Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
AT&T takes issue with antitrust criticism
| Technology
|
My Profile
Top News
Reuters top ten news stories delivered to your inbox each day.
Subscribe
You are here:
Home
>
News
>
Technology
>
Article
Home
Business & Finance
News
U.S.
Politics
International
Technology
Internet
Entertainment
Sports
Lifestyle
Oddly Enough
Health
Science
Special Coverage
Video
Pictures
Your View
The Great Debate
Blogs
Weather
Reader Feedback
Do More With Reuters
RSS
Widgets
Mobile
Podcasts
Newsletters
Your View
Make Reuters My Homepage
Partner Services
CareerBuilder
Affiliate Network
Professional Products
Support (Customer Zone)
Reuters Media
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
AT&T takes issue with antitrust criticism
Wed Jul 8, 2009 6:14pm EDT
Email | Print |
Share
| Reprints | Single Page
[-]
Text
[+]
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Telecommunications giant AT&T struck back on Wednesday at Sen. Herb Kohl, chair of a congressional antitrust panel, saying the lawmaker's concerns about a lack of competition in the wireless industry were unfounded.
Kohl wrote to the Justice Department's top antitrust regulator Christine Varney and Federal Communications Commission Chairman Julius Genachowski on Monday to reiterate concerns over texting prices, large carriers failing to cooperate with smaller carriers to resolve roaming disputes, disputes over spectrum and deals that give one or another carrier exclusive access to popular phones like the iPhone.
AT&T argued that cell service had become progressively cheaper, with revenue per minute falling 89 percent since 1994.
"U.S. wireless prices are much lower than in any other major industrialized country," wrote James Cicconi, an AT&T senior executive vice president.
Cicconi argued that texting prices had fallen because of package deals, "dropping almost 70 percent since January 2007," and asserted that the pay-per-use price cited by Kohl represented less than 1 percent of AT&T's customers.
Cicconi also argued that exclusive handset arrangements allowed a carrier and a manufacturer to split the high cost of marketing "an inventive but unproven new device." Kohl had called the deals "a serious barrier to competition."
"I think AT&T is right on the handset exclusivity," said Orrick antitrust expert David Smutny, who argued that telecommunications firms were vying to help manufacturers to come up with the new cool phone -- the iPhone killer -- in order to compete with the AT&T/Apple alliance.
"What AT&T cares about is getting people to sign up for its service and what Apple cares about is getting people to get its cool phone. That's pretty pro-consumer," he said.
Cicconi said that AT&T complied with FCC regulations, which required it to allow other companies' customers to roam to get voice service but not data, which means that they may not get email or Internet service on their phones if they are out of their servers' area.
AT&T also defended early termination fees as a way for the company to recoup money spent discounting handsets.
Overall, Orrick's Smutny said he failed to see significant antitrust issues in the wireless industry.
"Most people are served by at least three and sometimes five or six wireless carriers," he said. "On the specific issues that Sen. Kohl raises, I think that AT&T has the better of the argument."
(Reporting by Diane Bartz)
© Thomson Reuters 2009 All rights reserved
Share:
Del.icio.us
Digg
Mixx
Yahoo!
Facebook
LinkedIn
Next Article:
More web attacks likely, North Korea suspected
also on reuters
Blog: From illegal landfill to natural urban oasis
News Corp and CBS in the spotlight at Sun Valley
Video
Video: UK scientists create sperm in lab
More Technology News
News Corp won't buy Twitter, won't sell MySpace
| Video
Google takes aim at Microsoft with new PC platform
| Video
Apps a nail in coffin of broadcast mobile TV
Mobile entertainment seeking players and payment
Amazon cuts Kindle price to $299
More Technology News...
Editor's Choice
Slideshow
A selection of our best photos from the past 24 hours. Slideshow
Most Popular on Reuters
Articles
Video
UPDATE 1-Gaultier and Valentino appeal to crisis spirit
Michael Jackson's family silent on burial plans | Video
U.S. mortgage fraud 'rampant' and growing-FBI
UPDATE 1-More web attacks likely, North Korea suspected
ANALYSIS-Google-Microsoft war may bring down PC prices
After Honduras coup outburst, Chavez works in wings
Apps a nail in coffin of broadcast mobile TV
Cyber attacks may not have come from North Korea
China flexes muscles in strife-torn Xinjiang | Video
China confirms Rio Tinto staff arrests
Most Popular Articles RSS Feed
Video
Ghana awaits Obama with high hopes
Jackson memorial breaks records
Troops control China's trouble spot
Battle for control in Afghanistan
UK scientists create sperm in lab
Jackson fans mourn around the world
Fresh unrest in Chinese Uighur city
Jackson burial site unknown
Another economic stimulus?
China tightens security in Xinjiang
Most Popular Videos RSS Feed
We want to hear from you
Join the Reuters Consumer Insight Panel and help us get to know you better
Please take a moment to complete our survey
Reuters.com:
Help and Contact Us |
Advertise With Us |
Mobile |
Newsletters |
RSS |
Labs |
Archive |
Site Index |
Video Index
Thomson Reuters Corporate:
Copyright |
Disclaimer |
Privacy |
Professional Products |
Professional Products Support |
About Thomson Reuters |
Careers
International Editions:
Africa |
Arabic |
Argentina |
Brazil |
Canada |
China |
France |
Germany |
India |
Italy |
Japan |
Latin America |
Mexico |
Russia |
Spain |
United Kingdom |
United States
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Thursday, 9 July 2009 Clinton sees more Iran sanctions if outreach fails
Spain's Sacyr wins bid to expand Panama Canal: official
IMF projects stronger 2010 recovery
Army feeble as murders surge in Mexico drug war city
| International
|
Two car bombs kill 14 people in northern Iraq
| International
|
One death penalty in first Saudi terror trials
| International
|
Mobs roam China's restive Urumqi
US missiles kill up to 48 in Pakistan Taliban hub: officials
West Japan Railway chief indicted over train disaster
Taiwan's opposition boycotts China forum
News Corp won't buy Twitter, won't sell MySpace
| Technology
|
Philippines, rebels may resume talks next month
Watchdog: FEMA still lacks housing plan
Mobile entertainment seeking players and payment
| Technology
|
Overnight downpour fails to fix Mumbai water woes
Thorny thief snips 100 rose blooms from Maine park
Violent protests in Indian Kashmir capital, '50 hurt'
Amazon cuts Kindle price to $299
| Technology
|
14 US personnel treated for swine flu
Ex-defense contractor exec wants to plead guilty
Government Web sites attacked; NKorea suspected
Judge denies motion to fast-track GM sale appeal
Report: Probe found weaknesses in federal security
Important to talk to Iran, NKorea: Obama
Presidential records a time capsule of Bush years
McNair Girlfriend Felt Life "Spinning Out Of Control"
Senate hearing focuses on threats to wildlife
Blind Sailors Race In Boston Harbor
Medical First: 4 Hospitals, 8 Kidneys, 16 Surgeries
Google Developing New PC Operating System
Massachusetts Sues Over Federal Same-Sex Marriage Law
Biden: Hospitals To Give $155 Billion In Savings To Help Healthcare Overhaul
Poll Finds New York City Voters Favor Mayor Bloomberg, But Want Change
Richard Gere: Dog is hero in film about Japan tale
Test Reveals Security Breaches In Government Buildings; Bombs Smuggled Undetected
G8 spies economic danger signs as summit begins
Illegal Mexican Immigrants Sentenced For Abduction Of Fellow Drug Dealer
San Miguel takes stake in Philippines telecom outfit
SKorea, EU in final consultation on FTA: official
Ericsson inks $1.7 bln deals with Chinese firms
IMF raises Asia 2009 growth forecast
China says June bank lending doubles from May
Official: NKorea believed behind cyber attacks
Indonesia's Yudhoyono wins second term
40 years on, Paris shows 'A Man On the Moon'
In Jackson memorial, a new child star born?
U.S. Olympic Committee to launch TV network in 2010
| Entertainment
|
France begins hearings on banning the burka
Adelson says Singapore casino opening delayed
Indonesians vote calmly in presidential election
Sons of Taliban drug addict show Pakistan challenges
Payoff ends custody battle over Knut the bear
Real recruits seen drawing more Asian tourists to Spain
First individual Chinese tourists visit Japan
Aussie among three hurt in Pamplona running of the bulls
Malaysia drops English for math, science classes
La Toya Jackson scene cut from 'Bruno'
French Senate adopts rejigged Internet piracy bill
US general cites shortage of Afghan forces
Air France pilot union attacks safety bodies over Brazil crash
China flexes muscles in strife-torn Xinjiang
| International
|
South Korea, U.S. Web sites down for 3rd day on attack
GM could exit bankruptcy very soon
UN: Rape, sexual violence growing in Afghanistan
Honduras rivals to talk, but no sign of concessions
| International
|
Sharp to raise LCD panel output capacity
Eight killed in Russian Caucasus violence: reports
IMF projects stronger 2010 recovery from global recession
Bombings kill at least 41 in Iraq
| International
|
Two car bombs kill 14 people in northern Iraq
Blast outside school in Afghanistan kills 15
| International
|
Ireland to vote again on EU's Lisbon Treaty on Oct 2
Apps a nail in coffin of broadcast mobile TV
Twin car bombs kill 12 in Iraq
Iran won't back down one step in atom row
| International
|
Easter Island drug makes Methuselah mice
Data Domain accepts EMC takeover bid
Iraq car bombs kill 16
U.S. denies Israeli report of deal on settlements
CORRECTED: Amazon cuts Kindle price to $299
G8 sets Iran deadline for nuclear talks
| International
|
AT&T takes issue with antitrust criticism
Clerical discontent challenges Iran leader
Air France chief says reaction to crash was timely
| International
|
Amazon cuts Kindle price to 299 dollars
Colombia's Uribe backs hostage mediation
| International
|
UN: Israel must tear down West Bank barrier
U.N. rights experts stress Iran concerns, seek visit
Times Co. extends deadline for Boston Globe bids
Mobile entertainment seeking players and payment
Iraq group calls for further attacks on U.S. troops
Taiwan's women split over prostitution issue
News Corp won't buy Twitter, won't sell MySpace
| Technology
|
China flexes muscles in strife-torn Xinjiang
Google takes aim at Microsoft with new PC platform
| Technology
|
Rogers patient as Tour de France heads into Stage 6
Apps a nail in coffin of broadcast mobile TV
| Technology
|
Evans down, but not out at Tour de France
Firefighters Battling Brush Fire Near World Famous Getty Center Art Complex
Portland, Ore., street renamed Cesar Chavez Blvd.
Reports Find Bottled Water Less Tested Than Tap Water
AT&T takes issue with antitrust criticism
| Technology
|
Retiring US commander predicts easy Karzai win
1st Americans killed in Vietnam War are honored
US officials eye North Korea in cyber attack
Australian executive held on spy charge in China
More web attacks likely, North Korea suspected
| Technology
|
Schumer: Immigration bill to be ready by Labor Day
PROMISES, PROMISES: Politics shadow Obama's pledge
China tries new openness with foreign media
Sharp to raise LCD panel output capacity
| Technology
|
NKorea's Kim pays homage to late father in televised tribute
Obama names gene guru Francis Collins NIH chief
Anxiety over economic recovery weighs on stocks
Verdict reached in Jesse James Hollywood trial
Blagojevich aide pleads guilty in corruption case
Paris Hilton film trial rooted in Ponzi scheme
South Korea c.bank holds rates steady for 5th month
Taiwan dlr off 2-mth closing low as stocks rise
HIGHLIGHTS-South Korean central bank chief's comments
S.Korean T-bond futures jump ahead of rate vote
High school comedy "Beth Cooper" flunks out
Jackson doctor denies drug link after tributes
Seoul shares slip as techs, autos retreat
Indonesian president on track for re-election
Obama inauguration audience trumped Jackson memorial
Indonesia's president: a crooner and a general
Australian executive held on spy charge in China
Up to 74 Afghan migrants missing off Indonesia
Michael Jackson's family silent on burial plans
| Entertainment
|
AP newsroom is a setting for Drew Barrymore film
Q&A: Reality honcho Burnett dives into Shark Tank
| Entertainment
|
LA seeks ways to pass on cost for Jackson memorial
Scooby-Doo director takes on Smurfs movie
| Entertainment
|
Nielsen: 30.9 million watched Jackson memorial
Hope Davis to play Hillary Clinton
| Entertainment
|
Kate Gosselin to attend California women's forum
Robin Williams lined up for HBO comedy special
Award turns blind Japan pianist into music sensation
| Entertainment
|
`Transformers' hits $300 million mark in 14 days
Paris Hilton film trial rooted in Ponzi scheme
Dole sues Bananas documentary maker
| Entertainment
|
High school comedy Beth Cooper flunks out
| Entertainment
|
Dan Brown moves to Washington for new thriller
| Entertainment
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights