Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Special report: Putting the Gulf to work
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (0)
Email
Print
Reprints
Full Focus
Editor's choice
A selection of our best photos from the past 24 hours. Full Article
Read
Special report: Conservative donors let Christine O'Donnell sink
10:32am EDT
Appeals court stays ruling on gays in military
20 Oct 2010
U.S. plan hits opposition at G20, FX accord remote
11:06am EDT
CERN scientists eye parallel universe breakthrough
20 Oct 2010
UPDATE 1-Cirrus Logic Q2 misses; sees Q3 rev below Street view
8:59am EDT
Discussed
62
WRAPUP 1-Two Fed officials favor aggressive easing options
59
Jobs blasts rivals as iPad sales disappoint
50
Merkel says German multiculturalism has failed
Watched
Red faces over top model gaffe
Tue, Sep 28 2010
Russian spy poses for Maxim
Tue, Oct 19 2010
Rare public appearance
Sun, Oct 17 2010
Special report: Putting the Gulf to work
Tweet This
Share on LinkedIn
Share on Facebook
Factbox
In the Gulf, a public job beats a private one
9:23am EDT
Analysis & Opinion
The curse of the blue diamond
Related Topics
World »
A worker is silhouetted as Burj Dubai, the tallest tower in the world, is seen in the background at a construction site near Burj Dubai Mall, October 29, 2008.
Credit: Reuters/Ahmed Jadallah
By Erika Solomon and Regan E. Doherty
DUBAI/DOHA |
Thu Oct 21, 2010 9:23am EDT
DUBAI/DOHA (Reuters) - When Qatari paramedic Mohammed Majib rushed to Sheikh Khalifa bin Hamad al Thani's royal palace in the mid 1990s after a call for help, he wasn't sure what the ailing Sheikh found more shocking -- the heart attack he had just suffered, or the fact that his medic was a local. "You're Qatari?" the former ruler gasped, as Majib went to work. "Ma Sha' Allah. (God bless you)."
Khalifa's surprise was understandable. Across the Gulf, and especially in states where rapid growth is driven by oil and gas, locals rarely have hands-on jobs in health -- or anywhere in the private sector. In an unspoken pact between rulers and ruled, Gulf citizens seem all too happy to fill plush government jobs, where the pay is high, the hours short, and the work sometimes nonexistent. In the private sector, job after job is filled by South Asians, non-Gulf Arabs and Westerners.
Gulf Arab rulers have known for more than a decade that this is a problem, not least because it hands day-to-day power over whole sections of the economy to foreigners. Foreign workers make up more than 80 percent of the private workforce in many Gulf states and hold key positions running national airlines, real estate and financial service companies and the media industry.
In response, governments have introduced 'nationalization' schemes aimed at pushing their workers into the private sector. Oman was the first, setting out in the 1980s to 'Omanize' its workforce; governments in Bahrain, Kuwait, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates have all followed. Typically, the schemes combine tax incentives for private companies to hire locals, quotas, and investment in training local graduates.
It's not working. Most Gulf Arab rulers have found breaking a culture of easy-come government jobs and preparing their citizens for the private sector difficult. Qataris, about 16 percent of the country's 1.7 million people, still represent just 5 percent of the country's private-sector workforce, government statistics show. Locals fill about one percent of private-sector jobs in the United Arab Emirates. Saudi Arabia, with its large native population, has mustered a 10 percent participation rate.
"We need to share in the private sector," says Noora Al Bedur, a director of the UAE's Emiratization program. "The private sector is the backbone of a country's economy. And citizens have the right to work in this field. That is very important for us."
NEW STRUGGLES
Gulf Arabs have come to expect a nice government job as part of what Ingo Forstenlechner, an Austrian academic at the United Arab Emirates University, calls the region's ruling bargain: the rulers give you everything, but you don't ask for anything. "It's basically buying political acquiescence while distributing the oil wealth," Forstenlechner says.
That worked fine as long as government jobs were available. But in places like Saudi Arabia -- official unemployment is 10.5 percent, though diplomats and analysts say the real figure is likely to be higher -- state jobs are no longer guaranteed. In Kuwait, 12,000 nationals are waiting for government posts.
That's left young people frustrated. In an extremely rare public protest in late August, around 200 unemployed Saudi university graduates crowded in front of the education ministry in Riyadh carrying posters with slogans demanding government jobs and posters with slogans like "Enough Injustice."
Experts say unless unemployment is tackled, protests may increase -- adding to security risks. "The great majority of those recruited for terrorist activities are the unemployed," says Mustafa Alani, of the Gulf Research Center. "The (Saudi) government believes that the question of unemployment is a major problem with huge implications on security."
WHY BOTHER?
Part of the problem is that many Gulf nationals still don't see the point of seeking work in the private sector. In countries such as the UAE, where modest palm frond homes were replaced by glittering villas and skyscrapers in a generation or two, the government says most people are jobless by choice. Official statistics show 23 percent of Emiratis are unemployed -- a rate similar to the Gaza strip.
"These are strange economies -- they're economies that went from being rather poor and undeveloped to overnight having huge amounts of oil money invested in them," says Paul Dyer, a fellow at the Dubai School of Government who specializes in labor and political economy.
Khalid al Mutawaa, a 26-year-old Emirati who until recently worked as a project manager for an international bank, says the transformation has not been easy. "I think the older generations ... weren't ready for such a huge boom," he says, relaxing after work at a lounge in Dubai's beachside Ritz Carlton resort. "But I don't think the young people here were really ready for it either. UAE nationals have a very home-oriented environment. They see family as the priority."
1
2
3
4
Next
World
Add a Comment
*We welcome comments that advance the story directly or with relevant tangential information. We try to block comments that use offensive language or appear to be spam and review comments frequently to ensure they meet our standards. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters.
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Reader Feedback
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Analyst Research
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts
Venture Capital Journal
International Financing Review
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
FindLaw
Reuters on Facebook
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Thursday, 21 October 2010 Key tiger habitats in Russia at risk: WWF
US-TECH Summary
Chavez and Ahmadinejad say united to change world order
|
Pentagon seeks tight ties with cyber contractors
Britain unveils deep spending cuts to tackle record debt
Police see over 1,000 militant Islamists in Germany
|
Electronic Arts to buy "Angry Birds" game publisher
Flight Delays Cost U.S. Economy $33 Billion
Britain to cut half million public sector jobs
Samsung Galaxy on sale in US next month for 600 dollars
Suspected iPhone Thief Nabbed Due to "I'm Me" Tattoo on Forehead
Spanish PM replaces foreign minister in reshuffle
Florida Teens Accused of Torching Classmate Reject Plea Deal
Verizon prices Samsung Tab just under iPad
Wealthfront lets regular folks invest like the rich
Abbott Earnings Drop 40 Percent
Opposition says Moscow square rally given go-ahead
|
Tattoo Company Draws Interest With "Slutty" Slogan
Trapped Ecuador miners' lamps, boot found
|
Pizzeria Owner Tax Cheat Sentenced to Deliver Pizzas to City's Poor
Vietnam blogger arrested, says wife
Spanish PM poised to reshuffle cabinet
Fight over gays in U.S. military moves to appeals court
Belgian convicted in rival's parachute death dive
|
Six Years Later, Photos Still Not On Pilot Licenses
CIA Inquiry Finds Lapses Led To Deaths Of 7 Officers In Afghanistan
Jordan warned CIA about Afghan bomber
Gates Apologizes For Pakistan Missile Deaths, Promises Long Term Ties
Turkcell forced to call off board meeting
Robyn To Release Complete "Body Talk" Album In November
Telecom Italia to offer high-speed mobile service
Actor Van Damme suffers minor heart attack on set
Telcos scramble for piece of booming Saudi market
US-TECH Summary
Pakistan 'not calling in army' over political killings
Apple touts iPad-inspired Mac laptop
|
Samsung Galaxy on sale in US next month for 600 dollars
Pentagon seeks tight ties with cyber contractors
|
Facebook looks to grow Vietnam presence
Verizon prices Samsung Tab just under iPad
Verizon prices Samsung Tab just under iPad
|
Electronic Arts to buy Angry Birds game publisher
|
South Korea calls on North to honour nuclear deal
Telecom Italia to offer high-speed mobile service
|
ASEAN to upgrade ties with SKorea: draft document
Turkcell forced to call off board meeting
|
India considers more money for ailing Air India
Regulators agree tighter watch over big financial firms
Thailand holds rate steady as economic outlook dims
Shots, tear gas fired at Indonesia protests
Coal India IPO oversubscribed 11 times on day three
India's Micromax hopes to hit market soon with IPO
Obama takes his act to Jon Stewart's Daily Show
|
Taliban-style bomb kills 10 Afghan wedding guests
UK unveils deep spending cuts
France fights fuel cuts as pension vote nears
|
Kuwait drama stirs debate on Gulf Arab ties to Iran
Google says few Germans opted out of Street View
Russia, NATO must overcome historic distrust: Medvedev
Researchers discover 'cancer marker' gene
Activity detected at North Korea nuclear test site: report
|
US economy grows at 'modest' pace: Federal Reserve
Internet address sex.com attracts 13-million-dollar bid
Afghan govt throws out nearly a quarter of ballots
Mediators, lawyers to help integrate Roma: Council of Europe
Mexican student takes over police in drug war town
|
Ad Agency Makes Healthy Lifestyle Brands Less "Granola" For Veria TV
Lil Wayne Climbs To #1, Darius Rucker Debuts At #2 On Billboard Albums Chart
Rumsfeld is back... this time, on Twitter
Gene therapy could treat depression: US research
'Inhuman' conditions for migrants in Greece: UN expert
Bomb scare at Manila stock exchange a false alarm
|
Stocks Rebound On Strong Boeing Profits
Afghanistan annuls nearly a quarter of ballots
US appeals court lets military keep gay ban temporarily
Russia unveils 60 billion dollar privatisation drive
Black Rice Shown to Reduce Disease Inflammation
Last missing Ecuadorean miners found dead
|
'It Gets Better' message for gay youth in US goes viral
U.S. Taps Mexican Drug Cartel Phone Calls Deep In Mexico
ECB official gives cool reaction to eurozone reforms
Gays adopt wait and see approach on US military ban
Brazil polls show Rousseff rebound before election
|
Dell plans ad makeover to shed low-price image
Russia 'establishes causes' of Polish plane tragedy
US announces massive arms sale to Saudi Arabia
Strong quake shakes Chile, no damage reported
|
3 US airlines end quarter with flying colors, raising hopes
Investor group seeking to buy Boston Globe from Times Co
Ancient galaxy is more than 13 billion light years away
U.S.-Pakistani officials tackle difficult issues
|
Apple debuts iPad-inspired MacBook Air notebooks
Minimum and maximum temperatures in Celsius
Crystal Cathedral teeters on the edge
US-TECH Summary
China opposes UN report on Darfur bullets: diplomats
Appeals court keeps military gay policy for now
World turning blind eye to Myanmar: Nobel laureate
Hobbit films poised to leave New Zealand: director
UN envoy casts doubt on Myanmar vote amid new torture cases
Two Koreas exchange names for family reunions
Dell plans ad makeover to shed low-price image
|
Vietnam rescuers find passenger bus missing in flood: TV
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Google says few Germans opted out of Street View
|
Southern China braces for deadly typhoon
Penthouse magazine founder Bob Guccione dies
Singapore, Hong Kong restaurants best in Asia: report
"Hobbit" crisis triggers New Zealand protests
Comic's mockery of Justin Bieber book goes viral
California to stage mass quake drill
Mysterious French street artist JR wins coveted TED Prize
Russian Yulianna Avdeeva tops Chopin competition
Wary Chinese will complicate huge census effort: official
NZ consumer confidence falls in October
Gwyneth Paltrow to make country music debut
Jailed rapper Lil Wayne busts out atop album chart
China's econom slows in Q3, but remains strong
NZ credit-card billings higher in Sept
Taiwan dlr firms; spotlight on c.bank, U.S. economy
Seoul shares dip amid China caution; Hana Fin down
S.Korea bonds gain on firmer won; U.S. easing move eyed
Seoul shares up; gains limited before China data
Obama to visit Pakistan in 2011-White House
Racy Glee photos in GQ kick up a storm
|
Paranormal 2 sequel set to rattle box office
|
China's rapid growth slows further
Penthouse magazine founder Bob Guccione dies
|
Gwyneth Paltrow to make country music debut
|
China's growth slows, inflation rises
Comic's mockery of Justin Bieber book goes viral
|
Hobbit crisis triggers New Zealand protests
|
Jailed rapper Lil Wayne busts out atop album chart
|
Virginia man pleads guilty over ties to al Shabaab
|
French students clash with police in protests
Afghan peace council to offer concessions to Taliban
|
Sony expects TV price falls in U.S. by year-end
ECB chief has 'objections' to euro rules proposal
Top Putin aide confirmed as Moscow mayor
South China coast battens down as super typhoon nears
|
President Barack Obama To Appear On "The Daily Show"
Mexican student takes over police in drug war town
|
First-Time Jobless Claims Drop 23,000 For Week Ending Oct. 16
Far East Movement Earns First #1 Billboard Hot 100 Single With "Like A G6"
Clinton Hints U.S. Would Allow More Oil Sands From Canada
White House Says Obama Visit To Focus On Mumbai, New Delhi
Special report: Putting the Gulf to work
|
Lady Gaga Postpones French Concerts Due To Strikes
Teen Birth Rates Highest In Southern States
FDA Warns Of Heart Risks With Prostate Cancer Drug
Appeals Court Orders "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" Enforced
Feds Launch Lou Gehrig's Disease Registry
French protesters block Marseille airport
Myanmar Supreme Court 'to consider Suu Kyi appeal'
Report faults state prisons' treatment of mothers
China won't confirm Japan meeting as tensions return
Foreigner hurt in Beijing blast: state media
Vietnam rescuers recover bodies after flood tragedy
Netflix may offer U.S. Web service this year
Iran's Khamenei scores points with cleric critics
|
US, China in 'fundamental disagreement' over Liu
Google says 250,000 Germans opt out of Street View
Cuban dissident wins top EU rights prize
|
Belgian parachute murderer given 30-year jail term
|
Fifteen dead found with sunken Vietnamese bus
S.Africa's 'Facebook' captivates young cell phone users
Clashes intensify in Naples over waste dump plans
|
Thousands evacuated as Typhoon Megi nears China
Bus bomb kills nine in Philippines
N.Korea 'may be planning nuclear test'
China evacuates thousands as typhoon nears
US-TECH Summary
Sony expects TV price falls in U.S. by year-end
Microsoft Windows 7 sales top 240 million in first year
|
Nokia to cut 1,800 jobs after strong Q3
|
Dell plans ad makeover to shed low-price image
|
Lively Bahrain social media face government pressure
|
Study: Women give more to charity than men
Netflix may offer U.S. Web service this year
|
Sony expects TV price falls in U.S. by year-end
|
Pentagon seeks tight ties with cyber contractors
|
Pakistani stocks end up; rupee, o/n rates flat
China's central bank warns of inflation, bad loan risks
Toyota recalls 1.5 mln cars over brake fluid leak
Toshiba almost trebles first-half earnings forecast
G20 vows to avoid forex undervaluation
Random House signs global rights to Rushdie memoir
|
Haneda becomes Tokyo's second major airport
Pakistan's forex reserves jump to record $17.10 bln
Racy Glee photos in GQ kick up a storm
|
Taiwan bank chief's 'hot money' flow warning
Jersey Shore creator promises plenty of drama
|
Roxy Music's Bryan Ferry to release comeback album
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights