Forum Views () 
Forum Replies ()  
 
 
Read more with google mobile :
U.S., British generals lay out complex Afghan picture
| International
|  
 
 
  
  	
  	  
			 
  
  
    
    
    	
		
			
        
            	
            			   
		
            			   
            
    
            
			
			
				
                    
             
                
				
					My Profile 
					 
                    
            
            
                
			
		
  
	
	
    
		
  
	
    
		
          
	
  
 
 
	
	
	
    
		
	
     
Top News
Reuters top ten news stories delivered to your inbox each day.
Subscribe
  
  
	
	
	
    
		
	
 
	 
         
         
		
        
	
  
  
  		
  	You are here:
  
    Home
    
      >
      News 
      
      >
      International 
      
      >
      Article
	
    
		
          
  
 
    
               
      
Home
        
Business & Finance
        
News
        
U.S.
                
Politics
                
International
                
Technology
                
Entertainment
                
Sports
                
Lifestyle
                
Oddly Enough
                
Health
                
Science
                
Special Coverage
                
Video
                
Pictures
                
Your View
                
The Great Debate
                
Blogs
                
Weather
                
Reader Feedback
                
      
	
    
		
	
 
	 
         
         
		
        
	
  
               
      
	
Do More With Reuters
		
RSS
		
Widgets
		
Mobile
		
Podcasts
		
Newsletters
		
Your View
		
Make Reuters My Homepage
	
Partner Services
		
CareerBuilder
		
Affiliate Network
	
Professional Products
		
Support (Customer Zone)
		
Reuters Media
		
Financial Products
	
About Thomson Reuters
 
      
    
	
		
U.S., British generals lay out complex Afghan picture
	
Fri Sep 18, 2009 7:45am EDT
 
	 
 
               
       
	
	
	 
		
			Email | Print | 
Share
 | Reprints | Single Page
	
			[-]
			Text
			[+]
	
	
	
	
      
 
 
		
    
    
By Luke Baker
    
LONDON (Reuters) - In the past two days, one U.S. and three British generals have laid out their thinking on Afghanistan, and in doing so have revealed just how complex and even muddled the effort to defeat the Taliban has become.
    
The latest to speak out was Major General Nick Carter, who will shortly take over command of Britain's 9,000 troops in south Afghanistan, where the Taliban insurgency remains fierce.
    
Carter said on Friday the U.S. and NATO-led coalition, with nearly 100,000 troops on the ground, most of them American, was running out of time, with the need to show success quickly eight years into a war that looks increasingly bogged down.
    
"I absolutely acknowledge that time is not on our side and we have got to show positive trends as quickly as we possibly can," he told BBC radio. "We can't be everywhere, so what we've got to do is focus on achievable directives."
    
At the same time he said talking to the Taliban -- or at least moderate elements within the tribal, Pashtun-dominated movement -- might provide a way forward, putting the insurgency, which has intensified in the past two years, on the back foot.
    
"If we can talk to people then that may well be a much quicker solution than shooting them," he said.
    
While those comments chimed to an extent with Graeme Lamb, a retired British lieutenant general sent to Afghanistan to try to mediate with elements of the Taliban, they didn't go nearly as far as Lamb went in comments on Thursday.
    
Also speaking to the BBC, Lamb appeared to back a policy of buying off moderate Taliban. A former commander in Iraq, he said a similar approach had worked with militants there. "I always said in Iraq, you can buy an insurgency if you have enough money," he said. "These are local people who need to have a dialogue to understand why, and then they have the choice to have a better life.
    
"If somebody is on the wrong side of the wire and is inclined to come back then I have to set the conditions, or we have to set the conditions, whereby that young man comes back in, so he is not a pariah," he said, hinting at payments. "It's not a case of paying him a dollar and he'll stop fighting for a month or two," but about providing opportunities for employment and a better quality of life, he argued. "None of this is rocket science."
    
"HARD AS IRAQ"
    
It may not be rocket science, but Britain's most senior army officer, newly appointed General David Richards, made clear in his first major speech on Thursday that the formula for success was not there yet, even if the ingredients were.
    
Richards, a former NATO commander in Afghanistan who has worked closely with U.S. General David Petraeus, the man overseeing the Afghan effort from Washington, said Afghanistan was a long-haul war.
    
"The ingredients for success in Afghanistan are similar (to those in Iraq), but we have not yet confirmed the correct formula for that country," he told diplomats and military chiefs at Chatham House, a foreign affairs think-tank.
    
Richards, who oversees both Carter and Lamb, may have the more nuanced view of what needs to happen in Afghanistan, but the ultimate decider may well be Petraeus, who sounded a more realist note about the prospects while speaking in London.
    
"The challenges in Afghanistan clearly are significant, but the stakes are also high," he told military and security experts at the Policy Exchange, another think-tank.
    
"In truth it is I think accurate to observe that as in Iraq in 2007, everything in Afghanistan is hard, and it is hard all the time," he said, acknowledging the view of General Stanley McChrystal, the U.S. and NATO commander in Afghanistan, that the situation is serious even if the mission is doable.
    
    
    
      
      
 
      
         		© Thomson Reuters 2009 All rights reserved
    
               
      
	
    
		
 
	
		
 
		
Share:
		
Del.icio.us
		
Digg
		
Mixx
		
Yahoo!
		
Facebook
		
LinkedIn
	
  
      
               
      
 
	
			
 
		
  		    Next Article:
		Merkel makes case for centre-right before election
		
 
			
		
 
	
      
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
	
     
Also On Reuters
Citigroup CEO says $100 million annual pay is too much
Video 
Video: Tooth anchoring a lens restores sight
Blog: First Mac Plus -- owned by Roddenberry -- on auction
  
	
    
						
						
						
	
		
		More International News
    
  
  
		
				Iranian president raises stakes against Israel
  |  Video
				
		
				NATO proposes new era of cooperation with Russia
				
		
				North Korea's nuclear vows fail to sway skeptics
				
		
				Suicide car bomber in Pakistan kills 33
				
		
				Lockerbie bomber launches website claiming innocence
				
		
More International News...
  
	
    
  
	
	
    
     
     
    
    
        
	
    
  
	
    
		
  
  
	
		
		 
	
		
     
		
	 
               
       
      
               
      
	
Related News
		
			
				Casualties hit Italian support for Afghan mission
7:15am EDT
			
				FACTBOX: Military deaths in Afghanistan
7:15am EDT
			
				FACTBOX: Security developments in Afghanistan, Sept 18
7:45am EDT
			
      
	
    
		
          
	
            
                
Featured Broker sponsored link
            
            
                
	
 
	 
         
         
		
        
            
                
            
                
            
                
        
    
  
	
 
	
		
	
    
		
          
  
	
    
		 
Editor's Choice
	
     
Slideshow 
A selection of our best photos from the past 24 hours.  Slideshow 
  
  
	
    
		
          
	
 
	 
         
         
		
        
  
	
    
		
  
 
 
  
 
 
 
	
    
				
Most Popular on Reuters
				
					
					
Articles
					
Video
					
				 
			
			
  
               
      
	
	
		
		
						
				
			
Iranian president raises stakes against Israel  |  Video
				
		
			Study links 45,000 U.S. deaths to lack of insurance
				
		
			China's "cancer villages" bear witness to economic boom
				
		
			"Option" mortgages to explode, officials warn
				
		
			Iran president says Holocaust "pretext" to form Israel
				
		
			NATO hits "reset" button, belatedly
				
		
			NATO proposes new era of cooperation with Russia
				
		
			UPDATE 2-Citigroup CEO says $100 mln annual pay is too much
				
		
			U.S. regulators propose ban on "flash" trading
				
		
			Citigroup CEO says $100 million annual pay is too much
				
		
		
			
			
Most Popular Articles RSS Feed
		
		
      
               
      
	
	
		
            
                  
                  
										
                  Video 
		
    
			
 Yale lab tech charged with murder
    
			 Turkish man declared world's tallest
    
			 Eye-tooth restores sight
    
			 Obama resets missile defense
    
			 Obama shifts gears
    
			 Sweet smell of Tel Aviv centenary
    
			 Namibian seal clubbing video shown
    
			 Merkel's challenge to retain power
    
			 Americans jailed in baby scandal
    
			 Student petrol bombs German school
    
	
		
		
Most Popular Videos RSS Feed
	
	
      
               
      
 
      
	
	
	
	
    
		
 
 
  
 
 
          
  
    
Reuters.com: 
    Help and Contact Us  | 
    Advertise With Us  | 
    Mobile  | 
    Newsletters  | 
    RSS  | 
    Labs  | 
    Journalism Handbook  | 
    Archive  | 
    Site Index  | 
    Video Index
    
Thomson Reuters Corporate: 
		Copyright  | 
		Disclaimer  | 
		Privacy  | 
		Professional Products  | 
		Professional Products Support  | 
		About Thomson Reuters  | 
    Careers
  	
 
  	
International Editions:
  	
  	Africa  | 
  	Arabic  | 
  	Argentina  | 
  	Brazil  | 
  	Canada  | 
  	China  | 
  	France  | 
  	Germany  | 
  	India  | 
  	Italy  | 
  	Japan  | 
  	Latin America  | 
  	Mexico  | 
  	Russia  | 
  	Spain  | 
  	United Kingdom  | 
  	United States
    
 
    
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
    
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
  
 
 
     
 
 
 
 
 
 
    
 
Other News on Friday, 18 September 2009 Karzai defends Afghan vote  
EU head calls time on 'bonus bubble'  
Iranian regime's forces warn opposition over rally  
Wall Street Journal to charge for mobile access from Oct 24  
U.S. doubts U.N. report on possible Israel war crimes
| International
|  
World's big polluters kick off climate talks in Washington  
Taiwan reviews high-tech curbs on China investment: official  
IAEA denies report it is sure Iran seeking atom bomb
| International
|  
US-TECH Summary  
US home building lifted by apartment sector  
Scientists create digital models of World Heritage sites  
Ebay petitions EU to stop blocks on Internet trade  
U.S. military shuts largest detainee camp in Iraq  
Italy antitrust chief warns Google of heavy fines  
Iraqi man shot by U.S. forces after throwing shoe
| International
|  
Twitter funding would value it at $1 billion: report  
Israel defence chief: Iran not an existential threat  
Virtual reality used for blind to map real world  
Israel fears more Mumbai-like attacks in India soon
| International
|  
Sony Pictures takes side of "Defendor"  
Colo. man faces more questioning in terror probe  
GOP seeks Afghanistan info; Gates urges patience  
Google CEO questions Murdoch's online pay plan
| Technology
|  
Mafia assassin gets life for 4 NYC murders  
Myanmar announces amnesty for 7,114 prisoners  
Obama, Baucus pitch U.S. healthcare reform plan  
Phone exclusivity limits may make sense: Sprint CEO
| Technology
|  
Pakistan: Al-Qaida commander killed in US strike  
La. court: Rehire cop fired after taped beating  
Mass. lawyer pleads not guilty to bear-hug assault  
New Univision Networks president embodies future  
Vietnam memorial seeks photos of fallen soldiers  
Scientists create digital models of World Heritage sites
| Technology
|  
Myanmar grants amnesty to 7,000 prisoners  
U.S. replaces Bush plan for Europe missile shield  
AP source: Yale suspect's work attitude examined  
Nokia Siemens says makes first LTE call
| Technology
|  
Despite stroke, humorist Keillor not slowing down  
Pakistan: Al-Qaida commanders killed in US strikes  
Electric bikes start to gain traction
| Technology
|  
Testimony finishes at Cambodian Khmer Rouge trial  
Police: Terrorism mastermind Noordin Top dead  
China reports 9 dead, 9 missing from typhoon  
China, Russia navies on joint anti-piracy patrols  
China to keep loose monetary policy through next year: report  
Ex-Philippine president files libel case vs tycoon  
Emmy Countdown: Justin Timberlake, `Emmylover'  
Pakistan to hold T-bill auction on Sept. 25  
FTSE keeps Taiwan at advanced emerging mkt status  
FACTBOX-Five facts about Bank of Korea Governor Lee  
TV dance show makes peace with U.S. gay community
| Entertainment
|  
Carrie Ann Inaba trades ballroom for Emmy red carpet
| Entertainment
|  
Kazakhs unveil vast new electricity grid  
Pakistan's July-August c/a deficit narrows to $527 mln  
Suck takes bite at Twilight vampires
| Entertainment
|  
Overview of Indonesia's struggle with terrorism  
Ex-Clash stars re-record song to aid convicts
| Entertainment
|  
Paris is love/hate affair for Juliette Binoche
| Entertainment
|  
Rap duo Calle 13 leads Latin Grammy nominees
| Entertainment
|  
Ex-Clash stars re-record song to aid convicts  
PUBLISHERS WEEKLY BEST-SELLERS  
More British men seeking smaller 'moobs': figures  
Calle 13, Luis Enrique among Latin Grammy nominees  
China's Ai Weiwei: an artist with politics on his mind  
Designers return to kick-start London Fashion Week  
China tells tourists to boycott Taiwan city over Dalai Lama: report  
Chris Brown begins community service in Virginia  
Stage spectacular 'Ben Hur Live' opens in London  
Emmy Countdown: Justin Timberlake, `Emmylover'  
Europe agrees to claw back bankers' bonuses  
Afghan missions needs 'sustained commitment': US  
US-TECH Summary  
EU divided on German 'Tobin' tax proposal  
CORRECTION: HP snags Web pioneer Andreessen for board  
U.S. envoy resumes push for Israel settlement deal
| International
|  
Karzai rules out new Afghan vote round over fraud  
Spain sees Iceland, Croatia as EU members in 2010: FM  
EU leaders agree extra bonus clawback provisions  
More space business beckons for private transporters  
Google CEO questions Murdoch's online pay plan  
World's big polluters kick off climate talks in Washington  
US home building lifted by apartment sector  
U.S. judge orders Kuwaiti held at Guantanamo freed
| International
|  
Iran security forces clash with protesters: witness
| International
|  
Barak says nuke-armed Iran couldn't destroy Israel  
North Korea's nuclear arms aimed at South: official
| International
|  
Syria demands probe of former Hariri investigator  
France defends operation to close migrant 'jungle'  
Electric bikes start to gain traction  
IAEA denies report it is sure Iran seeking atom bomb  
Suspected suicide blast in Pakistan kills 12
| International
|  
Nokia Siemens says makes first LTE call  
Japan new cabinet targets waste, to keep stimulus
| International
|  
Google digital books can become instant paperbacks  
Netanyahu to world: Back Israeli self-defense  
Indonesia urged to stay alert for militant attacks
| International
|  
U.S. doubts U.N. report on possible Israel war crimes  
Death toll in Somalia suicide blasts rises to 14
| International
|  
Italy's migrant crackdown sparks political tensions
| International
|  
Iraqi shot after throwing slipper at US patrol  
Nokia Siemens says makes first LTE call  
Google CEO questions Murdoch's online pay plan
| Technology
|  
Two dead, 12 hurt in Beijing knife attacks  
England cricket captain calls for character after loss  
HP snags Web pioneer Andreessen for board
| Technology
|  
Wave of deaths hits Bangladesh zoo  
Malaysia wants militant leader Noordin's body  
Obama revamps Bush-era missile shield  
N.Korea's nuclear arms aimed at South  
Ahmadinejad says he regrets deaths of protestors  
More space business beckons for private transporters
| Technology
|  
Australian court extends sentence in diving death  
Mass. House approves Sen. Kennedy succession bill  
Afghan president defends vote, admits some bias  
Indonesia cannot relax militant fight: Australia PM  
Calif. man convicted in nationwide anthrax scare  
US to see if Japan has 'revised' thinking on NKorea  
Iran has no need of nuclear arms: Ahmadinejad  
AP NewsAlert  
Terror mastermind Noordin dead in Indonesia raid: police  
Dogs find scent in Calif. kidnap suspect's yard  
Teen indicted in shooting outside NJ roller rink  
US military deaths in Afghanistan region at 760  
BUY OR SELL-Taiwan insurers rally on China, but for how long?  
Maldives aims for action behind words on climate change  
S.Korea banks agree on need for property response  
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary  
Korea Hot Stocks- Hanwha up on Greece metro order  
Seoul shares flat; energy stocks up on foreign buying  
S.Korea T-bonds steady on auction, policy tension  
Black Eyed Peas, "Glee" fire up singles chart  
Jay-Z set to extend reign on albums chart  
Seoul shares recoup initial losses on foreign buying  
Curb Your Enthusiasm rounds up Seinfeld gang
| Entertainment
|  
Nissan NA to export engines to Japan  
Gelbart's colleagues remember master of masters
| Entertainment
|  
"Curb Your Enthusiasm" rounds up "Seinfeld" gang  
Chinese car maker BYD aiming to zoom past Toyota  
Aniston, Eckhart fail to click in "Love Happens"  
Jay-Z set to extend reign on albums chart
| Entertainment
|  
Aniston, Eckhart fail to click in Love Happens
| Entertainment
|  
WALL-E screenwriters receive Humanitas honor
| Entertainment
|  
Pakistan minister vows to revise blasphemy law  
France submits Audiard's Prophet to Oscars
| Entertainment
|  
Growing up alone: Girls on film at Toronto festival  
Black Eyed Peas, Glee fire up singles chart
| Entertainment
|  
Billy Ray Cyrus to star in Hallmark movie
| Entertainment
|  
Growing up alone: Girls on film at Toronto festival
| Entertainment
|  
New movie "Suck" takes bite at "Twilight" vampires  
Iranian president raises stakes against Israel
| International
|  
NATO calls for linking of US, Russia missile defences  
Panasonic develops bed that turns into wheelchair  
German producer prices shed 6.9% in August: data  
NATO wants to review security challenges with Russia  
Fed plans to approve banking salaries: report  
Israelis welcome Jewish New Year  
NATO proposes new era of cooperation with Russia
| International
|  
Lloyds bank to join govt's toxic asset plan: report  
Thousands march in Iran opposition protests  
Brown says G20 must coordinate exit strategies  
Lockerbie bomber launches website claiming innocence
| International
|  
Iranian hardliners attack opposition leader Mousavi  
U.S., British generals lay out complex Afghan picture
| International
|  
Iran regime battles new mass protests  
Merkel makes case for centre-right before election
| International
|  
Iran president says Holocaust "pretext" to form Israel  
Somali government says rebels have more car bombs ready
| International
|  
Turkish army seeks extension of n. Iraq mandate: TV
| International
|  
U.S. judge orders Kuwaiti held at Guantanamo freed  
NY prosecutor is summing up case vs Astor's son  
Ill. woman dies after catching fire during surgery  
Google revamps DoubleClick exchange
| Technology
|  
US Mideast envoy fails to strike settlement deal  
Psychiatrists call for action on anorexia sites
| Technology
|  
Microsoft files lawsuits against malvertisers
| Technology
|  
Lobby calls for EU scrutiny of Google book deal
| Technology
|  
Maine lobsterman, victim indicted in turf war  
UN official presses Sri Lanka to free war-displaced  
Suicide blast kills at least 10 in Pakistan: police  
In hundreds of cities, parking space become parks  
Suspected suicide bomb kills 5 in Pakistan market  
'One year of hell' for Philippine conflict displaced  
US battles for credibility on climate change  
Japan's new govt to suspend part of extra budget  
More fights ahead in Congress over health care  
China envoy meets North Korea's Kim Jong-il  
Ohio couple gets car stolen after auto accident  
More space business beckons for private transporters
| Technology
|  
Myanmar's Suu Kyi to hear appeal result in October  
Philippine police kill 4 kidnappers; rescue trader  
Polls give Japan's new Cabinet strong support  
Ex-Morgan Stanley banker jailed for 7 years in HK  
Report: American Airlines in joint bid to help JAL  
Taiwan dollar off 3-mth high; but seen stronger  
Ex-Morgan Stanley banker gets 7 years jail in HK  
Pakistani stocks gain over 2 pct to hit year's high  
SKorea prosecutors reject porn piracy charges  
JAL offered lifeline by American Airlines, BA, Qantas  
Seoul shares at new 15-mth high on foreign buying  
China approves Nasdaq-style board's first IPOs  
Goulash gluttons nation Hungary learns fine cuisine  
Serbias gays still fighting for acceptance  
Man who tried to get in Seacrest's car arrested  
Chinese suit maker soars on Buffett endorsement  
American and Muslim, Sufi mystics band goes global  
"WALL-E" screenwriters receive Humanitas honor  
Gelbart's colleagues remember "master of masters"  
France submits Audiard's "Prophet" to Oscars  
Billy Ray Cyrus to star in Hallmark movie  
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro  
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found  
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever  
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production  
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time  
AMD to Start Production of piledriver  
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs  
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia  
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air  
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch  
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent  
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up  
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform  
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis  
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets  
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights