Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
European court rules Google's ad model is legal
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (0)
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
Florida says several states to file healthcare lawsuit
22 Mar 2010
Republicans target Democrats on US healthcare reform
22 Mar 2010
Republicans target Democrats on healthcare reform
7:31am EDT
FACTBOX-US healthcare bill would provide immediate benefits
19 Mar 2010
Cracks in Great Chinese Firewall, even without Google
5:26am EDT
FACTBOX-US healthcare bill would provide immediate benefits
19 Mar 2010
Florida says several states to file healthcare lawsuit
22 Mar 2010
Super-sizing the "Last Supper"
6:33am EDT
UPDATE 1-Virginia to sue U.S. over healthcare reform
22 Mar 2010
UPDATE 2-Venezuela punishes 80 firms for power use
21 Mar 2010
Google vs China
Remaining Google units exposed to angry Beijing
Google's gambit in pulling the plug on its flagship search engine in China leaves its remaining operations there exposed to the whimsy of Beijing, whose initial reaction is far from reassuring. Full Article | Video
Cracks in Great Chinese Firewall, even without Google
What's next for Google's China workers?
Text of Chinese official comments on Google
Factbox: Google's footprint in China
Timeline: Google's bumpy foray into China
European court rules Google's ad model is legal
Michele Sinner and Georgina Prodhan
LUXEMBOURG/LONDON
Tue Mar 23, 2010 10:44am EDT
Related News
UPDATE 3-European court rules Google's ad model is legal
10:33am EDT
European court rules Google's ad model is legal
8:06am EDT
RPT-PREVIEW-Google adword win in Europe wouldn't end battles
Fri, Mar 19 2010
PREVIEW-Google adword win in Europe wouldn't end battles
Thu, Mar 18 2010
LUXEMBOURG/LONDON (Reuters) - Europe's highest court ruled Google Inc did not infringe trademark law by selling keywords to trigger ads after Louis Vuitton and others said the practice undermined their brands.
Technology | Media
The Court of Justice of the European Union said on Tuesday advertisers were free to buy keywords identical to trademarks of rivals as long as consumers were not confused on the provenance of goods and services by the way ads were displayed online.
The court said that in cases where ads could confuse consumers, brand owners should invoke their rights against the advertisers concerned, not against Google -- unless Google failed to act on a complaint or actively manipulated keywords.
The ruling validates the AdWords paid-search business at the core of Google's $23 billion online advertising operations, as well as the way competitors like Yahoo! Inc sell ads, and gives brand owners a way to protect their trademarks.
"It's a good decision in large parts," said Fabian Ziegenaus, an intellectual property lawyer at Linklaters.
"It does not forbid Google per se to sell trademark keywords, so the business model is not at stake, and brand owners are also protected through the decision."
Advertisers often buy brand names of their competitors as keywords to trigger their own ads. Google says the practice is in the interests of consumers, who do not want their search results to be limited to a single brand.
Brand owners can also bid for their own brand names as keywords and the order in which sponsored links are displayed online is determined mainly through this auction process.
Google used to block advertisers from buying others' brand names as keywords but changed its policy in North America in 2004 and four years later extended that to Britain and Ireland.
It says it will honor valid complaints from brand owners and prevent their rivals from using a trademarked keyword in their ad text.
VICTORY CLAIMS
Both Google and LVMH, the world's biggest luxury-goods group, claimed the court's decision as a victory.
"Trademarks ... are key for companies to market and advertise their products and services. But trademark rights are not absolute," wrote Google's senior litigation counsel for Europe, Harjinder S. Obhi (googlepolicyeurope.blogspot.com).
"We believe that user interest is best served by maximizing the choice of keywords, ensuring relevant and informative advertising for a wide variety of different contexts."
LVMH Vice Chairman Pierre Gode told Reuters: "We are very happy with the decision. We consider the decision is very important as the liability of advertisers is well established."
LVMH shares rose 0.88 percent to 87.57 euros by 1431 GMT.
The ruling will, however, make it more complicated for brand owners to pursue legal complaints, as they will have to go after advertisers one by one.
"It's a bit of a disappointment for the brand owners because they're going to have to police their brand in a more active way than they'd have to do if it were just Google they had to deal with," said John Mackenzie, partner at law firm Pinsent Masons.
The summary of the court judgment did not explicitly address the issue of counterfeit goods, but it did offer more clarity than expected on the misuse of trademarks in search results displayed to consumers.
"If the trademarks are actually used in the results that are shown to users and the advertiser does not own the trademark, that is likely to be deemed infringement," said Thomas Vinje, a partner at Clifford Chance specializingin European Union and intellectual property (IP) law.
"That would seem to defeat counterfeiters ... that would be to the advantage of the trademark owners," he said.
The European Brands Association, which represents 1,800 brand companies in 22 countries, said: "By confirming trademark rights online and holding sellers of keywords liable for illicit material, such as counterfeits, this ruling seems positive."
The court said the matter of whether consumers were likely to be confused by the way search results were displayed was a matter for national European courts to decide case by case. The LVMH case, for example, will now go back to France's top court.
LVMH scored a victory last month when a Paris tribunal found eBay Inc guilty of misleading consumers by using misspelt versions of its brand as search engine keywords to redirect users to eBay website links.
National courts guided by the principles in Tuesday's ruling will also have to decide whether in fact Google, eBay and others are as passive as they appear to be in the administration of their automated services.
If they are found to take a more active role, they will not be exempt from liability. "There are potential traps here for Google and eBay and all other Internet providers," said Nicola Dagg, head of IP for law firm Allen & Overy in London.
Several cases brought by brand owners are pending against advertisers at the ECJ, the first of which will be ruled on this week. Google also faces eight cases in the United States over the sale of trademarked keywords.
(Additional reporting by Foo Yun Chee in Brussels; Editing by Dale Hudson and David Holmes and Sharon Lindores)
Technology
Media
Add a Comment
More from Reuters
Obama to sign healthcare overhaul into law
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - President Barack Obama will sign into law on Tuesday landmark healthcare legislation, a hard-fought victory that will help shape his legacy and the Democrats' chances of holding power in Congress. | Video
Home sales dip, credit-related surge eyed
Google risks China's ire with slap to censorship
| Video
Wall Street edges up after home sales data
| Video
Fed's Plosser: better rules needed to manage risk
Germany sets tough terms for EU help for Greece
| Video
» More Top News
Bracing for the healthcare hit
Companies still shaking off the sour economy will now deal with what some are calling a "tax bill wrapped up in healthcare paper." Full Article | Video
What the bill means for small business
HMOs may hike premiums, slash jobs
Healthcare overhaul: The good news
Healthcare Reform
No Facebook? There's still porn
People outside China who have read about Internet censorship often imagine online life there is bleak and boring. The reality is very different. Full Article
Google risks Beijing's ire
Google units exposed to angry Beijing
Timeline: Google moves to Hong Kong
What's next for China Google workers?
Google
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts
Venture Capital Journal
International Financing Review
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Tuesday, 23 March 2010 Top Turkish judges attack Erdogan's planned reforms
Pressured Sarkozy to reshuffle government after vote disaster
US-TECH Summary
U.S. holds firm against Israel settlement policy
Foundem confident of EU formal probe into Google
UN wildlife body rejects bids to reopen ivory trade
Europe split amid rising Greek anger
Middle East envoy urges calm after settlement row
Ugandan rebels kill 10 and kidnap dozens in CAR
|
Activists launch anti oil-sands online game
Karzai holds peace meeting with militant group
Trout Season Set To Begin Throughout Country
BA strike sparks business warning, political row
EBay, NRF to take on organized retail crime
Website Aims To Put More Money In Taxpayers' Pockets
Starz Announces New "Camelot" Series For 2011
A judge may google to confirm intuition: court
E-Trade Taps Freiberg As CEO, Proposes Reverse Stock Split
Elephant trade ban reaffirmed for Tanzania, Zambia
|
Finnish high tech exports fall 45 pct in 2009: customs
Rapper T.I. Sued Over His Akoo Clothing Line
Tim Berners-Lee to head new institute of web science
Magnitude 5.9 quake hits Philippines
|
Suspected Rabid Fox Bites 4 People, 1 Dog
AT&T to sell Palm smartphones
Showtime Offers Free Preview Weekend To Over 50 Million Homes
AT&T to sell Palm smartphones
New Study Shows Plus-Size Models In Ads Unlikely To Work
Clinton, Bush join forces in Haiti
Nestlé Under Fire For "Censorship" Of Online Protest Against Palm Oil-Related Deforestation
Obama's healthcare overhaul faces new hurdles
Aziz Ansari To Host MTV Movie Awards, Announces New Tour Dates
US warns of possible Al-Qaeda attacks near Yemen
China's sandstorms blast Beijing with dust, sand
Typhoid, cholera feared in cyclone-hit Fiji
White House all-a-Twitter in historic healthcare vote
|
Thai 'Red Shirts' vow to shut down Bangkok with new rally
EBay, NRF to take on organized retail crime
|
Senators form Internet freedom caucus
|
Kidnapping reflects fears of Pakistan minorities
Connecticut bill would lessen teen sexting charge
|
China, South Korea sweep Asian film awards
A judge may google to confirm intuition: court
|
Pakistan police: Plot foiled on hotels, diplomats
TV and Internet use together growing
|
Pakistan foils plot to bomb Western targets
Activists unveil anti oil-sands game
|
German firm to build SE Asia's top commercial solar park
Sri Lankan protesters against Akon throw stones
India's Tata Motors invests in Myanmar
Boy George considers Culture Club reunion
Roadside bomb kills 1 in southwest Pakistan
Rio Tinto exec admits to some bribery charges
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
North Korea to put US citizen on trial
EU ups pressure on Merkel to aid Greece
Rio Tinto officials plead guilty to China bribery
Wagner's grandson dies at age 90
Okay to be gay in Malaysian films, if character repents
Pamphlet tells Brazil slum dwellers how to deal with police
Sri Lankan protesters against Akon throw stones
A list of winners at the 4th Asian Film Awards
Fans flock to Texas SXSW festival in record numbers
|
Miley Cyrus mentors American Idol singers
|
Craig Ferguson sees Conan debacle as wake-up call
|
Wagner's grandson dies at age 90
|
New York museum adds @ symbol to design collection
|
TV and Internet use together growing
|
Israeli soldier killed in "friendly fire" near Gaza
British ex-ministers suspended in lobbying row
Netanyahu in U.S.: Jerusalem not a settlement
|
Karzai holds peace meeting with militant group
Sprint, Radioshack ex-CEOs go into phone recycling
EU ministers vow to act against Iranian media censorship
British Airways counts cost of strike, fears new action
Football dominated cybersquatting complaints in 2009: WIPO
Rio staff face secrets charge after admitting bribes
|
Gates, Toshiba team up for nuclear reactor: report
Australia's Rudd kicks off re-election bid
|
Interpol launches G8 'most wanted' child sex offender site
Mariah Carey's Next Album Reportedly Canceled
Billboard Error An Embarrassment To Florida Career College
At Least 11 States Have Plans To Sue Over Constitutionality Of New Health Care Reform Bill
Israeli soldier killed in friendly fire near Gaza
|
Google Routes China Traffic To Hong Kong Site
Japan government to face big fund shortage in 2011/12: Nikkei
|
Supreme Court Declines to Block Chinese Muslim Transfers From Guantanamo
United Nations Secretary-General Ban Calls For Better Protection Of Water Resources
Ice cream sales a lifeline for Haitians in Caracas
|
U.S. Markets Rally On Gains In Heatlhcare Sector
Williams-Sonoma Q4 Profit Grows On Sales Strength, Announces Dividend Hike
Auschwitz attic trove names 'Angel of Death': historian
Google lifts censorship of Chinese search engine
Netanyahu, Clinton show no sign Israeli-US gap narrowed
U.S. judge orders release of Guantanamo detainee
Obama to sign health bill Tuesday
Connecticut bill would lessen teen "sexting" charge
Google risks China's ire with slap to censorship
|
New NY Times video program features inside look at newspaper
Senators form Internet freedom caucus
Sprint, Radioshack ex-CEOs go into phone recycling
|
Gates, Toshiba team up for nuclear reactor: report
|
US man held in N.Korea deeply religious: colleagues
Owner Postpones Auction For "Sex" Website
'Monster parents' plague Japan's schools
Bill Gates, Toshiba in early talks on nuclear reactor
Discovery's "Life" outperforms "Planet Earth"
NZ dollar seeks direction; debt flat
Sunday's "Breaking Bad" most-watched ever
Honda sees India, Southeast Asia boosting sales
Sarah Palin near deal for reality show
|
Nissan eyes green tie-up with Daimler: report
Nepal orders 3 Tibetans jailed for protest freed
TV and Internet use together growing
Seoul shares up on builders; Kumho Tire falls
Craig Ferguson sees Conan debacle as "wake-up call"
Anger over Taiwan's failure to intercept Russian plane
Sunday's Breaking Bad most-watched ever
|
New Zealand growth pace to pick up
Perez Hilton announces music countdown radio show
|
Seoul shares open higher on autos, techs
Google stops China censorship, Beijing condemns move
Discovery's Life outperforms Planet Earth
|
Rio staff face secrets charge after admitting bribes
Pakistani army chief in talks with US defense chiefs
Campaigns start in Malaysia Chinese party election
China media accuse Google of violating promises
Israeli settlements an economic choice, says study
Britain expels Israeli diplomat over passports
|
Ex-SS assassin given life sentence in Germany
Cracks in Great Chinese Firewall, even without Google
Britain to expel Israeli diplomat: media
Thailand extends security law for protests
|
DRAM market upturn to last three years: research
Sarkozy faces strikes after election drubbing
Iraq's divided vote may deepen Kirkuk dispute
Maoists bomb railway in India, derail high-speed train
|
Turner Sports to offer tech package for NBA game
Skype questions Egypt ban on mobile Internet calls
Iraq's two main Shi'ite blocs discuss merger
|
New abuse charges against Catholic clergy in Germany
|
German court gives ex-Nazi life for Dutch killings
|
Venezuela arrests Chavez critic for conspiracy
|
Detained Suu Kyi says would snub Myanmar polls
|
Greece wants European solution to debt crisis
|
Opera applies for its browser to get iPhone access
Obama to sign health plan as fight shifts to Senate
Fire in multistory building in India injures 18
Man stabs, kills 8 children at Chinese school
Top US officials head to Mexico as violence escalates
Army dominates Pakistan agenda for U.S. talks
Japan Democrats' No. 2 moves to defuse criticism
Chinese doctor hacks eight schoolchildren to death
Communist former rebel leader found dead in India
Google risks China's ire
Chaos as freak storm batters Australia's Perth
Indian military to weaponize world's hottest chili
UN envoy backs talks with Afghan militants
Ewan McGregor Joins Madonna's Upcoming Film Cast
Family Releases Photos Of Beaten Deerfield Beach Middle School Girl
Veteran Skydiver Dies After Rough Landing
Missouri, Illinois Men Charged With Dog Fighting
Toyota Warned Of Electronic Issues In '02
Discovery's "Life" outperforms "Planet Earth"
Walnuts May Protect Against Prostate Cancer
Substituting Polyunsaturated Fat May Reduce Heart Health Risk More Than Cutting Bad Fat
Diane Sawyer To Host Peabody Awards Ceremony
Director Michael Bay Adds New Cast Members To "Transformers 3"
Sixth Season Of "Weeds," Three New Series To Premiere On Showtime
Cracks in Great Chinese Firewall, even without Google
|
Nintendo to launch 3D-capable DS in 2010/11
|
European court rules Google's ad model is legal
|
Bollywood's Bachchan rules out retirement
Japan life insurer raising $11 billion from IPO
Indian star says he enjoys actor-filled family
Sarah Palin near deal for reality show
Google's action angers China, divides Web users
DRAM market upturn to last three years: research
|
Shell, PetroChina to develop natural gas field in China
India launches ultra-luxury Maharaja train service
Turner Sports to offer tech package for NBA game
|
High-level China, US talks set for late May
Smartphones not enough for carriers at CTIA
|
China's Geely expects Volvo deal by month's end
Perez Hilton announces music countdown radio show
India must double infrastructure spending: PM
Hong Kong's Sun Yat Sen film falls short at Asian awards
Shell, PetroChina set gas exploration deal
S.Korea bond prices tumble on policy remarks
Fans flock to SXSW festival in record numbers
|
S.Korea govt official says time to talk about exit
Japan's Dai-ichi Mutual Life IPO to be biggest since Visa
TV and Internet use together growing
|
Fans flock to SXSW festival in record numbers
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights