Home
U.S.
World
Entertainment
Sports
Business
Health
Science
Technology
Politics
Offbeat
Environment
Travel
News
Articles
Public Option Allowing States To Opt Out Gains Ground In Congress
October 23, 2009 1:21 p.m. EST
Kris Alingod - AHN Contributor
Washington, D.C. (AHN) - A form of government insurance plan that lets states opt out is being pushed by Senate Democratic leaders and may be part of the bill that goes to the chamber's full floor for debate. Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) is currently working to merge two healthcare reform proposals amid pressure from liberals to include a strong public option.
The Senate Health panel in June reported out a $600 billion measure that has a "robust" government plan, while the Finance Committee last week approved an $829 billion bill that has non-profit insurance cooperatives instead of a public alternative.
A public option is a government-run, voluntary program that would compete with private insurance by offering cheaper coverage. Democrats support it because according to them it would help make the costs overhauling the nation's healthcare system and expanding coverage to the 47 million uninsured more affordable. The GOP says it would cause more job losses, harm small businesses, and would not reduce costs nor provide insurers with fair competition.
The White House has repeatedly said that it is not a requirement in the final reform legislation, so long as this also offers choice and competition to for-profit insurance. The administration is aiming for a bill costing $900 billion over 10 years, and that has a limited public option covering less than five percent of Americans.
Apart from the two Senate measures, three bills in the House that include a government plan are awaiting scores from the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), a non-partisan agency, before they are incorporated into one measure.
Passage of a public option is more critical in the Senate, where the majority is much more fragile and where Democrats such as Sen. Blanche Lincoln (D-AR) and centrist Republicans such as Sen. Olympia Snowe (R-ME) oppose it. Sen. Kent Conrad (D-ND), who crafted the Finance panel's proposal for non-profit cooperatives, has also repeatedly said a government-run program has no hope of passing in his chamber.
But there is apparent momentum for a limited public option that lets states decide if they want to participate in a national program. The idea has been proposed by Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-NY), the third ranking Democrat, and is said to have the support of Reid.
Snowe has said she does not support the opt-out type of public option. The only Republican to vote for a Democratic reform proposal and one of only three from the GOP who voted to pass the President's stimulus bill, Snowe is the progenitor of the plan that would only be triggered if insurers in a state are unable to meet certain requirement on affordability -- the so-called "trigger" public option -- that failed to gain support from either Democrats or Republicans.
The White House has refused to say if it favors the proposal. The administration "has been involved in meetings that normally happen in the evening as the two committees look to merge their legislation in a process that's being led by Senator Reid, " and will "continue to evaluate proposals as they come down the pike that are involved in the merged legislation as we go forward," Press Secretary Robert Gibbs said late Thursday, only hours before Reid and other Senate Democrats met behind closed doors with the President for an update on healthcare.
Republicans have decried the private negotiations and said the first major vote on healthcare -- Wednesday's defeat of a majority bill to fix the Medicare payment formula -- forewarns of the future of the final reform bill.
"They are writing the health care bill in secret, even though the President called for all of this to be out on an open table and have C-SPAN cameras in the room," said House Minority Leader John Boehner (R-OH).
"At the moment, the final details of the Democrat health care plan are largely unknown to the American people," Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) issued from the floor. "That's because those details are being worked out in private by a handful of senior Democrats and White House officials. But we do know the basics. It will cost about a trillion dollars, it will raise insurance premiums and taxes, and it will slash Medicare for seniors by about a half a trillion dollars over the next ten years. This much we know."
The emerging support for a limited public option comes as an ABC News/Washington Post poll finds that 57 percent of Americans now back a government plan, and 76 percent support a public option if this is run by states and is offered only to people without access to affordable private insurance.
The survey also found that virtually half of all Americans, 51 percent, prefer legislation that includes some form of public option for those without affordable access, even if the measure does not have the support of Republicans.
In the House, the issue on the public option has been whether to base its payment rates on Medicare provider payments. House Progressives, who make up the largest caucus in Congress, have been warning that negotiated payment rates would "weaken" a government program.
The bill reported out by the chamber's Energy Committee allows doctors to negotiate payment rates and costs $900 billion, while the two bills from the Ways and Means and Education Committees each costing $1 trillion over 10 years do not.
Copyright © 2003 - 2009 AHN - All rights reserved.Redistribution, republication. syndication, rewriting or broadcast is prohibited without the prior written consent of AHN.License AHN news for your website, business, digital signage network or publication.
Recent Posts
Most Popular Comments
Recent Comments
Popular Threads
Home | U.S. | World | Entertainment | Sports | Business | Health | Sci / Tech | Politics | Weird / Offbeat
Follow AHN on Twitter
AHN Social News connects you with friends and the news
Client Login | Submit News | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Contact | Content Services © 2009 AHN All Rights Reserved
Other News on Saturday, 24 October 2009 Iran to respond next week on nuclear deal, snubs deadline
France approves broadside to digital pirates
Czech Republic's Klaus warms to EU treaty compromise
Nokia could seek up to $1 billion for iPhones: analysts
Iran delays reply on U.N.-backed atom deal to next week
Sarkozy's son joins business district board
Twitter entries satirize works of literature
Microsoft beats expectations to cap off big week
Ukraine opposition leader launches comeback bid
| International
|
Yemeni rebels report border clash with Saudi forces
Kenyan British aristocrat freed
Nokia says N900 sales delayed to November
Vatican synod urges corrupt African leaders to quit
| International
|
Microsoft launches Windows 7
Iran fails to endorse U.N. nuclear deal
Zimbabwe PM says unity government not at end
| International
|
Nokia says N900 sales delayed to November
No area sex offender suspects in Fla. girl's death
Strong earthquake rocks eastern Indonesia
Tips to have a flu-free party this holiday season
Militant attacks in Pakistan so far in October
Erratic typhoon weakens, keeps Philippines on edge
SIP: Bartending trend calls for nice ice, baby
Pipeline falls on train in India killing 2
Cambodian leader offers Thaksin adviser's job
NY teen's hidden camera catches adult locker thief
Foreign minister: US base should stay on Okinawa
Bill OK'd to increase blacks at Coast Guard school
Pipeline falls on train in India killing 1
'Distracted' US pilots fly plane off-course
Rebels free Indian officer after Maoists released
Health care issues: Do doctors back health revamp
Dems scrambling for support for public health plan
Amazon Adds 25 Points On Surprise Earning Hike
McCain's Mother Hospitalized
Public Option Allowing States To Opt Out Gains Ground In Congress
Submarine Headed To U.S. Seized With 10 Tons Of Cocaine Off Guatemalan Coast
Existing Home Sales Reach Highest Level In Two Years
Victims Of Domestic Violence In Illinois Call For Reform Due To Large Number Of Unserved Protection Orders
Federal Treasury Official Says Over $600 Million Of Credit For First-Time Home Buyers Are Suspicious
'Distracted' Pilots Forget To Land Plane
American Medics, Patients Hit Short Supply Of H1N1 Vaccine
Jet Drops Bomb At Utah Air Force Base Before Emergency Landing
Malaysia slashes spending in 2010 budget
Japan post office should boost rural economy: minister
General Motors pumps funds into South Korean unit
Indians go on gold-buying blitz: industry body
China Construction Bank 3Q net profit up 18.6 pct
China formally launches Nasdaq-style board
Pakistani stocks end flat; rupee firms
US safety chief seeks China's help on drywall
Taylor Swift first U.S. tour dates sell in minutes
| Entertainment
|
Simpson-Wentz, Egglesfield out at 'Melrose Place'
Lawmaker in Travolta mistrial mess blames rumor
| Entertainment
|
Vertical Horizon reforms band after 5-year break
World's biggest band adapts to changing times
Strong 6.0-magnitude quake hits Indonesia
Agents detail prescription record in Smith hearing
Iran to respond to UN nuclear proposal next week
New German coalition gets set for government
Icahn resigns from board
Asian leaders press free trade at talks
| International
|
Europe swine flu spreads, 'millions' infected in US
Merkel seals coalition deal
| International
|
Israel warns against U.N. council seeing Gaza report
Facebook revamps home page feed
New hope for EU treaty as Klaus accepts concession
Icahn resigns from board
Iraqi cleric's aide warns of chaos if vote delayed
Sarkozy slander trial ends after clash of titans
More evacuations as Puerto Rico oil blaze burns on
| International
|
Busy U.S. cell networks a bonanza for gear makers
US formally asks for Polanski extradition: Swiss authorities
Ukraine party selects favourite for presidential vote
Sarkozy slander trial ends, verdict due January 28
Chances growing Japan may sign off on U.S. base-media
| International
|
Microsoft beats expectations to cap off big week
Czech Republic's Klaus warms to EU treaty compromise
Abbas calls Palestinian elections for January 24
Iran ignores U.N. nuclear deadline
Italy's intelligences services launch website
NATO backs new Afghan strategy but no new troop offers
New from NASA, an iPhone application
Honduras crisis back to square one as talks fail
| International
|
Sony looks for box office hit with "This Is It"
Court document ties Young to Alaska corruption
NYC mayor breaks spending record with $85.2M
Pilots missed Twin Cities by 150 miles
Busy U.S. cell networks a bonanza for gear makers
| Technology
|
Hawaii regulators approve first US tuna farm
US probes pilots who overshot airport by 150 miles
Activists deride new ASEAN rights commission
Former NYC top cop getting quick hearing of appeal
3 bombs hit Pakistan in a day, killing 24
Cabinet members make many Nevada stops for Reid
Obama administration's foreign aid job left open
Maine gay marriage supporters lead in funding
Ala. city summons sex offenders on Halloween night
Japan to say U.S. relevant to Asia grouping idea
Japan govt coalition partner rejects US base proposal
US freezes assets of N.Korean bank
Three men killed, one woman wounded in Thai south
Cambodia and Thailand clash at summit over Thaksin
Japan FM: US base should stay on Okinawa
Mom gives birth on board airplane over Malaysia
Power unit shut at S.Korea nuclear plant
WTO to rule on China-EU metal fasteners dispute
China-Biotics CFO resigns to purse other interests
Justin Timberlake gets stay away order against woman
| Entertainment
|
Hip-hop band the Roots branch out on nightly TV
| Entertainment
|
Rapper Kanye West cleared in airport scuffle
| Entertainment
|
Sony looks for box office hit with This Is It
| Entertainment
|
Hip-hop band the Roots branch out on nightly TV
Billboard singles reviews: Norah Jones, Timbaland
| Entertainment
|
Michelle Obama's gripe: President's tennis game
Carly Simon has "good time" revisiting old songs
Billboard CD reviews: Air, Devendra Banhart
| Entertainment
|
Billboard CD reviews: Air, Devendra Banhart
Billboard singles reviews: Norah Jones, Timbaland
Justin Timberlake gets stay away order against woman
CORRECTED: Rapper Kanye West cleared in airport scuffle
Tiff over White House camera crew and Fox
Warhol portrait of Michael Jackson up for auction
Investigator: Smith had multiple sources for drugs
Judge, family members killed in Tehran
New German govt to cut taxes
US-TECH Summary
Pakistan troops retake Taliban stronghold in Waziristan
| International
|
Abbas insists on January date for Palestinian vote
| International
|
Lenovo expects big PC sales boost from Windows 7
Taliban threat to scupper Afghan run-off vote
Indonesia lifts tsunami alert after powerful quake
| International
|
Poll boost for British far-right after TV first
Palestinian PM sees state structure ready by 2011
Taliban threaten Afghan run-off vote
| International
|
Iran hardline lawmakers carp nuclear fuel deal
| International
|
Robert Mugabe refuses to budge over cabinet boycott
| International
|
Australia PM raises Rio case with China
| International
|
Obama: Time for big banks to help small businesses
Bank failures hit 106 for year; many more are weak
NJ priest slain in church rectory is mourned
LA officials to unveil $437M police headquarters
Army captures Pakistani Taliban leader's hometown
US mulls direct talks as NKorea envoy visits
Malaysia baby born on plane to go home healthy
Canada hits out at EU over visa spat
Asian nations look to 'lead world'
Japan calls on India to make climate commitment
SKorea: Summit should help resolve nuclear dispute
Pakistan army takes Taliban chief's hometown: sources
Sri Lanka faces fuel shortage in oil union protest
Taliban call for Afghans to boycott runoff poll
Malaysian native leader detained over anti-logging
Australians kick off world climate change protest
Lenovo expects big PC sales boost from Windows 7
| Technology
|
ASEAN to study free trade pact: officials
Pakistani C.Bank buys 110.8 bln rupees of govt paper
Japanese firms to develop small nuclear reactors
Teen Girl With No Memory Seeks Identity In New York City
U.S. Has Short Supply Of H1N1 Vaccine
Mexican Cartel Boss Pleads Guilty In U.S. Court
U.S. Air Strike Targets Militants In Pakistan
Environmental Group Says Half Of America's Rivers, Lakes Considered Too Polluted With Toxins For Swimming
U.S. Markets End Friday With Loss After Week Of Gains
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights