">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
G8 days numbered?
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Search
Search:
G8 days numbered?
AFP - Monday, July 6
PARIS (AFP) - - The Group of Eight industrialised powers, ineffectual in the face of the worldwide finance crisis, is slowly losing its grip on the global economy and now faces calls for its abolition.
ADVERTISEMENT
The G8 -- Britain, Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Russia and the United States -- has done little more than issue statements of principle since the start of the crisis last September, leaving the heavy-lifting to the broader Group of 20.
It was the G20, which in addition to the G8 includes such emerging market powerhouses as Argentina, Brazil, China, India and South Africa, that confronted the crisis head on at an April summit in London.
"As far as we can tell, no substantive results have come out of the G7-G8 meetings for many years," said Richard Portes, a researcher at the London School of Economics.
The G8, whose leaders are to meet July 8-10 in Italy, began as an informal grouping in 1975, when it was known as the G7 before the inclusion of Russia.
Portes said the G8 has now "become irrelevant to most of the major issues."
"It cannot deal with the environment, trade, international finance without bringing in China, India, Brazil or South Africa."
Added Barry Echengreen of the University of California at Berkeley: "It's silly to imagine that there could be a durable reform of the international monetary system that did not involve the largest reserve holder," a reference to China.
German Chancellor Angela Merkel has also questioned the G8 format.
"The problems we are confronting can no longer be resolved by the industrialised countries alone," she said last week.
One of the relatively few remaining defenders of the G8, John Kirton of the University of Toronto, has argued that the group does have "an essential role to play."
"The G20 summit basically followed the principles and guidelines set down first by the G7 and G8," he said.
But most international affairs experts believe the G8's days are numbered.
"If they want the G20 to survive and to be functional, the two (G8 and G20) cannot stay together," maintained Rajiv Kumar of the Indian Council for Research on International Economic Relations.
His position was echoed by Charles Wyplosz of the Institut de Hautes Etudes Internationales in Geneva.
"The end of the G8 must be prepared. There is a fundamental contradiction in maintaining this small team when it itself has turned over the big issues to the G20."
At Cornell University in the United States, Eswar Prasad said "the G20 is increasingly taking the role as the agenda-setting body for the world."
But Prasad also acknowledged that the G20, which rose to prominence in response to the finance crisis, might not survive the return of better times "because there are some very big tensions inside the G20" among emerging and developed nations on the question of (economic) regulation.
Kirton of the University of Toronto noted that the "enormous diversity amongst the G20" could also prove to be a handicap.
"China and Saudi Arabia have different conceptions than the rest of the G8 concerning democracy, which is crucial when you deal with financial regulation," he said.
Kumar of the Indian Research Council has said that a more streamlined formation than the vast G20 might be called for, citing the possibility of a Group of 4 -- Japan, China, the United States and the European Union.
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: China's Economy
Shanghai push for luxury crowd despite tough timesAP - 2 hours 10 minutes ago
TOPWRAP 1-China reassures on dollar before G8; markets subduedReuters - 2 hours 32 minutes ago
Asian stocks mixed as investors await profitsAP - 2 hours 49 minutes ago
Ford says China sales up 14 percent in first halfAP - Monday, July 6
Related Articles: Business
GLOBAL MARKETS-Caution rules on world economy before G8Reuters - Monday, July 6
JGB 10-year yield hits 3-month low on recovery doubtsReuters - Monday, July 6
China menswear designer Lilang eyes $100 mln HK IPO-reportReuters - Monday, July 6
RPT-BRIEF-Bemis to buy Rio's Alcan packaging unit for $1.2blnReuters - Monday, July 6
BRIEF-Moody's sees neg otlk for Korea non-life insurance sectorReuters - Monday, July 6
Enlarge Photo
G8 days numbered?
Related Photos
Slideshow Full Photo Coverage: Business & Economy
Related Full Coverage
China Economy
china economy
All Full Coverage
Most Popular – Business
Viewed
The daily grind: Sex for a week boosts sperm quality
Harry Potter's nemesis revels in hard-edged new film
Schwarzenegger declares emergency in California
Jackson fans told to stay away as tickets up for grabs
Questions mount over Jackson animal kingdom
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Monday, 6 July 2009 Iran frees foreign reporter amid fresh vote claims
Incoming MI6 chief in Facebook security slip
US-TECH Summary
Two British troops killed in major Afghan push
Media players plot survival in Sun Valley
Irish team in Sudan to help free kidnapped aid staff
Yemenia jet's black boxes 'will take days to recover'
Israel's Barak seeks peace 'understanding' with US
Crash probe locates doomed Yemeni flight recorders
| International
|
Iraqis skeptical about significance of US pullback
Iran: British-Greek reporter held for weeks freed
Three killed in riot in China's Xinjiang region
| International
|
3 dead after NC fireworks go off, 1 in Pa. blast
Mohawks v. Canada: Bridge shutdown hurts business
Missed revenue forecasts pose more woes for states
Suspected arson kills four in Japan: police
States digging deep to monitor water
Indian guards kill man crossing from Pakistan
Several Injured In Indiana Bridge Collapse
Tamil rebel shoots dead Sri Lankan soldier
Media players plot survival at Sun Valley confab
| Technology
|
Biden predicts more jobs because of stimulus money
Bomb blast near south Philippine cathedral kills 5
Former DC Mayor Marion Barry Arrested
Maine pound shows off rare orange, live lobsters
UN chief's failure to meet Suu Kyi a 'great loss': NLD party
Suspected Serial Killer Has Small SC Town On Edge
Biden: Israel free to set own course on Iran
U.S. to Give Pakistan Crucial Drone Technology
Pakistani jets pound Taliban on Afghan border
Disney Monorail Crash Kills One
Texas teen says father wrapped chain around him
Returning Yousuf repays Pakistan with Test century
Walt Disney World monorail crash kills employee
Developing: QB Steve McNair Found Dead In Apparent Homicide
N.Korean ship sails home after being tracked by US: report
Japan PM seeks votes with approval ratings low
Official: Palin cited toll of ethics complaints
Nomura breaks into Saudi investment banking market
New Zealand house price decline slows in June-survey
Obama and networks: a symbiotic relationship
14 killed after Indonesian train hits bus
'Slumdog' kid star to move into new home next week
Michael Jackson drug reports prompt doctors' warning
| Entertainment
|
Ice Age sequel heats up worldwide box office
| Entertainment
|
16 Afghan mine clearers, health workers abducted: govt
China says 140 dead in Xinjiang unrest
| International
|
Indonesian Facebook users defy clerics
Insurgent attacks in Iraq kill 2 in Mosul, Baqouba
Red Cross warning on poor nation epidemics
Ousted Honduran president fails in bid to return
| International
|
Iran: British-Greek reporter held for weeks freed
US manned space flight in doubt 40 years after moon walk
Calderon's party loses Congress vote in Mexico
| International
|
Suspected North Korea weapons ship heads home
| International
|
One British soldier killed in Afghanistan
| International
|
Suicide blast kills 2 Afghans outside foreign base
| International
|
Obama travels to Russia, arms deal seen
| International
|
Biden: Israel has right to deal with nuclear Iran
| International
|
Oxfam to G-8: Climate change will spread hunger
Recession pushed 90 million into extreme poverty
| International
|
Nigerian militants claim to destroy Chevron facility
Alaska observers say Palin had gone fishin' on job
US won't stand in Israel's way on Iran: Biden
Obama heads for high-stakes Russia visit
OMG!! Jackson fans beat odds for memorial tickets
No deal: NY Senate adjourns after 3-minute session
Irish pub happy as clam, wins Mass. chowder prize
Muslim minority riots erupt in China's west
Gambler sues casino for lost $23 mln fortune: report
China calls Xinjiang riot a plot against rule
China blames Muslim Uighurs for deadly protests
SKorea says NKorean missiles can hit key targets
Hundreds at funerals for 2 victims of SC killings
2 British soldiers killed in southern Afghanistan
Three killed in riot in China's Xinjiang region
Pakistan: Jets target N. Waziristan, up to 6 die
Torrential rain in China leaves at least 20 dead: state media
Japan PM dealt fresh blow in regional election
Lawyers set to square off over Jackson estate
| Entertainment
|
Clarification: Michael Jackson-TV
Jackson fans prepare for farewell service
Essence Festival ends 3 days of music, motivation
Chinese pen instant Michael Jackson biography
| Entertainment
|
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
DoCoMo invests $45.5 mln in US mobile video firm
Taiwan High Speed Rail in T$390bln refinance-sources
Lawyers set to square off over Jackson estate
OMG!! Jackson memorial passes start to trickle out
Ford says China sales up 14 percent in first half
G8 days numbered?
Al Sharpton calls for 'love vigils' for Jackson
"Ice Age" sequel heats up worldwide box office
Japan to sign crisis loan pact with Indonesia: report
'Ice Age,' 'Transformers' share box office top spot
Samsung estimates big rise in Q2 profit
Little people call for FCC to ban 'midget'
Ford says China sales up 20 percent in first half
Taiwan dollar flat in thin trade, eyes stocks
S.Korea bonds edge up ahead of auctions
Seoul shares slip; Samsung Elec up on forecast
Taliban launch 'operation' against Marines
Michael Jackson memorial tickets for sale online
US judge approves GM bankruptcy plan
Khamenei warns West not to interfere in Iran
| International
|
Nepal Tibetans mark Dalai Lama's birthday
Israel deports activists detained going to Gaza
Britain says eighth embassy worker freed by Iran
Bulgarian ex-bodyguard eyes government after vote
| International
|
Bomb kills 4, injures 9 in southeast Turkey
| International
|
Car bomb in Iraq wounds 10, policeman shot
| International
|
Media players plot survival in Sun Valley
| Technology
|
China tightens Web screws after Xinjiang riot
| Technology
|
NY congressman blasts Michael Jackson as 'pervert'
Police: 12 wounded in shooting at Miami party
Nokia denies plans phone running Google's Android
| Technology
|
Oldest Bible made whole again online
| Technology
|
British spy chief's cover blown on Facebook
| Technology
|
Survey: 73 Percent Of Canadians Believe Obama Is Doing A Good Job
Researchers study 'personality traits' of cars
Judge Approves GM's Bankruptcy Plan To Sell Assets To New Company
Nigerian militants say Chevron facility destroyed
NY Senate Still In Gridlock Despite Daily Emergency Sessions
Obama arrives in Russia for summit: AFP
U.S. Says North Korean-Flagged Ship Suspected Of Contraband Was Forced To Turn Back
Field-to-plate: Vt. college students try farming
Former Defense Secretary Robert McNamara Dead At 93
Virginia Plane Crash Kills Two
4 go on trial for roles in Texas school fight club
Alleged Drunk Driver Crashes Into California Congressman's Office
School bullying, once a silent battle, now a crime
Franken Takes Over Senate Office Monday
Obama Arrives In Moscow For Nuclear Arms Summit; Makes First Visit To Africa This Week
Indian market tumbles 5.8 percent on deficit fears
Audi reports record first-half Chinese sales
India pushes up deficit to spur growth
To spur growth, India sees budget deficit growing
Citi names 2 senior execs to lead Asia operations
India targets 'earliest' return to 9% GDP growth
India to increase deficit spending to boost growth
S.Korea to toughen home-backed lending soon-media
Ford China says sales up 14 percent in first half
Tokyo premiere launches return of Harry Potter
| Entertainment
|
Seoul shares up fueled by techs;Samsung Elec jumps
Lang Lang, Herbie Hancock in bold Montreux premiere
| Entertainment
|
Palestinian youngsters make music in former prison
| Entertainment
|
Jayhawks reunite with classic lineup
French act Nouvelle Wave perfect cover art
Britons turn living statues atop London plinth
En Vogue marks 20 years with Essence Fest concert
Divided Geneva marks 500 years of Calvinist rigour
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights