">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Unnatural selection: How far will parents go?
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Search
Search:
Unnatural selection: How far will parents go?
AFP - Sunday, February 8
PARIS (AFP) - - Picture this: prospective parents excitedly clicking through an online catalogue, ticking off the optimal mix of traits for their yet-to-be-conceived child.
Will they opt for blue eyes or brown. Perhaps green, for a touch of originality? What colour skin? And do they want a boy or a girl?
Are they aiming for an Olympian athlete, or will they stack the deck in favour of intellectual prowess? Why not both?
For some people, this would be a dream come true. For others, a nightmare of widening inequality touching on eugenics.
For biologists, it raises acute questions about evolution.
The principle of species change through natural selection was set down by Charles Darwin, who was born 200 years ago on February 12.
But what "natural selection" means when it comes to Homo sapiens is hard to define. It has already been challenged by medicine, habitat, diet and other factors that affect lifespan, reproduction and survivability.
Genetic selection means our species' evolutionary path would be even more radically changed.
We are not there yet -- but this vision clearly does not belong to the hazy future of science fiction.
Dozens of clinics in the United States, one of the least regulated markets for fertility services, already provide would-be parents in-depth profiles of potential sperm and egg donors.
Atlanta-based Xytex Corporation, for example, offers a long list of genetically-coded physical attributes, right down to the length of eyelashes, the presence of freckles and whether ear lobes are detached.
There is also a summary of the donor's medical history and -- for an additional fee -- personality and educational profiles, a personal essay and photos, as an adult and a baby.
Much of this information has no relation to genetic pedigree and even when it does, the result -- a human child -- may not come out as advertised. But that has not dampened enthusiasm for the tests.
Most heterosexual couples shop in this market to compensate for either male or female infertility.
But there is nothing -- in science or, in some countries, law -- to prevent matching a donor egg with donor sperm to create an embryo that can be purchased and implanted in the buyer's womb.
This option was offered by at least one "embryo bank" in Texas before it reluctantly withdrew the procedure under an ethical firestorm.
Even parents who don't need outside help to procreate may soon be clamouring for "preimplantation genetic diagnosis" of embryos to check not only for genetic defects and disease -- the original intent -- but also for sex and desirable traits as well, experts say.
"We need to look carefully at these selection technologies," said Marcy Darnovsky of the Center for Genetics and Society in Oakland, California.
"It is not bad to have a desire for a girl or a boy," she said by phone. "But in chatrooms and on bulletin board you can find moms, for example, that don't just want a girl, but a particular kind of girl -- 'I want to go shopping with her, play Barbie Dolls, paint her toenails pink'."
"What are they going to do if they don't get that kind of kid -- take her back?" she said.
An even more problematic scenario for some is the leap from genetic selection to genetic engineering.
That can happen in two ways. Gene therapy alters genes, for example, in a diseased organ in order to effect a cure.
But changes wrought by so-called germ-line therapy alter the blueprint itself, the human genome, and would thus be passed on to offspring.
"The pressure to change genes will probably come from parents wanting to guarantee their child is a boy or a girl, or to endow them with beauty, intelligence, musical talent or a sweet nature," notes Peter Ward, a scientist at the University of Washington and author of "Future Evolution".
For now, germ-line therapy is out of reach. But were science to master the genome, the temptation to tweak it to increase smarts, looks and longevity would be overwhelming, Ward argued last month in Science.
"One day, we will have it in our power to bring a new human species into this world," he said.
Not all researchers agree. "I think that all of these worries are misplaced -- genetics is far too complex to allow for easy manipulation of human traits," said Steven Pinker, an evolutionary biologist at Harvard University.
Nearly all diseases and traits are determined not by one or two genes but the interaction of many, he pointed out.
There is no such thing, in other words, as a master gene for intelligence or musicality.
"I doubt that parents would take a risk greater than five percent that something would go wrong," he told AFP. "Testing is easy and safe. Manipulation is hard and risky."
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Recommend this article
Average (1 vote)
Sign in to recommend this article »
Most Recommended Stories »
Enlarge Photo
Blood serum samples in a clinic in Manila. Picture this: prospective parents excitedly clicking through an online catalogue, ticking off the optimal mix of traits for their yet-to-be-conceived child
Most Popular – Top Stories
Viewed
Bus-sized boa slithers into record books
Volvo Group reports big loss but share price soars
US Air Force orders 15 Boeing C-17s
Toyota warns of 4.9 bln dollar annual loss
US Senate moves ahead on Obama stimulus plan
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Sunday, 8 February 2009 West threatens Iran sanctions, offers talks
| International
|
Rebels target new Somali president with mortars
| International
|
Ecuador's president orders U.S. official to leave
| International
|
Venezuela opposition protests Chavez reelection plan
| International
|
India's Congress wants Pakistan declared terror state
| International
|
Baluch group says holds American hostage in Pakistan
| International
|
Plague-Infested Mice Missing From New Jersey Research Lab
Vice President Biden Outlines America's "New Foreign Policy"
Mentally Ill Man Kills Parents, Wounds Police During Standoff
German Bosnia film takes critical view of tribunal
| Entertainment
|
Tommy Lee Jones stars as detective Robicheaux in new film
| Entertainment
|
Plague-Infested Mice Missing From New Jersey Research Lab
Israel says Gaza rocket hits south, damages cars
Bushfires rage in Australia, 50 dead
| International
|
NATO must go for drug lords: Afghan minister
Cairo seeks Gaza truce, prisoner deal: diplomats
| International
|
Cairo seeks Gaza truce and prisoner deal
Japan's Somalia piracy patrol possible in March: reports
| International
|
Last El Salvador soldiers back from Iraq
Amid deepening economic gloom, some see hope
Venezuela opposition protests Chavez reelection plan
| International
|
U.S. commanders favour slower Iraq pullout
Unnatural selection: How far will parents go?
Britain orders bank bonuses, management probe
Family of slain contractor sues Halliburton, KBR
Up to 25 shot dead at Madagascar demonstration: police
| International
|
German cabinet in limbo after finance minister's bid to quit fails
Military: 2 injured in accidental Iraq shooting
OPEC to cut output in March: Iraqi oil minister
Hamas heavyweight in Egypt for Gaza talks
Party rejects German minister's resignation: report
German economy minister submits resignation: spokesman
El Salvador withdraws last soldiers from Iraq
Obama's Labor Pick Dogged By Tax Issues
Obama to overhaul security team
Update: Rescuers Save Over 150 People From Lake Erie Ice, One Killed
Over 100 Trapped On 8-Mile Ice Slab On Lake Erie
Biden to meet Russian deputy PM
TED ends with hope clever solutions will trump daunting woes
US military deaths in Iraq war at 4,238
Computer model says Iran won't build nuclear bombs
US seeks fresh start in ties with Russia: Biden
US will ask others to take Guantanamo inmates: Biden
Swiss weigh up EU immigration in crucial vote
Slumdog, Milk win top screenwriting awards
| Entertainment
|
Japan's anti-piracy mission ready in March: minister
Drought-hit China to divert waters from two longest rivers: report
Boy feared snatched by crocodile in Australia
Bushfires rage in Australia, 65 dead
65 killed in Australia's wildfire 'hell'
Chinese mining group to invest 1 bln dollars in Peru
South Asian chasm of mistrust awaits Obama's envoy
Japan PM to draft 'Green New Deal:' report
Vietnam reports 2nd bird flu case this year
Fraud-hit Satyam's new CEO says firm can do 'the impossible'
Japan's Somalia piracy patrol possible in March
640 houses lost in Australia's deadly fires
Do you like green eggs and ham? Food designers push the limits
Malaysia to lower electricity cost by 7-10 pct: reports
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
"Slumdog", "Milk" win top screenwriting awards
Creator of iconic Obama 'Hope" poster arrested for graffiti: report
Senegal's rice farmers given boost by food crisis
Lil Wayne, Coldplay eye Grammys glory
Women to take to employment helm in the US
Guests for the Sunday TV news shows
Placido Domingo tries to turn back clock at Met
Israeli candidates battle for voters as election nears
Rain eases China drought
| International
|
Trial date set for Iraqi who threw shoes at Bush
24 bodies pulled from plane wreck in Brazil river
| International
|
US warns of battle worse than Iraq in Afghanistan
All eyes on US Treasury's upcoming banking plan
Gaza children traumatized after Israeli offensive
| International
|
Iran building four more satellites: report
| International
|
Egypt hopes for Gaza truce deal 'in few days'
Nearly 14,000 flee Sri Lanka's war zone
| International
|
Egypt hopes for Gaza truce deal 'very soon'
Iraq bomb kills two Shi'ite pilgrims
| International
|
Assault trial date set for Bush shoe assailant
| International
|
Workers end strike on Thai resort island
| International
|
U.S. Afghan troops unfazed by Kyrgyz base closure
American Head Of UN Relief Agency Kidnapped In Pakistan
Pope, Merkel mend fences over Holocaust row
First Woman To Swim The Atlantic Reaches Trinidad
U.S. Expresses Disappointed Over Russia's Plan To Put Up Bases In Abkhazia, S. Ossetia
Corrected: Navy Missile Cruiser USS Port Royal (CG 73) Grounded On Honolulu Reef
2 US soldiers defusing bomb killed in Afghanistan
Ferries collide in Bangladesh, 10 die
Sri Lanka navy destroys 2 rebel boats
10 dead in boat accident in Bangladesh
'Slumdog Millionaire' wins top screenwriting honors
Rain eases China drought
Iran's About Elly praised at Berlin fest
| Entertainment
|
Pakistan probes group's claim of holding American
Thai soldiers raid human rights office in south
China fights drought with chemical cloud-seeding
New Zealand house prices fall in January
Japan minister suggests additional stimulus plan
Iran's "About Elly" praised at Berlin fest
Thai PM defends economic stimulus package
Whitney Houston makes triumphant comback at party
TEXT-Elbit Systems's Elisra gets South Korean contract
'Slumdog Millionaire' wins top screenwriting honors
Hynix develops new 40-nm-class memory chip
Jessica Biel hosts Sci-Tech Oscars
Passengers Escape Burning Bus In Freak Accident
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights