Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Obama said to want revised Afghanistan options
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Obama said to want revised Afghanistan options
By BEN FELLER and ANNE GEARAN,Associated Press Writers -
Friday, November 13
Send
IM Story
Print
WASHINGTON – President Barack Obama rejected the Afghanistan war options before him and asked for revisions, his defense secretary said Thursday, after the U.S. ambassador in Kabul argued that a significant U.S. troop increase would only prop up a weak, corruption-tainted government.
Obama's ambassador, Karl Eikenberry, who is also a former commander in Afghanistan, twice in the last week voiced strong dissent against sending large numbers of new forces, according to an administration official. That puts him at odds with the current war commander, Gen. Stanley McChrystal, who is seeking thousands more troops.
Eikenberry's misgivings, expressed in classified cables to Washington, highlight administration concerns that bolstering the American presence in Afghanistan could make the country more reliant on the U.S., not less. He expressed his objections just ahead of Obama's latest war meeting Wednesday.
At the war council meeting, Obama asked for changes in the four options he was given that could alter the dynamic of both how many additional troops are sent to Afghanistan and their timeline in the war zone.
Defense Secretary Robert Gates said the discussion turned on "how can we combine some of the best features of several of the options to maximum good effect." He added: "There is a little more work to do. I do think that we're getting toward the end of this process."
One issue in the discussions, Gates said, has been "How do we signal resolve and at the same time signal to the Afghans and the American people that this isn't an open-ended commitment."
The president wants to clarify how and when U.S. troops would turn over responsibility to the Afghan government, said another official, who spoke on condition of anonymity discuss administration deliberations.
Meanwhile, Richard C. Holbrooke, Obama's special representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan, left late Wednesday for consultations with allies in Berlin, Paris and Moscow. British officials also are expected at some point to join the talks, part of a continuing effort to coordinate with allies, brief them on Obama's strategy review and discuss what more they might contribute in Afghanistan.
The developments underscore U.S. skepticism about the leadership of Afghan President Hamid Karzai, whose government has been dogged by corruption. The emerging administration message is that Obama will not do anything to lock in an open-ended U.S. commitment.
U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton on Thursday voiced a list of concerns about Afghanistan: "corruption, lack of transparency, poor governance, absence of the rule of law."
"We're looking to President Karzai as he forms a new government to take action that will demonstrate _ not just to the international community but first and foremost to his own people _ that his second term will respond the needs that are so manifest," Clinton said during a news conference in Manila with Philippine Foreign Secretary Alberto Romulo.
Obama is still expected to send in more troops to bolster a deteriorating war effort.
He remains close to announcing his revamped war strategy _ troops are just one component _ and probably will do so shortly after he returns from a trip to Asia that ends Nov. 19.
Yet in Wednesday's pivotal war council meeting, Obama wasn't satisfied with any of the Afghanistan war options presented by his national security team, one official said.
Military officials said Obama has asked for a rewrite before and resisted what one official called a one-way highway toward commander McChrystal's recommendations for more troops. The sense that he was being rushed and railroaded has stiffened Obama's resolve to seek information and options beyond military planning, officials said, though a substantial troop increase is still likely.
The president is considering options that include adding 30,000 or more U.S. forces to take on the Taliban in key areas of Afghanistan and to buy time for the Afghan government's inadequate and ill-equipped fighting forces to prepare to take over. The other three options on the table are ranges of troop increases, from a relatively small addition of forces to the roughly 40,000 that McChrystal prefers, according to military and other officials.
The war is now in its ninth year and is claiming U.S. lives at a record pace as military leaders say the Taliban has the upper hand in many parts of the country.
Ambassador Eikenberry, who was the top U.S. military commander in Afghanistan for two years ending in 2007, is a prominent voice among those advising Obama, and his sharp dissent is sure to affect the equation.
The options given to Obama will now be altered, although not overhauled.
Military officials say one approach is a compromise battle plan that would add 30,000 or more U.S. forces atop a record 68,000 in the country now. They described it as "half and half," meaning half fighting and half training and holding ground so the Afghans can regroup.
"The government of Afghanistan has to accept greater responsibility for its own defense," Clinton said Thursday. She had no comment on the Eikenberry memos.
Among the options for Obama would be ways to phase in additional troops, perhaps eventually equaling McChrystal's full request, based on security or other conditions in Afghanistan and troop levels by U.S. allies there.
The White House has chafed under criticism from Republicans and some outside critics that Obama is dragging his feet to make a decision.
Obama's top military advisers have said they are comfortable with the pace of the process, and senior military officials have pointed out that the president still has time since no additional forces could begin flowing into Afghanistan until early next year.
Under the scenario featuring about 30,000 more troops, that number most likely would be assembled from three Army brigades and a Marine Corps contingent, plus a new headquarters operation that would be staffed by 7,000 or more troops, a senior military official said. There would be a heavy emphasis on the training of Afghan forces, and the reinforcements Obama sends could include thousands of U.S. military trainers.
___
Associated Press writers Matthew Lee in Manila, Philippines, and Pamela Hess and Barry Schweid in Washington contributed to this report.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
CDC: Swine flu has sickened 22 million in 6 months AP - 1 hour 52 minutes ago
Suspect in Seattle police killing charged AP - 1 hour 36 minutes ago
Fla. man gets deal in dementia-plagued dad's death AP - 1 hour 33 minutes ago
Army: Fort Hood suspect charged with murder AP - 2 hours 2 minutes ago
Obama announces December forum on finding jobs AP - 2 hours 13 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Obama announces December jobs crisis talks
US new weekly jobless claims fall for second week
Trial to 'regrow' breasts after cancer surgery
Medvedev to set out economic reforms in speech
Kidnapped Irish priest free, in good health: military
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
US salutes 'Mighty Mouse' who ended Fort Hood massacre
New dinosaur discovered in S. Africa
Lack of health care killed 2,266 US veterans last year: study
US takes brown pelican off endangered species list
Kidnapped Irish priest free, in good health: military
More Most Viewed »
Somali centenarian weds 17-year-old
Fibre may keep asthma, diabetes at bay, study finds
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Friday, 13 November 2009 Expelled West Bank student petitions Israel court
Medvedev pushes reforms under Putin's watchful eye
Iraq cable project to slash telecom costs: CEO
Obama announces December jobs crisis talks
APNewsBreak: Diplomats: Iran nuke plant 7 yrs old
Elysee defends Sarkozy's Berlin Wall memories
Gameworld: Academics hope history in video games spurs interest
US new weekly jobless claims fall for second week
Palestinians postpones January polls
Iran exile group: Khamenei tightens intelligence grip
| International
|
Medevedev calls for Russia reforms
Electric cars need government support: Nissan-Renault CEO
Trial to 'regrow' breasts after cancer surgery
Abbas to accept Palestinian election delay
Ex-French minister links Chirac to arms scandal
| International
|
Britons To Watch Footage Of Queen Elizabeth's Coronation In 3-D
GameStop to sell digital game downloads
Owl City Hits #1 Again With "Fireflies" On Billboard Hot 100
Aid freeze in post-coup Honduras hurting poor
| International
|
Cellphone market fall ended in third quarter: Gartner
Carrie Underwood Scores #1 Album With "Play On"
South Africa white police allege discrimination
| International
|
Iraq warns of more violence before elections
Mobile phone sales rise in 3rd quarter: study
Taylor Swift Dominates CMA Awards With 4 Wins
Mike Tyson Arrested After Alleged Paparazzo Punch
WITNESS: Afghan night mission ends in bullets
| International
|
Intel pays AMD $1.25 billion in antitrust case
Nigerian football star sentenced to 40 lashes in Sudan
| International
|
Activision says "Call of Duty" sets launch record
Qualcomm announces multi-mode high-speed chips
Mobile phone sales rise in third quarter: study
APEC ministers credit China with fueling recovery
Fort Hood shooting suspect faces 13 murder charges
Jury to decide mom's mental health in murder trial
Sri Lanka's top general quits ahead of vote
Gates inspects new armored trucks for Afghan war
Apple plans 40-50 store openings in 2010
| Technology
|
US-Japan summit to focus on nuclear arms, climate: reports
Temperature records: More highs than lows
Japanese cheer emperor's 20th year on throne
FDA tackles gray area of social media
| Technology
|
CIA said to have won turf war against intel chief
Obama embarks on debut Asia mission
Lawyer: FBI asked Mass. suspect to be informant
Myanmar junta leader 'thrilled' to be in Sri Lanka
GameStop to sell digital game downloads
| Technology
|
Obama said to want revised Afghanistan options
Japan drops child-snatching case against Tenn. man
Thai ex-Cabinet member sentenced for corruption
Suspected Fort Hood shooter charged with 13 murder counts
Japan's emperor marks 20th anniversary on throne
FBI: Fla. lawyer's alleged fraud over $1 billion
Sri Lanka's top general resigns amid speculation
US Afghan envoy warns against troop surge: reports
George Hamilton to take part in British reality show
The end is near as Hollywood does the apocalypse
IMF sees recovery for Pakistan, country eyes bonds
China to top construction market from 2018: study
Bank of Korea keeps key rate at record low
Taiwan hopes to speed trade pact talks with China
APEC eyes trans-Pacific free-trade zone
Top cable programs for Nov. 2-8
Money returns unevenly to NY art auctions
Currency tensions flare as Obama heads to APEC
Idol champ Allen's CD reflects life on the road
| Entertainment
|
Cyprus tourism drop worsens in October
Deforestation threatens Indonesia's Papua region
John King to replace CNN's departing Lou Dobbs
| Entertainment
|
Pakistan's forex reserves rise to $14.27 bln
Mumbai art show draws on 2008 attacks
Japan 'concerned' over Russia car tariff hike
Jackson's This Is It passes $200 million worldwide
| Entertainment
|
Pakistani stocks end flat; rupee weaker
ABC shows `Hank' the door; another Grammer loss
Golden Globes to honor Scorsese with DeMille award
| Entertainment
|
John King to be replacing Dobbs' show on CNN
First woman pilot joins Britain's Red Arrows
Police: Mike Tyson in scuffle at LA airport
George Hamilton to take part in British reality show
James Taylor, Carole King plan tour together
Suicide blast near US base in Kabul: officials
British Airways, Iberia agree to merge
Intel to pay AMD $1.25 billion in antitrust case
Fewer tress cut down in Brazil's Amazon jungle
Obama eyes compromise strategy on Afghanistan
French ex-minister accuses Chirac over Angola arms sales
Bomber attacks Pakistani intelligence agency; 9 dead
| International
|
FDA tackles gray area of social media
Facebook provides alibi for robbery suspect
Maoists raid logging firm in Philippines, 23 dead
| International
|
Catholic Church needs more Internet savvy: bishop
launches Spanish mobile home page
British ex-PM Blair faces Iraq inquiry next year
| International
|
UK's ruling Labour keeps seat in Scottish fiefdom
| International
|
WITNESS: Afghan night mission ends in bullets
| International
|
Mobile phone sales rise in 3rd quarter: study
Lawyers: Colo. balloon boy parents to plead guilty
Family: Mo. child sex abuse claims are `repulsive'
French envoy: Talks with NKoreans frank, cordial
FDA tackles gray area of social media
| Technology
|
Suicide bombing near US base in Afghanistan: officials
2 dead, 14 hurt in eastern Oregon van rollover
Facebook provides alibi for robbery suspect
| Technology
|
Bombs kill 13 in Pakistan, intel agency targeted
Jury chooses life sentence in TV anchor killing
October U.S. video game sales down 19 percent: NPD
| Technology
|
Obama heads to Japan for first Asia tour
Suicide bombing near US base in Kabul: officials
Clinton applauded predicting Pacquiao boxing win
Police say missing girl seen at NC motel with man
Suu Kyi appeals to top court against house arrest
Texas man drives Bugatti into pond; blames bird
Maoists raid logging firm in Philippines, 23 dead
Fort Hood suspect charged with 13 counts of murder
China probes disappearance of NKorean diplomat
Hawaii to lay off 650 state workers by year's end
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
Australian officials to test 'Ned Kelly' skull
"Modern Warfare 2" blows away launch records
New Zealand PM says to keep free floating exchange rate
World Bank president: inflation a risk to recovery
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
China rejects $28B in steel, chemical projects
The Who to perform at SuperBowl: report
Biz leaders: Asia leading world out of downturn
The Who to perform at SuperBowl: report
| Entertainment
|
Brothel owner fears employee killed in Okla. fire
New Zealand, Hong Kong agree free trade deal
Idol champ Allen's CD reflects life on the road
| Entertainment
|
"2012" set to explode at box office
Report: Toyota plans bigger Prius with new battery
Clicker launches a TV Guide for the Internet
2012 set to explode at box office
| Entertainment
|
APEC ministers credit China with fueling recovery
Palin in book: McCain aides kept me 'bottled up'
Offshore holdings of NZ govt higher in October
Jackson's This Is It passes $200 million worldwide
| Entertainment
|
Next "Saw" horror movie will be in 3-D
Documentary group unveils film award nominees
S.Korea Q3 household income falls 3.3 pct yr/yr
Taylor Swift boosts ratings for country awards
| Entertainment
|
Taylor Swift boosts ratings for country awards
Seoul shares turn lower on U.S. consumer worries
Documentary group unveils film award nominees
| Entertainment
|
Xbox Live boots pirate videogame players
Next Saw horror movie will be in 3-D
| Entertainment
|
Clicker launches a TV Guide for the Internet
| Entertainment
|
Owl City, Rihanna shine on U.S. singles chart
| Entertainment
|
Canadian Winner Of $50 Million Jackpot To Use Money For Stroke Rehab
Parents Of 'Balloon Boy' Pleading Guilty To Felony, Misdemeanor
Britons To Watch Footage Of Queen Elizabeth's Coronation In 3-D
American Idol Meanie Top Earner On Prime Time TV
Nomads Free Irish Hostage In Philippines
Severe Heartburn Affects More Than Stomach; Study Shows Sleep, Work, Sex Life Suffers
Study Cites Side Effect Of Vaginal Cosmetic Surgery
Man Says Jesus To Blame For Drug Accessories
No Health Food For Her: Rihanna Demands Junk Food To Fill Her Dressing Rooms
Michael Jackson's Extravagant Funeral Bill Totaled $1 Million
October U.S. video game sales down 19 percent: NPD
Saudi villages evacuated due Yemen violence
Recession ends across Europe
Google to be taken to court by Swiss watchdog
Russia says one dead in arms depot blasts; report
| International
|
German growth confirms recession ended: statistics
Israeli troops kill Palestinian along Gaza border
'Modern Warfare 2' blows away launch records
Brown wants 5,000 extra foreign troops in Afghanistan
North Korea makes new threat as Obama arrives in Asia
| International
|
Europe to formally exit recession
US videogame sales slide 19 percent in October
S.Africa police have no license to kill; Zuma
| International
|
Israelis seen backing possible talks with Hamas
Man charged over Cindy Crawford extortion bid
Israel kills Palestinian in Gaza confrontation
| International
|
Taliban bomber strikes near US base in Kabul
Israelis seen backing possible talks with Hamas
| International
|
Iran's Supreme Leader cannot be removed
| International
|
France captures 12 suspected Somali pirates
| International
|
Critics say justice reform made to save Berlusconi
| International
|
France will oppose but not ban burqas
| International
|
Kyrgyzstan sharply hikes power, heating bills
Obama says base issue must be solved quickly
Dell to introduce smartphone based on Android
| Technology
|
Philippine president signs anti-torture law
Man pleads not guilty in case that led to bodies
US seeks to seize 4 mosques, tower linked to Iran
Coastal flooding a concern as storm moves up coast
NKorea vows to defend itself after sea clash
Cambodia detains Thai citizen on spy charges
Victims set to testify at evangelist's sentencing
S.Lanka refugees leave Australian ship: Indonesia
Fla. man arrested for calling 911, asking for sex
Major militant attacks in Pakistan since October
Former judge DeLaughter to be sentenced Friday
'23 dead' as Philippine communists, security clash
Communist rebel attack kills 12 in Philippines
Maoists block Nepal government headquarters
Taiwan eyes trade pact with China by end 2010
Japanese megabanks post mixed earnings
Japanese banks Mizuho, Sumitomo on recovery track
Yusuf Islam, aka Cat Stevens, on tour after 33 years
| Entertainment
|
Obama launches Asia tour in Japan
Harry Potter star Radcliffe denies smoking cannabis
| Entertainment
|
Opry, MySpace team up for Underwood performance
Hong Kong economy grows 0.4 percent in 3Q
Young Indians look to dance their way to fame, fortune
S.Korea apartment prices rise for 23rd week
S.Korea GS Shopping to buy $18.5 mln India TV channel stake
Chinese president pledges to boost domestic demand
US commerce secretary: Trade pacts must wait
Shanghai to pay millions to make way for Disney: media
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights