">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Terrorism arrests: snitch, sting, then controversy
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Search
Search:
Terrorism arrests: snitch, sting, then controversy
By DEBORAH HASTINGS,AP National Writer AP - Monday, May 25
NEW YORK - It usually starts with a snitch and a sting operation, followed by a great deal of publicity and controversy.
ADVERTISEMENT
Case in point: Four Muslim men charged last week with plotting to blow up synagogues and military planes. The informant is a convicted felon and Pakistani immigrant who turned informant seven years ago to avoid deportation. This wasn't his first foray into undercover work for federal authorities.
With considerable fanfare, a steady stream of terrorism busts has been announced by the FBI since Sept. 11, 2001. And in most cases, accusations soon followed that the stings were overblown operations that entrapped hapless ne'er-do-wells. Federal authorities say such arrests save lives.
But what happens to these cases after the media spotlight fades and the noise dies down? And are the snitches involved reliable?
"Most of these guys don't get tried," said security analyst Bruce Schneier. "These are not criminal masterminds, they're idiots. There's huge fanfares at the arrest, and then it dies off."
The New York men arrested last week were ex-convicts down on their luck. In federal court, one admitted that he'd recently gotten stoned. "I smoke it regularly," he told the judge. Not to worry, he added, "I understand everything you are saying."
James Cromitie, David Williams, Onta Williams and Laguerre Payen were calm as they appeared in court Thursday with shackled hands. They entered no pleas and were ordered held without bail. If convicted, they face life imprisonment.
Federal authorities are proud of their work, saying agents have prevented many attacks by nipping them in the bud. Among the biggest headline grabbers were alleged plots to blow up the Sears Tower in Chicago and underground gas pipes at John F. Kennedy International Airport, and allegations that others planned to storm the Fort Dix military base in New Jersey while dressed as pizza delivery men.
However, court statistics show that most domestic terrorism cases never make it to trial.
According to informant Shahed Hussain, who also helped the FBI in 2004 by posing as an arms dealer, he met the men arrested last week at a local mosque.
Cromitie, the alleged mastermind, told Hussain "I hate those mother-------, those f------ Jewish b------ .... I would like to get a synagogue," according to the complaint.
Hussain drove the men to scout targets and supplied them with weapons and explosive devices that, unbeknownst to the accused, were fake.
"Where he goes conspiracies blossom," said attorney Terence L. Kindlon, who represents one of two men sentenced to 15 years in prison based on Hussain's help in a 2004 case involving money laundering charges for a fictitious terror plot.
"We are not entrapping or encouraging anyone to commit a crime," said Joseph M. Demarest, head of New York's FBI office. "We merely facilitated their wishes."
Assistant U.S. attorney Eric Snyder said: "It's hard to envision a more chilling plot."
Which is almost exactly what then-U.S. Attorney Roslynn Mauskopf said in 2007 when announcing the bust of an alleged plan to blow up gas lines at JFK airport. Russell Defrietas _ described by neighbors as a man who slept in his car and couldn't read or write _ was arrested with three others on the work of an FBI informant, a twice-convicted drug dealer.
Mauskopf called it "one of the most chilling plots imaginable." Two years later, Defrietas, whom his attorney says is "mentally challenged," and three others sit in a Brooklyn jail. No trial date has been set.
As in last week's case, there was "a very active role played by a confidential informant," said attorney Daniel Noble, who represents Abdel Nur, a co-defendant in the JFK case. "There was never anything there," he said. "The question is whether anything would have happened without the informant."
That point was echoed by Schneier, of security firm BT Group. "Is the FBI manufacturing terrorists? What would happen if they were left on their own? They fall into the hands of an FBI informant, and then they get helped and egged on."
In Detroit, a case against four men once hailed as major victory over terrorism instead became a major embarrassment. In 2004, a federal judge threw out terrorism charges against two convicted men following widespread prosecutorial misconduct and questionable information from a self-described scam artist who once lived with the defendants and was trying to get a prison sentence reduced. One man was eventually deported and the fourth was acquitted.
Video tapes seized at the men's home were claimed to be terror surveillance shots. According to trial testimony, they were vacation videos taken at tourist spots including Disneyland.
However, claiming entrapment and problem informants are not enough to prevent convictions and strong punishments.
Five foreign-born men were convicted in December of conspiracy to kill U.S. soldiers in the Fort Dix case. Four were sentenced to life in prison. The fifth was sentenced to 33 years. Their trials relied heavily on two paid FBI informants who secretly recorded meetings and telephone calls during a 15-month operation and helped the men meet an arms dealer.
During the investigation, one of the men called a Philadelphia police officer saying he had been approached by someone who was pressuring him to obtain a map of Fort Dix and he suspected it was terrorist-related.
That didn't hold much sway with jurors.
Acting U.S. Attorney Ralph Marra said he hoped the sentences served as a warning.
"We're going to catch you and hopefully catch you before you do it," he said. "And we're going to punish you severely."
___
Associated Press writers Michael Virtanen and Tom Hays contributed to this story.
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: War On Terror
Terrorism arrests: snitch, sting, then controversyAP - Monday, May 25
Troops kill 60 rebels, make largest Afghan drugs bustAFP - Saturday, May 23
Bush criticized by former 9/11 commission memberAP - Saturday, May 23
Canadian man gets time served for terror sentenceAP - Saturday, May 23
Related Articles: World
30 hurt in clash at Sikh temple in AustriaAFP - Monday, May 25
UK-World SummaryReuters - Monday, May 25
Darfur rebels seize town from Sudan troops: UNAFP - Monday, May 25
Iran summit vows to fight drugs, extremismAFP - Monday, May 25
Darfur fighters take Sudan army baseReuters - Monday, May 25
Related Full Coverage
War On Terror
Global fight against terrorism
All Full Coverage
Most Popular – World
Viewed
Obama signs credit card reforms
Smokers duped by light cigarettes: US court
Vitamin D boosts brain power in middle-aged men
Popular cereal is a drug, US food watchdog says
Health chiefs warn against 'sneaky' flu virus
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Monday, 25 May 2009 British royal chauffeur suspended over security breach
Iran summit vows to fight drugs, extremism
Britain's Button wins Monaco Grand Prix
North Korea conducts nuclear test, faces more isolation
| International
|
Ecuador president nixes EU free trade deal
Darfur fighters take Sudan army base
World Bank chief warns about economic crisis
Iran says foreign troops no help to region's security
| International
|
British MPs claimed expenses for family hire: report
US military: Iraq attacks down nearly 60 percent
Sri Lanka's Tigers acknowledge leader's death
| International
|
GM, Chrysler face decisive week as deadlines loom
Israel to keep expanding settlements: Netanyahu
Myanmar says Thai meddling over Suu Kyi trial
| International
|
Facebook block ahead of Iran vote hampers youth
Gender issues worsen Iraq's medical woes
Hezbollah rejects report linking it to Hariri death
Darfur fighters take Sudan army base: peacekeepers
| International
|
Japan panel wants first strikes against enemies: report
| International
|
Iran hosts high-profile summit on drugs, extremism
Netanyahu: We'll build in existing settlements
Preacher dies after Sikh temple attack in Vienna
| International
|
US House Speaker Pelosi in China for climate talks
South Korea plans public funeral for ex-leader Roh
| International
|
Afghanistan's Karzai in Iran for terror, drugs summit
Gore, others urge CEOs to back climate change deal
Suicide car bomber kills 7 in Somalia, residents flee
| International
|
Netanyahu defies Obama on Israeli settlement freeze
| International
|
Heavy rains trigger flood alert in southern China
Sri Lanka pledges more democracy in Tamil zone
Indie filmmakers in Cannes still dreaming of 3-D
| Technology
|
Asian, European ministers to meet in Hanoi
Police chase ends with river rescue in upstate NY
Tigers admit leader dead; UN presses Sri Lanka over access
Australian flood waters create 'inland sea'
Search focuses on Calif., Mexico for mom, sick son
Australia stops boat of suspected asylum seekers
Terrorism arrests: snitch, sting, then controversy
Suu Kyi lawyers prepare defence in Myanmar trial
Bondsmen upset by policies that free more people
Japan to relax arms export ban: report
Ex-con's magazine focuses on advocacy, prison life
Democrats win Mongolia presidential poll: reports
Top U.S. military officer pushes Guantanamo closing
S.Korea bonds gain ahead of MSB auctions, maturity
Border Patrol chooses Canaan for new station
2 killed, 6 hurt in Ariz graduation party shooting
Seoul shares fall; ex-president's death weighs
China investors make deal for stake in NBA Cavaliers
Final exec faces sentence in SC firm's $275M bust
China's Hainan Airlines posts annual loss
Recession weighs heavily on aid to poor countries
Police: Officer kills Ohio man who took hostage
US, China set to grapple with economic concerns
Chinese traders leave as Kyrgyzstan closes markets
Danish 'Antichrist' provides Cannes' annual scandal
Porcupine, python strut catwalk for Russian zoo
YouTube star Susan Boyle through to talent show final
Cannes-winner Haneke probes dark secrets of bourgeois life
Gainsbourg crowned in Cannes for 'Antichrist' shocker
Haneke's chilling White Ribbon wins in Cannes
| Entertainment
|
'Night at the Museum' comes to life to claim top spot
Coco Chanel film brings curtain down in Cannes
| Entertainment
|
'White Ribbon' village drama ties up top prize at Cannes
Museum comedy beats Terminator at box office
| Entertainment
|
French 'Prophet' takes Cannes Grand Prix
Internet star Susan Boyle stuns again with Memory
| Entertainment
|
Haneke's 'White Ribbon' takes top prize at Cannes
Cannes Film Festival prize winners
Indie filmmakers in Cannes still dreaming of 3-D
| Entertainment
|
Theatre fans up in arms over Marcel Marceau auction
| Entertainment
|
Italian showman Benigni brings Dante to America
| Entertainment
|
ETA warns of new strategy for independence
Facebook block ahead of Iran vote hampers youth
Pakistani soldiers battle Taliban in Swat town
| International
|
Iran's Ahmadinejad rejects Western nuclear proposal
| International
|
Myanmar opens trial again, Suu Kyi may take stand
| International
|
Riots in India after Austrian Sikh killing
| International
|
Karadzic files motion detailing immunity deal
| International
|
Muslim nations link better ties with Israel to peace
| International
|
Afghan floods kill 94, make thousands homeless
| International
|
Atlantis lands after successful Hubble fix
Nokia starts roll-out of Apple App Store rival
| Technology
|
Craps player sets record at NJ casino
Iranian moderate candidate criticizes Facebook ban
| Technology
|
Congress to Obama: Gitmo plan before Gitmo money
YouTube star who witnessed shooting comes clean
| Technology
|
Bride is on board after Grand Central proposal
Correction: Giuliani-Harassment Arrest story
Man killed in NJ boating accident died of drowning
New Yorkers prepare for car-free Times Square
Deadly Indian riots after Sikh shooting in Austria
Huge lobster roll to be colossal creation
Police foil bomb attack at Philippine port
Vegas casinos try bargains to lure back visitors
Korea Hot Stocks
Kenya to enact laws regulating mobile phone banking
| Technology
|
Tamil Tigers admit leader is dead
China's herders plea for help as wolf packs return
Myanmar looms over foreign ministers' meeting
American diver missing off Malaysia
Thousands mourn former SKorea leader
Myanmar rejects ASEAN statement on Suu Kyi
Guru dies after Austrian temple clash: police
Kumble heroics not enough as Deccan win IPL
Popular film wins Cannes, but Antichrist lingers
| Entertainment
|
Museum comedy beats Terminator at box office
| Entertainment
|
Internet star Susan Boyle stuns again with Memory
| Entertainment
|
Small Explosion Damages New York City Starbucks; Residents Evacuated
San Diego Brush Fire Believed To Be Caused By Human Activity
First African-American To Lead NASA
Pelosi Leads Climate Change Delegation To China
U.S. Soldiers With H1N1 Flu Leave Kuwait
Obama Visits Tomb Of Unknown Soldier As Nation Marks Memorial Day
Ohio Man Who Believed Neighbor Kidnapped Parents Goes On Shooting Rampage; Shot Dead By Police
North Korea Conducts Second Nuclear Test; Ignites Tensions In Peninsula, Washington
Kim Jong Il, Obama Express Condolences After South Korean Leader's Suicide
Herbert York, Physicist Who Helped Develop Atomic Bomb And Later Advocated Arms Control, Dead At 87
Raise a glass to Hangover
| Entertainment
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights