Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Haiti aid effort marred by slow U.N. response
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
UPDATE 2-Clinton says U.S. deficit now a security issue
25 Feb 2010
Adrenaline addicts seek designer thrills
22 Feb 2010
Orca kills trainer at Florida's SeaWorld
| Video
25 Feb 2010
Dubai Mall partly evacuated after aquarium leak
25 Feb 2010
Obama dominates the room at healthcare summit
25 Feb 2010
UPDATE 2-Clinton says U.S. deficit now a security issue
25 Feb 2010
Obama, Democrats ponder next healthcare moves
| Video
2:21am EST
Dubai Mall partly evacuated after aquarium leak
25 Feb 2010
Nine killed in Taliban attacks in central Kabul
1:24am EST
Giant iceberg breaks off from Antarctic glacier
1:38am EST
Haiti aid effort marred by slow U.N. response
Tom Brown
PORT-AU-PRINCE
Fri Feb 26, 2010 2:05am EST
PORT-AU-PRINCE (Reuters) - Clutching automatic assault rifles, truckloads of U.N. troops patrolled the streets of Haiti's shattered capital on the day after the earthquake hit last month, seemingly oblivious to the misery around them.
World | Natural Disasters
Cries for help from people digging for survivors in collapsed buildings were drowned out by the roar of heavy-duty engines as the troops plowed through Port-au-Prince without stopping to join rescue efforts, much less lead them.
A common sight since they were deployed in 2004, the U.N. troops huddled in the shade of their canopied vehicles.
There were about 9,000 uniformed U.N. peacekeepers stationed in Haiti when the quake struck on January 12 and they were the logical "first responders" to the disaster in the impoverished Caribbean country, whose notoriously weak central government was overwhelmed by the scale of the tragedy.
Initially, however, none of the peacekeepers appeared to be involved in hands-on humanitarian relief in what emergency medical experts describe as the critical first 72 hours after a devastating earthquake strikes.
Their response to the appalling suffering was limited to handling security and looking for looters after the magnitude 7.0 quake leveled much of the capital and took what Haitian President Rene Preval says could be as many as 300,000 lives.
There was looting in the capital, but it paled in comparison with the severity of the humanitarian crisis.
Horribly-injured patients flooded overstretched hospitals, forcing medical staff to decide which patients to treat and which were already too far gone to try saving.
"Doctors played God," said Tyler Marshall, a veteran former Los Angeles Times correspondent working with an international aid group that helped out in a tent city erected at the height of the carnage on the grounds of Port-au-Prince's University Hospital, the country's largest.
Scores of U.N. personnel died in the quake, including Hedi Annabi, head of the U.N. mission that was set up in 2004. That helps explain what many have criticized as a glacially slow kickoff of relief operations after one of history's worst natural disasters.
But in the days and weeks that followed it often seemed that lessons from other disasters were ignored in Haiti as fears of rioting or lawlessness overshadowed concerns about getting aid out quickly.
The U.N.'s top humanitarian aid official, John Holmes, is among those who have chided relief agencies, including the United Nations itself, for doing too little to help Haiti.
"We cannot ... wait for the next emergency for these lessons to be learned," Holmes wrote in a confidential email first published on the website of the journal Foreign Policy.
"There is an urgent need to boost significantly capacity on the ground, to improve coordination, strategic planning and provision of aid," said Holmes.
Edmond Mulet, acting head of the U.N. mission, acknowledged in an interview that it played a limited humanitarian role in the first few days after the earthquake since its operations were effectively decapitated.
"At the very beginning it was very difficult because all the headquarters was completely destroyed and all the leadership of the mission was killed," Mulet told Reuters.
'CRIMINALS AND BANDITS'
Mulet gained notoriety for wielding an iron fist during a previous stint as head of the U.N. mission when he led mostly Brazilian "blue helmet" troops in a successful crackdown on Haiti's heavily armed gangs.
And he has made no secret about juggling the competing needs of relief operations with law enforcement, in his bid to track down the more than 3,000 inmates who took advantage of the earthquake to escape from its main prison.
"We are here also to provide security," he said when asked about the failure of convoys of rifle-wielding U.N. troops to search for people trapped in the rubble of the ruined capital.
"I still have to patrol, I still have to go after all these criminals and bandits that escaped from the national penitentiary, the gang leaders, the criminals, the killers, the kidnappers. I cannot really distract myself from doing that."
The relief mission shifted into higher gear after U.S. troops deployed in large numbers and set up a supply chain to get food and medicine into areas crying out for aid.
But there were still many bottlenecks and setbacks, often involving U.N.-linked food distributions hobbled by inadequate organization, supplies and crowd control.
Unfortunately, U.N. troops in Haiti have over the years gained a reputation for toughness and abuse more than for easing suffering in the poorest country in the Americas.
"The only time I've seen one of these U.N. troops jump out of the back of a truck was to beat up on somebody or take a shot at them," said a member of the U.S. Army's 82nd Airborne Division, as he worked security during a recent aid handout.
"These guys have given all of us in uniform a bad reputation here," he said, asking not to be identified.
Haiti's wrecked infrastructure and poor transport links made it difficult to get aid out and keep it flowing, but that hardly made the situation different from that in other recent disasters around the globe.
'POOREST AND MOST VULNERABLE'
"The poorest and the most vulnerable people tend to live in the regions that are hit the most by natural disasters," said Solomon Kuah, an emergency medical physician based in New York who spent four weeks in Port-au-Prince after the quake.
There are no reliable estimates for the number of survivors who died from injuries due to inadequate medical supplies.
But Henriette Chamouillet, the World Health Organization's representative in Haiti, said everything from staff shortages to bureaucracy and a lack of packing lists snarled the delivery of containers full of medicines from Port-au-Prince's airport to doctors on the ground.
Port-au-Prince sits just 700 miles off the coast of Miami, which is home to a large Haitian-American community, and it seemed absurd that so few of the U.S. troops rushed there spoke French or were accompanied by translators.
One gripping image of chaotic food distributions came when U.S. helicopters offloaded boxes of MREs (Meals Ready to Eat) at a site in the capital. Many Haitians opened them up only to toss them away in disgust because no French or Creole-language instructions were included with the apparently useless packets of dust, explaining that they needed to be mixed with water as part of their preparation.
Rajiv Shah, head of the U.S. Agency for International Development, has touted the Haiti relief mission as "the largest and most successful international search and rescue effort ever assembled in history."
But more than six weeks after the quake hit, the mission is still largely in an emergency response mode. The U.N.'s World Food Program is limiting its food rations to 55-pound (25 kg) bags of rice and the Haitian government estimates that a million quake survivors are still living in the streets in makeshift encampments with no running water or toilets.
Doctors are almost done dealing with traumatic injuries but rehabilitation for some 40,000 amputees and rebuilding Haiti's health infrastructure are among long-term challenges.
"This is really a disaster of Biblical proportions," said Lewis Lucke, who was the USAID director in Iraq before coming to Haiti as U.S. ambassador.
U.N. and other officials have said the global response to Haiti's quake was quicker and more effective than in other recent disasters, including the Asian tsunami that killed 226,000 people in 13 countries in December 2004.
But experts say the United Nations has a lot to learn from smaller, more nimble medical groups like International Medical Corps, or IMC, and Paris-based Medicins Sans Frontieres, along with charities more experienced in distributing aid, such as CARE and Catholic Relief Services.
Kuah, who coordinated relief efforts for IMC, a California-based group that had highly skilled doctors treating patients in Haiti 23 hours after the earthquake struck, stressed the "need for speed" when it comes to saving lives.
"When you ask yourself if there were ways you could have prevented more mortalities or diminished excess mortality, with earthquakes, in particular, it's more timing than anything else," said Kuah.
(Additional reporting by Catherine Bremer, Jackie Frank, Patricia Zengerle, Mica Rosenberg and Andrew Cawthorne; Editing by Kieran Murray)
World
Natural Disasters
More from Reuters
Toyoda meets with LaHood, thanks workers at plant
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Toyota Motor Corp President Akio Toyoda had a "cordial and open" meeting on Thursday with Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood before thanking workers in Kentucky for supporting him during his appearance before Congress.
Taliban attacks in central Kabul kill 14
Job-creation efforts stall again in Congress
U.S. demurs as Israel pushes "crippling" Iran sanctions
Giant iceberg breaks off from Antarctic glacier
Blackstone nails down some commitments to China fund
» More Top News
Special Report:
The Street's jobless recovery
Although profits are back and bonuses are soaring at financial firms and banks, big paydays have not translated into bigger payrolls. Full Article | Related Story
Fixed income hot in slow recovery
Traders return to sell-side fold
Bank crisis CEOs return
Economy
Vancouver 2010:
The best from day tweleve
Canada joined Germany and the U.S. at the top of the medal standings, but it was a bronze medal from Joannie Rochette that captivated the host nation. Slideshow
Yuna obliterates the opposition
Video: Ghana's Snow Leopard ready
The just-add-water-and-freeze strategy
2010 winter olympics
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts.com
Buyouts Europe:
Buyouts Conferences:
Venture Capital Journal
EVCJ
International Financing Review
International Securitisation Report
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Friday, 26 February 2010 Pressure mounts on Israel over Hamas killing
Environmental disaster looms after River Po oil spill
Palm cuts revenue view on weak phone sales
EADS accepts A400M financing offer: France
Turk president urges calm after crisis talks
Vitamin B3 May Help With Stroke Recovery
EU budget chief to enforce Greek cuts
Skipper unveils world's biggest solar-powered boat
Clashes erupt in West Bank town over holy sites
Indonesian student prosecuted over Facebook insult
Article not found
Cablevision to roll out network-DVR in April
Syria and Iran defy Clinton in show of unity
Greece May See Debt Downgrade Due To Deficit Worries
Weekly US jobless claims jump to three-month high
Bloom Energy unveils fuel cell of the future
Libya's Gaddafi urges jihad against Switzerland
|
Mexican Drug Lord Sentenced To 25 Years, Ordered To Forfeit $50 Million In Illicit Profits
Iran, Syria shrug off US call to weaken alliance
Pressure mounts on Israel over Hamas killing
Only plastic between Haiti homeless and storms
|
Pentagon Opens Bidding For Controversial Tanker Contract
"Old Man" Could Face Jail Time For Bank Heists ? Again
University Rapist Allowed To Stay In School
"Real Time With Bill Maher" Returns To HBO February 26
Twenty-one dead, 50 hurt in Bangladesh factory fire
|
New Report Predicts Average House Price Will Continue To Drop
Coca-Cola To Acquire North Amercan Unit Of Bottler CCE
Juarez drug capo's turf war feeds Mexico bloodshed
|
Iran, Syria leaders brush aside US call to weaken alliance
India, Pakistan take 'first step' to rebuild broken trust
Obama, Republicans clash at health summit
Row simmers at US health reform summit
China faces balancing act in Iran nuclear issue
Palm cuts revenue outlook on weak phone sales
|
Myanmar court to rule Friday on Suu Kyi appeal
Japan says willing to sign treaty on child abduction
Cambodia court warns lawyers for KRouge leader
Ex-Guantanamo inmate can sue Australia over 'torture'
Philippines claims third militant scalp
N.Korea blasts war games amid bid to revive nuclear talks
Zheng loses to Chang at Malaysia Open tennis
China may be hiding US Treasury bond purchases: experts
IMF delays loan tranche to Sri Lanka
Mitsubishi signs British wind turbine deal: government
Toyota chief's tears win over forgiving Japan
India invites bidders for long-delayed 3G auction
Suzuki, Nissan, Daihatsu announce recalls in Japan
Tata unit gets $519 bln 'clean technology' car loan
Honda launches sporty hybrid, vows to keep quality
Pakistan's forex reserves rise to $14.37 bln
US Congress poised to approve tourism boost
'Do you speak Deutsch?': Germany acts to promote language
Radiohead's Thom Yorke names new band Atoms For Peace
|
A Minute With: Disney's John Lasseter creating Oscar magic
Odeon, Disney agree deal over 'Alice In Wonderland'
Official: Climate change treaty unlikely this year
US-TECH Summary
Taliban suicide attack kills 14 in Afghan capital
England clarifies law on assisted suicide
'Avatars' can make us better people: study
Taliban attacks in central Kabul kill 14
|
Senior suspects released in Turkey coup probe
Huge explosion shakes Afghan capital: witnesses
Apple board re-elected as company sits on its cash
Italian court throws out case against Berlusconi lawyer
China may be hiding US Treasury bonds: experts
Cuba struggles to preserve past in hard times
|
RBS shares rally after earnings improve
'Zombies' have free speech rights too, US court rules
McCain Fails To Outgrow Presidential Campaign Animosity
Giant iceberg breaks off from Antarctic glacier
|
U.S. says does not seek crippling sanctions on Iran
Microsoft uses law to cripple hacker spam network
Thailand on edge ahead of Thaksin wealth verdict
|
Woman Chronicles Abortion On Twitter, YouTube
Absent Ashton under fire from EU defence ministers
Florida killer whale to stay in park after deadly attack
Turkey hopes releases head off crisis with military
|
Growing fury at Dubai killing reaches Australia
Congressmen Propose Lifting Embargo Of Cuba For U.S. Farm Products
Obama health summit heals few divides
Myanmar court rejects Suu Kyi appeal: court witness
|
U.S. Markets Hit By Jobs Data, Despite Late Rally Still Closed Down
Virtual reality games may help stroke victims recover: study
Israel plans more homes for East Jerusalem: report
|
MTA Fare Hike May Follow Layoffs, Service Cuts
Haiti aid effort marred by slow U.N. response
|
Rihanna, Justin Bieber First Confirmed "Kids Choice Awards" Performers
Australian PM demotes former rock star Garrett
|
Ivory Coast announces new electoral commission
|
US Congress extends anti-terrorism laws
Flawless Kim wins Olympic women's title
Apple's Jobs says cash hoard allows for bold moves
|
US open to peace talks with North Korea
Obama warns Republicans he will pass health care
Indonesian police: suspected smuggler tricked us
Mossad regularly faked Australian passports: ex-agent
Appeal for Myanmar's Suu Kyi release rejected
Taliban claims responsibility for Kabul attacks
Afghan police: 7 die in series of blasts in Kabul
Global Weather-Celsius
Afghan official: 7 dead in Kabul bombing attacks
Hollywood stars, royalty at 'Alice in Wonderland' premiere
S.Korea relishes bigger world role as G20 chair
Battered Japan Airlines to release new figures
Indian growth slow in last quarter of 2009
Air China, Cathay Pacific plan cargo joint venture
Japan factory output rises for 11th straight month
Japan output rises, deflation threatens recovery
Nintendo to launch bigger console in Europe, US next month
Baghdad printers working flat out ahead of Iraq polls
'Little Big Soldier' innovative vehicle for Chan
PAKISTAN
Corrected: Police find body thought to be actor Andrew Koenig
Burton's "Alice" update a wonder to behold
Police find body thought to be actor Andrew Koenig
|
S.Korean bonds edge down on data, regulation talk
Record company EMI files "Down Under" royalties appeal
Whitney Houston dismisses critics, says tour going well
|
Sting to tour with Royal Philharmonic
Black Eyed Peas make history again on U.S. chart
|
Batman comic fetches $1.075 million, rewrites record
Batman comic fetches $1.075 million, rewrites record
|
Hollywood stars, royalty at 'Alice in Wonderland' premiere
Fendi's Lagerfeld colours Milan
Radiohead's Thom Yorke names new band Atoms For Peace
Sting to tour with Royal Philharmonic
|
Burton's Alice update a wonder to behold
|
Woman sues rapper 50 Cent over sex tape
|
Aerosmith, singer end feud for European tour
|
British economic growth data revised upwards
Isolated Australia in social networking craze
UN to review controversial climate panel
Lloyds bank suffers 2009 loss as bad debts rocket
Lloyds bank posts major losses
Sade Remains At #1 On Billboard Albums Chart For Second Week
Dubai cameras shine light on killers' dark arts
|
Hezbollah chief meets Ahmadinejad in Damascus
Booted "Idol" Contest Chris Golightly Sings The Blues At Press Conference
Inked deals lull oil firms, but Iraq risks remain
BBC to slash website, cut radio and imports
UN expected to renew call for Gaza 'war crimes' probe
Greek PM to visit Germany, seeks EU solidarity
|
26 dead in Timbuktu mosque stampede
|
Lebanon arrests six suspected of spying for Israel
|
Israel won't drag Palestinians to violence: Fayyad
|
Cynicism in both India and Pakistan after talks
|
End to bickering urged to achieve new climate pact
Philippines to lower prices on more medicines
Suicide bombers strike in heart of Kabul; 17 dead
Old story is similar to Ala. prof's Mass. shooting
India says up to 9 citizens killed in Afghanistan
Killed trainer's childhood much like SeaWorld show
Thai court seizes $1.4 bln of Thaksin family wealth
NY gov hurt by scandal, no support but plows ahead
China, Kenya to search for ancient Chinese wrecks
Two huge icebergs let loose off Antarctica's coast
Fire races through Bangladesh factory; 21 dead
Snowstorm in Northeast, rain pounds New England
US, Israeli defense chiefs discuss Iran sanctions
Northeast Winter Storm Batters Residents, Causes Delays, NY Death
Thai court to rule on ex-leader Thaksin's wealth
Myanmar court rejects Suu Kyi's appeal for release
Shakira Hooks Up With Rafael Nadal For Latest Video "Gypsy"
"Doctor Who" Premieres April 17 On BBC America
Daughter Witnesses Parents' Murder Suicide
Aerosmith Bury The Hatchet, Announce European Tour
Georgia Man Becomes 10 Billionth iTunes Downloader
Single Engine Plane Crash Leaves Flight Instructor Dead, Student Grappling With Serious Injuries
Bradley Cooper Drops Out Of "War" For Another "Hangover"
Marcia Gay Harden To Co-Host Aspen Film's Oscar Party
Researcher Finds Taxing Unhealthy Food Works Better To Encourage Healthy Eating
Jaguar, Land Rover sales boost India's Tata Motors
India tackles deficit in budget
China stress tests strong currency impact: media
China's Yanchang to explore for Thai gas, oil
German wind power firm to withdraw from Taiwan
South Korea apartment prices rise this week
Seoul shares rise; Hynix, KB Financial retreat
Japan factory output rises, retail sales gain
Hopes fade for Indonesian landslide survivors
State-owned film studio eyes Shanghai listing
3-D films face new test with Burton's Wonderland
|
Ryan Reynolds, Nicolas Cage voice "Croods" cartoon
Black Eyed Peas make history again on U.S. chart
|
EMI files "Down Under" royalties appeal
Hollywood North readies for Bollywood West role
|
Three "ER" alumni cast in pilots
"Crazies" director crazy for genre movies
Slamming the brakes on Games danger-seekers
Crazies director crazy for genre movies
|
Three ER alumni cast in pilots
|
Record company appeals Men At Work rip-off ruling
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights