Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Special report
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Special report - Cables detail Saudi royal welfare programme
Reuters - Tuesday, March 1
Send
IM Story
Print
By Simon Robinson
LONDON , apparently intended to placate Saudis of modest means and insulate the world's biggest oil exporter from the wave of protest sweeping the Arab world.
But some of the biggest handouts over the past two decades have gone to his own extended family, according to unpublished American diplomatic cables dating back to 1996.
The cables, obtained by WikiLeaks and reviewed by Reuters, provide remarkable insight into how much the vast royal welfare program has cost the country -- not just financially but in terms of undermining social cohesion.
Besides the huge monthly stipends that every Saudi royal receives, the cables detail various money-making schemes some royals have used to finance their lavish lifestyles over the years. Among them: siphoning off money from "off-budget" programmes controlled by senior princes, sponsoring expatriate workers who then pay a small monthly fee to their royal patron and, simply, "borrowing from the banks, and not paying them back."
As long ago as 1996, U.S. officials noted that such unrestrained behaviour could fuel a backlash against the Saudi elite. In the assessment of the U.S. embassy in Riyadh in a cable from that year, "of the priority issues the country faces, getting a grip on royal family excesses is at the top."
A 2007 cable showed that King Abdullah has made changes since taking the throne six years ago, but recent turmoil in the Middle East underlines the deep-seated resentment about economic disparities and corruption in the region.
A Saudi government spokesman contacted by Reuters declined to comment.
MONTHLY CHEQUES
The November 1996 cable -- entitled "Saudi Royal Wealth: Where do they get all that money?" -- provides an extraordinarily detailed picture of how the royal patronage system works. It's the sort of overview that would have been useful required reading for years in the U.S. State department.
It begins with a line that could come from a fairytale: "Saudi princes and princesses, of whom there are thousands, are known for the stories of their fabulous wealth -- and tendency to squander it."
The most common mechanism for distributing Saudi Arabia's wealth to the royal family is the formal, budgeted system of monthly stipends that members of the Al Saud family receive, according to the cable. Managed by the Ministry of Finance's "Office of Decisions and Rules", which acts like a kind of welfare office for Saudi royalty, the royal stipends in the mid-1990s ran from about $800 a month for "the lowliest member of the most remote branch of the family" to $200,000-$270,000 a month for one of the surviving sons of Abdul-Aziz Ibn Saud, the founder of modern Saudi Arabia.
Grandchildren received around $27,000 a month, "according to one contact familiar with the stipends" system, the cable says. Great-grandchildren received about $13,000 and great-great- grandchildren $8,000 a month.
"Bonus payments are available for marriage and palace building," according to the cable, which estimates that the system cost the country, which had an annual budget of $40 billion at the time, some $2 billion a year.
"The stipends also provide a substantial incentive for royals to procreate since the stipends begin at birth."
After a visit to the Office of Decisions and Rules, which was in an old building in Riyadh's banking district, the U.S. embassy's economics officer described a place "bustling with servants picking up cash for their masters". The office distributed the monthly stipends -- not just to royals but to "other families and individuals granted monthly stipends in perpetuity". It also fulfilled "financial promises made by senior princes".
The head of the office at the time, Abdul-Aziz al-Shubayli, told the economics officer that an important part of his job "at least in today's more fiscally disciplined environment, is to play the role of bad cop". He "rudely grilled a nearly blind old man about why an eye operation promised by a prince and confirmed by royal Diwan note had to be conducted overseas and not for free in one of the first-class eye hospitals in the kingdom." After finally signing off on a trip, Shubayli noted that he himself had been in the United States twice for medical treatment, once for a chronic ulcer and once for carpal tunnel syndrome. "He chuckled, suggesting that both were probably job-induced."
FOLLOWING THE MONEY
But the stipend system was clearly not enough for many royals, who used a range of other ways to make money, "not counting business activities".
"By far the largest is likely royal skimming from the approximately $10 billion in annual off-budget spending controlled by a few key princes," the 1996 cable states. Two of those projects -- the Two Holy Mosques Project and the Ministry of Defence's Strategic Storage Project -- are "highly secretive, subject to no Ministry of Finance oversight or controls, transacted through the National Commercial Bank, and widely believed to be a source of substantial revenues" for the then-King and a few of his full brothers, according to the authors of the cable.
In a meeting with the U.S. ambassador at the time, one Saudi prince, alluding to the off-budget programs, "lamented the travesty that revenues from 'one million barrels of oil per day' go entirely to 'five or six princes,'" according to the cable, which quoted the prince.
Then there was the apparently common practice for royals to borrow money from commercial banks and simply not repay their loans. As a result, the 12 commercial banks in the country were "generally leery of lending to royals."
The managing director of another bank in the kingdom told the ambassador that he divided royals into four tiers, according to the cable. The top tier was the most senior princes who, perhaps because they were so wealthy, never asked for loans. The second tier included senior princes who regularly asked for loans. "The bank insists that such loans be 100 percent collateralised by deposits in other accounts at the bank," the cable reports. The third tier included thousands of princes the bank refused to lend to. The fourth tier, "not really royals, are what this banker calls the 'hangers on'."
Another popular money-making scheme saw some "greedy princes" expropriate land from commoners. "Generally, the intent is to resell quickly at huge markup to the government for an upcoming project." By the mid-1990s, a government programme to grant land to commoners had dwindled. "Against this backdrop, royal land scams increasingly have become a point of public contention."
The cable cites a banker who claimed to have a copy of "written instructions" from one powerful royal that ordered local authorities in the Mecca area to transfer to his name a "Waqf" -- religious endowment -- of a small parcel of land that had been in the hands of one family for centuries. "The banker noted that it was the brazenness of the letter ... that was particularly egregious."
Another senior royal was famous for "throwing fences up around vast stretches of government land."
The confiscation of land extends to businesses as well, the cable notes. A prominent and wealthy Saudi businessman told the embassy that one reason rich Saudis keep so much money outside the country was to lessen the risk of 'royal expropriation.'"
Finally, royals kept the money flowing by sponsoring the residence permits of foreign workers and then requiring them to pay a monthly "fee" of between $30 and $150. "It is common for a prince to sponsor a hundred or more foreigners," the 1996 cable says.
BIG SPENDERS
The U.S. diplomats behind the cable note wryly that despite all the money that has been given to Saudi royals over the years there is not "a significant number of super-rich princes ... In the end," the cable states, Saudi's "royals still seem more adept at squandering than accumulating wealth."
But the authors of the cable also warned that all that money and excess was undermining the legitimacy of the ruling family. By 1996, there was "broad sentiment that royal greed has gone beyond the bounds of reason". Still, as long as the "royal family views this country as 'Al Saud Inc.' ever increasing numbers of princes and princesses will see it as their birthright to receive lavish dividend payments, and dip into the till from time to time, by sheer virtue of company ownership."
In the years that followed that remarkable assessment of Saudi royalty, there were some official efforts towards reform -- driven in the late 1990s and early 2000s in particular by an oil price between $10-20 a barrel. But the real push for reform began in 2005, when King Abdullah succeeded to the throne, and even then change came slowly.
By February 2007, according to a second cable entitled "Crown Prince Sultan backs the King in family disputes", the reforms were beginning to bite. "By far the most widespread source of discontent in the ruling family is the King's curtailment of their privileges," the cable says. "King Abdullah has reportedly told his brothers that he is over 80 years old and does not wish to approach his judgement day with the 'burden of corruption on my shoulder.'"
The King, the cable states, had disconnected the cellphone service for "thousands of princes and princesses." Year-round government-paid hotel suites in Jeddah had been cancelled, as was the right of royals to request unlimited free tickets from the state airline. "We have a first-hand account that a wife of Interior minister Prince Naif attempted to board a Saudia flight with 12 companions, all expecting to travel for free," the authors of the cables write, only to be told "to her outrage" that the new rules meant she could only take two free guests.
Others were also angered by the rules. Prince Mishal bin Majid bin Abdulaziz had taken to driving between Jeddah and Riyadh "to show his annoyance" at the reforms, according to the cable.
Abdullah had also reigned in the practice of issuing "block visas" to foreign workers "and thus cut the income of many junior princes" as well as dramatically reducing "the practice of transferring public lands to favoured individuals."
The U.S. cable reports that all those reforms had fuelled tensions within the ruling family to the point where Interior Minister Prince Naif and Riyadh Governor Prince Salman had "sought to openly confront the King over reducing royal entitlements."
But according to "well established sources with first hand access to this information," Crown Prince Sultan stood by Abdullah and told his brothers "that challenging the King was a 'red line' that he would not cross." Sultan, the cable says, has also followed the King's lead and turned down requests for land transfers.
The cable comments that Sultan, longtime defence minister and now also Crown Prince, seemed to value family unity and stability above all.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
'All my people love me,' Kadhafi tells foreign media AFP - 2 hours 49 minutes ago
US freezes $30 bn in Libyan assets AFP - 18 minutes ago
Cut powerline electrocutes Brazil parade, 16 dead AFP - 27 minutes ago
UK-World Summary Reuters - 29 minutes ago
U.N. charge on Ivorian arms smuggling is denied Reuters - 29 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
US consumers curbed spending in January
Dior's Galliano hit by fresh anti-Semitism charges
EU seeks to bridge divisions over competitivity pact
Iran opposition leaders arrested: websites
Libya live report
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
'Runaway millionaire' arrested in NZ: police
'I wanted to die', says quake penknife amputee
Oscars Live Report
Libya live report
Michelle Obama gets a Republican boost on obesity
More Most Viewed »
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2011 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Tuesday, 1 March 2011 Iran opposition says leaders held, judiciary denies
Indian Ocean pirates hold seven Danes including three teens
Dior's Galliano hit by fresh anti-Semitism charges
Google repairing disrupted Gmail accounts
Iran arrests two opposition leaders
Egypt bans Mubarak and family from travel
Iran opposition leaders arrested: websites
Turkey touts tech credentials at CeBIT fair
Berlusconi tax fraud trial resumes
Libya live report
Libya live report
US-TECH Summary
Iran arrests two opposition leaders: opposition website
|
EU seeks to bridge divisions over competitivity pact
Analysis: After years of buying, Cisco may need to sell
US consumers curbed spending in January
Iran blames broken pump for atom fuel removal
Bahraini protesters move to parliament building
|
Eurozone inflation hits 2.3%, lower than estimated
Groupon launches online bargain site in China
Kadhafi, Mubarak slapped with travel bans
Revolution: "One more reason to visit Egypt"
Iran says it hopes for further nuclear talks
|
JPMorgan says tablets to grow into $35 billion market by 2012
Special report
Egypt agrees dates for referendum, polls: activist
|
Videogame makers seek footing on shifting landscape
Fidel Castro expected to resign as Cuba party chief
|
NATO: 4 service members killed in Afghanistan
Athens top city for online flirting-dating website
U.N. charge on Ivorian arms smuggling is denied
|
JPMorgan fund in talks to buy Twitter stake: report
Thailand to further probe killing of Reuters journalist
Jewish settlers protest home demolitions in West Bank
|
British Airways worker guilty of plane terror plot
Minimum and maximum temperatures in Celsius
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Banks, law enforcement crack down on laundered drug money
Charlie Sheen escalates rants, publicist quits
Oscar telecast among least-watched, show panned
Fela! comes home to Nigeria
Search continues in rural Georgia for elderly Ohio couple
French actress Annie Girardot dies
Wisconsin budget protest continues as Republican pledges support for unions
The Razzies roasts film losers "The Last Airbender," "Sex and the City 2"
Unrepentant Charlie Sheen vows to sue TV producers
Three quakes shake Arkansas within 24 hours.
Zach Anner, Kristina Kuzmic-Crocco both win on Oprah's "Your OWN Show"
Analysis: After years of buying, Cisco may need to sell
|
Tom Cruise confirmed to star in "Rock of Ages" musical film
Savings in fuel cost helped Boeing win $35-billion Air Force contract
Chicago Children's Museum First Metropolitan Board Benefit A Success
Amy Adams wears $1.35 million baubles, Helena Bonham Carters shows off patriotism at the Oscars
Charlie Sheen escalates rants, publicist quits
|
Oscar telecast among least-watched, show panned
|
Iran says it hopes for further nuclear talks
Spanish police arrest four suspected ETA members
Japan camera prettifies subjects, even adds "makeup"
Ivory Coast's Gbagbo turns forces on UN
Egypt agrees dates for referendum, polls
Dior's Galliano hit by fresh anti-Semitism charges
Morgan Stanley hit by China-based hackers: report
N.Zealand quake to hit growth: finance minister
Iran opposition says leaders held
Website aims to transform New York's blighted areas
Japan's jobless rate steady, household spending dips
Gaddafi forces mass as world raises pressure on Libya
|
Japan's jobless rate unchanged at 4.9% in January
Google backs weather insurance startup
US awards first deepwater permit post-Gulf spill
South Korea urges North Korea to hold talks
|
SocialEyes lets Facebook friends video chat
Opposition says resuming exports of Libya's oil
Castro says Cuba's mass layoffs delayed
|
U.S. calls China's Baidu "notorious market"
EU seeks to bridge divisions over competitivity pact
New Zealand falls silent in quake memorial as toll rises
|
Vivendi seen posting higher 2010 profit, SFR in focus
Google, Khosla back weather insurance startup
U.N. charge on Ivorian arms smuggling is denied
|
Intel completes McAfee acquisition
U.S. moves warships closer to Libya, freezes assets
New Zealand falls silent in quake memorial, toll rises
US freezes $30 bn in Libyan assets
Buxom actress Jane Russell dead at 89
Philippines warns drug lords using Facebook
British Airways worker guilty of plane terror plot
ITC judge rules for Samsung in Spansion patent spat
South Korea urges North Korea to hold talks
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Clinton says Gaddafi must go, foreign efforts grow
Malaysians tell of horror journey out of Libya
Xoom sales 'off to good start': Motorola CEO
Death penalty for 11 for in India train burning
Cambodia court rejects opposition leader's appeal
Women rally against "Eve teasing" in S. Asia
Air force jets crash during practice in Sri Lanka
U.S. calls China's Baidu notorious market
|
South says Koreas mustn't repeat 'dark history'
Will Charlie Sheen ever work again?
Morgan Stanley hit by China-based hackers: report
|
Voice from history exposed by New Zealand quake
Well, at least Canadian viewers liked the Oscars
Ex-Apple employee pleads guilty in kickback scheme
|
Legendary GI pin-up Jane Russell dies at 89
China rolls back press freedoms amid protest calls
Beady Eye: Liam Gallagher's life after Oasis
Google, Khosla back weather insurance startup
|
Buxom actress Jane Russell dead at 89
Website aims to transform New York's blighted areas
|
French Renaissance art gets royal treatment in US
GM South Korea unit to invest $4 bln over 3 yrs
Nelly Furtado to give away $1 million Gaddafi fee
Japan camera prettifies subjects, even adds makeup
|
S.Korea sukuk bill unlikely to pass soon
Pakistan
Strong South Korea Feb exports boost rate rise case
New Zealand commodity prices hit record high in Feb -ANZ
NZ 91-day T-bills yield 2.75 pct at tender
NZ FinMin says need to be flexible on surplus target
US group: Inflation biggest concern in S China
Toyota recalls 145,000 Corolla cars in Brazil
NZ earthquake to slash 2011 growth
Will Charlie Sheen ever work again?
|
Buxom actress Jane Russell dead at 89
|
Kirstie Alley, Ralph Macchio among Dancing stars
|
Nelly Furtado to give away $1 million Gaddafi fee
|
Well, at least Canadian viewers liked the Oscars
|
King's Speech and tradition triumph at Oscars
|
Oscar telecast among least-watched, show panned
|
German defence minister quits after plagiarism row
Iran denies opposition leaders jailed
Panasonic says has dropped game development project
Hat-trick hero Malinga destroys Kenya
Settlers rampage in W.Bank after outpost dismantled
German unemployment edges lower in February
Saudi economy sees no adverse impact from turmoil
Barclays buys Citigroup's Egg credit card division
Saudi authorities detain Shi'ite cleric over sermon
Oman army tries to disperse protests, wounds one
|
Iran forces fire teargas, clash with protesters
|
Chinese manufacturing slows in February
NATO: 3 service members killed in Afghanistan
Tens of thousands protest in Yemen, clashes in south
|
Settlers rampage in West Bank after outpost dismantled
|
Gaddafi speech turned into dance remix, goes viral on YouTube
German defense minister quits in plagiarism row
|
Egypt military sets short timetable for democracy
|
Japan lower house passes budget, PM's outlook bleak
Ivorian troops shot at arms investigators: U.N.
|
Malaysia court allows tribes to fight land claim
British press celebrates Oscar success
Laureate Yunus faces removal from Grameen Bank
New bird flu cases strike West Java, Indonesia
China's population now stands at 1.34b
Oscar winner Portman condemns Dior designer Galliano
Revamped China history museum skips taboo subjects
Surrogacy banned under Malaysian fatwa
British press celebrates Oscar success
China sets out disputes facing "arduous" climate talks
Supreme Court rejects AT&T corporate privacy rights
|
WikiLeaks, Internet in record Nobel Peace field
|
Kirstie Alley, Ralph Macchio among "Dancing" stars
Panasonic says has dropped game development project
|
Diddy-Dirty Money announce first-ever U.S. tour
Wisconsin governor to outline budget plan Monday as protest continues
U.S. doctors want tanning beds off limits to minors
Suddenly quitting smoking with little effort may be early sign of lung cancer
Two and a Half Men crew will get paid for canceled episodes
U.S. freezes $30 billion of Libyan assets
U.S. grants deepwater drill permit to Noble Energy for Gulf of Mexico site
JPMorgan fund wants to become minority shareholder in Twitter
Federal agents arrest Masseys security chief over lying to FBI in mine explosion probe
U.S. hesitates to support Crown Prince and define post-Gaddafi Libya
Dior fires Galliano after racism video
|
Oscar winner Portman condemns Dior designer Galliano
|
Harry Potter finale gets Trafalgar Square premiere
|
Nelly Furtado to give away $1 million Gaddafi fee
|
Charlie Sheen escalates war of words with TV bosses
|
Gaddafi speech turned into dance remix, goes viral on YouTube
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights