">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Calif wants to cut legal aid attorneys for poor
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Search
Search:
Calif wants to cut legal aid attorneys for poor
By DEBORAH HASTINGS,AP National Writer AP - Tuesday, June 16
Lawyers for the poor, who say they already are stretched to the breaking point by huge caseloads and dwindling staff, face layoffs across the country as local governments slash spending in these hard economic times.
ADVERTISEMENT
Nowhere is the threat to public defenders more apparent than in California, the state with the biggest population _ at 38 million_ and the largest deficit _ $24.3 billion and counting.
There's far more at stake than cutting jobs, say prosecutors and defense lawyers alike. Eliminating attorneys for the indigent may actually cost more money than it saves.
Unlike any other public service, court-appointed counsel cannot be scaled back. According to the Constitution, every criminal defendant, rich or poor, gets one. If the defendant can't pay, the government does. And if public defenders aren't available, private attorneys must be hired, at rates costing at least twice as much and often more.
"Counties can't just say `I'm not going to pay,'" said San Francisco Public Defender Jeff Adachi, who's locked in a very public fight with Mayor Gavin Newsom over a recent directive to cut the defense lawyer's budget by nearly $2 million.
Adachi said his office would be devastated and would have to fire 15 to 20 attorneys, about 20 percent of his staff.
Then, he said, "The whole system would begin to fail."
Defendants would sit in jail longer, increasing incarceration costs, Adachi said. Cases would be delayed while private attorneys get up to speed, creating bigger clogs in a legal pipeline that barely trickles now.
Adachi's current budget is nearly $24 million _ "less than half what the police and sheriff's departments spend in overtime," he notes. Slashing it would mean farming out 6,000 cases to private lawyers, ranging from misdemeanors to felonies. That would cost $3 million to $4 million, Adachi estimates, or up to twice as much as the cut itself.
"It's robbing Peter to pay Paul," he said, because, inevitably, it's the county general fund that has to pay the extra costs _ the same fund that pays for his office. "It's really shortsighted."
Sacramento County has already laid off 18 staffers, and will give pink slips to 29 attorneys if it doesn't get a fiscal break quickly. Los Angeles County Public Defender Michael Judge said he doesn't know how much will be cut from his office, which employs about 600 attorneys and is the state's largest indigent defense system.
"I don't know if I'm going to have to lay anybody off yet," he said.
California counties are particularly troubled as they head toward a July 1 budget deadline for new fiscal year. Their local revenues have tanked, thanks to huge drops in sales tax and property tax incomes caused by businesses closing and home loan foreclosures.
Then there's further recession fallout, including shrinking amounts of state funds.
San Francisco and Los Angeles have experienced layoffs before in less dire recessions. But when expensive bills started coming in from private lawyers, stunned county officials rehired public defenders, who'd been doing the same job for considerably less.
Desperate Sacramento County officials face a deficit of $140 million and say legal services for the poor may be cut by 24 percent.
Prosecutors haven't been spared, either. The district attorney's office is braced to lose $13 million and 46 attorneys _about 23 percent _ during the new fiscal year.
"It's bad for the system all the way around," said the DA's chief deputy, Cindy Besemer. "It's to the detriment of everyone involved. Victims get hurt because everything is left hanging. The longer you delay a case, the harder it is to prove because you're asking people to testify about something that happened a year ago."
The problems are far from unique to California.
Minnesota eliminated the jobs of 53 public defenders, or about 12 percent of the staff. Last summer, the office stopped representing parents involved in child welfare cases, referring them instead to counties, which hired private lawyers.
"The counties incurred a lot of costs they weren't happy about," said John Stuart, head of the state's public defender office. "It was about 9 percent of our caseload."
So far, Minnesota has avoided more attorney cuts, partly by finding unusual ways of generating revenue, including increasing the license fees of lawyers by $75.
"It's like telling the county pothole-filling crews to chip in an extra $10 to pay for the asphalt," Stuart said dryly. "But it's better than not following the Constitution."
Unlike California, where counties bear the burden of funding public defenders, Minnesota has a statewide office.
Court systems across the country also are targeted for drastic cuts. Some courtrooms will go dark for at least one day a month to save costs, adding more weight to backlogged dockets.
In Los Angeles County, which has the nation's largest court system with nearly 600 courtrooms, steep cuts will force nearly all operations to shut down one Wednesday per month, beginning July 15. But the furlough plan may not be enough to avert laying off 25 percent of the court's 5,400 employees, officials warned.
Though President Barack Obama's economic stimulus package has made billions available, it's still not enough to plug every budget hole.
"We're already in a very precarious position," said Fresno County Public Defender Kenneth Taniguchi, whose central California district lies in a vast agricultural area that supplies much of the nation's produce.
"It's inadequate right now as it is," he said. "It's not a pretty picture."
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: World
Gas prices rise for 48th day as oil sells offAP - 1 hour 44 minutes ago
NJ man to be freed after '87 convictions reversedAP - 2 hours 9 minutes ago
Judge: Holocaust Museum suspect can't appearAP - 2 hours 9 minutes ago
2 found dead in Indiana eye doctor's officeAP - 2 hours 19 minutes ago
Man rescued in Fla. after falling from cruise shipAP - 2 hours 21 minutes ago
Most Popular – World
Viewed
Earth-Venus smash-up possible in 3.5 billion years: study
Paris bailiffs chase Saudi princess for unpaid bills
Obama signs note for girl who played hooky to see him
Luanda is world's most expensive expat city: survey
Dumped mattress lands cash in trash in Israel
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Tuesday, 16 June 2009 Iran protester slain after huge pro-reform rally
Air France planes get new speed probes after probe
US-TECH Summary
Palestinians angered by Netanyahu peace terms
Men's 'stiff upper lip' may explain cancer death rate
Nokia and Samsung heat up smartphone contest
North Korea's May nuclear test few kilotons: U.S.
| International
|
Obama cranks up health reform hard sell
One protestor shot dead at Tehran rally: local photographer
Universal, Virgin hail 'world first' unlimited music downloads
Virgin Media, Universal to offer unlimited music
EU "disturbed" by Iraq executions, calls for freeze
Analysis: Netanyahu's overture likely too little
Indian, Pakistani leaders expected to meet on Tuesday
| International
|
Protestor 'shot dead' at mass anti-Ahmadinejad rally
Russia threatens to veto West's U.N. Georgia plan
| International
|
U.S. commander sees fewer foreign fighters in Iraq
EU disturbed by Iraq executions, calls for freeze
| International
|
U.S. and EU cautious on Netanyahu
Nokia, Samsung heat up smartphone contest
Nokia and Samsung heat up smartphone contest
| Technology
|
US Gen McChrystal takes command in Afghanistan
Calif wants to cut legal aid attorneys for poor
China-US naval incident part of a rising trend
U.S. senators ask FCC to review mobile handset deals
| Technology
|
Higher-ed pinching pushes college presses to brink
Alleged Khmer Rouge torturer cries in court
Pentagon struggling to explain bombing incident
SKorean president arrives for talks with Obama
Ill. blogger who lied about sick baby apologizes
Lawmakers want IRS to suspend tax shelter penalty
Sheriff: 4 dead in Fla. family murder-suicide
Afghan presidential candidates prepare to campaign
US called `deeply troubled' by events in Iran
Court: Anti-aging guru's ex can't discuss divorce
Hundreds riot in China over new furniture tax
Photos of girl's body allowed in Ore. prayer case
Malaysia police fire tear gas on Iran election protest
Seventh Sumatran elephant killed in Indonesia
NASA will try to launch space shuttle Wednesday
Vietnam Airlines planning to buy 18 Airbus jets
Filipino remittances up 2.2 percent in April
Moody's wants clarity on Pakistan's foreign support
Harry Potter publisher denies plagiarism claim
| Entertainment
|
French prosecutor seeks dissolution of Scientology
Idol auditions attract thousands in Mass.
French prosecutor seeks dissolution of Scientology
| Entertainment
|
Bill Engvall `nervous' about hosting CMT awards
Brad Pitt, family give $1M to Missouri hospital
Gory British prison drama wins Sydney Film Festival
| Entertainment
|
Makana shares aloha with his slack key music
McCartney and Yoko push 'meat-free Mondays'
7 killed as anti-Ahmadinejad protests turn deadly
Plane makers scramble for deals at Paris Air Show
Seven killed at Tehran rally, more protests planned
| International
|
Twitter streams break Iran news dam
Iran state TV says seven people killed near rally
Court orders Exxon to pay $507.5 mln for 1989 spill
Son of North Korea's Kim visits China as heir-media
| International
|
Sun Micro kills "Rock" high-end chip project: report
Indian, Pakistani leaders expected to meet on Tuesday
| International
|
Seven people killed near Tehran rally site: radio
YouTube testing video ad viewing options
US urges Iran to accept invite to nuclear talks
Russia hosts first BRIC summit, India-Pakistan meet
| International
|
U.S. senators ask FCC to review mobile handset deals
Tweeting Iran: Elex news in 140 characters or less
U.S. commander in Afghanistan reviews strategy: report
| International
|
U.S. and EU cautious on Netanyahu
Berlusconi eyes concrete results for G8 summit
| International
|
US commander: US to stick to Iraq withdrawal date
China to swap bullets for lethal injections
| International
|
Samsung, Nokia heat up smartphone contest
Bomb kills two police, teacher shot in Thai south
| International
|
Obama welcome's Israeli prime minister's speech
Iran's supreme leader becomes political referee
Aussie senator unsure humans cause climate change
Chinese waitress walks free after killing official
| International
|
Officials vow support for renewable energy in West
Darkness at noon: Beijing's skies turn black
US calls for release of arrested Vietnam activist
RIM aims to cross categories with BlackBerry Tour
| Technology
|
China to execute inmates by injection, not bullets
Sun Micro kills Rock high-end chip project: report
| Technology
|
Waitress on trial in stabbing of Chinese official
Adobe to charge users for Acrobat.com
| Technology
|
Sen. Coburn questions 100 stimulus projects
Opera adds media, file sharing services to browser
| Technology
|
Son of North Korea's Kim visits China as heir
Clear Channel deal gives musicians Web channels
| Technology
|
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
Indian, Pakistani leaders expected to meet on Tuesday
Detainee sheds light on CIA interrogations
Another school closed by swine flu in Hong Kong
Britain to unveil plans for digital future
| Technology
|
Ore. woman indicted in death of pregnant woman
NKorean 'heir apparent' visits China: report
SKorea condemns slaying of SKorean woman in Yemen
Co-worker arrested in Va. bus station shooting
Florida man dies in Yosemite National Park
Chief blames `knuckleheads' for Lakers disturbance
ACLU: Hospital discriminated against gay couple
Hollywood rep: private sector key in China access
Judge nixes move to charge `Bounty Hunter' star
A new role as 'risk regulator' could reshape Fed
Wash. murder charge for man accused in AZ killings
Big four emerging economies meet for first summit
Offshore holdings of NZ govt debt rose in May
Docu to chronicle Swinton's Berlin Wall bike ride
Korea Hot Stocks
Taiwan dlr firms as stocks cancel US dlr appeal
China, Nigeria state firms find oil in Niger Delta
S.Korea government bonds rise on U.S. lead
Seoul shares fall led by banks; MSCI news weighs
Nigeria urges court to dimiss S. Korea firm's oil suit
Docu to chronicle Swinton's Berlin Wall bike ride
Former Nirvana bassist ends Wash. protest campaign
David Letterman apologizes for flawed Palin joke
| Entertainment
|
Clear Channel deal gives musicians Web channels
Blame gets shared for dark side of reality TV fame
| Entertainment
|
Tarzan, Jane, and the animals, reviewed
Susan Boyle returns to tour after rest day
| Entertainment
|
David Letterman apologizes for "flawed" Palin joke
DiCaprio playing poker in new drama
| Entertainment
|
DiCaprio playing poker in new drama
Clear Channel deal gives musicians Web channels
| Entertainment
|
Architect slams Prince Charles' 'unconstitutional' intervention
Docu to chronicle Swinton's Berlin Wall bike ride
| Entertainment
|
Curtis, Chenoweth sign on for comedy Again
| Entertainment
|
Letterman apologizes for Palin daughter joke
Natalie Portman in step with Black Swan
| Entertainment
|
Letterman apologizes to audience for 'bad' joke
Docu exposes disturbing truth about U.S. food supply
| Entertainment
|
Review: `Food, Inc.' offers plenty to chew on
Opera launches new media, file sharing service
Saab to be bought by sports-car Koenigsegg
Iraq lawmakers to question oil minister over deals
Broadband gains traction despite economic crisis
Iranian blogosphere backs Mousavi as protests mount
Israel sees deal soon with Obama over settlements
| International
|
Microsoft files lawsuit over "click fraud"
Iraqis take control of Baghdad's Green Zone
| International
|
Bing search makes porn easy to filter out
Campaign underway for Afghan presidential poll
| International
|
Yahoo expands mobile presence in Asia
Italy quake survivors protest reconstruction plans
| International
|
Pakistan face tough Taliban foe in tribal belt
Adobe to charge users for Acrobat.com
World sleepwalking into disasters: U.N. aid chief
| International
|
Cyber attacks gow on SKorea military networks
Asia set to become biggest climate change driver
Georgia angry after Russia vetoes U.N. monitors
| International
|
Britain to unveil plans for digital future
Yahoo expands mobile presence in Asia
Ky. authorities investigate boy's elevator death
China acknowledges incident between sub, US ship
Ohioans ticketed for parking in own driveways
Indonesia coal mine explosion traps 30
The Nation's Weather
Police: SKorea man kills boy to hide drunk driving
Low tide: Shrimp industry hit by imports, prices
Twitter delays down time to aid Iranian protesters
| Technology
|
Teacher, 2 policemen killed in troubled Thai south
Obama's Day: Meeting with South Korean leader
Fighter plane crashes in Bangladesh, pilot safe
Iranian blogosphere backs Mousavi as protests mount
| Technology
|
Irish family's road trip ends tragically in crash
Asia set to become biggest climate change driver
Judge upholds ND's anti-corporate farming law
6 die after a mine blast in Indonesia
Microsoft files lawsuit over click fraud
| Technology
|
Italy agrees to take 3 detainees from Guantanamo
China Communist Party newspaper to expand coverage
ADB approves $3.4B loans for Asia to ease crisis
UK company debuts 2-seat hydrogen car prototype
Private equity firms eye Taiwan's services sector
Asia's economic growth bolsters climate change: ADB
Pakistan stocks fall further, budget fails to impress
HK officials face pay cut, jobless rate at 5.3 pct
Hopes fade for Indonesian miners after explosion
HK officials face pay cut, jobless at 3-year high
6 die, at least 24 trapped in Indonesia mine blast
Q&A-Is South Korea's economy ready for higher rates?
Indonesia Bukit Asam says 30 staff trapped in landslide
Japan's SMFG plans to raise $9.6 bln in share sale
Bank of Japan holds rate
Fashion world honors new stars Rodarte _ and Obama
`Transformers' toys live up to big-screen robots
Sharon Gless is a scene-stealer on 'Burn Notice'
Albert Hall loading bay gets pop music makeover
| Entertainment
|
Another move for 'Chess' _ on public television
Taylor Swift's CMT opener sounds simply dreamy
Docu exposes disturbing truth about U.S. food supply
Natalie Portman in step with "Black Swan"
Curtis, Chenoweth sign on for comedy "Again"
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights