Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
COMMENTARY: Doubtful benefits of dual listings
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Australia
China
India
Indonesia
Japan
Malaysia
Philippines
Thailand
Vietnam
COMMENTARY: Doubtful benefits of dual listings
ANN - 2 hours 37 minutes ago
Send
IM Story
Print
Petaling Jaya (The Star/ANN) - Last week's announcement by Thailand's Total Access Communication Plc (TAC) that it gained little from a dual listing and intends to de-list from the Singapore Exchange has drawn attention to the perennial debate about this issue.
TAC, Thailand's second largest mobile operator and majority owned by Norway's Telenor AS, was listed in Singapore in 1995 but subsequently listed on the Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET) in 2007. Since its listing on SET, trading volumes of TAC shares in Singapore dropped to 1% of total shares last year.
TAC officials said since the company's principal business activities were in Thailand, it expected a large proportion of new investors to trade its shares on the SET.
This raises the question of whether Malaysia-based companies actually gain from dual listings.
"The strategy of dual listings no longer makes sense because capital markets have become more liquid and integrated and investors more global. The best market to list your company remains the country where your main operations are," said a research head from a local brokerage.
Malaysia Smelting Corp Bhd (MSC) opted to have a secondary listing on the Singapore Exchange.
The company said the move was "a catalyst for MSC to improve its presence amongst investors in the region (and) provides an avenue to increase the trading activity of MSC shares as well as to provide an alternative market for MSC to raise funds for its working capital purposes."
While this rationale runs counter to the theory that investments will flow to deserving companies no matter where they are listed, the fact remains that MSC raised an estimated RM100mil (US$32.7mil) from the secondary listing of 25 million new MSC shares in Singapore.
"The question is, couldn't MSC have done a fund-raising exercise in Malaysia via a rights issue and/or a placement of its shares to the same Singapore investors who bought the Singapore-listed MSC shares?" one market observer questioned.
A fund manager added that stocks listed in the Singapore stock exchange had generally higher liquidity than their peers here.
MSC's secondary listing in Singapore made it the sole Malaysian company which had a dual listing, after Tanjong plc (which was listed both on Bursa Malaysia and the London Stock Exchange) was taken private by tycoon T. Ananda Krishnan last year.
CIMB Group has started the process of a dual listing in Thailand and expressed interest in having a secondary listing on the Jakarta Stock Exchange.
AirAsia Bhd has also been reportedly seeking a dual listing on a mature market, such as the US or Hong Kong.
A 2008 study by McKinsey & Co revealed that companies from developed markets derived no benefit from second listings in foreign equity markets.
Among its findings was that the trading volumes of dual listed shares of European companies in the US stock market, typically accounted for less than 3% of these companies' total trading volumes.
It also stated that in an age when electronic trading provides easy access to foreign markets, the argument that foreign listings could give companies a broader shareholder base was no longer valid.
"A foreign listing is not even a condition, let alone a guarantee, for attracting foreign shareholders," the report said.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Japanese women sue to keep maiden names AFP - 33 minutes ago
Hong Kong rare whales plan riles activists AFP - 36 minutes ago
N. Korea proposes lawmaker talks with South AFP - 1 hour 5 minutes ago
Thousands in S. Korea help clear record snow AFP - 1 hour 10 minutes ago
Anwar trial restarts as questions grow over Malaysia opposition Reuters - 1 hour 13 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
EU, IMF seek to repair Greek rift after asset furore
Points, Murray win at Pebble Beach golf tournament
Boeing unveils latest 747
Europe set for landmark launch with robot freighter
Bono causes stir over S. African anti-apartheid song
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
US golfer Woods finds old habits hard to shake
Russia loses military satellite: reports
US auto sales jump 17 percent in January
Dow closes over 12,000 for first time since June 2008
Egypt's Mubarak to step down at September election
More Most Viewed »
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2011 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Monday, 14 February 2011 Maliki fills power, trade, other Iraq cabinet jobs
Swiss vote to keep army guns at home
US-TECH Summary
Clashes in Algeria as opposition plans new protest
Bono causes stir over S. African anti-apartheid song
EU, IMF seek to repair Greek rift over asset sale
Sony takes gaming console war to phones
Military rulers dissolve Egypt's parliament
Thousands of Italy's women rally against Berlusconi
Egypt military dismantles Mubarak regime
Samsung beats Apple to second tablet computer
Abbas' cabinet to resign on Monday: sources
|
Swiss vote to keep army-issued weapons at home
Egypt protesters call for Friday celebration march
Smartphone makers to woo developers in Barcelona
Algeria opposition says to hold weekly rallies
|
Nearly 1,000 Tunisians arrive in Italy overnight
Internet firms to refund users cut off in Egypt
Readers, bloggers sound off on Huff Post sale
Britain considering 'gay marriage' in churches
Iran pressures opposition ahead of planned rally
Maltese bulk carrier believed seized by pirates
|
Iran names attacked scientist nuclear chief
Wenders takes 3D to next dimension at Berlin fest
Venezuela's Chavez mocks foes' Egypt comparisons
|
Prized Pharaonic objects missing from Egypt Museum
US-TECH Summary
Egypt military rulers dissolve parliament: state TV
Samsung beats Apple to second tablet computer
Opposition protesters back on streets of Bangkok
BAFTAs 2011
Wenders takes 3D to next dimension at Berlin fest
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Movie fans catch Bieber fever at box offices
Samsung beats Apple to second tablet computer
|
Grown-up Londoners share their teenage angst
French animator brings 3D magic to Berlin festival
Eminem hoping to avoid another Grammys shocker
Flair lights up runways at NY Fashion Week
Sony takes gaming console war to phones
|
Stars glitter on red carpet at UK's BAFTA awards
|
Movie fans catch Bieber fever at box offices
|
Iran 'steadily' produces enriched uranium: IAEA head
23 fishermen missing in Russia: report
EU, IMF seek to repair Greek rift after asset furore
Crucial test looms for key Afghan battleground
Europe set for landmark launch with robot freighter
Points, Murray win at Pebble Beach golf tournament
Mother fails to find Swiss twins in Corsica
Boeing unveils latest 747
Army asserts command as Egypt drifts back to work
|
Gaddafi tells Palestinians: revolt against Israel
Italy appeals for EU aid as migrants flee Tunisia
Abbas's cabinet to resign on Monday: sources
|
Ouattara says may extend Ivorian cocoa export ban: report
|
Egypt cyber activist kissed soldiers on release
Japan's ruling party proposes suspending powerbroker Ozawa
|
Witness: Joy at Mubarak's demise contrasts with tense accession
|
Thousands in S. Korea help clear record snow
BAFTAs 2011
Colombia's FARC rebels free kidnapped policeman
|
Indonesia cleric defiant in face of terror charges
Italian women protest over Berlusconi sex scandal
|
At least 10 Chinese moles infiltrate Taiwan
Zynga talks may value it at up to $9 billion: report
Michael Jackson's dad in Vietnam 'Happyland' scheme
Nuance offers mobile users non-typing choices
Myanmar's Suu Kyi risks 'tragic end': state media
ZTE aims for 5-fold smartphone sales growth in 2011
Lady Antebellum wins song of the year Grammy
Smartphone makers woo developers at trade
R. Kelly's "Star Spangled Banner" Highlight of Clive Davis Event
Campaign vests are fashion disasters: Taiwanese blogger
Country trio Lady Antebellum leads Grammy winners
Nokia CEO sees billions from Microsoft deal
Tweet, don't text, telco tells lovers
Israel gears up to go electric
Smartphone makers woo developers at trade
|
COMMENTARY: Doubtful benefits of dual listings
News on first Nokia Windows Phone within days
Analysis: Telcos battle tech, banking titans in mobile payment
|
Serious, light moments in Pacquiao-Mosley presscon
Apple developing smaller, cheaper iPhones: report
Nokia CEO sees billions from Microsoft deal
|
COMMENTARY: World Cup fever yet to grip Indians
Linux group hopes to gain from Nokia-Microsoft pact
Grammys pays tribute to Aretha Franklin
Zynga talks may value it at up to $9 billion: report
|
Linux group hopes to gain from Nokia-Microsoft pact
|
Lady Gaga "hatches" from egg, sports pointy shoulders
Paul McCartney wins Grammy for "Helter Skelter"
ZTE aims for 5-fold smartphone sales growth in 2011
|
'Khodorkovsky' director wary of showing film in Russia
Nuance offers mobile users non-typing choices
|
Ukrainian group makes bare breasts political weapon
Venezuela's Chavez mocks foes' Egypt comparisons
Militia says Western spies concocting Iran revolt
Human chain in Dresden marks WWII bombing
Country trio Lady Antebellum leads Grammy winners
|
Linux group hopes to gain from Nokia-Microsoft pact
Lady Gaga hatches from egg, sports pointy shoulders
|
Pop idol Justin Bieber: No Grammys, no worries
|
Old and new stars come together Grammy awards show
|
Paul McCartney wins Grammy for Helter Skelter
|
Movie fans catch Bieber fever at box offices
|
R. Kelly's Star Spangled Banner Highlight of Clive Davis Event
|
US-TECH Summary
Nokia CEO sees billions from Microsoft deal
Sony takes console war to cellphones
News on first Nokia Windows Phone within days
Sony takes gaming console war to phones
Taiwan to let China firms invest in LCD firms
US hedge fund eyes China elderly housing: report
Seoul shares rise 1.9 pct as techs rally
China's trade surplus drops 53.5% in January
Pakistan
Japan overtaken by China as No. 2 economy
Taiwan may allow bigger China stakes in LCD firms
UK will maintain contested £1 billion India aid
Seoul shares rise 1.9 pct as techs rally
S.Korea c.bank to offer 28-day term deposit facility
Prince William picks Harry as best man
Taliban suicide attack kills two at Kabul mall
Obama eyes tax hikes, spending cuts to curb deficit
Egypt police march in Tahrir to support revolution
Abramovich slips down Russia's rich list
U.S. reaches out to Iranians in Farsi on Twitter
Iran police fire teargas at protest marchers: witness
|
Airline trade body says 3.3 bln passengers by 2014
Berlusconi shrugs off women's protests
Russia kicks off new privatisation drive
Egypt cyber activists say they met military rulers
Berlusconi refuses to resign, dismisses protest
|
Iran police fire teargas at protest marchers
Kabul suicide attack kills two guards at mall
Yemen police struggle to break up clashing protesters
|
Analysis: Telcos battle tech, banking titans in mobile payment
Afghan prosecutors seize vote data: officials
Italy and Tunisia in row over illegal migrants
|
Iran police fire tear gas in clash with protesters
Mexican police chief killed in bold attack: report
|
Blast at hotel complex in Afghan capital kills 2
Ballot disputes cast shadows over Afghan parliament
|
Protesters, police clash in Bahrain on Day of Rage
|
Suicide attack on Kabul hotel kills two
|
Britain's Prince Harry to be William's best man
Thai 'kissathon' claims new world record
Old and new stars come together at Grammy awards show
Justin Bieber: No Grammys, no worries
China's ZTE aims for top 3 in telecom gear
|
Experiment volunteers to 'walk on Mars'
Indonesian clerics soften tone to Valentine's Day
Arcade Fire wins album of the year Grammy
Nokia's Microsoft tie-up gets renewed hammering
|
Analysis: For now, small is good for Android apps publishers
|
Barnes & Noble invites Amazon affiliates to switch
|
Corrected: AOL Chief Executive Tim Armstrong doubles investment
|
RIM says state security demands are normal
|
Consumers would pay for premium telco services: study
|
Nokia CEO sees billions from Microsoft deal
|
Film takes unusual view of Chernobyl disaster
|
Britain's Prince Harry to be William's best man
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights