Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Data tweaks reflect a changing China: economists
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Data tweaks reflect a changing China: economists
AFP - Wednesday, February 23
Send
IM Story
Print
SHANGHAI (AFP) - – China raised eyebrows last week by tweaking key inflation gauges just as it seeks to stem public anger about prices, but analysts said the revisions were necessary and not a bid to cook the books.
The government adjusted the consumer price index and its national survey of property prices -- both of which have become monthly sources of anxiety to worried consumers and to markets sensitive to policy changes.
But economists said the revisions reflect the evolution of the Chinese economy and consumer buying power, and are a step towards improving statistical accuracy in the world's second-largest economy.
"If you're pursuing the story that there's something to this adjustment other than a routine adjustment based on changing consumption patterns, I don't see any evidence to support that," said Andy Rothman, a Shanghai-based economist with CLSA.
Concern over the veracity of official Chinese figures is not new.
In the worst days of China's state-planned economy, officials routinely passed on fictitious statistics to appease their superiors. While experts say the situation has improved, questions over transparency continue to be raised.
Even Vice Premier Li Keqiang, who is expected to take over as premier within two years, described economic growth figures as "man-made" in 2007, according to a US diplomatic cable leaked recently by whistleblower website WikiLeaks.
Li has also pressed for sharper data from the National Statistics Bureau (NBS), which makes major revisions every five years and was scheduled to do so this year.
The bureau reduced the weighting of food prices -- which have a history of sparking public unrest -- in the consumer price index, while increasing the weight for rents and other housing costs.
As a result, overall inflation came in at 4.9 percent for January. A Dow Jones poll of 15 economists had forecast a 5.4 percent increase.
The government has raised interest rates three times in the last four months and taken other measures aimed at slowing galloping inflation, and the price data has become an increasing focus amid market fears of further monetary tightening steps.
But economists say the consumer price revision is in line with "Engel's Law" of 19th-century economist Ernst Engel, who said that as incomes rise, the proportion spent on food falls.
"This is a big trend for any country that is growing. The weight of the food will surely decline in a consumption basket," said Lu Ting, a Hong Kong-based China economist with Bank of America Merrill Lynch.
"It's always been a big problem for China's CPI basket in that the weight of rent is sometimes too low. Even after recent revisions it is still too low."
Rent accounts for about nine percent of the index, compared to 40 percent in the US CPI.
The NBS said the revision was undertaken to reflect "changes in China's social and economic development and in the consumption structure of urban and rural residents" and ensure the accuracy of the numbers.
But Hua Min, an economics professor at Shanghai's Fudan University, said applying Engel's Law to Chinese consumers was premature.
"For your average low-income worker, spending on food remains their major living expenditure," he said.
"They may find the rise in inflation released by the NBS does not match the feelings they get of spending a lot on food in real life."
But any gap between the old and new readings is too small to affect policy, he added.
The national property survey by the NBS and the National Development and Reform Commission, meanwhile, was revamped to focus only on price data for individual cities to prevent extreme changes in specific localities from distorting national data.
It also aims to improve the accuracy of the figures by drawing on data from real estate sales centres rather than surveying property agents and developers.
A Standard Chartered Bank analysis concluded the changes should have only a minor impact on government policies, which are focused on fighting inflation by reining in liquidity and curbing property speculation.
It dismissed accusations of political motivations to play down inflation but said the poor quality of Chinese rental price data meant the new consumer price index could fail to reflect inflation rises.
But as CLSA's Rothman says, statistics cannot perfectly mirror reality.
"You could have this same discussion about the CPI basket in every country because it's trying to be an average, but nobody is really average," he said.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Mass rally against inflation in Indian capital AFP - 18 minutes ago
SNAPSHOT-Indian policy highlights on Wednesday, Feb 23 Reuters - 24 minutes ago
HIGHLIGHTS 3-Key comments from BOJ Deputy Governor Yamaguchi Reuters - 39 minutes ago
US-BUSINESS Summary Reuters - 22 minutes ago
Fed policy should stay loose for some time: Evans Reuters - 41 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Japan logs first trade deficit in almost two years
Baby dolphins dying along oil-soaked US Gulf Coast
10 percent global rise in biotech crops: study
Libya live report
Oil prices soar amid Libya crisis
More Top Stories »
Related Full Coverage
China Economychina economy
All Full Coverage »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Oral sex linked to cancer risk
Machu Picchu victim of own success: UN
Social media, cellphone video fuel Arab protests
Planet could be 'unrecognizable' by 2050, experts say
Libya live report
More Most Viewed »
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2011 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Wednesday, 23 February 2011 Iran ships pass via Suez, Israel says provocation
US-TECH Summary
Amazon takes aim at Netflix with streaming video
Key ministers stay in Egyptian cabinet reshuffle
US consumer confidence hits three-year high
New York oil prices jumps 8% on Libya worries
Iranian warships enter Med despite Israel warning
Next model of iPad will not be delayed: source
Android, video games dominate mobile confab
Sudan's parliament ends southern membership early
Erdogan warns Libya on violence as Turks await rescue
Egypt tells embassies to seek Mubarak asset freeze
England edge Netherlands in W. Cup cricket
Tensions rise over Afghan civilian deaths
Iran ships pass via Suez, Israel says provocation
|
Japan ruling party suspends 'Shadow Shogun'
Thai court frees seven protest leaders on bail
Algeria to end 19-year state of emergency
|
Mexican leader slams U.S. coordination in drug war
|
Hong Kong 'milkshake murder' defendant testifies
Protests turn Iraqi Kurd city into military zone
|
Nepal sends civil servants up Everest
Ton-up Ten Doeschate shocks England in World Cup
Pirates kill four U.S. hostages near Somalia
China silent on protest call, hails 'stability'
CBS sets deal with Netflix to stream some TV shows
|
Time Inc Chief Digital Officer Rothenberg exits
|
RIM says rivals will face same pressure from India
|
Apple deemed top of movie product placement charts
|
Sandra Bullock's ex-husband to pen memoir
|
Justin Bieber gets wax figure and cuts hair
|
Oscar fashion goes bold. Thank Lady Gaga!
|
Apple deemed top of movie product placement charts
|
Huawei wins preliminary order in Motorola trade
Defiant Gaddafi vows to die as martyr, fight revolt
|
Libya live report
Judge bars website from live TV, baseball streams
New Zealand quake toll at 75 as damage costs seen at $12 billion
|
Newsmaker: Vision quest haunts Apple CEO-in-waiting
Japan logs first trade deficit in almost two years
Baby dolphins dying along oil-soaked US Gulf Coast
Gun battles erupt in Ivory Coast's main city
|
HP stock slides on trimmed earnings forecast
10 percent global rise in biotech crops: study
Libya live report
Egypt swears in new ministers, Islamists dismiss
|
Wife held in burned Vietnam reporter's death: reports
Cellphone calls alter brain activity: study
Oil prices soar amid Libya crisis
Asia plans mass rescue of citizens from Libya
New York crude oil soars 8.5% on Libya crisis
Xoom tablet debuts Feb. 24 with $800 price
Shuttle Discovery 'ready to fly' on last space mission
New Zealand quake toll at 75, damage costs in billions
Cyber-titan Estonia drafts e-squad to secure election
Defiant Kadhafi vows to remain in Libya
Apple iPad launch due on March 2
China envoy arrives in Taiwan
Renewed call for 'Jasmine rallies' in China
Obama faces pressure to intervene in Libya
Huawei wins preliminary order in Motorola trade
Frantic hunt as NZ quake leaves 400 dead, missing
Xoom tablet debuts Feb. 24 with $800 price
Web becomes virtual crisis centre in NZ quake
Pirates kill four U.S. hostages near Somalia
NZ quake breaks off 30 million tonnes of ice from glacier
World races to aid New Zealand quake rescue
Man with the largest family in the world
Newsmaker: Vision quest haunts Apple CEO-in-waiting
|
Milan abuzz as Fashion Week kicks off
Apple iPad launch due on March 2: source
|
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Huawei wins preliminary order in Motorola trade
|
Chris Brown allowed near Rihanna, 2 years after attack
New York mayor bans smoking in parks, beaches
Judge bars website from live TV, baseball streams
|
Berlusconi's 'Ruby' expected at Vienna Opera Ball
Online retailer Amazon streams films
Seoul shares fall as techs, transporters weigh
Cellphone calls alter brain activity: study
|
New Zealand must expect higher quake toll-PM Key
Big fat Indian weddings could face the axe
HP trims 2011 sales forecast, shares plummet
|
Mideast oil price surge a 'big challenge': IATA
Oscar fashion goes bold. Thank Lady Gaga!
RIM says rivals will face same pressure from India
|
Apple deemed top of movie product placement charts
Pakistan
Justin Bieber gets wax figure and cuts hair
Typewriters still thrive in modernising India
BP deal to boost India's energy output: analysts
Data tweaks reflect a changing China: economists
Seoul shares post third straight session of losses
Oil higher as turmoil in Libya continues
PROFILE-South Korea's President Lee Myung-bak
Chris Brown allowed near Rihanna, 2 years after attack
|
Sandra Bullock's ex-husband to pen memoir
|
Oscar telecast nixing montages, elaborate tributes
|
New version of Justin Bieber film to hit theaters
|
Libya live report
British Gas owner Centrica signs major Qatar deal
Saudi king back home, orders $37 bln in handouts
Commerzbank swings back to profit
Libya live report
Music and mafia: life under Afghanistan's neo-Taliban
Greece hit with general strike over austerity measures
Protests turn Iraqi Kurd city into military zone
Greek police clash with anti-austerity protesters
|
Arsenal look for win in Premiership after FA shock
Huawei wins preliminary order in Motorla secrets case
Bahrain frees prisoners to mollify protesters
|
Seven Yemen MPs quit ruling party over violence
|
China pledges to revive stalled nuke talks
Saudi king back home, orders $37 billion in handouts
|
Asia plans mass rescue of citizens from Libya
Thousands march against India's embattled government
|
US talks with Myanmar's Suu Kyi about aid
Insurers may face up to $8 bln NZ quake hit
Ireland's Fine Gael extends lead: final survey
|
Book by Japan man accused of killing Briton sells well
Designers vie to showcase wares on Oscars catwalk
US diplomat, Suu Kyi talk about aid to Myanmar
Israel to Europe: Iran ships augur nuclear spread
|
Japan, S. Korea pray for N. Zealand quake students
Thousands march against India's embattled government
Pakistan choose to bat against Kenya
Toll Brothers posts third consecutive profitable quarter
Police say 16-year-old killed Florida officer
Union unrest spreads in 3 Midwestern states
It's not over 'til the tenor sings -- now in 3D
Dockers challenges men to Wear the Pants and pursue their dreams in new contest
Designers vie to showcase wares on Oscars catwalk
Emanuel takes Chicago without specter of runoff, budget issues loom
Digital China eyes iPad supplier rights
|
U.S. Supreme Court disallows lawsuit against vaccine maker
Stolen children leave mothers grieving in Pakistan
Justin Guarini to star in Green Day musical "American Idiot"
Ancient Inca grain is new health food darling
Diane Von Furstenberg embarrassed by comment that she was "disappointed" with First Lady Michelle Obama's fashion choice
U.S. stocks plummet on soaring oil prices, fall in home prices
DirecTV profit beats Street; shares rise
|
December freezes yield diminished sugar cane crop in Florida
Hynix says to invest $568 million to expand plant
|
Citigroup, BofA, 4 others cut HP price target
|
Cellphone calls alter brain activity: study
|
Digital China eyes iPad supplier rights
Hynix says to invest $568 million to expand plant
Oscar fashion goes bold. Thank Lady Gaga!
|
It's not over 'til the tenor sings -- now in 3D
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights