Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Analysis: Campaign vow meets harsh Afghan reality
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Analysis: Campaign vow meets harsh Afghan reality
By BETH FOUHY,Associated Press Writer -
1 hour 26 minutes ago
Send
IM Story
Print
NEW YORK – As a presidential candidate, Barack Obama denounced the war in Iraq, saying there is no military solution there. Now he may be forced to decide there is no military solution in Afghanistan, either.
"He really did make a strong point as a candidate about the significance of Afghanistan as the place to fight against terrorism, but it's a lot easier said than done," said Natalie Davis, a political science professor at Alabama's Birmingham-Southern College. "You have a sense now that the current thinking among many around him is that this is a loser, that it really does resemble Vietnam."
Campaign rhetoric is coming up against a tough reality for the president, who now must make a crucial decision about how to proceed in what he's called a war of necessity.
White House spokesman Robert Gibbs said that whatever course Obama chose would be consistent with his pledge during the campaign to treat Afghanistan as the central front in the war on terrorism.
"There isn't a military solution alone to any of this," Gibbs said, but rather "a series of solutions."
At issue is the recent assessment by Gen. Stanley McChrystal, commander of U.S. forces in Afghanistan, that more resources are needed to fight the Taliban or any hope of a military victory is lost. McChrystal has asked for up to 40,000 more troops, a major combat commitment to a mountainous, ungoverned nation that has been a quagmire for every invader.
During the campaign, Obama vowed as president to send two more brigades _ about 7,000 combat troops _ to Afghanistan. He has done that and more, sending 21,000 troops to Afghanistan in March while vowing a new, robust strategy to keep the Taliban from returning to power.
But now, because of McChrystal's report, Obama is weighing the request for additional troops against advice from others on his national security team.
Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton and Richard Holbrooke, the special envoy to Afghanistan, are said to be leaning in favor of a troop increase while Defense Secretary Robert Gates has not signaled his preference. Others are more skeptical, including National Security Adviser Jim Jones and Vice President Joe Biden who wants Obama to consider dialing down U.S. forces in favor of a counterterrorism campaign along the Pakistan border where many al-Qaida operatives are believed to be hiding.
On that score, another campaign pledge could face a test. In August 2007, Obama made a major foreign policy speech in which he said that as president, he might order U.S. troops to breach the Pakistan border and nab terrorism suspects if there were "actionable intelligence" of high-level targets.
Obama's threat of military force in Pakistan was criticized at the time by Clinton, then Obama's chief rival for the Democratic nomination, and by Republican John McCain, the 2008 GOP presidential nominee. Both Clinton and McCain suggested it showed Obama did not understand the complexities of the region and that it undermined the U.S. relationship with Pakistan and its leader at the time, Gen. Pervez Musharraf.
Even now, some of Obama's political allies are warning him against taking such a path, including Gen. Wesley Clark, the former supreme commander of NATO.
"Taking the fight directly into Pakistan with ground forces risks expanding the conflict and undercutting a fragile Pakistani civilian government," Clark wrote in a recent op-ed piece.
Right now, the border is being patrolled by unmanned aircraft, or drones, that have launched missile attacks on dozens of targets. Officials said the drone attacks have succeeded in taking out dozens of suspected terrorists.
Obama finds himself in a situation not unlike that confronting President George W. Bush in early 2007: Whether to buck public opinion and commit thousands of additional troops in a country riven by rivalries with an unstable and possibly illegitimately elected government.
But Bush's quandary was about Iraq. And faced with a growing insurgency and deteriorating military situation, Bush accepted the recommendation of his commanders and sent some 25,000 additional troops. Obama strongly opposed the increase and voted as a senator in May 2007 to cut money for troops there.
The strategy, undertaken just as the Sunni resistance was parting ways with its more hard line al-Qaida allies, worked. It stabilized the country and reduced the violence enough that the U.S. is on track to begin drawing down troops next year.
To be sure, the strategic challenges in Iraq and Afghanistan aren't fully analogous, including the decision to send more troops.
Topographically, Iraq is much less daunting; its hot desert terrain makes a more manageable environment for conventional military maneuvers than does Afghanistan's often snowy and impassable mountains.
Iraq also proved to have no weapons of mass destruction and few if any links to al-Qaida or any other terrorist organizations before the U.S. invasion. Afghanistan, by contrast, served as a safe haven for al-Qaida plotters who launched the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001.
___
EDITOR'S NOTE _ Beth Fouhy covers politics for The Associated Press.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Dem leader faces tough job in crafting health bill AP - 1 hour 26 minutes ago
Afghan battle probe a reminder of war's challenges AP - 1 hour 34 minutes ago
Mild winds aid firefighters in Calif. blaze AP - 1 hour 43 minutes ago
Analysis: Campaign vow meets harsh Afghan reality AP - 1 hour 26 minutes ago
UK-World Summary Reuters - Tuesday, October 6
News Search
Top Stories
Dairy farmers bring Brussels to a standstill
Brazil joins emerging-nation boost to IMF funds
Brazil switches roles with helping hand for IMF
US trio win Nobel Medicine Prize for research on ageing
Victorious F1 driver Vettel now looks to Brazil
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Mother in plea to Elton John over adoption plan
Oldest hominid skeleton sheds light on human origins
T-Rex fails to impress Las Vegas bidders
13 million premature births worldwide: US charity
Nobel guessing game at fever pitch
More Most Viewed »
Ozone hole smaller in 2009 than 2008: WMO
Nanoparticles could pose threat to humans: scientists
Oldest hominid skeleton sheds light on human origins
Implanted tooth helps blind US woman recover sight
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Monday, 5 October 2009 Palestinians slam Abbas over UN Gaza report delay
BAE Systems could still reach deal on corruption case
Berlusconi visits Sicily after landslide kills 23
Welcome to Hawaii Pacific Teleport
Top US adviser doesn't see Taliban returning to power
Pakistan has forces, equipment for Taliban assault: U.S.
| International
|
Head of UN nuclear watchdog sees Iran cooperation
Argentine folk legend Mercedes Sosa dead at 74
Gaza woman freed in last step of soldier-video swap
Fatah and Hamas eye truce deal, but hurdles remain
| International
|
IAEA to inspect Iran's Qom site October 25
Last known rebel leader disarms in Nigeria's delta
| International
|
Five hurt in south Yemen protests: reports
| International
|
Adviser downplays threat of renewed al-Qaida haven
Devices locate kids, parents find peace of mind
Yale lab tech due in court to face murder charge
White House sees progress from talks with Iran
Fires char wildland in Calif., Ariz.
Greenspan says unemployment will top 10 percent
Ex-Ala. judge accused of trading sex for leniency
6 members of Supreme Court attend Catholic Mass
Report: 13 million babies worldwide born premature
Aid push to villages wiped out by Indonesia quake
GOP senator silent on whether Ensign should stay
Latest typhoon kills 16 in northern Philippines
Lavish welcome for Chinese premier in Pyongyang
Traditions fade as China settles nomads in towns
Billions in US aid never reached Pakistan army
NKorea open to nuclear talks: state media
North Korea's Kim woos visiting China Premier
Chinese premier meets Kim Jong Il on NKorea visit
Report: Seized NKorean ship allowed to leave India
Quake jolts south Philippines; no injury reports
Fans feast on undead as `Zombieland' opens to $25M
'Zombieland' top destination at box office
| Entertainment
|
Argentine folk singer Mercedes Sosa dies aged 74
Nick Hornby brings middle-age mindset to new works
Mannequins hit by discrimination -- and loss of face
Argentine singer Mercedes Sosa dies at 74
| Entertainment
|
Author Coetzee eyes Booker triple, Mantel favorite
Nick Hornby brings middle-age mindset to new works
| Entertainment
|
Saudi fires cleric who criticised mixed university
Mother in plea to Elton John over adoption plan
China vows to stand by isolated North Korea
| International
|
Major report details India's infant mortality crisis
Eight US troops die in one of worst Afghan battles
Tensions in Jerusalem after new Al-Aqsa clashes
Some schools reopen in quake-hit Indonesia city
| International
|
Bomb at Pakistani U.N. office, 2 dead: police
| International
|
Abbas faces uproar over deferred war crimes vote
Berlusconi visits Sicily after landslide kills 23
13 million premature births worldwide: US charity
Nobel guessing game at fever pitch
Passenger train derails in Thailand, 5 dead: report
| International
|
Fuel truck explodes near Baghdad airport
Typhoon turns back, dumps rain on northern Philippines
| International
|
IMF takes on bigger role, seeks more funds
Support for Japan's PM above 70 percent: media
| International
|
Support for Japan's PM above 70 percent
Tiger rescued from poacher's trap in Malaysia
3 dead, 4 seriously injured in NY speedboat crash
SKorea seized suspected NKorean cargo containers
T-Mobile USA kicks off corporate Wi-Fi push
| Technology
|
Landslides in Myanmar kill 3
Government finds higher autism figure: 1 in 100
China, NKorea reaffirm relations
China vows to stand by North Korea
Government report questions rescue claims
Samoans join in prayer after tsunami
Schools hold class in tents after Indonesia quake
Hatoyama support at more than 70 percent: poll
Britain offered Libya funds to end IRA support: report
California fires force thousands to evacuate
At least seven dead as Thai train derails: police
Peg Mullen, author of "Unfriendly Fire," dies
US military deaths in Afghanistan region at 774
Reggae artist says NYC man slashed him with sword
Neighbors: Accused Andrews stalker kept to himself
S.Korea c.bank ready to act to check won's rise
Banks, tech plays send Seoul shares down 2.3 pct
Heavy rains hold up search for bodies in Indonesia
Multitasker Beyonce thrives on hectic pace
IMF takes on enhanced global role
Neighbors: Accused Andrews stalker kept to himself
British supermarket chain shelves Fox News: report
Country's Luke Bryan doing his thing with new album
U.S. Prudential mulls sale of South Korean units
CORRECTED: U.S. Prudential mulls sale of South Korean units
Broadway performance canceled when actor falls ill
Korea Hot Stocks
Kiwi dollar higher than govt expected
Tight security, recession dampen Munich beer fest: city
Seoul shares fall after U.S. data;Hana Fin tumbles
Linkin Park frontman resurfaces with side project
Taiwan LCD makers eye China as leverage against rivals
Rock band Cartel mounts comeback after MTV failure
Carrie Fisher journeys through showbiz celebrity
Canada music labels combine to take on U.S. market
Lady Gaga to tour without Kanye West
| Entertainment
|
Multitasker Beyonce thrives on hectic pace
| Entertainment
|
Arrested Development movie script in works
| Entertainment
|
Still a long way to the top for rapper MC Wale
| Entertainment
|
Social Distortion road-testing new songs on tour
| Entertainment
|
Linkin Park frontman resurfaces with side project
| Entertainment
|
Rock band Cartel mounts comeback after MTV failure
| Entertainment
|
Iraq's joint Kurd, Arab, US patrols face big hurdles
Dairy farmers bring Brussels to a standstill
New Afghan vote rules may ensure Karzai victory
| International
|
US-TECH Summary
US trio win Nobel Medicine Prize for research on ageing
Brazil switches roles with helping hand for IMF
Sample audit in Afghan vote gets under way
Vonage unveils mobile app for iPhone, BlackBerry
IT to generate 5.8 million new jobs by 2013: IDC
Suicide bomber kills at least 6 at Iraqi funeral
| International
|
Cutting child mortality 'cheap and achievable'
T-Mobile USA kicks off corporate Wi-Fi push
India floods leave 2.5 million homeless, 250 dead
| International
|
Victorious F1 driver Vettel now looks to Brazil
Kenya leaders deny delay on post-election reform
| International
|
Training, drug use major issues for Afghan police
UK ministers' Pakistan terrorism talks: officials
Greek Socialists work on cabinet with big majority
| International
|
Taliban under attack in area where U.S. soldiers killed
| International
|
Suicide bomber kills 5 at UN office in Pakistan
Microsoft's Ballmer says Web search buys unlikely
| Technology
|
The nation's weather
Five dead as suicide blast hits UN Islamabad office
Vonage unveils mobile app for iPhone, BlackBerry
| Technology
|
President Obama continues health care push Monday
Al-Qaeda number two 'vows to kill Westerners'
China, North Korea laud ties on scrutinized visit
Swine flu vaccine arriving, but don't line up yet
Bomber kills 5 at Pakistani U.N. food office
Analysis: Campaign vow meets harsh Afghan reality
Sarkozy urged to tell Kazakhstan to improve rights
India floods leave 1.5 million homeless: officials
UN closes offices in Pakistan after attack
Exiled Uighur leader Kadeer invited to New Zealand
Japan Post bosses 'must resign by end-October'
Indonesia calls off rescue efforts in quake-hit city
Peace eludes victims of East German secret police
Mazda to raise $1.1 bln, forecasts smaller loss
Japan's Mazda cuts loss forecast
Rain, landslides threaten Indonesian quake victims
Mittal 'may pull $20 bln India steel plant plan'
Edison Chen in 1st movie since sex photo scandal
Japan's Mazda forecasts smaller loss
Filipinos cling to their Christian faith during crisis
"Arrested Development" movie script in works
FACTBOX-S.Korean officials' comments on property boom
GRAPHICS-S.Korea c.bank getting tough on property boom
Author Coetzee eyes Booker triple, Mantel favorite
| Entertainment
|
South Korea's c.bank ready to clamp down on housing boom
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights