Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Twins' bid to void Facebook settlement meets doubt
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Twins' bid to void Facebook settlement meets doubt
Reuters - Wednesday, January 12
Send
IM Story
Print
Cameron (L) and brother Tyler Winklevoss leave the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals after a hearing on a settlement dispute with Facebook's Mark Zuckerberg in San Francisco, January 11, 2011. REUTERS/Stephen Lam
By Dan Levine and Alexei Oreskovic
SAN FRANCISCO - Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss found a skeptical audience on Tuesday as they tried to persuade a U.S. appeals court to release them from a $65 million settlement over the founding of online social network Facebook.
The saga of the Winklevoss twins and Facebook Chief Executive Mark Zuckerberg became silver screen lore with the release of the film "The Social Network" last year. It has long been a legal battle as well.
Should the case be revived, it could be a big headache for the fast-growing social networking firm, which has seen a frenzy of investor interest for its privately held shares and is being closely-watched for signs that it might eventually stage a blockbuster initial public offering.
The 6-foot, 5-inch brothers were hard to miss in the front row at the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals on Tuesday. The two, Olympic rowers who participated in the 2008 games in Beijing, wore dark suits and listened quietly as a three-judge panel peppered their attorney with questions.
Zuckerberg did not attend the court hearing involving his former Harvard University classmates. In the movie, actor Armie Hammer played both identical twins, who Zuckerberg's character snidely referred to on-screen as the "Winklevi."
The twins, along with Divya Narendra, started a company called ConnectU while at Harvard. They say that Zuckerberg stole their idea. Facebook denies these claims.
The twins argue that based on an internal valuation that Facebook did not disclose, they should have received more Facebook shares as part of their 2008 settlement resolving their lawsuit. Facebook argues it was under no obligation to reveal an internal valuation.
Judge Barry Silverman asked why the twins' attorneys didn't press harder for the internal figure during settlement talks.
"Why didn't you ask about that at the time?" he said.
Winklevoss attorney Jerome Falk argued that Facebook had a legal duty to disclose the information. Facebook attorney E. Mark Rosenkranz disagreed.
"It's called due diligence because it's supposed to be diligent," Rosenkranz said.
He later added that "ConnectU's founders struck a deal that made them very, very rich, and that's making them richer by the day."
After the hearing, Cameron Winklevoss said they are looking forward to a decision.
"I just think it's in the hands of the court," he said.
Facebook has said in court filings that the Winklevoss twins "suffered a bout of settlers' remorse" after agreeing to the deal which had been valued at $65 million. A Facebook representative said via email on Tuesday that the company appreciates the court's time and also looks forward to a decision.
Facebook earned $355 million in net income and $1.2 billion of revenue in 2010's first nine months, according to documents that Goldman Sachs provided to clients last week to entice investors in a special fund set up to invest in the social networking giant.
A growing secondary market has developed for trading private shares of Facebook.
A federal trial court judge refused to allow the twins and Narendra to get out of the settlement. The ConnectU founders then asked the 9th Circuit to revive the lawsuit to its pre-settlement status.
Senior Judge J. Clifford Wallace pointed out on Tuesday that the twins had several lawyers representing them at settlement talks, and that their father was a professor at the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School.
That makes it difficult to believe that anyone took advantage of them, Wallace said.
"I agree my clients were not behind the barn door when brains were passed out," Falk said.
Goldman Sachs and Russia's Digital Sky Technologies this month snagged a deal to invest up to $1.5 billion in Facebook, valuing the world's No. 1 social network at roughly $50 billion -- exceeding the likes of Yahoo Inc and many other large, multinational companies.
Google Inc, operator of the world's No. 1 Internet search engine, has a market capitalization of roughly $197 billion.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
US-TECH Summary Reuters - 33 minutes ago
Singapore moves to curb popular news website Reuters - 34 minutes ago
Phone chats plus Web program help smokers quit: study Reuters - 36 minutes ago
AMD CEO left partly over mobile strategy: source Reuters - 1 hour 16 minutes ago
ConnectU faces skeptical judges in Facebook appeal AFP - Wednesday, January 12
News Search
Top Stories
Europe launches new era of economic coordination
US on guard against chocolate eggs from Canada
World auto sales set to zoom ahead: Ford
Anger grows in Tunisia as 50 reported killed in riots
Planck telescope probes 'cosmic treasure trove'
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Falling blackbirds baffle Arkansas officials
Hasta la Vista: Arnie quits as California governor
Goldman deal 'values Facebook at $50 billion'
Spain lotto winner nearly loses millions by tossing tickets
Brazil's 2010 trade surplus lowest in 8 years: official
More Most Viewed »
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2011 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Wednesday, 12 January 2011 Troops caused $100 million damage: Afghan officials
Russia sets first vote on US arms pact for Friday
Myspace slashing 500 jobs, nearly half its staff
News
News
Anger grows in Tunisia as 50 reported killed in riots
Russia says considering Iran fuel sites offer
Pakistan president appoints aide as Punjab governor
News
News
Verizon to offer iPhone, ending AT&T monopoly
Biden says US will help Afghanistan after pullout
News
Iran come from behind to beat foes Iraq
US-TECH Summary
News
Only a threat of force will halt Iran nukes: Israel
|
US, China spies offer model for military ties: Gates
Biden visits training center for Afghan forces
MySpace lays off nearly half its staff
Assange extradition hearing set
U.S .sees North.Korea becoming direct threat, eyes ICBMs
News
Japan's NTT Docomo, Dai Nippon launch e-book service
Arizona gunman in court as Obama leads mourning
N. Korea and UAE in scoreless stalemate
News
News
Shares of AMD slump following CEO's departure
Muslim policeman shoots Egyptian Christian dead
|
Verizon Wireless to sell $200 iPhone
N. Korea could soon pose direct threat to US: Gates
Verizon stock dips ahead of expected iPhone news
Google names former Microsoft India MD as new India chief
News
Milan readies for men's fashion fest
News
Verizon Wireless ends long wait for iPhone fans
|
Polish researcher patents zero-calorie wafers
Record number of Austrians quit Church last year: data
MySpace lays off nearly half its staff
|
News
News
WikiLeaks activists may seek to quash demand for docs
|
News
News
S.African farmers look for greener pastures abroad
Power cuts strangle Zimbabwe's economic revival
Facebook-Winklevoss twins case goes to court
|
News
Pakistani stocks, o/n rates end down; rupee firms
News
Pakistan to announce monetary policy on Jan 29
Elbit's Elisra unit gets Korean army deal
Japan to buy bonds to support eurozone
News
S.Korea won dips, front-end bonds down on rate view
Jersey Shore star Snooki turns novelist
|
S.Korea regulator to toughen derivative trade rules
Michael Douglas says tumor gone, cancer may be beat
|
Samsung ordered to pay $532 million to creditors
BBC found guilty of age discrimination
|
Shaw Media stands by decision to air Kennedys
|
Four killed, 29 wounded in Kabul suicide attack
German pig cull after dioxin find
Obama to meet Lebanese PM Hariri Wednesday
ConnectU faces skeptical judges in Facebook appeal
Europe launches new era of economic coordination
Ten killed in Sudan ambush as south votes
Twins' bid to void Facebook settlement meets doubt
Australia floods inundate Brisbane, 67 missing
|
Assange vows more leaks, fears death penalty
Netanyahu calls for military threat to Iran
US on guard against chocolate eggs from Canada
Companies warily eye new consumer complaint sites
Assange fears death penalty if extradited to US
Third Kabul bomb attack in a month kills two
|
Israel missile kills Islamic Jihad militant in Gaza
British lawmaker faces jail over expenses
Verizon to offer iPhone, ending AT&T monopoly
Rival Koreas resume contact via border hotline
|
Suicide bomber kills 2 in Afghan capital
Myspace slashing 500 jobs, nearly half its staff
Assange to face extradition hearing next month
Suicide bomber in Afghan capital kills 2
Israel missile kills Islamic Jihad militant in Gaza
|
Suicide bomb in Afghan capital kills 2
Suicide bomb in Afghan capital; 2 dead, 4 wounded
Kazakh voters back campaign to extend leader's rule
|
Iran says talks could be West's last chance: IRNA
|
'Miracle' Aussie baby born during deadly floods
New Brazil restaurant goes to the dogs
Muslim policeman shoots Egyptian Christian dead
Storm kills 10, injures seven in Mozambique
|
Chinese artist says Shanghai studio demolished
Bond is back: 007 film revived after MGM crisis
US defence chief hails 'successful' China visit
Jackson doctor to stand trial for manslaughter
Family of Arizona shooting suspect expresses sorrow
Homeless 'golden voice' web star arrested in LA
N. Korea reopens border hotline with S. Korea
AMD CEO left partly over mobile strategy: source
|
Asia frets over food price hikes
Costly "Terra Nova" sci-fi TV show lands in May
AIG agrees $2.16 billion sale of Taiwan unit
Verizon Wireless ends long wait for iPhone fans
|
Australia floods inundate Brisbane, 67 missing
TIMELINE-The protracted sale of AIG's Taiwan unit
Anne Hathaway, Jessica Biel on "Batman" short-list
Companies warily eye new consumer complaint sites
|
Rival Koreas resume contact via border "hotline"
Seoul shares post fresh historical closing high
Justin Bieber to reprise role on "CSI" in February
Phone chats plus Web program help smokers quit: study
|
Australia's Brisbane besieged by major flood crisis
South Korea Dec household loan growth slows vs Nov
Britney Spears' new single blasts on to radio
China says stealth jet test-flight should not scare U.S.
Singapore moves to curb popular news website
|
Steven Tyler says Aerosmith not dead, plans new album
Japan PM Kan to replace No.2 minister
S. Korea economy posts strong jobs growth
Indian budget airline in $16bn deal with Airbus
South Korea Dec job growth at 7-mth high
Seoul shares rise after U.S. gain, refiners advance
Chinese bank allows yuan trade in US: report
Renault executives deny espionage charge
Judge orders Michael Jackson doctor to stand trial
|
Anne Hathaway, Jessica Biel on Batman short-list
|
Costly Terra Nova sci-fi TV show lands in May
|
Britney Spears' new single blasts on to radio
|
Steven Tyler says Aerosmith not dead, plans new album
|
Justin Bieber to reprise role on CSI in February
|
Oprah Winfrey's OWN draws 18.5 million in first week
|
James Bond to blast back into movie theaters
|
Italian comedy passes Avatar five-day gross record
|
Haitians yearn for change after year in hell
|
Polish president's aides 'pressured air crash pilots'
Singapore moves to curb popular news website
Hezbollah and allies resign from Lebanon government
|
Germany grows record 3.6% in 2010
Suicide bomber kills 17 police and soldiers in Pakistan
|
Phone chats plus Web program help smokers quit: study
Sudan turnout to pass 60 percent threshold: commission
|
Crew under pressure to land Kaczynski plane: Russia
|
Israel army brass and Barak clashed on Iran war: report
|
At least 61 dead in rain-hit Brazil towns
|
Hi tech pays tribute to Eiffel Tower's origins
Kuwaiti PM in Iraq for first visit since war
Companies warily eye new consumer complaint sites
|
Russia hands Poland final plane crash report
Talks could be West's "last chance"- Iran envoy
Buyer says considering IPO for AIG Taiwan unit
Bodies of Frenchmen killed in Niger arrive in Paris
Witness
UK confidence in online shopping rattled by snow: poll
|
Cambodia says investment approvals halved in 2010
Hezbollah, allies to topple Lebanon government
Pakistan Dec inflation revised down to 15.46 pct yr/yr
US insurer AIG to sell Taiwan unit for $2.16bn
Bombings kill 4 Afghan intelligence employees
N. Korea cling to Asian Cup hopes after draw
China's rich live on the lap of luxury
Indonesian man admits to kidnapping, molesting and selling 96 children
Minimum and maximum temperatures in Celsius
Indonesia slams Saudi maid abuse sentence
Cleveland Clinic, MedStar form new medical alliance
Illinois lawmakers pass huge tax hikes to help close $13B deficit
Wisconsin GOP leader ahead in race for national party chair
Enrollment drop in New York archdiocese leaves 3,700 students without a prayer
The Bellamy Brothers claim Britney Spears ripped off their song
Supervalu Shares Drop After 3Q Loss, Lowered Outlook
Thailand raises interest rates to curb inflation
Daniel Craig reprising James Bond role as 23rd Bond film gets go signal
Vaccine cuts shingles rates by more than half
China Southern Airlines' net profit soars in 2010
Former Zuckerberg partners seek reopening of 2008 Facebook legal settlement
Book tells inspiring tale behind King's Speech film
|
S.Korea expands foot-and-mouth vaccination drive
WikiLeaks founder fears he may face death penalty if extradited to U.S.
Pakistan to announce results of T-bills on Wednesday
China's No. 2 to lead Asian charge in Pattaya Open
Viet Nam, EU to kick off FTA negotiations
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights