Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Charges unlikely for husband in NY wrong-way crash
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Search
Search:
Charges unlikely for husband in NY wrong-way crash
By FRANK ELTMAN,Associated Press Writer AP - Sunday, August 9
GARDEN CITY, N.Y. -
There isn't much chance the husband of Diane Schuler could face criminal charges for the fiery crash she caused while driving the wrong way on a highway, killing herself and seven others, attorneys agree.
Prosecutors would have to prove Daniel Schuler was aware his wife was intoxicated _ and failed to stop her _ when she packed her two children and three nieces into a minivan at an upstate campground for the ride home to Long Island. A witness who saw her there said she was sober, and state police have said she wasn't impaired an hour after she left.
So what was defense attorney Dominic Barbara doing when he paraded the teary-eyed widower before a mob of reporters this week to dispute autopsy findings that Diane Schuler was high on marijuana and drunk when she smashed head-on into a sport utility vehicle?
Attorneys suspect it was the first step in trying to soften the hearts of potential jurors for civil litigation that some victims' families intend to pursue.
"For obvious reasons, the family wants to rehabilitate this lady's reputation," said attorney Vincent Trimarco, who is not involved in the case. "She's not the most popular person out there. To most people, she committed a murder."
Beginning with a dramatic, tear-filled press conference Thursday, Daniel Schuler, his family and attorney have argued that the 36-year-old Long Island mother was revered and trusted with children and suggested that separate medical conditions could have affected her driving before the July 26 crash on the Taconic State Parkway, about 35 miles north of New York City.
Tom Ruskin, an investigator working for Barbara, is looking at four calls Diane Schuler made a couple of hours before the crash; most were to her brother, and in one, her 8-year-old niece, Emma Hance, got on the phone and said that her aunt was having trouble seeing and speaking, he said.
Toxicology reports from Schuler's autopsy found her blood-alcohol level was .19 percent, more than double the state's legal limit, and high levels of the key ingredient in marijuana in her system, suggesting she had smoked pot from 15 minutes to an hour before the 1:30 p.m. crash.
Schuler slammed her minivan head-on into an SUV about a half-hour after her last phone call after driving south on the northbound lanes of the highway for nearly two miles. She died along with her 2-year-old daughter, three nieces and three Yonkers men in the SUV. Her 5-year-old son survived.
A couple in a third car were also injured. A lawyer for Michael and Guy Bastardi, a father and son killed on their way to a family dinner, has said someone should be held criminally responsible for the crash and suggested many people around Schuler would have known she had a drinking problem.
"I find it very hard to believe that anybody will be charged with the homicides of these victims," attorney Stephen LaMagna said. He represented Martin Heidgen, who was convicted of murder after driving the wrong way on a Long Island parkway in 2005, killing a limousine driver and a 7-year-old flower girl coming home from a family wedding.
"It's horrible. We want to hold somebody up to the public to be brought to justice," LaMagna said. "But in this case, the responsible party also died in the accident."
J. Herbie DiFonzo, a former federal prosecutor who is a law professor at Hofstra University, said insurance companies are likely to be the ones fighting it out in the coming months and years.
The lawyer for the Bastardis has said victims' families will pursue civil lawsuits.
"She is legally responsible for the deaths of all the individuals," DiFonzo said. "First, they will turn to the insurance companies, and then perhaps go after her estate."
But DiFonzo noted that any assets co-owned by both Daniel and Diane Schuler _ like their home, perhaps _ would not be vulnerable because he can't be held liable for her actions.
Police and investigators are also trying to determine when Schuler began drinking and smoking pot. A broken, extra-large bottle of Absolut vodka was found in the wrecked minivan.
Ruskin has said the family had a bottle of vodka they would take from their Long Island home to the upstate campground for the summer and wasn't sure which car it was in when the couple drove separately home that Sunday morning.
Ann Scott, co-owner of the Hunter Lake campground, said there was no sign Schuler had been drinking when she left at about 9:30 a.m.
Investigators say she stopped at a McDonald's in Liberty, N.Y., where witnesses reported seeing no signs that the woman was suffering any physical ailments.
She left the restaurant at about 10:45 a.m., state police said, and was last heard from when she made a cell phone call to her brother _ the father of Schuler's nieces _ at 1:02 p.m.
Daniel Schuler and attorneys have pointed to medical conditions like gestational diabetes _ which goes away after childbirth _ a stroke or an untreated bump on her leg that could have caused problems for Diane Schuler. And they say she was a loving, responsible mother who never would have driven drunk.
Experts say that now, more than anything, Daniel Schuler may be trying to salvage his family's legacy.
"It's his name," said Jeremy Saland, a former prosecutor and defense attorney. "He doesn't want his family, for the next generation, to be known as the family involved with that horrible mother who perpetrated a crime against her children."
___
Associated Press writer Colleen Long in New York City contributed to this report.
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: World
Peru's Fujimori to face another trial in SeptemberAFP - Saturday, August 8
Afghan mission could last 40 years: new army chiefAFP - Sunday, August 9
Angry Americans disrupt town-hall healthcare talksReuters - Saturday, August 8
AP News in Brief at 5:58 a.m. EDTAP - Saturday, August 8
Salmonella product recallsAP - Saturday, August 8
Most Popular – World
Viewed
Scientists decode HIV genome structure: study
Manson murders back in spotlight 40 years on
Taiwan's Jay Chou goes to Hollywood: report
Explosions at besieged 'terror hideout' in Indonesia
Three new bank failures bring to 72 number of collapsed US banks
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Sunday, 9 August 2009 Iraq asks Iran about 3 detained Americans
Georgia leaders to face 'retribution' for war: Medvedev
EU defends action against Intel after report leaked
Three new bank failures bring to 72 number of collapsed US banks
French woman, embassy staff confess in Iran trial
Georgia blogger blames Russia for mass cyber attack
German energy giant unveils huge cost-cutting plan
Fatah endorses Abbas as party leader
French embassy targeted in Mauritania
| International
|
One Turkish soldier killed in PKK violence
Huge crowd shows solidarity with Tel Aviv gays
| International
|
Afghan presidential contender denies Karzai deal
| International
|
Look at what Congress has done so far this year
Analysis: To-do list largely undone
Obama says `worst may be behind us' on recession
Helicopter, plane collide over Hudson, 9 likely dead
Clinton: US to work with Afghan election winner
Sotomayor becomes first Hispanic US Supreme Court justice
Afghan challenger blasts government security
Hong Kong firm to pay Australia $21m for toxic oil spill
Ga. teen accused of shooting stepsister 10 times
Sri Lanka holds postwar polls in northern towns
Go-to guy on foreclosure cleanouts sees it all
Sotomayor sworn as first Hispanic on U.S. Supreme Court
Exiled Uighur activist say she is 'woman of peace'
Bomb outside NW Pakistan school wounds 6
Militants say Pakistan's Mehsud alive, deny report
Myanmar marks 21 years since student uprising
Taiwan's Jay Chou goes to Hollywood: report
Grammer says heart attack gave him chance to re-tool
| Entertainment
|
Mad Men still spellbinding in Season 3
| Entertainment
|
Techno music fans turn out for Zurich rave party
Venice Film Fest introduces 3D film award
Report: Missing Japanese actress turns herself in
Jackson show insurance excluded 'illicit' drug use
Huge crowd shows solidarity with Tel Aviv gays
Taliban leader's death disputed, shootout claimed
ETA claims Spanish police deaths: statement
French lecturer and embassy staffers go on trial in Iran
Climate change to challenge US military: report
Iran charges French woman, embassy workers with plot
| International
|
British actor claims he fathered Jackson's daughter
Fighting erupts between Taliban rivals and Pakistan government
| International
|
Iran charges French woman, embassy workers with plot
Jonas Brothers Team Up With Verizon And LG Mobile Phones To Give Fans A Chance To Win A Kickball Game With The Band
Crown Prince Willem-Alexander And Princess Maxim Of The Netherlands To Sue Over Photos
Sri Lanka's first post-war polls show mixed results
| International
|
Director John Huges Dead At 59
Late Actor Heath Ledger's Anti-Whaling Modest Mouse Music Video Finally Released
Disney To Premiere Environmental Charity Single Featuring Jonas Brothers, Miley Cyrus
Former Intern Recounts Alleged Sexual Abuse By Dr. Phil
Hollywood Production Manager Ted Swanson Dies At 72
Bushfire Survivor Sam The Koala Dies
Clinton seeks better ties with oil giant Angola
| International
|
Aerosmith's Steven Tyler Falls From Stage During Show
Chavez asks Colombia's Uribe to explain base plan
| International
|
Miley Cyrus' Stalker Busted Again
Springbok skipper Smit commends battling Wallabies
Feared toll from Tongan ferry tragedy rises to 95
93 people missing in Tongan ferry disaster
Plane, copter collide over Hudson; 9 believed dead
Charges unlikely for husband in NY wrong-way crash
Government and pro-rebel party win local elections
One dead, eight missing as Typhoon Morakot hits Taiwan
Collision turns attention to for-hire flights
Sotomayor, veteran judge, is rookie on high court
Flood overwhelms Philippines rescuers, death toll at 20
Nine feared dead after New York mid-air collision
Fighting erupts between Taliban rivals-Pakistan government
North century piles on agony for England at Ashes
AP NewsAlert
Safety of Russian planes in Afghan war questioned
US military deaths in Iraq war at 4,331
World pins recovery hopes on rising house prices
Hollywood abuzz at South African sci-fi film
SKorean steelmaker opens Mexico plant
Grammer says heart attack gave him chance to "re-tool"
Stock exchanges hit highest levels this year
Investors crave stability as Shanghai stocks rocket
ABC wants Paula Abdul to dance on over post-'Idol'
Hollywood abuzz at South African sci-fi film
Snowin' in the Wind? Dylan Christmas album due
| Entertainment
|
Dancing with Stars role for Paula Abdul?
| Entertainment
|
Beatles fans swarm Abbey Road on album anniversary
"Dancing with Stars" role for Paula Abdul?
ABC puts faith in ambitious programming
| Entertainment
|
Celebrities, recession fuel interest in etiquette
Police: Suspect planned attack on Indonesia leader
ABC puts faith in ambitious programming
Snowin' in the Wind? Dylan Christmas album due
Dance queen Lady GaGa fashions booming career
| Entertainment
|
Gary Sinise headlines free concert in Denver park
Report: Jackson kids' godfather claims paternity
Celebrities, recession fuel interest in etiquette
| Entertainment
|
Tel Aviv gay solidarity event draws 70,000: organisers
Palestinian Fatah seeks renewal, rejuvenation
U.S. says evidence Taliban chief dead pretty conclusive
| International
|
Saudi closes broadcaster after sex confession
China's east coast battered by typhoon
| International
|
Indonesia awaits DNA proof of suspect militant's ID
| International
|
Pakistani Taliban appears in turmoil after shootout
North Korea wants better ties with U.S. : security adviser
| International
|
Israel warns Hezbollah over assassination report
| International
|
France condemns Mauritania suicide attack
| International
|
Palestinian Fatah seeks renewal, rejuvenation
| International
|
Ship with Russian crew disappears: report
| International
|
Madagascar rivals agree power-sharing deal
| International
|
Clinton in Angola to sweeten trade ties
Kepler Telescope Finds Distant Planet During Test Run
Kansas man wins big in lottery for 2nd time in '09
Israel recalls diplomat who warned about US ties
Violent Riots Break Out At California Prison
Obama Travels To Mexico To Discuss Energy, Climate Change And Drug Wars
Consumer protections lost in health care debate
Clinton on oil mission to Angola
7 People, Including 4 Children Killed In California Car Crash
Two Top Pakistani Taliban Leaders Reportedly Killed
Three Bodies Found In Midair Crash Over The Hudson
Obama in first summit with Mexico, Canada leaders
BREAKING NEWS: Small Plane And Tourist Helicopter Collide Over Hudson River In Manhattan
Holder to name prosecutor to probe CIA abuses: report
Aerospace Company Alliant Techsystems Reports Quarterly Profit Surge
Eunice Kennedy Shriver, 88, In Critical Condition
Chinese secrets agency says Rio spied for 6 years
China searches for high-tech leap forward
Japanese actress arrested in Tokyo
Experts gather in Bali to discuss AIDS fight
Indonesia awaits DNA test to confirm terror leader's death
Doubts raised that dead terrorist was top leader
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights