Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Modernising Bhutan questions where happiness lies
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (0)
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
Flu pandemic may change US flu approach forever
17 Dec 2009
Obama faces healthcare insurrection from left flank
17 Dec 2009
Citi could face heavy U.S. influence for some time
17 Dec 2009
Journalist deaths hit record in 2009: report
17 Dec 2009
MTV deletes "Jersey Shore" punch scene
14 Dec 2009
Citi could face heavy U.S. influence for some time
17 Dec 2009
RIM profit, outlook top forecasts; shares surge
17 Dec 2009
Flu pandemic may change US flu approach forever
17 Dec 2009
HK shares hit 3-wk low; China falls
12:14am EST
U.S. architecture billings index falls in November
16 Dec 2009
Modernising Bhutan questions where happiness lies
Alistair Scrutton
THIMPHU
Thu Dec 17, 2009 7:19pm EST
THIMPHU (Reuters) - It is a sign of the times for Bhutan that a $9 million McKinsey consultancy report to find ways to accelerate Bhutan's economic growth has sparked soul-searching among this isolated and mostly conservative people.
World
For this is a nation famed for being guided by Gross National Happiness, an economic measurement that takes into account indicators ignored by conventional GDP, from recreational time, to forest cover and emotions like anger and envy.
Unnoticed by much of the outside world, Bhutan's new democracy is aiming at a breakneck economic expansion in the next decade of 9 percent a year that would put it on par with the growth ambitions of its huge neighbors India and China.
The question for many in Bhutan is how its "don't worry, be happy" philosophy is compatible with boosting tourism fourfold, building new roads and massive hydroelectric power projects - some being planned with the help of a multinational consultancy.
But Bhutan's new democracy is now facing the reality of ensuring its younger, and more wired, generation, have more jobs, better incomes and good schools.
Underlying this lie worries that if Bhutan does not get it right economically, its new democracy will falter. Its leaders look warily at nearby Nepal, which has suffered protests and economic stagnation chaos since a new democracy emerged in 2006.
"The biggest challenge that worries me is democracy itself," Prime Minister Jigmi Y. Thinley told Reuters in an interview. "In this region and beyond there are so many democracies failing."
"It is not simply to accelerate growth," he added. "I have emphasized that this whole thing again must be put within the context of gross national happiness.
First formulated in the 1970s, GNH has become the guiding principle for Bhutan.
When the young, Oxford-educated Jigme Khesar Namgyel Wangchuck was enthroned as the new king in 2008, and a new parliamentary government was elected, GNH still had pride of place in Bhutan.
It is enshrined in the constitution and recently the national planning commission which oversees the economy was renamed the Gross National Happiness Commission.
"DON'T WORRY, BE HAPPY"
Much of Bhutan still strains at the very idea of globalization. Television was only introduced in 1999. Public smoking is banned and the capital has no traffic lights after residents complained they were unsightly. Around 80 percent of the population lives in villages.
"This is a country where we debate whether to introduce meditation into schools," said Karma Tshiteem, secretary of the Gross National Happiness Commission.
But no longer is GNH a cute and vague concept. It now has an economic edge.
Bhutan's first democratically-elected government has raised expectations among many in this nation of 700,000 people, where more than a fifth lives in poverty on less than $0.70 a day.
Bhutan already has free primary education and health care. It is not uncommon for Indians living on the border to cross over to Bhutan, where they have access to better clinics, residents say. But all this costs money.
Nearly half Bhutan's budget is dependent on official aid -- 23 percent of the budget is funded by India. It is a dependency that irks Bhutan. With aid falling in a global crisis, economic growth will be the only way to fill the funding gap for social programs.
"The idea that economic development is necessary for building a vibrant democracy is seeping in," said Sonam Kinga, vice chairman of the upper house National Council. "Jobs have to be created. There is growing unemployment.
The government is planning to quadruple tourism numbers to around 100,000 a year in the next few years and increase its hydroelectric power capacity from 1,500 MW to 10,000 MW by 2020. Hydroelectric power, sold to India at subsidized rates, is the backbone of the economy. High-end tourism runs second.
Still, plans like boosting tourism numbers or plans to set up an IT park in Thimphu, are raising eyebrows.
"I don't see call centers as being compatible with GNH," said opposition leader Tshering Tobgay. "If there is nine percent growth in isolation there is disconnect. If income disparity grows there is disconnect."
But the government must create jobs. Officials estimate that the global economic crunch may have pushed its growth under seven percent last year -- under the annual average of the last decade. Unemployment is at 4 percent, a historical high.
"It is ironic that in a country where we talk about gross national happiness with every breath, we still have places where there is no electricity, no accessible healthcare, no motorable road and no telephone connectivity," said By Yangchen, a 25-year-old student in Thimphu.
Those are the ideas that worry Bhutan's leaders. The government believes it is up to Bhutan's first democratic government to show voters that GNH can live side by side with economic prosperity.
"The big issue is democracy. If democracy fails, nothing, not even GNH, will save us," said Tobgay.
(Editing by Sugita Katyal)
World
Add a Comment
More from Reuters
U.N. climate negotiators hammer out initial draft
COPENHAGEN (Reuters) - Negotiators facing a Friday deadline hammered out an initial draft U.N. climate pact overnight that calls for a two degree Celsius cap on global temperatures and billions in aid for poor nations, sources said. | Video
Nikkei slips; banks, resource shares fall
| Video
China to stay a plodding "ox" in year of the tiger
Military spending bill clears Senate hurdle
U.S. FINRA launches inquiry into firms' trading tips: report
Super Saturday expectations high for U.S. retailers
» More Top News
Citi's next challenge
Citigroup's plan to extract itself from the government's clutches didn't go as planned. For the bank to succeed, one of two things need to happen. Full Article
Treasury eyes max price for Citi shares
How the Citi stock offering flopped
Citgroup share price
ECONOMY
"We're not asking for a bailout"
If the U.S. is serious about creating jobs it should invest in aviation programs, says the chief of the Aerospace Industries Association. Just don't call it a bailout. Full Article
Defense companies eye deals in 2010
Senate panel concerned over F-35
Is Jet-A addictive?
AEROSPACE & DEFENSE SUMMIT
© Copyright 2009 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts.com
Buyouts Europe:
Buyouts Conferences:
Venture Capital Journal
ECVJ
International Financing Review
International Securitisation Report
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Friday, 18 December 2009 Car bomb near central Baghdad restaurant kills 3
BA wins court battle to stop Christmas strikes
State Department revamps website in Web 2.0 push
CORRECTED
Early snow as cold snap hits northwestern Europe
Serra closer to Brazil candidacy as rival quits
|
Sony's Stringer says e-reader to stay a book device
US jobless claims rise for second week
RIM says BlackBerry email issue resolved
Spain's Catalonia to debate ban on bullfighting
|
Nigeria court dismisses charges against ex-governor
Air France crash report recommends black box change
|
Sony in e-reader deal to offer Wall Street Journal
Sony's Stringer says e-reader to stay a book device
|
More vaccine has US urging swine flu shots for all
RIM says BlackBerry email issue resolved
|
Japan mines toxic e-waste for precious materials
Palm, Verizon may unveil phone tie-up at tech show
|
US dad arrives in Brazil, hopes to take son home
Hewlett-Packard eyes Africa for customer support
|
China is willing to detail emission efforts
Ashanti's mom says crazed fan terrorized her
Bomb kills six on restive Myanmar border
US drone strikes in NW Pakistan 'kill 14'
Wis. cops have jolly good time in Christmas video
12 charged in upstate NY airport immigration sting
NKorea approves French plan to open office
Auditors challenge $1 billion in Afghanistan costs
SEA Games: Malaysia win football, Thailand on top
Guilty plea in leak case from ex-linguist for FBI
Pressure on Pakistani leader to quit; drones kill 12
Ariz. teacher on leave for taking choir to Hooters
What were they thinking? Let's review
Biographical details of Fed Chairman Bernanke
China's Shaolin monks plan deal with travel co.
Pakistan's forex reserves ease to $13.54 billion
Hollywood to film cult Millennium crime trilogy
Oscar-winning actress Jennifer Jones dies at 90
|
Red Hot Chili Peppers guitarist quits, again
|
Fox looks for merchandising bonanza from Avatar
|
A Minute With: Sarah Ferguson on making Young Victoria
|
AP NewsAlert
Jay-Z, Alicia Keys lead singles chart for 5th week
|
London art show cancelled over Liechtenstein row
Paris Pompidou Centre reopens after strike
Hollywood to film cult Millennium crime trilogy
Winfrey donates $1.5M to Atlanta private school
"Basterds," "Precious" among top SAG nominees
French rocker Hallyday in legal action over surgery
Hugh Grant returns to films after 2-year absence
Dozens missing after freighter sinks off Lebanon
British, Irish PMs want early N.Ireland resolution
Coup denied as Pakistan minister blocked from leaving
|
Pentagon plays down security breach with US drones
W.Sahara activist arrives home after hunger strike
Clooney, Cruz lead Hollywood's screen actor nominations
Tale of war and peace in the 2004 tsunami
|
Dozens missing after cargo ship sinks off Lebanon
Sex, hot online search topic for children: Norton
Brazilian confesses to sticking needles into two-year-old
W.Sahara activist heads home, declares triumph
Fired Afghan envoy starts legal action against U.N.
|
France clears Airbus execs of insider trading
Amazon's Kindle reader breaks monthly sales record
Seven killed, 11 injured in Myanmar bombing
|
Microsoft challenged for Bing trademark
Air France crash inquiry doubts Airbus speed monitor safety
Taiwan, China to hold free-trade talks
|
Oracle expects EC green light for Sun bid in January
Berlusconi leaves hospital with appeal for calm
Dozens missing after cargo ship sinks off Lebanon
|
US begins handing out broadband stimulus funds
Mexico drug war raids endanger residents
|
Libraries ask for oversight of Google books product
Venezuela's Chavez accuses Dutch of aggression
|
Blackberry in North America goes down briefly
Modernising Bhutan questions where happiness lies
|
Ex-FBI linguist pleads guilty to leaking secret documents
Palm, Verizon may unveil phone tie-up at tech show
Sony's Stringer says e-reader to stay a book device
Man charged in Washington state triple homicide
Report: Death sentences decline; death rows shrink
Amazon's Kindle reader breaks monthly sales record
|
DNA test sets US inmate free after 35 years in jail
Libraries ask for oversight of Google books product
|
Obama: Santa to use Yellow Room chimney
Hackers steal SKorean-US military secrets
Obama heads to high-risk, uncertain climate talks
Tribunal charges 3rd ex-Khmer Rouge with genocide
Diocese bankruptcy judge unseals victim settlement
Palm shares off as Sprint customer demand tepid
|
Chinese envoy's visit to test Taiwan's Ma
LA police release new sketches of serial killer
Ex-SKorea prime minister arrested in graft probe
Japanese man sentenced to death for stabbing spree
Global Weather-Celsius
Aide quits Paul's Senate campaign after blog post
CA teen charged with shooting friend, burning body
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
Genocide charge for Cambodia's KRouge ex-head of state
Report: Blast in northern Myanmar kills 7
Suspected NKoreans hack war plan for SKorea
Nancy O'Dell says goodbye to `Access Hollywood'
Paparazzo crashes bike into Anne Hathaway's car
Taiwan steel firm to buy stake in Brazil miner
World Bank lends 182 million to Sri Lanka refugees
China protests against Rio-BHP iron ore tie-up
Jetstar in joint venture talks with AirAsia
Avatar director James Cameron back in spotlight
|
PAKISTAN
Man accused of stalking Jennifer Garner and Ben Affleck
|
Bank of Japan vows to step up fight against deflation
Desperate Indonesians sell organs online
Japan central bank leaves interest rate
Record labels seeking profits in T-shirts, tours
|
Estonian Christmas market offers anti-crisis cheer
Coup denied as Pakistan minister blocked from leaving
Mexican pop diva Gloria Trevi marries attorney
FACTBOX-South Korea M&A deals in the pipeline
Korea Life applies for estimated $2 bln IPO
Grammy winner held after playing at drug cartel party
Avatar box office seen topping $75 million in debut
|
Parlez-vous Na'Vi?
Deep sea freediver pushes endurance to the limit
"Avatar" box office seen topping $75 million in debut
Loretta Lynn feels 'great,' is recovering from flu
SAG nods cap busy week for film award watchers
'Big Brother 9' winner released to drug treatment
Greek financial sector is hit by new credit doubts
Hardliners chant Death to Mousavi at Iran rallies
|
Strauss, Trott launch solid England reply
Iraq official confirms Iran incursion in oil area
|
Deutsche Bank staff to share burden of bonus tax
Deutsche Bank to 'globalise' bonus tax pain: report
Ryanair says deal for 200 Boeing aircraft collapses
Infamous work sign stolen at Auschwitz death camp
|
Accused Mumbai attacker retracts confession
|
New genocide charge in Cambodian Khmer Rouge trial
|
Kurdish MPs to stay in Turkish parliament
|
Yemen opposition says govt attacks killed civilians
|
Police: 2 adults, 2 children slain in Utah apt.
Twitter hacked by Iranian Cyber Army?
|
Calif. school team's success linked to Snoop Dogg
Mumbai attacks suspect says he was framed
Google in talks to buy Yelp: report
|
India says it has pulled 30K forces from Kashmir
Twitter briefly blocked by hackers
Suicide bombing at mosque 'kills 11' in NW Pakistan
Domestic violence victim granted asylum in US
'Christmas' Banned From Christmas Song
Minnesota College Student Back On Campus After Facebook Threats
US, Russia close to nuclear deal: foreign ministry
N.Korea leader 'receives letter from Obama'
Palin Blacks Out McCain
French court rules against Google over book copying
|
It's now Democrat vs. Democrat on health care
Farmers return to erupting Philippine volcano
Pennsylvania Poll Has Specter Neck-And-Neck With Conservative Rival
Senator places hold on bill over custody battle
NKorea thanks SKorea for swine flu medicine
Pepsi Passing On Super Bowl Ads
Mumbai gunman recants confession, alleges torture
Free after 35 years; DNA clears Florida inmate
'Iranian Cyber Army' Hacks Twitter
Bomb blast near mosque kills 5 in Pakistan
DNA Evidence Frees Florida Man After 35 Years In Prison
US executions down by half over past decade: report
Report Supports Obama Administration Investment Plans In Broadband
Bomb targets mosque in Pakistan, fatalities feared
Arizona Man Wrestles Bobcat To Death
FEC Elects Petersen Chairman For 2010, Bauerly To Serve As Vice Chair
Suspected suicide bomber kills four in NW Pakistan
Beijing Autos to explore new cooperation with Saab
Delta leads in bidding war for stake in JAL: report
Bank of Japan says won't tolerate deflation
Taiwan dollar near six-week low on Fed, outflows
Chinese confront wrecking ball in property war
Fox says Time Warner Cable may drop Fox TV shows
|
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
"Avatar" director James Cameron back in spotlight
Aussie exhibition evokes yearning for 'simpler' 1980s
Diver Attempting To Fix Leak Has Foot Stuck In Pipe, Dies
'Christmas' Banned From Christmas Song
Minnesota College Student Back On Campus After Facebook Threats
Nazi Sign Missing From Auschwitz Memorial
Salvation Army In Canada Only Halfway Of $16 Million Collection Goal By Christmas Day
Palin Blacks Out McCain
Half Of Canadian Men Are Last-Minute Shoppers
Arizona Man Wrestles Bobcat To Death
Century-Old Convicted Pedophile Released From Prison
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights