Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Cablegate leaks divide opinion on freedom of information
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Cablegate leaks divide opinion on freedom of information
AFP - Wednesday, December 1
Send
IM Story
Print
Cablegate leaks divide opinion on freedom of information
PARIS (AFP) - – WikiLeaks' mass exposure of US diplomatic cables has divided liberal intellectual opinion between supporters of total government transparency and those who see a threat to democratic rule.
While the world's press has splashed the revelations across its front pages even some journalists have begun to wonder whether too much exposure is a good thing in an era of instant global electronic communication.
"Much, but not all state information should be public," argued the Financial Times, in a leader. "In order for states to conduct their affairs effectively, and ensure the security of their citizens, some secrets must remain."
WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange defended previous leaks of US military reports from Iraq and Afghanistan by declaring he was "trying to stop two wars" -- but some fear his latest stunt could provoke new ones.
News that Arab leaders and Israel are pushing for US air strikes on Iran and that China is rethinking its protection of North Korea's erratic regime has increased tensions in two of the world's most dangerous flashpoints.
And some fear that if diplomats can no longer be confident that they can exchange frank views in private, then it will be harder for capitals to resolve disputes without inflaming public opinion or angering rival players.
"In a world criss-crossed by violent conflict, a state can not permanently operate under the constant gaze of opinion," warned Laurent Joffrin, editor of France's left-wing Liberation daily, a champion of media freedoms.
The stolen cables were downloaded from a supposedly secure US government network that was set up in the wake of the terror attacks of September 11, 2001 in order to allow analysts to rapidly share and compare information.
Some have expressed concern that diplomatic and intelligence agencies will retreat inside their shells and fail to prevent future attacks if clues are scattered across different, more tightly-controlled networks.
During previous WikiLeaks revelations, the group was also accused of putting the lives of US informants and locally recruited agents at risk.
Such concerns even motivated groups more usually associated with campaigning for openness and press freedom to criticise the all-or-nothing character of an operation that exposed tens of thousands of documents.
This time round, however, there has been praise for the professional investigation run by the five newspapers which got first sight of the files -- the New York Times, The Guardian, Le Monde, El Pais and Der Spiegel.
Rather than splashing a quarter of a million cables unmediated onto the public domain, reporters from the dailies pored over them for weeks, seeking stories of public interest and evaluating the risks of exposure.
"We're more or less satisfied with WikiLeaks' evolution," said the head of independent press watchdog Reporters Without Borders, Jean-Francois Julliard.
"We like this partnership with the newspapers and this work to put things in context, verify the information and draw lessons from it," he said.
Others are less convinced and fear the leaks will erode the bonds of trust between rival capitals without really advancing the cause of open government, especially in the democratic world.
"There's demagogy and a naive faith in thinking that radical transparency will help us reach another democratic level," French political scientist Philippe Braud told AFP, branding the publication an elite parlour game.
"The enlightened few learned very little and the others still think we're hiding everything from them, which can only feed anti-democratic instincts," he said, arguing it is normal to allow leaders special rights and duties.
And, at a time when social networking sites can expose a citizen's private life at the touch of a button, some see in the WikiLeaks exposure another sign of how the Internet itself can erode freedoms.
"There's no reason that democratic checks and balances have to take the form of a sort of electronic 'Big Brother,'" complained former French foreign minister Hubert Vedrine in a newspaper op-ed.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Facebook co-founder's new venture to promote causes AFP - 23 minutes ago
WikiLeaks says it is under new cyber attack: Twitter feed AFP - 49 minutes ago
US-TECH Summary Reuters - 53 minutes ago
Egypt Facebook user jailed over army recruit group: lawyer AFP - 1 hour 15 minutes ago
EU launches Google antitrust probe AFP - 1 hour 34 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Eurozone debt crisis deepens
Negotiators get down to details at UN climate talks
US consumer confidence hits five-month high
EU launches Google antitrust probe
Euro plunges to two-month low under 1.30 dollars
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Britain's Prince William happy to wait for crown
Ecuador offers WikiLeaks founder residency
Billions of EU's euros going unused: report
Obama calls for US government pay freeze
Iran says nuclear scientists, programme attacked
More Most Viewed »
'Naked' airport scanners may be 'dangerous'
Pilgrims stone 'devil' as Muslims celebrate Eid
World leaders scramble for funds to save the tiger
US, S.Korea plan war games after N.Korean attack
Obama gets 12 stitches after 'elbow in the lip'
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Wednesday, 1 December 2010 Egypt's Islamists say they might withdraw from vote
Euro plunges to two-month low under 1.30 dollars
Medvedev warns West of new arms race
Sanctions squeeze Dubai's trade with Iran
Negotiators get down to details at UN climate talks
Student protests disrupt Italian roads, railways
|
Coalition ramps up air war over Afghanistan
Picasso treasure trove surfaces in France
US consumer confidence hits five-month high
Eurozone debt crisis deepens
Sony sells 4.1 million Move systems
Afghan gunman had no criminal background
Ugandan paper says it will keep outing gays
|
Iraq delays first census since 1987 over land row
|
Swiss slammed as 'black sheep' over expulsion vote
Chile's Collahuasi resumes wage talks with workers
|
Amid doubts, Cubans pursue private sector dreams
|
Solarz, US lawmaker who broke with Marcos, dies
Warhol's portrait of Dutch queen sold for 400,000 euros
China postpones Norway talks as Nobel tensions rise
China suspends Norway trade talks amid Nobel fury
Lagerfeld undresses Greek gods for Pirelli calendar
France's top HK diplomat fired for stealing wine: sources
Classic Bob Dylan lyrics up for auction in New York
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
GM hiring to push electric effort beyond Volt
|
"Winter's Bone" wins best film at Gotham Awards
RIM shares jump on positive view of new OS
|
"Winter's Bone," "Kids" come up big at Spirit Awards
U.S. secret documents on N.K. and Kim Jong-il revealed
Lowe's to boost online biz, margins initiatives
|
Wall collapses at Pompeii's House of Moralist
Thai group organises rally criticising court verdict
Veteran French rockers Noir Desir split: drummer
Sony sells 4.1 million Move systems
|
Finnish vineyards use creativity, not grapes, for wine
UK's Telegraph newspaper says no paywall decision
|
Filmmaker Zucker pays tribute to Leslie Nielsen
Winter's Bone, Kids come up big at Spirit Awards
|
Michael Douglas eyes Liberace after chemotherapy
|
Roger Waters honors war casualties on Wall tour
|
US-TECH Summary
Lowe's to boost online biz, margins initiatives
FCC proposes broadcast airwaves for wireless use
Sony sells 4.1 million Move systems
UK's Telegraph newspaper says no paywall decision
Cablegate leaks divide opinion on freedom of information
Google close to buying shopping site Groupon: reports
Indian tech firms link with China to take on Western brands
Chinese micro-blog re-emerges after shutdown
'Sarkozy the American' mulled troops for Iraq: WikiLeaks
INTERPOL issues global arrest request for WikiLeaks' Assange
South Korea plans new drills as China avoids blaming North
|
Comcast, Netflix partner feud over 'open Internet'
Sarkozy to run for second term: UMP
Don't hunt down my son, says mother of WikiLeaks founder
|
Complacency fuels new AIDS surge in West: UN
Heavy snow hits airports and roads across Europe
China arrests hundreds of hackers, says situation grim
|
Wireless firms playing bigger role in Linux
Palestinians have other options if talks fail: Abbas
Branson scoops Murdoch with digital magazine
Russia's Putin warns West over missile defense: report
|
Finger length predicts prostate cancer risk: study
China's healthcare plans bump against rural skills gap
|
Google in crosshairs of the wary and watchful
Landslides and flooding kill 21 in Venezuela
|
New York Times looks to WeightWatchers for Internet tips
Activision cool to mobile, social games
Opposition cries foul at Ivory Coast poll result delay
|
Obama and Republicans agree to negotiate on taxes
BofA may be next WikiLeaks target; stock falls
Motorola to split in two in January
Global Weather-Asia-Celsius
Branson launches glossy iPad magazine, 'Project'
U.S. military study gives green light to end gay ban
Motorola to split in two in January
Pakistan dismisses nuclear fears in leaked US cables
E.Timor leader pushes for ASEAN membership
Swiss Timing charged in Delhi Games graft case
Malaysia detains Indonesian terror suspect: report
"Tron: Legacy" may fall short at box office
Hong Kong to hold inquest over Manila bus hijack
Michael Douglas on 'upward curve' from cancer
FCC proposes wireless use of broadcast airwaves
|
China's healthcare plans bump against rural skills gap
Complacency fuels new AIDS surge in West: UN
Wireless firms playing bigger role in Linux
|
China arrests hundreds of hackers, says situation "grim"
Judge issues rulings in estate's superhero battle
Google close to clinching Groupon deal: reports
|
Amy Poehler trades "SNL" skits for single character
US, S.Korea wrap up war games amid N.Korea crisis
CBS revamps low-rated "Early Show," ousts anchors
Branson scoops Murdoch with digital magazine
|
China's manufacturing activity picks up in November
iPad has real Xmas rival in Galaxy tablet
Michael Jackson's dad files new wrongful death suit
Activision cool to mobile, social games
|
S.Korea Nov exports, PMI ease slowdown concerns
Uma Thurman stalker back in jail
New York Times looks to WeightWatchers for Internet tips
|
NZ to hold two minutes' silence for dead miners
Seoul shares end up 1.3 pct on autos, refiners
USOC eyes revival of Olympic TV network
Tiger Woods all a-Twitter at Sherwood
|
S.Korea bonds rise as Nov inflation decelerates
China arrests hundreds of hackers, says situation grim
|
Korea Hot Stocks -Vaccine issues up on Foot-Mouth disease fears
South Korea won stronger on brisk exports data
Seoul shares open up helped by U.S. data
S.Korea Nov mfg PMI ends 6-month fall
Argentina, China sign 'historic' farm trade deals
Surveys show China manufacturing up in November
Michael Jackson's dad files new wrongful death suit
|
CBS revamps low-rated Early Show, ousts anchors
|
Amy Poehler trades SNL skits for single character
|
Uma Thurman stalker back in jail
|
Judge issues rulings in estate's superhero battle
|
Tron: Legacy may fall short at box office
|
Bob Dylan lyrics seen fetching big money at auction
|
Egypt opposition threatens to boycott runoff
Hamas would honor referendum on peace with Israel
|
Egypt ruling party heads to sweeping win in vote
Israel torn on U.S. arming Arabs against Iran: WikiLeaks
|
Iran hangs woman for murdering love rival
FCC to take up net neutrality at December meeting
U.S. calls for stronger OSCE support for Afghan war
|
U.S. condemns Palestinian report on Western Wall
Bailout chief says EU serious about protecting euro
Euro recovers -- but fears of Portugal bailout
Egypt Islamists say quitting rigged election
|
Taliban kidnap demining team in east Afghanistan
Afghanistan announces last set of election results
|
Pakistan rejects fears over its nuclear weapons
|
Iran says U.N. sanctions helped scientist's killers
|
Al Qaeda finds in Yemen a society ripe for infiltration
|
South Korea spy chief says more attacks likely
Iran biggest drug supplier for Indonesia
Former Soviet republic giving up nuclear materials
Indonesian presenter Susan divorces husband
Bangladesh protests hit businesses
Indonesia sees pre-marital sex active among teenagers
Bangladesh ex-PM's son faces money laundering charges
Bali gears up for influx of holiday visitors
FCC to take up net neutrality at December meeting
|
Home alone: Life of a 6-year-old HIV-positive boy in China
FTC report to push stronger Web privacy but limited
|
India ratifies key spending bill amid corruption row
AC/DC drummer hit with NZ cannabis conviction
Cyber Monday sales hit all-time high: comScore
|
Chinese firms keen on Taiwan IT show: organisers
NZ housing confidence touch softer in Q3
Japan's Skymark to hire 470 former JAL staff
IMF likely to delay next Pakistan loan tranche-source
Vietnam urges 'strong measures' to stabilise forex, gold
Group urges Indonesia's Aceh to repeal sharia bylaws
India's Maruti car sales top 100,000 for fifth month
Pakistan's 3-month fiscal deficit at 1.6 pct of GDP
Eurozone, China fears weigh on Asian markets
Thailand hikes interest rate to 2.0 percent
Pakistan to announce results of T-bill acution on Wednesday
MTV launches Me, Myself and HIV film on AIDS day
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights