Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Town on SF Bay wants to photograph every car
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Search
Search:
Town on SF Bay wants to photograph every car
By MICHELLE LOCKE,Associated Press Writer AP - Monday, July 20
TIBURON, Calif. - Visitors should be prepared to have their pictures taken as they enter and leave this picturesque town of million-dollar views and homes along the San Francisco Bay.
Officials want to photograph every car and use the license plate information to solve crimes in the town of 9,000. Critics see the plan as an intrusion into the rights of visitors, but proponents say it is a sensible precaution that absolutely will not cross privacy lines.
"As long as you don't arrive in a stolen vehicle or go on a crime spree while you're here, your anonymity will be preserved," said Town Manager Peggy Curran. "We don't care who you are and we don't know who you are."
Cameras are already watching Americans as they drive, bank and shop, and police around the country routinely use cameras to enforce speeding and traffic violations and spot stolen cars.
But Tiburon's plan may be a little different if only because its geography _ laid out on a narrow peninsula with only two roads in and out _ makes it possible to keep a close eye on everyone who comes to town.
Melissa Ngo, a privacy rights attorney and consultant who publishes privacylives.com, said she is not aware of a situation where a town is keeping a record of all visitors.
"The point is we live in a land where people are considered innocent until proven guilty," Ngo said. "Not a land where it's supposed to be _ prove that you're not doing anything wrong by letting us watch you do everything."
Curled on the edge of the San Francisco Bay in Marin County, Tiburon is not a high-crime spot. In 2008, police report there were 99 thefts, 20 burglaries and two auto thefts.
That was not a significant change from the year before. But police say with most of the crimes taking place at night, and suspects identified so far as out-of-towners with criminal records, they believe having the license plate information would be helpful in solving crimes.
The issue has prompted debate on the trade-off between private freedoms and public security.
Walking his dogs along Tiburon's stunning waterfront on a recent sunny morning, Bill McDougal, who lives in nearby Sausalito, was not enthusiastic about the license plate plan. "It's one more step to Big Brother," he said.
But Brooke Togmazzini, owner of a wine tasting room near the waterfront, said that while she initially had qualms about the system, she has become convinced there are enough safeguards in place to make it nothing more than a useful investigative tool.
"There isn't someone watching every car that comes in and out," she said.
Curran believes the proposal, expected to go before the Town Council for final approval within a few months, has been misunderstood.
If they go forward, officials intend to set clear limitations on how the license plate database can be used. For instance, they said the system will not be used for traffic enforcement, and the data will not be public record _ no trying to find out if a spouse has been wandering.
The way the system would work is still cameras set up at town entry points will take a photograph of license plates _ but not drivers. License plate numbers collected would be erased within 30 to 60 days and would not be viewed unless there is a crime to solve.
Officers would search for plates of vehicles in town at the time of the crime that are connected to someone with a criminal history. Any hits would be used as leads.
"There'd be just none of the real-time monitoring that people worry about or that we're somehow wanting to be unfriendly or discourage visitors in any way," Curran said.
Civil liberties groups have concerns about the data being collected on Americans.
A 2007 study by California affiliates of the American Civil Liberties Union of 131 jurisdictions found that 37 cities in the state had some type of video surveillance program and 18 cities had significant surveillance of public streets and plazas.
Lee Tien, senior staff attorney for the Electronic Frontier Foundation, appreciates Tiburon officials' efforts to limit the use of the license plate database.
But he is still not sold on the idea.
"The logic is always, well, wait a minute. If you keep pushing this, then that means we should track everyone just because some people might be bad guys. That's not the way I think America is supposed to be."
___
On the Net: http://www.ci.tiburon.ca.us/
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: World
3 rescued off NJ coast after fleeing burning boatAP - Monday, July 20
Mexico detains 10 in killings of federal agentsAP - Monday, July 20
Mormon 'kiss-in' in Utah leads to shouting matchAP - Monday, July 20
Town on SF Bay wants to photograph every carAP - Monday, July 20
Chances of OJ winning release? Depends who you askAP - Monday, July 20
Most Popular – World
Viewed
Shark attack victims fight for their attackers
Man who went to the moon and came back an artist
World's oldest man, British WWI veteran dies at 113
Talking toy 'translates' dog barks
Miniskirts, cleavage upset male SKoreans: survey
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Monday, 20 July 2009 Ahmadinejad criticized over vice president choice
Iran bails British embassy staffer
Iran hardliners criticize Ahmadinejad over deputy
Ahmadinejad's controversial VP pick quits: report
Time to talk to Taliban: Musharraf
Ahmadinejad's controversial VP pick resigns: report
Palestinian negotiator met Iranian FM: top official
Govs resist added federal expenses from Congress
SF train operator's actions come under scrutiny
Michael Jackson's boyhood home still draws curious
Friend: Slain woman, accused husband had split
Mormon 'kiss-in' in Utah leads to shouting match
3 rescued off NJ coast after fleeing burning boat
Town on SF Bay wants to photograph every car
Chances of OJ winning release? Depends who you ask
Palin: Alaska tour is thanks, not goodbye
Palin gears up to leave Alaska governor's mansion
Madonna visits family of dead Marseille stage hand
US-TECH Summary
Honduras crisis talks end in failure
| International
|
German's Merkel slams Swedish nuclear operator
British airlines blocking swine flu travellers
Fire destroys Anne Frank barracks in Netherlands
White House budget director expects better GDP figures
404 Not Found
Zuma names new chief for S.Africa's central bank
Fears for fate of French hostages in Somalia
Online music video site MUZU signs up global indies
| Technology
|
India takes firm line with Clinton on climate change
Myanmar detains dozens of opposition members
China says recent Urumqi unrest was premeditated
Rains kill 26 in Pakistan's biggest city
CORRECTED
Tiny Tuvalu says all its energy renewable by 2020
China says police killed 12 people in Urumqi unrest
NATO: Helicopter crash at Afghan base kills 16
Monsoon rain kills 16 in Pakistan: officials
AEG Live negotiates for Jackson documentary: report
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
AEG Live negotiates for Jackson documentary: report
Madonna visits victims of French stage accident
Thriller sales soar close to Eagles' Hits
| Entertainment
|
Online music video site MUZU signs up global indies
Online music video site MUZU signs up global indies
| Entertainment
|
Report: Abdul's return to 'American Idol' doubtful
Carla Bruni sings in NY at Mandela show
| Entertainment
|
AEG Live negotiates for Jackson documentary: report
| Entertainment
|
Pop collaborations take French DJ beyond clubs
Musicians' country gathering results in Glory
| Entertainment
|
"Thriller" sales soar close to Eagles' "Hits"
Musicians' country gathering results in "Glory"
"Harry Potter" smashes "Spider-Man" records
Carla Bruni sings in NY at Mandela show
Pop collaborations take French DJ beyond clubs
| Entertainment
|
USF Star Kicker Takes A Tumble Off Skyride At Busch Gardens
Father And Daughter Perish After Plunging From Waterfall
US review calls for overhaul of Bagram prison
CIT nearing three-billion-dollar rescue deal: report
Frank McCourt, of 'Angela's Ashes' fame, dead: NYT
Thousands flee western Canadian wildfires
| International
|
US marks 40 years since man stepped on the moon
NATO aircraft crashes in southern Afghanistan
| International
|
Japan opposition keeps lead ahead of poll: survey
| International
|
South Korea pushes to restart nuclear talks with North
| International
|
Indonesia TV identifies Jakarta hotel bombing suspect
| International
|
Economy, rights on agenda for ASEAN ministers
| International
|
Nicaragua's leftist president calls for re-election
| International
|
Swine flu in Vietnam forces school's closure
Pakistan: 4 police officers killed in ambush
Kids' lower IQ scores linked to prenatal pollution
STIMULUS WATCH: Neediest areas not first for money
1,000 flee homes after chemical leak in China
Report: Taiwan and China to set up tourism offices
Starting to get crowded in 100-year-olds' club
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
RNC chairman attacks Obama on health care
Microsoft deal talk, optimism overshadow results
| Technology
|
Forest fires force thousands to evacuate in Canada
Solar eclipse pits superstition against science
US envoy to discuss NKorea with Seoul officials
Abdul's return to 'Idol' reportedly doubtful
Apollo 11 astronauts look beyond moon, toward Mars
AP source: CIT board meeting Sunday night
Idaho town prays for return of captured US soldier
Japanese stock markets closed for national holiday
New Zealand services sector lower in June-survey
Seoul shares open higher on earnings momentum
NZ investor confidence lifts off lows in Q2-survey
Unseen Jackson U.K. footage on the way
'Angela's Ashes' author McCourt dies in NYC at 78
Unseen Jackson U.K. footage on the way
| Entertainment
|
USF Star Kicker Takes A Tumble Off Skyride At Busch Gardens
TN Man Arrested In Multiple Homicides Tied To Domestic Dispute
Jay-Z unveils latest Blueprint for success
| Entertainment
|
Iraq colonel: US troops now in 'prison-like bases'
Lost love letter reunites couple after 16 years
Ayatollah warns against helping Iran's enemies
| International
|
LL Cool J Quarantined During Mid-Air Flight Drama
Iceland announces relaunch of rescued banks
NATO jet crashes in Afghanistan, two hurt: military
Mumbai attacker in surprise guilty plea
| International
|
Japan PM set to call poll as party at risk of defeat
| International
|
'Afghans raise flag on highest peak'
U2 Pledges $7 Million To National Music Program For Young People
Afghans raise flag on country's highest peak
Pohoda Music Festival Storm Claims 1 Life, Injures 40
Iran supremo slams 'meddling', reformers eye referendum
404 Not Found
Iraq car bombing kills three
News Anchor Legend Walter Cronkite Dies At 92
Settlers torch West Bank trees: Palestinians
| International
|
"Angela's Ashes" Author Frank McCourt Dies At 78
Bomb kills 11 civilians in Afghanistan: officials
Saudi Government Cancels first Jeddah Film Festival
German police catch underwear thief
| International
|
Fifty-six more on trial in Turkish coup plot case
| International
|
Report: Taiwan and China exchange tourism offices
La. menagerie keeper adds 'roo pouch to outfits
Pakistan: 5 security officers killed in northwest
One dead, six wounded in Philippine blasts
Grenade blast wounds 7 in southern Philippine city
Obama takes on health care, meets Apollo 11 crew
China's drinking culture in spotlight: state media
Trial resumes for evangelist accused of sex crimes
SKorea deciding how to inspect suspicious NK ships
NKorea shows no signs on nuke talks: US envoy
EMC takes control of Data Domain
| Technology
|
Locally killed is latest trend in high grade meat
Clinton touts prospects for better ties with India
Miss. shows Katrina recovery at govs' convention
EU sets hearing over Google books deal
| Technology
|
Obama's approval rating drops below 60 pct
IT spending forecasts improve, Cisco popular: UBS
| Technology
|
Thailand's exports decline for eighth month
Clinton touts prospects for better ties with India
San Miguel toll road investment, eyes Dole Food
Seoul shares at 10-mth closing high; techs, banks up =2
Samsung Elec to invest $4.3 bln in green R&D
Chinese oil firms to 'buy stake in Angola block'
Aussie MasterChef hits out at 'fix' claims
Competition aims to make Bruce Lee home a museum
Cambodia set to award Total oil exploration rights
Seoul shares at 10-mth closing high;techs, banks up
1st funeral held for Jakarta bomb victims
Jakarta hotel suicide bomber identified: reports
Jay-Z unveils latest "Blueprint" for success
Pakistani c.bank buys 5.0 bln rupees of govt paper
Harry Potter smashes Spider-Man records
| Entertainment
|
Korea Hot Stocks
Madonna visits workers injured in French stage collapse
| Entertainment
|
Unfinished Greene novel serialized in magazine
| Entertainment
|
Antichrist director says outrage suits me fine
| Entertainment
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights