Forum Views () 
Forum Replies ()  
 
 
Read more with google mobile :
Online vendor of 25-cent Beatles songs loses case
|  
 
 
 
 
	
	
		
Edition:
		
U.S.
		
		
	
	
		
			
				
					
					
						
					
				
				
					
					
						
					
				
				
					
					
						
					
				
			
		
	
	
	
		
			
				
				
			
		
	
 
	
 
	
 
 
	
		 
		
		 
		
		
	        
		
	
	
    	
		 
		
		 
		
		
	        
		
 
	
 
	
		
Article
    
Comments (0)
               
      
	
Email
	
Print
Reprints
      
	
	
    	
		 
		
		 
		
		
	        
		
 
	
		 
		
		 
		
		
	        
		
	  
 
 
               
      
		
Read
		
		
		
Judge rejects key part of Obama healthcare law
| 
		
	13 Dec 2010 
	
Stockholm bomber's friends recall friendly teenager
	13 Dec 2010 
	
Murdered Alabama children were tortured: documents
	09 Dec 2010 
	
Special Report: Julian Assange versus the world
	13 Dec 2010 
	
WikiLeaks's founder Assange seeks bail in UK court
	13 Dec 2010 
	
	
		
		
      
               
      
      
               
      
		
Discussed
		
		
		
69
			Special Report: STD fears sparked case against WikiLeaks boss
68
			Australia blames U.S. over WikiLeaks, founder held in UK
61
			WikiLeaks backers hit MasterCard and Visa in cyberstrike
	
		
		
      
               
      
		
Watched
		
		
                                 	
					  
                      
     
			
Bejeweled bra exposed in NY
		Thu, Oct 21 2010
                                 	
					  
                      
     
			
Row over vote orgasm video
		Fri, Nov 19 2010
                                 	
					  
                      
     
			
US diplomat Holbrooke dies
		Mon, Dec 13 2010
		
		
       
	
		
		
		 
		
		 
		
		
		
	
	 
	
	
	
    	
		 
		
		 
		
		
	        
		
 
		
	
Online vendor of 25-cent Beatles songs loses case
	
	     
	        
	            
	          		
	                 
	            
 Tweet This
	            
Share on LinkedIn
	            
 Share on Facebook
	             
					 
	                
	                
	                By Eriq Gardner
NEW YORK (Hollywood Reporter) - A federal judge has ruled on summary judgment that BlueBeat.com is liable for violating copyrights in thousands of songs. In making the decision, the judge had swatted away one of the stranger defenses...	
	                
	                
	            
	    
	
               
      
 
      
               
      
	
Related News
	
		
		
George Clinton sues Black Eyed Peas over sample
Mon, Dec 13 2010
Lawsuit seeks to expose truth behind 'Catfish'
Fri, Dec 3 2010
Judge issues rulings in estate's superhero battle
Wed, Dec 1 2010
Dow Jones, Briefing.com settle "hot news" lawsuit
Tue, Nov 16 2010
UPDATE 3-Dow Jones, Briefing.com settle "hot news" lawsuit
Mon, Nov 15 2010
	
      
               
      
    
Related Topics
        
            
                
Technology »
                
Music »
                
        
    
      
               
      
 
      
               
      
 
                     
      
 
 
        
By Eriq Gardner
        
        Mon Dec 13, 2010 11:48pm EST
        
    
NEW YORK (Hollywood Reporter) - A federal judge has ruled on summary judgment that BlueBeat.com is liable for violating copyrights in thousands of songs. In making the decision, the judge had swatted away one of the stranger defenses to infringement of sound recordings.
Last year, BlueBeat made headlines for selling tracks for 25 cents and streaming songs for free. Most notably, the company was one of the only venues at the time that offered for sale digital tracks from The Beatles -- and the only U.S.-based company that claimed to do so legally.
Record labels put BlueBeat's legal theories to the test in a lawsuit filed in November 2009.
Hank Risan, CEO of BlueBeat, said in an interview that the company made single copies of each sound recording, then analyzed them and destroyed the copies before creating a new simulation based on parametrics of sound.
According to BlueBeat, the scheme was protected by a section in the copyright law that doesn't extend rights of copyright owners to "the making or duplication of another sound recording that consists entirely of an independent fixation of other sounds, even though such sounds imitate or simulate those in the copyrighted sound recording."
It was dubbed the "psycho-acoustic simulation" defense.
The labels responded that the language of the law only pertained to their rights -- that it didn't permit companies to re-record recordings in an attempt to get around copyright liability.
In a decision on Thursday, Judge Josephine Staton Tucker agrees: "BlueBeat fails to provide any evidence ... showing how or why its purported 'simulations' are anything but illicit copies of the Copyrighted Recordings," she says.
The judge says that BlueBeat didn't provide evidence that it had obtained a valid re-recording license, that copies were used solely by BlueBeat, and that copies were destroyed.
Instead, Judge Tucker rules that "Risan's obscure and undefined pseudo-scientific language appears to be a long-winded way of describing 'sampling,' i.e. copying, and fails to provide any concrete evidence of independent creation."
Having rejected BlueBeat's arguments that its "simulations" are original, independent works -- and also rejecting a defense that record labels don't have standing to bring claims for pre-1972 recordings -- the judge grants the record companies' motion for partial summary judgment.
Notwithstanding an appeal, the case now moves into determining what damages BlueBeat must pay to the record companies.
			
Technology
			
Music
			
 
	 
    
     
    
    
    
     
    
    
We welcome comments that advance the story directly or with relevant tangential information. We try to block comments that use offensive language, all capital letters or appear to be spam, and we review comments frequently to ensure they meet our standards. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters.
Comments (0)
Be the first to comment on reuters.com.
    
Add yours using the box above.
    
Social Stream (What's this?)
 
 
 
 
 
 
		
	
		
	
		
	 
  
	
		
	
		
	
		
	
		
	
	
 
	
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
	
	
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
 
Reuters
	
Contact Us
	
Advertise With Us
	
Help
	
Journalism Handbook
	
Archive
	
Site Index
	
Video Index
	
Reader Feedback
 
	
Mobile
	
Newsletters
	
RSS
	
Podcasts
	
Widgets
	
Your View
	
Analyst Research
Thomson Reuters
	
Copyright
	
Disclaimer
	
Privacy
	
Professional Products
	
Professional Products Support
	
Financial Products
	
About Thomson Reuters
	
Careers
Online Products
	
Acquisitions Monthly
	
Buyouts
	
Venture Capital Journal
	
International Financing Review
	
Project Finance International
	
PEhub.com
	
PE Week
	
FindLaw
 Reuters on Facebook
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
 
	
	
 
 
 
 
 
 
    
 
 
 
 
Other News on Tuesday, 14 December 2010 Afghan lawmakers demand Karzai inaugurate parliament  
Berlusconi offers 'pact' with foes ahead of vote  
US-TECH Summary  
Swedish bomber 'planned Christmas carnage'  
Iranian president fires foreign minister: report  
WTO rules against China over tyre exports to US  
Toshiba plant to make LCD panels for Apple: report  
Dell to buy Compellent for $960 million  
Oil prices rally above 91 dollars  
Leading figures urge freedom for Iran stoning woman  
Special Report: Julian Assange versus the world
|  
Security Council must tackle climate change: Germany  
Dell eyes cloud-computing in $820 mln deal  
Suicide bomber kills at least 3, wounds 13 in Iraq  
U.S. says Sudan out of time on Abyei referendum
|  
Elizabeth Hurley announces marriage split on Twitter  
French police end sword-wielding teen hostage drama  
EU launches Ivorian sanctions as tensions grow
|  
Arrests in Afghan attack that killed 6 US troops  
Nokia's Navteq buys traffic service Trapster  
U.S. envoy seeks progress despite talks' collapse
|  
British police search home of alleged Swedish bomber  
WikiLeaks rival Openleaks "coming soon": website  
Clinton: Iran made good start in nuclear talks
|  
Swedish prosecutor almost certain of bomber identity  
Nokia's Navteq buys traffic service Trapster  
Russia prods North Korea on nuclear programme, attack
|  
French school siege drama 'ends with hostages freed'  
Four French schoolkids, teacher freed in hostage siege  
U.N. sleuths say China rights crackdown alarming
|  
Spanish flamenco star Enrique Morente dead at 67: family  
Bomb hits school bus in Pakistan  
WTO rules against China over tyre exports to US  
 News  
Second Indian envoy in US airport frisking row  
Bollywood to Hollywood: Indian actors chase dreams  
Special Report: Julian Assange versus the world
|  
S.Lanka denies move to ban national anthem in Tamil  
Gangster film wins big at Australian Film Institute awards  
Teachers being killed in southwest Pakistan: HRW  
Website to export French-style adultery to 'puritan' US  
Justin Bieber tops list of most-viewed YouTube videos
|  
Indian minister blames migrants for Delhi crime  
Indonesian rock star stands trial over web sex videos  
Chinese oil company wins drilling contract in Norway  
Indian parliament ends session without passing a bill  
Parliament blocks Philippines condom funding  
Activision sells 3.3 million Warcraft games on first day
|  
China extends order for banks to set aside money  
Bomb rips through Pakistani school bus  
New York critics name Social Network best film
|  
Senators press China on piracy, counterfeiting
|  
Elizabeth Hurley announces marriage split on Twitter
|  
Japan to cut corporate tax to stimulate economy  
Toshiba expects U.S. PC sales to outpace market
|  
Justin Bieber tops list of most-viewed YouTube videos
|  
Gwyneth Paltrow and fans are giddy over Glee
|  
Bollywood to Hollywood: Indian actors chase dreams
|  
Rapper Ja Rule faces prison after hiding gun
|  
New York critics name Social Network best film
|  
Gangster film wins big at Australian Film Institute awards
|  
Activision sells 3.3 million Warcraft games on first day
|  
Veteran US diplomat Holbrooke dies  
Domestic violence kills one Russian woman an hour: report  
German minister under fire for Afghan 'PR' trip  
South Korea suspects North has more uranium sites
|  
WikiLeaks founder to appear in British court  
U.N. confirms northern air raids on south Sudan  
Bernard Madoff will not attend son's funeral: lawyer  
Riots expose Russia's problems ahead of World Cup  
WikiLeaks's founder Assange seeks bail in UK court
|  
Gamers go gaga for "World of Warcraft: Cataclysm"  
Chavez says decree powers may last 18 months
|  
Toshiba to make LCD panels for Apple iPhone: report  
Facebook in challenge to Google crown  
Cuba launches Wikipedia-like online encyclopedia  
Nissan delivers first Leaf in San Francisco  
Yahoo to lay off more than 600 staffers: sources
|  
Email, birthdays of McDonald's customers hacked
|  
WikiLeaks's founder Assange seeks bail in UK court
|  
Toshiba to make LCD panels for Apple iPhone: report
|  
Online vendor of 25-cent Beatles songs loses case
|  
Hundreds clash over Taiwan petrochemical project  
WikiLeaks's founder Assange seeks bail in UK court  
Cuba launches Wikipedia-like online encyclopedia
|  
Obama presses angry allies on tax deal  
TI bets on analog chips with new capacity
|  
Peak viewing for 'shooting stars' meteor show  
TI bets on analog chips with new capacity  
Sprint may cut Clearwire votes to avoid debt risk  
BlackBerry Torch seen aiding RIM's results
|  
Veteran U.S. diplomat Richard Holbrooke dies  
Google defends local search results  
Sprint may cut Clearwire votes to avoid debt risk
|  
Veteran US diplomat Holbrooke dies  
Ireland blocks 40 million euros in bank bonuses  
Search for sunken S.Korean trawler survivors ends  
Mexican drug cartel branches out in Costa Rica: US  
Malaysia parliament urged to suspend Anwar  
Judge rules Obama health reform unconstitutional  
Support for Japan PM plunges to new low  
Oprah appoints herself Australian 'ambassador'  
Disabled workers enslaved in China factory: report  
Team China punished for brawl with Brazil  
Seoul shares open higher, index hits 2,000 points  
Sony names Nobel chemist Negishi as research advisor  
Black Swan in spotlight as Oscar season heats up
|  
Toronto film critics honor Social Network
|  
Dexter star and his TV sister getting divorced
|  
George Clinton sues Black Eyed Peas over sample
|  
A no-name actress may nab key Snow White role
|  
Neve Campbell in talks for Singularity
|  
North Korea operating 3-4 more uranium sites  
Workers sacked at New Zealand death mine  
US mourns Holbrooke, the 'warrior for peace'  
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary  
Bollywood to Hollywood: Indian actors chase dreams  
NZ retail sales fall in Oct, rates seen on hold  
NZ dollar falls after weak retail data  
New Zealand slow growth into 2011, before solid pick up-survey  
India serves notices on telecom firms in scandal  
Online vendor of 25-cent Beatles songs loses case  
"Should I stay or should I go?" Romanian doctors ponder  
Toyota recalls 94,000 cars due to brake fault  
ThumbDrive inventor out to prove he is no one-hit wonder  
Neve Campbell in talks for "Singularity"  
Japan to cut corporate income tax: reports  
Jeff Bridges helps revive cult sci-fi movie 'Tron'  
Wham win most annoying Xmas song award with 'Last Christmas'  
"Dexter" star and his TV sister getting divorced  
'Strange acting alien' Paltrow honored in Hollywood  
NBC and "Survivor" producer to launch "Idol" rival  
Oprah, Sandra Bullock, Halle Berry to present Oscars  
Narnia weaves magic at American box office  
US Afghan report set to see progress and hurdles  
Berlusconi narrowly survives no-confidence vote
|  
UK court frees WikiLeaks' founder Assange on bail
|  
ECB calls for bigger eurozone emergency fund  
Hamas leader says group will never recognize Israel
|  
Sweden bomber sought big targets; new threat made
|  
Fed likely to keep rates low despite tax cut deal  
Berlusconi's fate on a knife-edge as MPs vote  
Electioneering to the fore in Irish bank bonus bust-up
|  
Eurozone industrial output rebounds in October  
Bangladesh factory fire kills 25, injures 100
|  
Record profits forecast for airline industry  
China, India meet to focus on trade, despite mistrust
|  
Police arrest Nepal's ex-crown prince over gunshot  
Islamic party quits Pakistan government over minister
|  
Roadside bombs kills 3, wound 32 in Iraq
|  
Club Med looks to profit from China's skiing craze  
Bangladesh factory blaze kills 22, injures 100  
Why made-in-China goods cost more on Chinese mainland?  
The Princess and the 'Soft Power'  
'Strange acting alien' Paltrow honored in Hollywood  
WikiLeaks, web to revolutionize reporting: Pilger
|  
The lips have it over the eyes when flirting online
|  
Exclusive: American Apparel to take Groupon deal to Europe
|  
China to hike some rare earth export duties  
Indonesia's hard-line Islamic group to protect churches during Christmas  
Acer sees big growth in China, tablet market
|  
Foreigners flock to Florida real estate bargains  
Ba'asyir is leader of Al Qaeda's Mecca verandah: Indonesian police  
Pakistani stocks end higher; rupee, o/n rates flat  
UK court frees WikiLeaks' founder Assange on bail
|  
Philippines aiming for peace with communists in three years  
Apple accused of selling pirated Japan novels online  
Colin Firth wins Variety International Star of Year  
Nokia delays flagship E7 phone to early 2011
|  
Nissan, Mitsubishi boost ties, target Middle East  
Dell doubles China spending to $250 billion by 2020
|  
China to appeal WTO ruling on tyre exports to US  
Nokia to cut about 800 jobs in Finland
|  
Indian PM seeks to ease corporate fears over phone taps  
Japanese ship attacked off Somalia, crew slightly injured  
Hugh Jackman injured in Oprah TV show stunt in Australia  
Exhibition hunts radical solutions in Angolan slums  
China 2011 inflation to hit 4 percent: govt  
By the thousands, Mexicans flee blood-stained Juarez  
Indonesia police say aged cleric was terror chief  
Petronas: six injured in oil platform fire  
"Black Swan" in spotlight as Oscar season heats up  
Indian state to debate microfinance crackdown  
Toronto film critics honor "Social Network"  
A no-name actress may nab key "Snow White" role  
Indonesia parliament agrees to curb fuel subsidies  
King's Speech leads Golden Globe nominations
|  
Hugh Jackman injured in Oprah TV show stunt in Australia
|  
S.Korea to examine foreign bank branches frequently  
WikiLeaks, web to revolutionize reporting: Pilger
|  
Michael Jackson photo sells for just under $35,000
|  
Acer sees big growth in China, tablet market  
Nokia delays flagship E7 phone to early 2011  
Taiwan scientists claim microchip 'breakthrough'  
Dell doubles China spending to $250 billion by 2020  
Assange still committed to publishing secret documents: mother  
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro  
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found  
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever  
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production  
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time  
AMD to Start Production of piledriver  
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs  
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia  
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air  
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch  
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent  
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up  
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform  
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis  
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets  
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights