Forum Views () 
Forum Replies ()  
 
 
Read more with google mobile :
Climate change study had 'significant error': experts  
 
 
 
 
 
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
  
 
 
 
 
  
 
 
 
 
 
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
 
 
 
Top Stories
Most Popular
Photos
Full Coverage
Sitemap
 
 
 
  
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Climate change study had 'significant error': experts
 
 
  
 
 AFP - 1 hour 20 minutes ago
 
 
Send
 
IM Story
 
Print
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
WASHINGTON (AFP) - – A climate change study that projected a 2.4 degree Celsius increase in temperature and massive worldwide food shortages in the next decade was seriously flawed, scientists said Wednesday.
 
The study was posted Tuesday on EurekAlert, a independent service for reporters set up by the American Association for the Advancement of Science, and was written about by numerous international news agencies, including AFP.
 
But AAAS later retracted the study as experts cited numerous errors in its approach.
 
"A reporter with The Guardian alerted us yesterday to concerns about the news release submitted by Hoffman & Hoffman public relations," said AAAS spokeswoman Ginger Pinholster in an email to AFP.
 
"We immediately contacted a climate change expert, who confirmed that the information raised many questions in his mind, too. We swiftly removed the news release from our website and contacted the submitting organization."
 
Scientist Osvaldo Canziani, who was part of the 2007 Nobel Prize winning Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, was listed as the scientific advisor to the report.
 
The IPCC, whose figures were cited as the basis for the study's projections, and Al Gore jointly won the Nobel Prize for Peace in 2007 "for their efforts to build up and disseminate greater knowledge about man-made climate change," the prize committee said at the time.
 
Canziani's spokesman said Tuesday he was ill and was unavailable for interviews.
 
The study cited the UN group's figures for its projections, combined with "the business-as-usual path the world is currently following," said lead author Liliana Hisas of the Universal Ecological Fund (UEF), a non-profit group headquartered in Argentina.
 
But climate scientist Ray Weymann told AFP that the "study contains a significant error in that it confuses 'equilibrium' temperature rise with 'transient temperature rise.'"
 
He also noted that study author Hisas was told of the problems in advance of the report's release.
 
"The author of the study was told by several of us about this error but she said it was too late to change it," said Weymann.
 
Scientist Scott Mandia forwarded to AFP an email he said he sent to Hisas ahead of publication explaining why her figures did not add up, and noting that it would take "quite a few decades" to reach a warming level of 2.4 degrees Celsius.
 
"Even if we assume the higher end of the current warming rate, we should only be 0.2C warmer by 2020 than today," Mandia wrote.
 
"To get to +2.4C the current trend would have to immediately increase almost ten-fold."
 
Mandia described the mishap as an "honest and common mistake," but said the matter would certainly give fuel to skeptics of humans' role in climate change.
 
"More alarmism," said Mandia. "Don't get me wrong. We are headed to 2.4, it is just not going to happen in 2020."
 
Many people do not understand the cumulative effect of carbon emissions and how they impact climate change, Mandia said.
 
"This is something that people don't appreciate. We tied a record in 2010 (for temperature records) globally. That is primarily from the C02 we put in the atmosphere in the 70s and early 80s, and we have been ramping up since then," he said.
 
"So it is not good. We are seeing the response from a mistake we were making 20 years ago, and we are making bigger mistakes today."
 
Marshall Hoffman of the public relations firm that issued the report on the UEF's behalf said the group stands by the study.
 
"Earlier, NASA and NOAA estimated that the global temperature increased one degree from 2005-2010. If this stays on the same path, that will be two degrees by 2015. We see that path increasing more rapidly," Hoffman said, in part, in his explanation.
 
Asked for comment on Hoffman's response, Mandia told AFP: "He is still confused."
 
 
 
 
   
 
 
 
 
 
 
Recommend
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Send
 
IM Story
 
Print
 
 
 
 
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
News Search
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Top Stories
 
 
 
 
Climate change study had 'significant error': experts
Rosneft, BP to complete tie-up in 3-4 weeks: company
China 'agrees $45 bn trade deal with US'
Britain reviewing royal succession ahead of wedding
Goldman Sachs posts steep drop in quarterly profit
 
 
 
 More Top Stories »
 
 
 
ADVERTISEMENT
 
 
  
 
 
 
 
Most Popular
 
 
 
 
Most Viewed
 
 
 
 
Researchers aim to resurrect mammoth in five years
 
Steve Jobs steps aside as Apple profits soar
 
Russian women 'dress like strippers': church spokesman
 
Rape laws blurry for Israelis: researcher
 
Apple's Steve Jobs taking new medical leave
 
 
 More Most Viewed »
 
 
 
 
 
 
 More Most Recommended »
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
  
 
 
 
 
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
 
 
 
 
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
 
 
Stars and latest movies
 
 
Best travel destinations
 
 
 
 
 
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
More on Yahoo! News
 
 
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
 
Also on Yahoo!
 
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
 
Site Highlights
 
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network 
 
 
 
 Copyright © 2011 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
 
 
    
  
   
 
 
    
   
 
Other News on Thursday, 20 January 2011 Afghanistan delays opening parliament for a month  
Rosneft, BP to complete tie-up in 3-4 weeks: company  
US-TECH Summary  
Saudi Arabia quits Lebanon mediation efforts  
Swiss whistleblower guilty of breaching bank secrecy: court  
More tech workers get bonuses, pay raises: survey  
U.N .council gets draft condemning Israel settlements  
Climate change study had 'significant error': experts  
At least 207 missing in Brazil floods, 727 dead
|  
Juror could face charges for online research  
China 'agrees $45 bn trade deal with US'  
Powers to press defiant Iran in nuclear row  
Study marks spooky step towards quantum computers  
Britain reviewing royal succession ahead of wedding  
Powers to press defiant Iran in nuclear row
|  
Twin suicide blasts kill 16 in central Iraq  
Goldman Sachs posts steep drop in quarterly profit  
Swiss ex-banker linked to Wikileaks found guilty  
Berlusconi vows new laws to stop legal persecution
|  
Foreign broadcasts, DVDs challenge Iran grip on TV  
SAP sets ambitious goals, faces restructuring: report  
Mexico's Sinaloa gang grows empire, defies crackdown
|  
Afghanistan delays parliament opening by a month  
Ericsson faces margin squeeze as sales improve  
South Sudanese in most states back independence  
Sudanese police clash with opposition protesters
|  
Afghan president delays parliament by 1 month  
Karzai delays parliament to allow more fraud probes
|  
Rights, trade billions claim spotlight as Hu visits  
Panic as major quake hits Pakistan  
US, China ink $45 bln of export deals  
Obama presses China's Hu on currency and rights  
Wife of China dissident speaks out on abuse  
Obama publicly raises human rights with China's Hu  
Obama raises rights as Chinese President arrives  
Southeast Asian bloc mulls bid for 2030 World Cup  
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary  
Chiese leader Hu gets warm White House welcome  
Meryl Streep drops in on British parliament  
More tech workers get bonuses, pay raises: survey
|  
Chinese man sentenced for ivory possession in Kenya  
Anne Hathaway cast as Catwoman in new "Batman" movie  
Cake sets record for lowest selling No. 1 album  
Sundance film festival defies economic slowdown  
Greece pledges to enforce disputed smoking ban  
China to buy Boeing planes worth $19 bn  
Study marks spooky step towards quantum computers
|  
Angry Birds developer sets sights on animated series  
Indian police arrest 3 Chinese telecom employees  
Juror could face charges for online research
|  
Serbia to project historic bridge hologram over Danube  
Confidence in Japan lost without reforms: minister  
White Lies shrug off reports of "death of rock"  
China's massive annual holiday migration begins  
Indonesian taxman jailed in massive graft case  
Street clashes as Bangladesh shares dive again  
Lawsuit for Japan Airlines a year after bankruptcy  
Update: Joe Lieberman Formally Announces Retirement  
Apple profits hit record high $6b for quarter  
Court martial awaits verdict on HIV-positive 'swinging' airman  
Justice Dept. appeals Virginia healthcare ruling  
Cake earn first and lowest-selling #1 album on Billboard with "Showroom of Compassion"  
Dismembered girls stepmom charged with bigamy  
AMR 4Q loss narrows to $97 million  
Kanye West, Arcade Fire headline Coachella 2011  
Anne Hathaway cast as Catwoman in new Batman movie
|  
Survey: 3 in 4 workers go to workplace ill  
Alabama Governor: Non-Christians are not his 'brothers and sisters'  
Zsa Zsa Gabor's mansion on market for $28 million
|  
Jennifer Aniston says Rachel haircut ugliest ever
|  
The Kennedys: what the first episode reveals
|  
Meryl Streep drops in on British parliament
|  
White Lies shrug off reports of death of rock
|  
Cake sets record for lowest selling No. 1 album
|  
Powers to press defiant Iran in nuclear row  
Berlusconi rages against magistrates for sex scandal enquiry  
Samsung acquires e-paper technology firm Liquavista  
Sudanese police clash with opposition protesters  
US, China ink $45 bln of export deals  
eBay earnings shine on PayPal performance  
Tunisia protesters demand change, prisoners freed
|  
Bedbugs resistant to pesticide, study finds  
Britain bans US pastor Jones for 'the public good'  
Pay for a latte by mobile at Starbucks  
Obama, Hu air divides but seek common ground  
Climate change study had 'significant error': experts  
Nintendo says reaction to 3D warning was overblown  
Nokia cancels X7 phone destined for AT&T: source  
Seagate sales, profit fall; shares decline  
EU halts emissions trading after hacking  
Olympics: 2012 technology put to the test  
Taiwan may test missiles again after flop  
Samsung acquires e-paper technology firm Liquavista  
Goss leads Tour Down Under, Matthews wins stage  
Pay for a latte by mobile at Starbucks  
Gervais defiant as Globes controversy simmers  
Nokia cancels X7 phone destined for AT&T: source  
Hong Kong seizes $33 mn cocaine haul  
Child dies as Australia floods return  
Bieber movie ad to air on post-Bowl "Glee"  
Google to ride busy holidays, faces growth question
|  
Graft scandal pressures Indonesia leader: analysts  
EBay outlook beats Street as turnaround bears fruit
|  
Rampant Rafa, Clijsters on course at Australian Open  
Nintendo says reaction to 3D warning was overblown
|  
Rebels kill four in attack on Thai military  
Nokia cancels X7 phone destined for AT&T: source
|  
'Rubbish hotel' opens in heart of Madrid  
Charges for Aborigine 'cooked' in prison van  
Japan firm makes eco-friendly electronic rickshaw
|  
Gervais defiant as Globes controversy simmers  
HP directors to investigate Hurd departure: filing
|  
New Zealand bomb scare a false alarm: police  
Bieber movie ad to air on post-Bowl "Glee"  
Ernest Borgnine dismissive of modern movies  
Samsung acquires e-paper technology firm Liquavista
|  
Publicist's murder "no conspiracy": police  
US, China ink $45 bln in export deals  
Jennifer Lawrence: the making of an "It" actress  
Seoul shares end 0.4 pct down, techs take breather  
US college students don't learn core skills: study  
KOGAS to buy 20-pct stake of MGM Energy gas reserve  
Texas group to sell 'The Backs' sculptures by Matisse  
China says economy grew 10.3% in 2010  
Bob Dylan rolling out six more books: report  
S.Korea mulls raising inflation-linked bond issues  
Seoul shares slip 0.4 pct, techs take breather  
GM renames S. Korea unit, uses Chevrolet brand  
Apple criticised in China green survey  
Samsung Electronics buys Dutch LCD firm  
Glee and Project Runway among GLAAD award nominees
|  
Pakistan  
Gervais defiant as Globes controversy simmers
|  
Bob Dylan rolling out six more books: report
|  
Johnny Depp may replace Downey in Oz
|  
Jennifer Lawrence: the making of an It actress
|  
American Idol book misses the right notes
|  
Bieber movie ad to air on post-Bowl Glee
|  
Danish cartoonist 'escaped certain death'  
Embattled Irish PM sets election for March 11
|  
Taliban, Pakistan deny Mullah Omar heart attack report  
Amazon to buy full control of UK's Lovefilm  
Korea breakthrough as Seoul agrees to talks with North
|  
NATO and Afghan forces kill 10 insurgents in north  
2010 warmest ever year, says UN weather agency  
Lithuania seeks compensation from Russia  
Sony Ericsson held back by outdated handsets  
2 NATO service members killed in Afghan attacks  
Iran denies coming to atom talks with new swap offer
|  
Japan firm makes eco-friendly electronic rickshaw  
Bomb attacks on Shi'ites, Iraqi police kill 48
|  
Turkey says Lebanese must tackle crisis themselves
|  
Afghan opium crop may rise after cash bonanza
|  
Israeli soldiers kill Palestinian gunman: army
|  
Sony Ericsson quarterly results lag  
Swiss ex-banker faces new probe over WikiLeaks data
|  
At least 207 missing in Brazil floods, 741 dead
|  
Korea breakthrough as Seoul agrees to talks with North  
China leader faces rough welcome in US Congress  
Japan PM 'concerned' over China's defence build-up  
Green group accuses Apple of lax supplier oversight
|  
Raging inflation adds to Pakistan's long list of woes  
Swiss ex-banker faces new probe over WikiLeaks data
|  
China's Hu faces U.S. lawmakers in bid to boost ties  
Sony Ericsson held back by outdated handsets
|  
S.Korea aims to produce lithium from seawater  
China's cabinet approves demolition regulation  
HP directors to investigate Mark Hurd's departure: filing
|  
More foreign wives in Korea seeking legal advice  
Sony Ericsson back in black in 2010  
Hermaphrodite child reported in Indonesia  
S.Korea plans to buy grain elevator at U.S. production site  
China economy grows 10.3%, inflation fears mount  
Japan government finances to worsen: report  
Macy Gray asks fans if she should boycott Israel
|  
A Minute With: Sundance festival director John Cooper
|  
Indonesia prosecutors seek jail in torture trial  
Global 2010 recorded music sales fall about 9 percent
|  
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro  
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found  
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever  
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production  
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time  
AMD to Start Production of piledriver  
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs  
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia  
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air  
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch  
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent  
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up  
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform  
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis  
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets  
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights