Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Tensions rise over Afghan civilian deaths
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Tensions rise over Afghan civilian deaths
By PATRICK QUINN and RAHIM FAIEZ,Associated Press -
Wednesday, February 23
Send
IM Story
Print
KABUL, Afghanistan – An investigation into claims that international troops killed scores of civilians in northeast Afghanistan escalated into a feud Tuesday between President Hamid Karzai and senior U.S. military officials who cited a report that Afghan parents have been known to discipline children by burning their hands and feet.
Karzai spokesman Waheed Omar described comments made by Rear Adm. Gregory Smith, director of communications for the U.S.-led coalition, also known as International Security Assistance Force, as being "outrageous, insulting and racist." He demanded a clarification.
The flap started during a discussion at the presidential palace about claims that NATO forces killed about 60 civilians during a four-day operation in Kunar province _ a charge that has been contested by the international coalition.
Media reports and television footage broadcast after the claims showed severely injured children and others with burns on their faces, hands and feet _ yet is was unclear if they were injured in military operations.
The Washington Post, quoting unidentified individuals who attended the palace meeting, reported Tuesday that Gen. David Petraeus, the top NATO commander in Afghanistan, had suggested that Afghans might have intentionally burned their own children to exaggerate claims of civilian casualties.
The coalition vehemently denied the report.
"Gen. Petraeus never said that children's hands and feet were purposely burned by their families in order to create a CIVCAS (civilian casualty) event," Smith said. "Rather, he said that the injuries to the children appeared inconsistent with the types of munitions used and that the burns to their hands and feet may have been the result of discipline sometimes handed out to Afghan children. Regrettably this is customary among some Afghan fathers as a way of dealing with children who misbehave."
Omar said that Karzai was demanding an explanation.
"The president was extremely annoyed by the comments made by Adm. Smith that Afghans boil the hands and feet of their children to discipline them and we find these comments outrageous, insulting and racist," Omar told The Associated Press.
"Afghans love their children and to suggest that Afghans boil the hands and feet of their children suggests a lack of information or ... someone's feeling for Afghans. We want NATO and the ISAF leadership to take serious note of these comments and the president will ask for clarification from ISAF in this," he said.
Omar added that "on the one side, Afghan children and women are killed brutally by terrorists and on the other side they are insulted in this manner."
Although relatively unheard of, there have been some such incidents reported in the past. A 2009 human rights report issued by the U.S. State Department said that "in extreme examples of child abuse, observers reported several instances of deliberately burned children in Paktia (province); the children sustained burns after their parents submerged them in boiling water."
Earlier in the day, a government delegation, sent by Karzai, met with tribal elders from the remote Ghazi Abad district, and other provincial officials to investigate the claims of civilian casualties.
Nawrdin Safi, a provincial council member from Kunar who attended the meeting, said tribal elders repeated their allegation that "more than 60 people have been killed in the four days of the operation and around 50 of that number are civilians, including women and children."
He said that the delegation was discussing a trip to Ghazi Abad.
"We have to go personally to the site to find out what's really going on and what number is correct, and how many of those killed are really civilian. ... The real investigation will be at the site," Safi said, adding that the delegation would also examine grave sites. "Hopefully we will be able to determine exactly how many have been killed."
The coalition, which also is investigating the allegation, has said video of operations on Feb. 17 _ the main event of a more than three-day operation _ showed troops targeting and killing dozens of insurgents, not civilians.
"We are reviewing all operations, to include several involving the use of fighter aircraft that dropped various munitions on other remote mountainous areas in the Ghazi Abad district prior to and after this event," Smith said.
"The review of these engagements is still under way, so there's always the possibility one of them may have resulted in civilian casualties, but reports from elders in the region appear unrealistically high and unsupported by anything we know to date. The work of the joint assessment team is still ongoing, so no final judgments are being made at this time."
Smith said video of the Feb. 17 operation showed no women, children or buildings near the site of the attacks against the insurgents.
"In all, we estimate somewhere around 40 armed insurgents were killed by coalition air," Smith said.
Afghan and coalition officials also are investigating how the civilians, filmed being treated at a hospital in the provincial capital of Asadabad, were injured.
The director of the health department for Kunar province, Assadulah Fazeli, said all their injuries were caused by a bomb and none were deliberate. He added that what burns they had were consistent with an explosion. All the patients are from Ghazi Abad district, but Fazeli said he did not know where or when they had been injured.
"They are all from the same family and all the injuries they have are multiple wounds from a bomb," Fazeli said. "This has been determined by the doctors in the hospital that the wounds are from an air strike and each one of these patients has multiple wounds on different parts of their bodies."
A recent U.N. report documented 2,412 conflict-related civilian casualties in the first 10 months of 2010. More than three-quarters of them were caused by militant activity, a 25 percent increase from the same period in 2009, the report said. At the same time, civilian casualties attributed to pro-government forces, including those from the NATO coalition, decreased.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Defiant Kadhafi vows to remain in Libya AFP - 51 minutes ago
Four Americans killed by Somali pirates: US AFP - Wednesday, February 23
African leaders pursue peace plan in Ivory Coast AFP - Wednesday, February 23
Libya live report AFP - 26 minutes ago
UK-World Summary Reuters - 1 hour 26 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Libya live report
US consumer confidence hits three-year high
Defiant Kadhafi vows to remain in Libya
New York oil prices jumps 8% on Libya worries
World markets tumble, oil spikes on Libya unrest
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Oral sex linked to cancer risk
Planet could be 'unrecognizable' by 2050, experts say
Machu Picchu victim of own success: UN
Social media, cellphone video fuel Arab protests
Libya shockwaves hit Italian businesses
More Most Viewed »
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2011 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Wednesday, 23 February 2011 Iran ships pass via Suez, Israel says provocation
US-TECH Summary
Amazon takes aim at Netflix with streaming video
Key ministers stay in Egyptian cabinet reshuffle
US consumer confidence hits three-year high
New York oil prices jumps 8% on Libya worries
Iranian warships enter Med despite Israel warning
Next model of iPad will not be delayed: source
Android, video games dominate mobile confab
Sudan's parliament ends southern membership early
Erdogan warns Libya on violence as Turks await rescue
Egypt tells embassies to seek Mubarak asset freeze
England edge Netherlands in W. Cup cricket
Tensions rise over Afghan civilian deaths
Iran ships pass via Suez, Israel says provocation
|
Japan ruling party suspends 'Shadow Shogun'
Thai court frees seven protest leaders on bail
Algeria to end 19-year state of emergency
|
Mexican leader slams U.S. coordination in drug war
|
Hong Kong 'milkshake murder' defendant testifies
Protests turn Iraqi Kurd city into military zone
|
Nepal sends civil servants up Everest
Ton-up Ten Doeschate shocks England in World Cup
Pirates kill four U.S. hostages near Somalia
China silent on protest call, hails 'stability'
CBS sets deal with Netflix to stream some TV shows
|
Time Inc Chief Digital Officer Rothenberg exits
|
RIM says rivals will face same pressure from India
|
Apple deemed top of movie product placement charts
|
Sandra Bullock's ex-husband to pen memoir
|
Justin Bieber gets wax figure and cuts hair
|
Oscar fashion goes bold. Thank Lady Gaga!
|
Apple deemed top of movie product placement charts
|
Huawei wins preliminary order in Motorola trade
Defiant Gaddafi vows to die as martyr, fight revolt
|
Libya live report
Judge bars website from live TV, baseball streams
New Zealand quake toll at 75 as damage costs seen at $12 billion
|
Newsmaker: Vision quest haunts Apple CEO-in-waiting
Japan logs first trade deficit in almost two years
Baby dolphins dying along oil-soaked US Gulf Coast
Gun battles erupt in Ivory Coast's main city
|
HP stock slides on trimmed earnings forecast
10 percent global rise in biotech crops: study
Libya live report
Egypt swears in new ministers, Islamists dismiss
|
Wife held in burned Vietnam reporter's death: reports
Cellphone calls alter brain activity: study
Oil prices soar amid Libya crisis
Asia plans mass rescue of citizens from Libya
New York crude oil soars 8.5% on Libya crisis
Xoom tablet debuts Feb. 24 with $800 price
Shuttle Discovery 'ready to fly' on last space mission
New Zealand quake toll at 75, damage costs in billions
Cyber-titan Estonia drafts e-squad to secure election
Defiant Kadhafi vows to remain in Libya
Apple iPad launch due on March 2
China envoy arrives in Taiwan
Renewed call for 'Jasmine rallies' in China
Obama faces pressure to intervene in Libya
Huawei wins preliminary order in Motorola trade
Frantic hunt as NZ quake leaves 400 dead, missing
Xoom tablet debuts Feb. 24 with $800 price
Web becomes virtual crisis centre in NZ quake
Pirates kill four U.S. hostages near Somalia
NZ quake breaks off 30 million tonnes of ice from glacier
World races to aid New Zealand quake rescue
Man with the largest family in the world
Newsmaker: Vision quest haunts Apple CEO-in-waiting
|
Milan abuzz as Fashion Week kicks off
Apple iPad launch due on March 2: source
|
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Huawei wins preliminary order in Motorola trade
|
Chris Brown allowed near Rihanna, 2 years after attack
New York mayor bans smoking in parks, beaches
Judge bars website from live TV, baseball streams
|
Berlusconi's 'Ruby' expected at Vienna Opera Ball
Online retailer Amazon streams films
Seoul shares fall as techs, transporters weigh
Cellphone calls alter brain activity: study
|
New Zealand must expect higher quake toll-PM Key
Big fat Indian weddings could face the axe
HP trims 2011 sales forecast, shares plummet
|
Mideast oil price surge a 'big challenge': IATA
Oscar fashion goes bold. Thank Lady Gaga!
RIM says rivals will face same pressure from India
|
Apple deemed top of movie product placement charts
Pakistan
Justin Bieber gets wax figure and cuts hair
Typewriters still thrive in modernising India
BP deal to boost India's energy output: analysts
Data tweaks reflect a changing China: economists
Seoul shares post third straight session of losses
Oil higher as turmoil in Libya continues
PROFILE-South Korea's President Lee Myung-bak
Chris Brown allowed near Rihanna, 2 years after attack
|
Sandra Bullock's ex-husband to pen memoir
|
Oscar telecast nixing montages, elaborate tributes
|
New version of Justin Bieber film to hit theaters
|
Libya live report
British Gas owner Centrica signs major Qatar deal
Saudi king back home, orders $37 bln in handouts
Commerzbank swings back to profit
Libya live report
Music and mafia: life under Afghanistan's neo-Taliban
Greece hit with general strike over austerity measures
Protests turn Iraqi Kurd city into military zone
Greek police clash with anti-austerity protesters
|
Arsenal look for win in Premiership after FA shock
Huawei wins preliminary order in Motorla secrets case
Bahrain frees prisoners to mollify protesters
|
Seven Yemen MPs quit ruling party over violence
|
China pledges to revive stalled nuke talks
Saudi king back home, orders $37 billion in handouts
|
Asia plans mass rescue of citizens from Libya
Thousands march against India's embattled government
|
US talks with Myanmar's Suu Kyi about aid
Insurers may face up to $8 bln NZ quake hit
Ireland's Fine Gael extends lead: final survey
|
Book by Japan man accused of killing Briton sells well
Designers vie to showcase wares on Oscars catwalk
US diplomat, Suu Kyi talk about aid to Myanmar
Israel to Europe: Iran ships augur nuclear spread
|
Japan, S. Korea pray for N. Zealand quake students
Thousands march against India's embattled government
Pakistan choose to bat against Kenya
Toll Brothers posts third consecutive profitable quarter
Police say 16-year-old killed Florida officer
Union unrest spreads in 3 Midwestern states
It's not over 'til the tenor sings -- now in 3D
Dockers challenges men to Wear the Pants and pursue their dreams in new contest
Designers vie to showcase wares on Oscars catwalk
Emanuel takes Chicago without specter of runoff, budget issues loom
Digital China eyes iPad supplier rights
|
U.S. Supreme Court disallows lawsuit against vaccine maker
Stolen children leave mothers grieving in Pakistan
Justin Guarini to star in Green Day musical "American Idiot"
Ancient Inca grain is new health food darling
Diane Von Furstenberg embarrassed by comment that she was "disappointed" with First Lady Michelle Obama's fashion choice
U.S. stocks plummet on soaring oil prices, fall in home prices
DirecTV profit beats Street; shares rise
|
December freezes yield diminished sugar cane crop in Florida
Hynix says to invest $568 million to expand plant
|
Citigroup, BofA, 4 others cut HP price target
|
Cellphone calls alter brain activity: study
|
Digital China eyes iPad supplier rights
Hynix says to invest $568 million to expand plant
Oscar fashion goes bold. Thank Lady Gaga!
|
It's not over 'til the tenor sings -- now in 3D
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights