.
"I had one child and now I want to have a second one," the 31-year-old said.
"But not every family can afford to have a second child," she added.
"To raise a second child you have to take all the financial costs into consideration, otherwise it's not responsible."
"The fact this caused such a media storm shows the wind is blowing the other way and it's about time," said Wang Feng, a sociology professor at the University of California, Irvine.
"It's a monumental decision that China has to face: what to do about a policy that came out as an emergency measure and was supposed to last for only a generation," Wang said.
Regardless of whether China decides to phase out the one-child policy, population decline is inevitable after more than 15 years of fertility rates below the replacement level of 2.1, Wang said.
The government has yet to understand that young career-minded women and rising living costs signal demographic trends similar to those in Western Europe, and birth rates will fall even further, Wang said.
"China needs to realise there is a demographic crisis quickly in order to prevent it from deepening," he said.
Even though the rules for having a second child are not new, by publicly encouraging people to take advantage of them Shanghai officials may be trying to counter propaganda tilted towards encouraging only one child, he said.
"Having a second child is often portrayed as if it's a sign of backwardness and not contributing to the country's goal of controlling population growth," Wang said.
A senior Shanghai district family planning official insisted that encouraging eligible couples to have a second child had been going on for nearly five years since new exceptions to the one-child policy were introduced.
Couples are asked a series of questions when they register to marry to determine if they can have more than one child, the official said, declining to be named due to the sensitivity of the issue.
She provided a bright booklet distributed in Shanghai since 2005 which spells out who is eligible to have a second baby, with children's book-style illustrations showing a young father with two children hanging off his arms.
Conditions include one of the couple being disabled, one working on a fishing boat at sea for five years, and one being an only child from a rural household.
Urban couples who do not meet the criteria but have a second child nonetheless, are fined the equivalent of three times the per capita income in their city, the booklet said.
The fine for a Shanghai couple, based on 2008 figures, would be about 80,000 yuan (11,800 dollars) -- a price wealthy families are often willing to pay.
But in a Shanghai park bouncing her six-month-old grandson on her knee, 51-year-old Huang Yuanxiang said that, for most of the younger generation, the biggest barrier to having more than one child is economic.
For her grandson to prosper, he will have to go to good schools that cost money.
"In my generation, none of us was rich and things were not expensive so it cost little to have more than one child," she said. "We didn't face the same financial burden as they do."
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: Asia Pacific
Nepal Gurkhas name beauty spot after 'Ab Fab' starAFP - Saturday, August 1
Japanese unemployment hits six-year highAFP - Saturday, August 1
One-child policy debate reignited in ChinaAFP - Friday, July 31
Emotional reunion for long-lost mongrel 'Muffy'AFP - Saturday, August 1
Myanmar court delays Suu Kyi verdictAFP - Friday, July 31
Enlarge Photo
One-child policy debate reignited in China
Most Popular – Asia Pacific
Viewed
Custody deal agreed for Jackson's children
Sunbeds elevated to top cancer risk level: WHO
Beer flows as Obama tries to cool down a hot furor
Comets probably won't cause the end of life as we know it: study
Doctor gave Jackson drug that killed him: CNN
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Friday, 31 July 2009 British Iraq war inquiry will call Blair: chairman
Majorca lockdown after car bomb kills police
Iran police clash with protesters on mourning day
New jobless claims higher in past week
With a few beers, Obama tries to patch up a race furor
Energy giant Shell profits slump on weak oil prices
Taliban call for boycott of Afghan polls, 'jihad'
Custody deal agreed for Jackson's children: statement
Taliban threaten Afghan poll, deadly month nears end
| International
|
ExxonMobil profit slumps 66%
China committed to enforcing North Korea sanctions: U.S.
| International
|
Israel says investigating 100 Gaza war complaints
| International
|
Airbus recommends speed sensor switch after crash
| International
|
Nigerian Islamic sect leader killed in detention
| International
|
Cuba to create agency to fight corruption cancer
| International
|
Iraq acknowledges deaths at Iran exile camp
| International
|
Motorola rebounds, posts profit
Videogame industry looks for second-half comeback
| Technology
|
iPhone vulnerable to hacker attacks: researchers
| Technology
|
US to release young Afghan detainee from Guantanamo
Yahoo gets hard look from investors following deal
| Technology
|
New jobless claims higher in past week
Senate passes energy and water bill
American Samoa gov. seeks help with minimum wage
Correction: Hawaii Health Insurance-Glance
Jury hands man life sentence in Arizona shootings
India inflation in negative terrain for 7th week
Taiwan's TSMC Q2 net profit soars
Mazda posts net loss in Q1, but cheers record China sales
Pakistan's forex reserves fall to $11.77 bln
Japan's NEC announces Q1 loss
Japan's Fujitsu sees red
Softbank outshines DoCoMo in Japan's cellphone battle
Pakistani c.bank closing forex window for diesel
Just A Minute With: Ashley Tisdale on her rising career
| Entertainment
|
Moore's credit crunch film tops bill in Venice
| Entertainment
|
Albania to allow gay marriages: PM
Photographer Leibovitz sued for breach of contract
| Entertainment
|
Singapore visitor arrivals down 11.5% in first half: govt
Taiwan bans international match-making services
Update: Baby Cut From Mother's Womb Found Alive In New Hampshire, Robber-Killer Arrested
Rain, smoking bans dampen German beer sales
White House Beer And Chat Moved To Rose Garden
Reconciliation falters in Kenya's explosive Rift Valley
NASA Defends New Moon Mission Rockets Before Panel
East German Stasi feared Michael Jackson Berlin gig
| Entertainment
|
Pregnant Women To Get First Shot At Swine Flu Vaccine
Obama's Approval Rating Slipping; Economic, Healthcare Approval Declines
Wanting Clean Bathroom, Man Gets Hazmat Team, Trip To Hospital
White House Names Stephen Hawking, Jack Kemp, Sidney Poitier As Medal Of Freedom Recipients
Men at Work loses first stage of copyright lawsuit
Report: Goods In Canada Only 6.8 Percent More Expensive Compared To U.S.
Poll Finds Californians Turning Away From Schwarzenegger, Obama
Alexander Becomes First Republican Leader To Support Sotomayor
Computer giant Dell fined in Taiwan over consumer dispute
Fast new Internet link slow in reaching African users
Motorola rebounds, posts profit
British govt: we did not do enough for troops
Briton wins landmark ruling on assisted suicide
Myanmar court delays Suu Kyi verdict to August 11
| International
|
US military reviews use of social networks
Eurofighter deal to be inked: sources
Japan LDP tries to steal opposition policy thunder
| International
|
Iran police clash with protesters on mourning day
MySpace launches myspace.com email
German regulator says HRE rescue saved banks worldwide
U.S. envoy says Sudan sanctions should be eased
Microsoft CEO 'surprised' by market reaction to deal
Iran police break up memorial for protest victims
| International
|
Pfizer, Nigeria sign $75 mln settlement in drug suit: official
Pirate Bay website banned in Netherlands
Iraq says 11 dead in Iran camp as Amnesty seeks probe
Israel military holds criminal probes over Gaza war
Honduran rulers insist Zelaya cannot be president
| International
|
Presidents meet for security summit in Tajikistan
Comets probably won't cause the end of life as we know it: study
Nigerian militant leader shot in police custody
| International
|
U.N. council extends mandate of Darfur peacekeepers
Police car blown up during summit in Tajik capital
| International
|
CORRECTED
Japan kid payouts may win votes, not up birthrate
| International
|
US insists on six-way talks for NKorea
Myanmar delays Suu Kyi verdict to Aug 11
Drum roll for the first robotic gamelan orchestra
| Technology
|
Yahoo gets hard look from investors following deal
| Technology
|
Obama backs Philippine peace push
YouTube wedding video sends Chris Brown to charts
| Technology
|
US envoy warns of possible new sanctions on North Korea
Hazardous Chemical Fire Causes Evacuation Of Bryan, Texas
Microsoft CEO surprised at Yahoo deal reception
| Technology
|
U.S. jobless claims rise, but trend seen slowing
Schipper snags fly gold ahead of Olympic champ Liu
Judge Orders Release Of One Of Youngest Gitmo Detainees
GOP senator tamps down hopes for health care bill
EBay says no changes to Skype IPO plans
| Technology
|
U.S. Treasury sanctions North Korea trading firm
Update: White House Four-Way Beer And Chat Takes Place
Foxconn suicide turns spotlight on China counterfeiting
| Technology
|
Heavy rains flood Shanghai: state media
House panel goes back to work on health care
Thai PM warns against royal pardon petition for Thaksin
SD court overturns Alaska man's death sentence
Australia's Watson lands opening blows
Taiwan reports first death from swine flu
Japan's Mizuho Financial posts small Q1 loss
Japanese unemployment hits six-year high
S.Korea buys dlrs to cap won's gains -traders
Korea Hot Stocks
South Korea bonds steady early as key data awaited
Japan's jobless rate hits six-year high of 5.4 pct
Seoul shares rise; Samsung Elec up, eyes on data
Suzuki says no plans to exit Canada plant venture with GM
Jackson mother gets custody, Rowe gets visits
| Entertainment
|
Funny People laughing loudest at box office
| Entertainment
|
Swine flu scanner at Indonesian president's house
Hamas sponsors mass wedding in Gaza
Hollywood stars visit Havana amid U.S.-Cuba thaw
| Entertainment
|
New Michael Moore film in Venice film fest line-up
HBO renews Hung, True Blood, Entourage
| Entertainment
|
Organist wins share of 'Whiter Shade of Pale' royalties
Zuma's daughter lands role in South African soap
Last minute concert tickets hot items in recession
| Entertainment
|
Gaza kids seek kite world record in uplifting moment
YouTube wedding video sends Chris Brown to charts
| Entertainment
|
Black Eyed Peas set record on U.S. singles chart
| Entertainment
|
Bald Songbird Discovered In Remote Area Of Laos
'Radical' Jet To Take Tourists To Space
Wanting Clean Bathroom, Man Gets Hazmat Team, Trip To Hospital
Amy Winehouse's Father Faked A Heart Attack In Attempt To Scare Her Off Drugs
London Fog Airbrushed Gisele Bundchen's Baby Bump Out Of Her Latest Ad Campaign
Queen Elizabeth Delighted By School Kids' Underwear Designs For Her Majesty
Saudi Bank Officials Get Flack For Dance Video
Officers Suspended For Running Background Check On Obama
Energy-Burning 'Brown Fat' Discovery May Help Combat Obesity
Strong Perfume Prompts Panic At Texas Bank
Medvedev in Central Asia to bolster Russian clout
Bombs kill at least 28 near Baghdad mosques
| International
|
Afghan clash 'kills 11 militants, one policeman'
Organic food not healthier, says British study
Eurozone deflation deepens as prices fall 0.6%
US drones to target Taliban in Afghan war: report
U.S. troops killed in deadliest month of Afghan war
| International
|
Michael Jackson's Autopsy Results Delayed Indefinitely
BA announces £148m loss, says outlook uncertain
Iran's Ahmadinejad warns rivals their plans will fail
| International
|
Men Arrested Over Home Sneak-In Of SJP And Matthew Broderick's Surrogate
Cuba's Communist Party postpones key congress
| International
|
Sony Taps Google To Offer 1 Million E-Books
Bus crash involving Dutch tourists kills six in Spain
Katherine Jackson Gets Custody Of Michael's Kids; Debbie Rowe Agrees On Visitation Rights
Pakistani court says Musharraf trampled constitution
| International
|
China says Xinjiang riot media openness a success
| International
|
Men At Work Loses First Round Of Plagiarism Lawsuit
Ex-Soviet states meet for 'Russian NATO' summit
Former Jaipur Queen Gayatri Devi Dies At 90
U.N. experts ask Azerbaijan to stop free speech curbs
| International
|
Afghan war spreads to residential areas: U.N. report
| International
|
Nepal Gurkhas name beauty spot after 'Ab Fab' star
British hacker loses bid to avoid US extradition
Japanese unemployment hits six-year high
Beer flows as Obama tries to cool down a hot furor
British hacker loses U.S. extradition appeal
| Technology
|
One-child policy debate reignited in China
Texas chemical fire forces evacuation of 72,000
Emotional reunion for long-lost mongrel 'Muffy'
Reid says more cuts ahead for Yucca Mountain
Australia says Uighur leader is no 'terrorist'
Future of McNair's charity work is questionable
Indonesian 'sex cult' leader jailed: report
Obama to award Presidential Medal of Freedom to 16
US mulling European missile defense alternatives
S.Korean fishermen face N.Korea probe
Russia starts building major Asian gas pipeline
Japan's MUFG first quarter profits soar 48%
US GDP will offer clues on end of recession
23 films vie for Venice's Golden Lion
Seoul shares up 1.5 pct, post 12 pct rise in July =2
China July new loans below 500 bln yuan: report
Thailand's wine gets a woman's touch
Japan's ANA flies into red with $300 mln loss
Fall in SKorea industrial output eases in June
Pakistani stocks up over 3 pct on IMF loan hopes
S.Korea won at 9-1/2-mth closing high on stocks
Meryl Streep emerges as summer box-office sensation
| Entertainment
|
'Gilligan's Island' actress has auction in Idaho
Ashley Tisdale breaks out of 'High School' mode
Ang Lee attends NY screening of 'Taking Woodstock'
Photographer Leibovitz sued for breach of contract
| Entertainment
|
UK court rules in favor of Procol Harum organist
Update: Space Shuttle Endeavour Lands Safely In Florida
ESPN reporter complains of harassment in 911 call
Update: Space Shuttle Endeavor Cleared To Land; Begins Deorbit
Amid Declining Approval Ratings, Obama Holds First Cabinet Retreat
Emmy changes: Some awards to be taped
U.S. Economy Shows Sign Of Recovery As Q2 GDP Contracts By 1.5%
Ruling delayed on `Brutal Legend' release
House Panel May Finish Healthcare Bill Friday; Progressives Warn Against Compromise With Blue Dogs
Space Shuttle Endeavour Prepares For Friday Landing
Americans Spending Billions Out-Of-Pocket On Alternative Medicine
Update 2: After White House Beer Summit, Prof. Gates And Sgt. Crowley Agree To Meet Again
House Passes $636B Defense Budget Without F-22 Funds
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights