Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Federal judge shutters Idaho grazing allotment
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Federal judge shutters Idaho grazing allotment
By JOHN MILLER,Associated Press Writer -
Tuesday, October 20
Send
IM Story
Print
BOISE, Idaho – A federal judge has ordered a western Idaho rancher to keep his sheep off his family's traditional grazing ground on public land to protect wild native bighorns. Federal land managers on Monday opted not to fight the ruling.
U.S. District Judge Lynn Winmill ruled last week that a pact between a Salmon River rancher and the state to keep his domestic herd separate from bighorns on a Bureau of Land Management allotment fell short of a 2009 law aimed at helping Idaho's ranching industry and protecting the native wild sheep.
The Wilderness Society, Western Watersheds Project and Hells Canyon Preservation Council had all contended that a bighorn herd near Riggins was in danger of catching deadly diseases if the allotment near Partridge Creek opened to domestic herds on schedule Thursday.
The number of Idaho bighorns has dwindled by half since 1990 to about 3,500 after several mass die-offs. Wildlife managers believe bighorns can catch diseases such as pneumonia when they come into contact with domestic sheep. Winmill said he was trying to prevent more outbreaks.
"Irreversible damage is possible here," Winmill wrote in his 17-page ruling. "Bighorns could become infected and roam far up-river in the Salmon River drainage, infecting the other native bighorns along the way, causing large-scale losses."
This year, Idaho lawmakers passed a plan requiring the state Department of Fish and Game director to certify that the risk of disease transmission between bighorn and domestic sheep was "acceptable for the viability of the bighorn sheep" once ranchers and the state had crafted Best Management Practices, or BMPs, to keep the two species apart.
The state and rancher Mick Carlson, whose family has grazed the Partridge Creek allotment since 1937, negotiated such an agreement in August. Among other things, he agreed to have two herders, three guard dogs and three herding dogs with each band of sheep. He was also allowed to kill bighorns that wandered into his herd.
In his ruling Winmill said that agreement relied on voluntary compliance and could not be enforced by the Bureau of Land Management.
"The director here certified that the risk has been reduced to an acceptable level," the judge wrote. "Acceptable to who? Acceptable under what standard?
"These questions are not answered," Winmill added. "There is no certification in this case that upon implementation of the BMPs, the risk of disease transmission will be acceptable for the viability of the bighorn sheep."
Another hearing on Winmill's order to close the grazing allotment was planned for Nov. 2. But the Bureau of Land Management on Monday asked the judge to cancel that court date and said it would live by his order until it had a chance to do a new environmental analysis on the effects of grazing at Partridge Creek on wild bighorns.
The judge "found fundamental flaws in (Idaho's law) that rendered the Idaho Department of Fish and Game's certification of the Partridge Creek allotment meaningless and irrelevant in this case," the federal agency's lawyers wrote in their filing Monday. "For those reasons, the BLM does not oppose imposition of an injunction in this case until such time as an environmental analysis has been completed."
State Fish and Game officials did not respond to a request for comment.
Jon Marvel, director of Western Watersheds in Hailey, said Winmill's order underlined the weakness of Idaho's new law.
"These Best Management Practices are, first of all, voluntary, and second, there is no testimony in the record from any scientist that concludes that they will be effective in protecting bighorn sheep."
The Nez Perce Tribe, which opposes the grazing on its traditional homeland, called the decision a victory for bighorns.
"The use of BMPs to try and create separation between domestic and bighorn sheep in occupied bighorn sheep habitat is not supported by scientific literature or scientists," said Brooklyn Baptiste, Vice-Chairman of the Nez Perce Tribal Executive Committee.
Carlson, who has already been barred from grazing on nearby U.S. Forest Service allotments, argued in court that he cannot run his operation in a profitable manner if more than 800 of his sheep are kept away from Partridge Creek.
A phone call to Carlson was not returned, but in court he contended it would cost him about $9,000 if he was forced to restrict his sheep to his private ground along the Salmon River and to the south in Emmett.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
UK-World Summary Reuters - Tuesday, October 20
Honduras de facto government scolds Zelaya, cools talks Reuters - Tuesday, October 20
Karzai set to announce decision on Afghan run-off Reuters - Tuesday, October 20
Karzai under pressure after poll fraud probe AFP - Tuesday, October 20
Judge postpones another Ohio inmate's execution AP - Tuesday, October 20
News Search
Top Stories
EU has doubts, but unlikely to challenge Opel sale
IBM executive in insider trading case placed on leave
Euro chiefs express 'worries' over US, China export squeeze
World 'catastrophe' if no climate deal: British PM
Balloon boy parents ready to surrender to police: lawyer
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
British economy in for painful recovery: report
Hurricane Rick gains monster Category 5 status: forecasters
US balloon drama 'was a hoax': police
Earnings leap at Saudi Sabic
Huge crowds at Dublin funeral of Boyzone star
More Most Viewed »
Oldest hominid skeleton sheds light on human origins
Boyzone singer Gately dies in Spain
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Tuesday, 20 October 2009 Iraq picks up pace on oil deals, elections loom
ETA 'political chief' believed held in French raid
Plastic Logic to unveil first e-reader in January
ETA's 'political chief' held in France: Spain
Abu Dhabi Media Co. invests in music video site VEVO
Parents, care groups venture into children's digital limbo
U.S. keeps Sudan sanctions but offers dialogue
US-TECH Summary
Balloon boy parents ready to surrender to police: lawyer
Stimulus 'saved 250,000 education jobs': W.House
Spotify to launch mobile offering with 3, HTC
Sudan says new U.S. policy has positive points
| International
|
Iran and western powers hold 'constructive' uranium talks
Iran accuses US, Britain, Pakistan over bombing
Karzai vote cut to 48%: US monitor
Abu Dhabi Media Co. invests in music video site VEVO
Afghan fraud probe seen depriving Karzai of outright win
Egypt's Moussa does not rule out presidency run: report
| International
|
Afghan fraud report orders vote invalidation
Honduras de facto leader lifts ban on media, protests
| International
|
Kurd militants surrender to back Turkish reforms
| International
|
Colombia probes vice president over militia ties
| International
|
Feds issue new medical marijuana policy
Lawyer for balloon boy's parents expects charges
LA's top prosecutor vows to target pot shops
Octuplets mom's doc expelled from organization
Calif toddler OK after 30-foot fall onto rocks
Japan first lady awarded for looking good in jeans
Hurricane Rick weakens as it approaches Mexico
Japan's first lady honoured as 'jeans ambassador'
Chinese ship seized as Somali piracy drifts East
Fed boss says US should cut budget deficit
Beyonce's Kuala Lumpur debut postponed
Health care issues: What president, Congress have
China builds quake monitoring station at Everest
Bosses Who Bully Likely Feel Incompetent
Unspoken rules govern cell phone etiquette
| Technology
|
A Fortnight Before Elections, Paper of Record Endorses Gov. Corzine
U.S. Plane Carrying Marine Commandos Ordered To Land For Straying Into India
Motorola rises ahead of next Android phone launch
| Technology
|
Bernanke warns against trade imbalances
Nissan's Ghosn is bullish on electric vehicles
JAL loss to be larger than expected: report
Madonna's New York neighbor sues over noise
| Entertainment
|
Andy Garcia takes on Saakashvili role
| Entertainment
|
Colombian town cancels concert over Uribe T-shirt
| Entertainment
|
Nobel winner slams Bible as 'handbook of bad morals'
Beyonce postpones Malaysia gig amid Islamist ire
Singer death column sparks Twitter rage
Slight drop in attendance at Frankfurt Book Fair
Phil Collins not pounding the skins
Def Leppard cancels N.American tour dates
| Entertainment
|
Elvis' hair leaves the building -- sold for $18,300
Beyonce delays Malaysia show amid Muslim criticism
D'oh! Bash marks 'The Simpsons' 20th anniversary
'Babel' director Inarritu heads Tokyo fest jury
Karzai under pressure after poll fraud probe
Karzai likely to agree run-off election
| International
|
U.S. video game sales up 1 percent in Sept; PS3 top: NPD
EU has doubts, but unlikely to challenge Opel sale
Pakistan forces seize key town in Waziristan push
| International
|
US videogame sales break losing streak: NPD
Iran accuses US, Britain, Pakistan over lethal bombing
IBM executive in insider trading case placed on leave
Iran vows reprisals after bombing kills dozens
Iran demands U.N. council condemn bomb attack
| International
|
US consumer electronics spending to rise this Christmas: CEA
Iran, Western powers hold 'constructive' uranium talks
Google wooing Microsoft business customers
Kurd militants surrender to back Turkish reforms
Euro chiefs express 'worries' over US, China export squeeze
Honduras de facto government scolds Zelaya, talks stall
| International
|
Unspoken rules govern cell phone etiquette
Egypt's Moussa does not rule out presidency run
Airbus, others sued in U.S. over Air France crash
| International
|
West Bank separation barrier draws protests
Somali pirates seize Chinese ship in Indian Ocean
| International
|
Sunni insurgent group in Iran
IT spending to rebound in 2010: Gartner
Spain says Cuba's Castro committed to reform
| International
|
Hurricane Rick kills man, nears Mexico coast
| International
|
Philippines starts evacuation ahead of new typhoon
| International
|
AP source: Karzai expected to accept he fell short
Judge postpones another Ohio inmate's execution
Taiwan seeks high-level US visit: official
Federal judge shutters Idaho grazing allotment
NJ mass murderer who killed 13 in 1949 dies at 88
New Zealand to hold referendum on voting system
Baby food recalled, may be tainted with botulism
Justice blocks names in gay rights ballot measure
USDA: Pork Safe To Eat Despite H1N1 Virus In Minnesota Pig Sample
U.S. Markets Gain As Dow Keeps Climbing Above 10,000
Philippines starts evacuation ahead of new typhoon
Aussie junior sailor asleep in collision: inquiry
New York Times To Cut Another 100 News Staff Jobs
US to ease prosecutions for 'medical marijuana' use
Japan's Samurai art on show in New York
U.S. video game sales up 1 percent in Sept; PS3 top: NPD
| Technology
|
Barnes & Noble e-reader has color, $259 price: report
| Technology
|
US says ready for NKorea talks
Any North Korea meeting must lead to six-way talks
Somali pirates seize Chinese ship in Indian Ocean
HRW urges fair hearing for jailed Kazakh activist
Philippine militants abduct school principal
Japan's Toyota sells new models in SKorea
Nissan in electric car batteries recycling venture
Detroit faces siege by Hollywood movie
Seoul shares rise 0.5 pct on LG Display, Lotte
S.Korea T-bonds edge down on foreign sale
Taiwan mulls easing controls on LCD tech in China -paper
Japan FM suggests 50 trillion yen bond issuance: Nikkei
Seoul shares up; LG Display rises on Corning news
Nissan aims to make batteries 'core business': Ghosn
China to invest in Zambia despite downturn: official
Michelle Obama to appear on Jay Leno Show
| Entertainment
|
U2 teams with YouTube for live concert broadcast
| Entertainment
|
Detroit faces siege by Hollywood movie
| Entertainment
|
NBC Universal's Graboff says TV windows collapsing
| Entertainment
|
Judge allows Chris Rock Good Hair film to open
| Entertainment
|
Where the Wild Things Are tops weekend box office
| Entertainment
|
NKorea's showcase Arirang festival ends
Adam Lambert single leaked online
| Entertainment
|
Birkhead: Prosecutor chastised my testimony
Arrested Development to air on IFC
| Entertainment
|
Campaign to stop mass animal sacrifice in Nepal
NBC Universal's Graboff says TV windows collapsing
"Biggest Loser" trainer hits the road in new series
U2 teams with YouTube for live concert broadcast
Judge allows Chris Rock "Good Hair" film to open
Kenyan training camps running into trouble
Michelle Obama to appear on "Jay Leno Show"
Adam Lambert single leaked online
Iranian-American academic gets 12 years for unrest
German rail faces fine for email spying: spokesman
Australian burglar betrayed by leech
Aghanistan to hold election run-off Nov 7
Abbas says to issue decree for Palestinian vote
| International
|
Group behind deadly Iran bombing based in Pakistan: FM
Karzai to accept final vote result: spokesman
Iran honors Guards killed in attack, blames U.S
| International
|
Iran court jails U.S.-Iranian scholar: report
| International
|
Pope makes it easier for Anglicans to convert
| International
|
North Koreans quit Danish embassy in Hanoi for South Korea
| International
|
Berlusconi sparks feminist backlash in Italy
| International
|
Iran says Vienna talks won't curb nuclear drive
| International
|
Psychiatrist describes Anna Nicole as addicted
Jury selected in Birmingham, Ala., mayor's trial
Lawyer: Nurse assistant denied care after attacks
Biden to reassure Poles during European trip
US scientist accused of trying to sell secrets
Ain't that America: balloon boy's cultural moment
US scientist in court over attempt to spy for Israel
Apple smashes forecasts, stock hits record
| Technology
|
Playing the White House: music on a higher scale
Police Detectives Save Bronx Cat Trapped In Car Engine
Another Top Conservative Chooses To Support Gov. Crist's Rival
Former NASA Scientist Charged With Espionage
Biden Visits Central Europe To Allay Concerns About Missile Defense
Authorities Focus On Transient's Role In Massive WildFire That Killed 2 Firefighters
Illnesses Often Not Discovered Among The Uninsured
Taiwan stocks edge higher, helped by tech shares
S.Korea spotted buying dlrs to curb won's rise -traders
Seoul shares rise 0.6 pct on LG Display; POSCO down
Bank of China exec resigns, tipped for IMF post
China auto output hits record 10 mln: state media
Temasek raising $1.5 billion from bond sale
Beijing Autos says watching ex-Ford engineer case
China auto output hits 10 mln units for 1st time
U2 to stream entire concert live on YouTube
| Entertainment
|
Hardness is the way to happiness: sex survey
Swiss court rejects Polanski bid for release
| Entertainment
|
Indonesia's Yudhoyono sworn in for second term
China's anniversary film breaks 400M yuan mark
Indonesians fed up with crippling graft, poverty
Lessons of balloon hoax to go unlearned: analysts
From Colombia to Lebanon: Father Dario Escobar
Epic African roadtrip aids poor ahead of 2010 WC
Ashkalis: suffering of Kosovo's forgotten minority
Bumper harvest turns sour for Bulgaria's grape growers
Tensions rise as Bhutan refugees leave Nepal
Ending death penalty could save US millions: study
Wine country renaissance near Bordeaux
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights