">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Obama faces shoot-down dilemma with NKorea launch
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Australia
China
India
Indonesia
Japan
Malaysia
Philippines
Thailand
Vietnam
Search
Search:
Obama faces shoot-down dilemma with NKorea launch
AFP - Tuesday, March 17
WASHINGTON (AFP) - - If the North Korean regime goes ahead next month with a rocket launch, US President Barack Obama will face the dilemma of whether or not to shoot it down.
ADVERTISEMENT
A decision to knock the rocket out would assume US missile defense weaponry would work as designed, something skeptics question.
Even if military success was assured, Obama would have to weigh the risk of retaliation by the Stalinist regime along with inflaming international opinion.
The window for a decision would be a matter of minutes.
In the early stage after launch during the "boost phase," it would remain unclear if the rocket was bound for space with a satellite as North Korea has announced.
"You don't know from the path it's going on at that point whether it's headed to put something into space or to reach the US or somewhere close," said Bruce Bennett of the Rand Corporation in California.
During those early minutes, the president could order US Aegis destroyers and cruisers in the Sea of Japan to knock out the suspected missile, possibly on grounds that it posed a threat to Japan.
Similar US Navy ships successfully shot down an errant satellite last year over the Pacific.
Further into the launch, the trajectory of the missile would become apparent, either heading towards space or on a lower sub-orbital path like that used by intercontinental ballistic missiles.
"By the time you get over the Pacific depending upon the design of their system, they may or may not have released the satellite, but you have a better idea of whether it's really trying to head toward the United States or put something into orbit," Bennett said.
At that point, Obama could use the second line of defense, interceptors based in Alaska and California, to shoot down the missile. The reliability of that system has been fiercely debated, but the military says it has worked in 37 of 47 tests.
Due to Russia's reluctance, the United Nations' Security Council has yet to issue a clear warning to North Korea ahead of the April launch. Washington and its allies say any launch would violate UN resolutions.
The absence of UN Security Council backing would make it diplomatically difficult for Washington to pull the trigger, especially as Obama blasted his predecessor for backing unilateral action.
In its public statements, the US administration has not appeared to be laying the ground for firing on the missile, said Michael O'Hanlon of the Washington-based Brookings Institution.
"I'm dubious that we will or that we should," unless there was a direct threat to Japan or legal backing from the Security Council, he told AFP.
The best case scenario for Obama would be another failed launch by the North Koreans, which was the result in 2006.
If Obama opts for restraint and the North Koreans stage a successful launch, the regime will have demonstrated that is making progress in its missile program.
And analysts say it would provide a boost to North Korean leader Kim Jong-Il as it would come before South Korea's first domestic satellite launch in June.
The more hawkish view is that the United States would then be drawn into a Cold War-era type of standoff, potentially blackmailed by a regime wielding the threat of ICBMs.
But some analysts say the regime is still some distance away from being able to manufacture a nuclear warhead that could be fit onto a missile and survive re-entry into the atmosphere.
Perhaps the greatest risk of ordering a "shoot-down" is that it might fail, an embarrassing outcome that would hand a triumph to North Korea.
"That would significantly undermine the credibility of our missile defense program, both within Congress which would likely say then why are we spending all this money, and with our allies who we are trying to encourage to become involved in the program," Bennett said.
Gauging the right US diplomatic response will also present a dilemma, analysts say, as North Korea might see a softer tone as a sign of weakness while a heavier reaction might be exactly what the regime is looking for.
In 1993, the regime tested another new US president, Bill Clinton, in a similar way, announcing it would withdraw from the Nuclear Non-Proliferation treaty.
While the regime is portrayed as erratic, North Korea is "totally predictable" when it comes to missile tests, said Andrew Grotto, an analyst at the Center for American Progress.
"They test missiles whenever they want attention, fear that they are losing diplomatic initiative, or to remind countries in the region that they are a force to be reckoned with," he said.
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Recommend this article
Average (0 votes)
Sign in to recommend this article »
Most Recommended Stories »
Related Articles: Asia Pacific
Red Cross hostage tents found after Philippine clashAFP - 1 hour 33 minutes ago
Kangaroos in the firing line in AustraliaAP - 1 hour 35 minutes ago
World Heritage Sites to be proposed in CambodiaAP - 1 hour 35 minutes ago
Australian rangers hunt 'killer croc'AFP - 1 hour 45 minutes ago
No Japan-China summit this month: officialsAFP - 2 hours 1 minute ago
Enlarge Photo
Obama faces shoot-down dilemma with NKorea launch
Most Popular – Asia Pacific
Viewed
Twin boys for Charlie Sheen and wife
Arrest warrant issued for Lindsay Lohan
For sale: nagging wife, very high maintenance
Bailed-out AIG plans bonuses worth millions: report
World Bank warns of "very dangerous" year ahead
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Tuesday, 17 March 2009 U.S. forces shot down Iranian drone over Iraq
| International
|
Differences remain in talks over Israeli soldier
| International
|
Merkel says EU must consolidate before growing
| International
|
Life in North Korea dire and desperate, U.N. forum told
| International
|
U.N. aid workers freed after kidnap in Somalia
| International
|
Kuwait ruler accepts cabinet resignation in new crisis
| International
|
Hearst prints final Seattle PI as newspapers dwindle
| Technology
|
E-prescribing to soar with new spending
| Technology
|
Phone firms seek low bar for broadband grants
| Technology
|
Cisco to sell servers aimed at data centers
| Technology
|
Obama to appear on the Tonight Show
| Entertainment
|
Elvis memorabilia offered in online auction
| Entertainment
|
Bands often scalp tickets: Nine Inch Nails' Reznor
| Entertainment
|
Egypt author wins Arab fiction prize for Beelzebub
| Entertainment
|
Madagascar's president isolated but defiant
| International
|
US military shoots down Iranian drone
No deal reached in Israel-Hamas prisoner talks
Reformist Khatami quits Iran presidential race
Britain's Brown says should have curbed markets
Israel says Hamas hardens stance in soldier release talks
Chrysler insists it will avoid bankruptcy
Khatami pulls out of Iran's presidential race
OPEC chief demands rich nations act on crisis
US military says Iraqi girl killed in US shooting
In power, El Salvador ex-rebels seek U.S. ties
| International
|
US intervenes to boost small business loans
Sudan wants foreign groups to stop distributing aid
Iran's Khatami says out of presidential race
| International
|
Turkey disregards minority rights in schools
Shooting inside Madagascar presidency: AFP
North Korean premier lauds China as regional anchor
| International
|
Iraqis most upbeat since 2003: poll
US industrial output falls to 2002 low
Best view in Rio? Pushing limits of slum tourism
| International
|
Iraqi fan kills soccer player in close game
Riot police quell protest as water forum opens
Modernization poses new challenges for Tibetans
| International
|
More flee as Sri Lanka rebels mount suicide attack
| International
|
INSIDE WASHINGTON: Rivalry stymies wind-power goal
8 Dems oppose quick debate on global warming bill
EU 'fact-finding' mission on Guantanamo inmates
U.S. raises new anti-terrorism approach with EU
Red Cross report renews call for probe of Bush era
Intel says AMD breached patent licensing pact
US military deaths in Iraq war at 4,259
www@20: How the techies tamed the cyber zoo
Mexico retaliates with tariffs on 90 US products
Apple Mac U.S. units down 16 pct in February: NPD
Cisco to go head-to-head with HP, IBM
Peace Corps pulls out of Madagascar due to unrest
US says it shot down Iran drone north of Baghdad
Hearst prints final Seattle PI as newspapers dwindle
Thousands of Tamils decry Sri Lankan 'genocide'
Cisco to sell servers aimed at data centers
Baptized by Fire: Men of Killer Blue face future
Russian woman held for eating friend: report
Potty-mouthed video game grabs profanity record
Vatican website to be available in Chinese
Zombies, stories and wordplay win SXSW Web awards
Phone firms seek low bar for broadband grants
NGO expelled from Darfur considered ICC cooperation
| International
|
Malaysian lawmaker charged with sedition
Obama faces shoot-down dilemma with NKorea launch
NKorea premier visits China amid missile tensions
9th Australian soldier dies in Afghanistan
NATO soldier dies after attack in Afghan south
China labor activist free after 7 years jail
Hearst prints final Seattle PI
| Technology
|
Philippine unemployment rises: govt
"Traveler's Wife" to embark this summer
Elvis memorabilia offered in online auction
| Technology
|
Bomb lobbed at police station in China's west
Japanese fashion robot to hit Tokyo catwalks
| Technology
|
NKorean premier arrives in China amid tensions
Intel says AMD breached patent licensing pact
| Technology
|
No Japan-China summit this month: officials
Shanghai probes waterlogged beef food scare
Apple Mac U.S. units down 16 pct in February: NPD
| Technology
|
Disney cuts 30 jobs in HK as park expansion stalls
S.Korea says raised US swap extension during G20
Rudd, Segel bring perfect chemistry to bromance
Taiwan dollar scales 1-week high on econ optimism
White House: Obama to appear on Leno's show
South Korean bonds rise on extra budget plan
Steve-O skips `Dancing' because of back injury
Seoul shares up;stronger won lifts banks, airlines
Tween "Dora" won't be a bad girl, say guardians
S.Korean department stores enjoy brisk sales on won drop
DJ AM seeks $20 million for plane crash damages
Connick set to receive honorary Tulane degree
'Good Negro' examines '60s civil rights movement
"The Greatest" inks distribution deal with Senator
Indonesia wants solution for Myanmar boat people
Review: Rudd, Segel elevate `I Love You, Man'
'Witch Mountain' casts box office spell
Family Guy wins court battle over song
| Entertainment
|
Tween Dora won't be a bad girl, say guardians
| Entertainment
|
Heath Ledger's music videos come to light
| Entertainment
|
Rudd, Segel bring perfect chemistry to bromance
| Entertainment
|
Andy Samberg to host MTV movie awards
| Entertainment
|
Sopranos creator Chase reveals Dreams for HBO
| Entertainment
|
Traveler's Wife to embark this summer
| Entertainment
|
The Greatest inks distribution deal with Senator
| Entertainment
|
Pope begins Africa tour
| International
|
Hamas says hopes Israel will resume talks on soldier
Israel could use ballistic missiles against Iran: report
| International
|
Iran's Khatami says out of presidential race
American U.N. official kidnapped in Pakistan said sick
| International
|
Iraq urges execution of Saddam-era officials
| International
|
EU faces protests despite recovery signs
Hamas says hopes Israel will resume talks on soldier
| International
|
Curb climate change to save polar bear: Norway
Darfur peacekeeper killed in ambush: force spokesman
| International
|
Pope takes off on first trip to Africa
North Korea slows disablement pace further: report
| International
|
Isolated Madagascar president faces end of reign
More flee as Sri Lanka rebels mount suicide attack
| International
|
Miniature carnivore dinosaurs roamed North America
Pakistan to restore democracy in key province: PM
| International
|
UV light can zap TB in hospitals: study
Curb climate change to save polar bear: Norway
Dell unveils world's thinnest laptop
| Technology
|
Nokia to cut 1,700 jobs in sinking phone market
| Technology
|
India leaders blog, text to plug in to young voters
| Technology
|
US-TECH Summary
Cybersquatting cases hit record in 2008
Cybersquatting cases hit record in 2008
| Technology
|
Dell unveils world's thinnest laptop
India leaders blog, text to plug in to young voters
Money management sites promise financial salvation
Japanese fashion robot to hit Tokyo catwalks
US-TECH Summary
Dell unveils world's thinnest laptop
Amy Winehouse denies assault charge
| Entertainment
|
Natasha Richardson critically injured
| Entertainment
|
India: Nehru relative to face hate crime charges
China voices concern as tensions flare in Koreas
12 SKoreans who survived Yemem bombing return home
Malaysia's leadership battle hit with corruption probe
China's milk victims complain of intimidation
Pakistan to restore democracy in key province
Bomb blast in Tibetan area: police
China concerned over situation on Korean peninsula
Yemen bomber posed for pics with SKoreans: report
China phone carrier expands data network to Europe
Imus in Mass. a day after his cancer announcement
Bank of Japan announces fresh crisis measures
Amy Winehouse pleads not guilty to assault
South Korea to propose $12 bln stimulus package
Natasha Richardson reportedly critically hurt in accident
Philippine unemployment rises 7.7 percent
Amy Winehouse denies assault charge
Tyra: `Top Model' auditions to resume after melee
Kyrgyz deficit to be covered by Russian aid
Screenwriter Millard Kaufman dies at 92
S.Korea to sell up to 19 trln won bonds for budget
The dark side of Cuban cigars
HK's jobless rate rises to 5 percent, 3-year high
Hong Kong moves to send plastic bags packing
Elbit's Elisra gets $25 mln South Korea contract
NKorea reopens border to SKoreans at showpiece zone
Indonesian plane badly damaged in runway mishap
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights