Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Courtney Love's tweets lead to court trial
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
World
Courtney Love's tweets lead to court trial
Reuters - Thursday, January 6
Send
IM Story
Print
By Matt Belloni and Eriq Gardner
LOS ANGELES - Courtney Love was very upset.
The firebrand rocker had been locked in a dispute with Dawn Simorangkir, a fashion designer who was demanding payment for a few thousand dollars worth of clothes.
So on March 17, 2009, Love took to her Twitter account and began hurling a stream of shocking insults at the designer known as the "Boudoir Queen." Love's tweets, which instantly landed in the Twitter feeds of her 40,000 or so followers , announced that Simorangkir was a drug-pushing prostitute with a history of assault and battery who lost custody of her own child and capitalized on Love's fame before stealing from her. "She has received a VAST amount of money from me over 40,000 dollars and I do not make people famous and get raped TOO!" Love wrote.
That tirade, along with others the Hole frontwoman unleashed on social media platforms including MySpace and Etsy.com during the next four days, form the basis of a groundbreaking lawsuit headed to court in Los Angeles on January 18: the first high-profile defamation trial over a celebrity's comments on Twitter.
"There has never been anything like this case before," says Simorangkir attorney Bryan Freedman, who will attempt to convince a Los Angeles jury that Love's false statements destroyed his client's fashion career, thus entitling her to potentially millions of dollars in damages.
In an age when influential public figures from Kanye West to Ryan Seacrest communicate with thousands -- sometimes millions -- of followers on social platforms, the Love case raises the question of whether celebrities, like the news media, should be liable for what happens if they intentionally put untrue and damaging statements in front of their loyal readers.
"We don't believe there's any defamation, and even if there were defamatory statements, there was no damage," says James Janowitz, an attorney for Love.
A key to the case, say First Amendment lawyers, could be whether an average Twitter user would interpret Love's vicious tweets as facts rather than merely her opinion.
"I'll be interested to see if the court gives people posting on Twitter more latitude than other media," says Alonzo Wickers, a defamation expert who has handled matters for such media clients as Comedy Central and TMZ. "The way Twitter is evolving, it seems to be more of a means to express opinion. I would hope courts give tweets the same latitude as they do an op-ed piece or a letter to the editor."
To aid her case, Simorangkir plans to call to the stand Jessie Stricchiola, a social media expert who was tasked with studying how many people saw the Love rants and what kind of credibility is given to statements made on a casual forum like Twitter. Stricchiola will report her findings at trial.
Love, who is scheduled to testify in court, already gave a deposition in the case, during which she argued that she was only repeating in her tweets what she had heard from Simorangkir herself. She did acknowledge Love's influence as a fashion icon, of sorts, and Simorangkir plans to use those statements at trial to demonstrate that Love was enough of a trendsetter to effectively kill her reputation. In addition, e-mails and phone calls made by Love to Simorangkir in the aftermath of her Twitter rampage, some of which purportedly exhibit remorse about the comments, will be introduced to jurors.
Love's attorneys have their own witnesses, including a medical expert who plans to testify that even if Love's statements were untrue, her mental state was not "subjectively malicious" enough to justify the defamation lawsuit.
That claim -- something akin to an insanity defense for social media -- suggests that Twitter was so appealing and addictive for Love that she had no appreciation for how the comments she posted would be received by others.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Perez Hilton calls Korean boyband TVXQ music video 'too hot to handle' ANN - Thursday, January 6
French TV star accused of Hemingway plagiarism AFP - Thursday, January 6
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary Reuters - Thursday, January 6
Heart disease killed Boney M frontman Farrell Reuters - Thursday, January 6
Courtney Love's tweets lead to court trial Reuters - Thursday, January 6
News Search
Top Stories
First EU bond for Ireland attracts strong demand: HSBC
New mass death of birds in Sweden
Hundreds pregnant in UK despite contraceptive implant
Jackson doctor in court over pop icon's death
S.Korea's Samsung Group to invest 38 bln$ in 2011
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Falling blackbirds baffle Arkansas officials
Hasta la Vista: Arnie quits as California governor
Goldman deal 'values Facebook at $50 billion'
Spain lotto winner nearly loses millions by tossing tickets
Brazil's 2010 trade surplus lowest in 8 years: official
More Most Viewed »
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2011 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Wednesday, 5 January 2011 Netanyahu asks Obama to pardon jailed Israeli spy
Clouds block first 2011 solar eclipse
New Year ski tweet for Medvedev and Schwarzenegger?
Egypt bomber planned blast inside church: police
Spanish builder ACS closes in on German rival
Skype's partner says it is legal in China
Clouds block first 2011 solar eclipse
Analyst view
Goldman and Digital Sky invest in Facebook
Anti-government riots hit Jordan desert city
Lebanon asks UN to guard gas from Israeli drilling
Iran lifts ban on reformist weekly
Netanyahu asks Obama to pardon jailed Israeli spy
|
Egypt church blast death toll rises to 23
Sudan's Bashir offers hand of peace to south
Haiti second round vote impossible before February
|
Pakistani governor assassinated in Islamabad
Afghan leader complains of foreign interference
Cash-strapped Cuba moves ahead with job cuts
|
Pakistan crisis deepens as governor shot dead
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Iran offers India oil supply plan for January
"Social Network" among Hollywood producers nominees
Foetus found on UAE flight to Manila
Taiwan plans major scheme to boost births
Asian Cup hosts Qatar aim to prove World Cup merit
U.S. envoy to Libya in Washington for talks on ties
Philippine politician catches 'killer' on camera
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
EA tees up new Tiger Woods video game for March
|
Pakistan's Punjab province governor shot dead
Police say Lindsay Lohan violated probation
Gunfire at Islamabad shopping area frequented by foreigners
What to look for at the Consumer Electronics Show
|
Masters makes videogame debut, boosts Tiger brand
Dell to buy SecureWorks to beef up security
|
Madrid's Prado suffers drop in visitor numbers
Court tosses ABC indecency fine over NYPD Blue
Court backs Uniloc in patent fight with Microsoft
|
Syria makes low-key opening of casino
Japanese maestro Ozawa cancels concerts due to surgery
Investors warm to Motorola spinoffs, shares rise
|
"Social Network" among Hollywood producers nominees
French TV star accused of Hemingway bio plagiarism
Pink Floyd re-signs to EMI, sides end legal row
Police say Lindsay Lohan violated probation
|
Prosecutors claim Jackson doctor acted too slowly
|
Social Network among Hollywood producers nominees
|
Gwyneth Paltrow to host Saturday Night Live
|
Singer Toni Braxton Lands cable reality show on WE
|
Bigger revenues and attendance for Broadway in 2010
|
U.S. looks to China as talks begin on North Korea
|
Scottish singer Gerry Rafferty dies aged 63: agent
US-TECH Summary
Iran nuclear invitation draws Western scepticism
Jackson doctor in court over pop icon's death
Toshiba plans big push on glasses-free 3D TV
Australia floods cause catastrophic damage
|
Protesters stage anti-Brazil rallies across Italy
S.Korea's Samsung Group to invest 38 bln$ in 2011
Chavez floats Stone, Penn, Clinton for U.S. envoy
|
Samsung Group to lift investment by 18 percent in 2011
Fifth of cardiac implants harmful: US study
Copyright verdict restored against Microsoft
Sat-nav turtles go on trans-ocean trek
Police probe hacker attack on Brazil president's site
US automakers outpaced rivals in 2010
Mexico arrests leader of Saint Death cult
|
Microsoft Windows vulnerable to new type of attack
Pakistani governor assassinated in Islamabad
Icy rains force 58,000 to evacuate in southern China
|
Investors warm to both Motorolas
African powers insist Gbagbo stand down despite talks offer
Odds of an IVF baby? There's an app for that
Son of Iran shah kills himself in U.S.
|
Chavez floats Stone, Penn, Clinton for U.S. envoy
Court backs Uniloc in patent fight with Microsoft
Citi's service guru Tweets more bank customers
Samsung Group to lift investment by 18 percent in 2011
Iran opens nuclear sites to selected nations
US envoy discusses North Korea in Seoul
Investors warm to Motorola spinoffs, shares rise
Australia resumes fight over alleged Nazi war criminal
China completes stealth fighter prototype
Obama meets Chinese envoy ahead of Hu visit
Alec Baldwin "very, very interested" in political run
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Pakistan to bury assassinated governor
Australia floods cause "catastrophic" damage
Goldman's friends get week to mull Facebook bet
|
Cook, Bell put England in command of final Ashes Test
Toshiba plans big push on glasses-free 3D TV
|
Obama meets Chinese foreign minister: WHouse
Eight big changes coming to "American Idol"
Aussie star Webb named to LPGA Board of Directors
George Clooney to star in serial-killer film
Microsoft Windows vulnerable to new type of attack
|
Gemma Arterton joins "Hansel and Gretel" makeover
Sirius XM slashing talent salaries, says former DJ
Samsung Group to lift investment by 18 percent in 2011
|
Alec Baldwin "very, very interested" in political run
China state newspaper's Web unit plans IPO
|
S.Korea's Hyundai Steel hikes export prices again
O.J. Simpson co-defendant freed from prison in deal
S.Korea's Samsung to invest 38.3 bln dlrs in 2011
Citi's service guru Tweets more bank customers
|
Prosecutors claim Jackson doctor acted too slowly
Trillion-dollar forecast for gadget sales
Kathy Bates says "Harry's Law" role fit like a glove
PGA Tour gives fans green light to use mobile phones
|
Seoul shares dip on refiners; Hyundai Motor jumps
Odds of an IVF baby? There's an app for that
|
Lenovo 'LePad' combines tablet and laptop
S&PReport: Taiwan Tech firms face uncertain long-term growth
BYD auto firm fails to hit 2010 China sales target
China party newspaper's website plans Shanghai IPO
Korea Hot Stocks-Banks fall, Hyundai Motor rises
Japan eyes building its own GPS system
Lawyer slams cops who say Lindsay Lohan violated probation
|
Prosecutors claim Jackson doctor acted too slowly
|
Eight big changes coming to American Idol
|
Alec Baldwin very, very interested in political run
|
O.J. Simpson co-defendant freed from prison in deal
|
George Clooney to star in serial-killer film
|
Sirius XM slashing talent salaries, says former DJ
|
Kathy Bates says Harry's Law role fit like a glove
|
EU says IAEA should visit Iran nuclear sites
China completes stealth fighter prototype
First EU bond for Ireland attracts strong demand: HSBC
Israeli strike foils rare Russian president visit
Gadget charger harnesses walking power
Pakistani scholars say mourning slain governor risky
|
EU says IAEA should inspect Iran's nuclear sites
Anti-U.S. Shi'ite cleric visits Iraq after years
|
China state newspaper's Web unit plans IPO
Israel said would keep Gaza near collapse
Earthquake injures 16 people in southern Iran
Ouattara says no risk of civil war in Ivory Coast
|
Iran FM heads to Baghdad to boost ties
Egypt church bomb hints at al Qaeda gaining toehold
|
Afghanistan says attacks against VP thwarted
Samsung Group to lift investment by 18 percent in 2011
Israel said would keep Gaza near collapse: WikiLeaks
|
Afghan authorities say they thwart planned attacks
Copts on global Christmas alert after Egypt bombing
|
Chavez backers, foes rally for Venezuela parliament
|
Freeze wreaks havoc in southern China
EU says up to IAEA to inspect Iran's nuclear sites
|
Thailand recovers some missing Saudi gems
Australian floods spread, threaten Barrier Reef
800 soldiers in dock at Bangladesh mutiny hearing
Delhi Games chief quizzed by police over corruption
French TV star accused of Hemingway plagiarism
Mother killed in China land protest
Heart disease killed Boney M frontman Farrell
Goldman's friends get week to mull Facebook bet
|
Courtney Love's tweets lead to court trial
Mattel partners with THQ in new licensing deal
|
Courtney Love's tweets lead to court trial
|
Heart disease killed Boney M frontman Farrell
|
Gwyneth Paltrow to host Saturday Night Live
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights