Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
How were Social Security numbers given away?
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Search
Search:
How were Social Security numbers given away?
By HOLLY RAMER,Associated Press Writer AP - Monday, August 17
CONCORD, N.H. - When Tropical Storm Chata'an struck the Federated States of Micronesia in 2002, the U.S. government sent 1,300 blankets, 4,000 disposable diapers, 30 cases of sardines _ and my Social Security number.
ADVERTISEMENT
The nine digits that govern so much of Americans' identities are supposed to be ours for life _ and only ours. But mine ended up linked to a Micronesian man who defaulted on a disaster loan from the U.S. Small Business Administration.
I didn't find out until March, in a letter from a debt collector threatening to garnish my wages if I didn't pay $7,306 in two days. The same could happen to an unknown number of others, because of a processing glitch that the U.S. Social Security Administration didn't even know existed and the federal government hasn't fixed.
Who is giving away American Social Security numbers to strangers in other lands? The answer is not so simple.
The problem involves three Pacific island nations, each of which has its own, independent Social Security Administration. The three _ the Federated States of Micronesia, the Republic of the Marshall Islands and the Republic of Palau _ grant defense rights in the region to the U.S., and in exchange receive aid, including grants and loans after disasters.
For instance, the Federal Emergency Management Agency sent $20 million to 9,700 people in the Federated States of Micronesia after the 2002 storm. The three countries together have received USDA housing grants and loans worth $33 million since 2000.
Some federal agencies collect locally-issued Social Security numbers from grant and loan applicants and report them to credit bureaus as if they were U.S. numbers, regardless of whether the numbers already are in use.
That's the beginning of the problem, which isn't identity theft but can create some of the same headaches when identities become linked in the eyes of lenders or creditors.
"This can really slow you down if there is a default or a history of bad payment," said Chris Jay Hoofnagle, director of information privacy programs at the Berkeley Center for Law and Technology.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture has known for years that it creates "overlapping" Social Security numbers when granting loans in the three island nations, said Donald Etes of the agency's rural development office in Hawaii. The office that processes loans is working on a fix, but there have been no software or policy changes yet, he said.
My own case _ involving a Micronesian man who failed to repay an SBA loan _ illustrates how the resulting hassles play out and also shows that I'm probably not alone. Of 299 people in Micronesia who took out SBA loans, more than 200 haven't paid up, increasing the odds that others have shared my experience. No one has a good estimate of numbers.
The collection agency told me the debt, though listed under another name, was associated with my Social Security number. Despite knowing I wasn't at fault, I felt my face grow hot as the debt collector rattled off a list of everywhere I had ever lived.
"You've never had any debt like this?" he pressed. "NEVER?"
He backed off within days, but I spent weeks calling and e-mailing federal agencies, banks, credit bureaus and collection agencies in four countries and five time zones trying to untangle the rest. In many cases, no one could explain why it happened, because they weren't convinced it could happen.
It turns out that Social Security numbers in two of the three Pacific Island nations don't even have nine digits like U.S. numbers. They have eight, but some U.S. computers automatically add a zero to the front to fill in the blank.
Sometimes, that creates new numbers beginning with a double-zero _ just like New Hampshire's Social Security numbers, and Maine's.
Bottom line: If your U.S. number starts with 002-6, 003-9, 005-7 or 007-8, it could match a number in Micronesia. Numbers that start 006-4 could match numbers in Palau. Those that start with 004 could match numbers in the Marshall Islands.
That works out to roughly 135,000 possible matches, according to an Associated Press comparison of the numbering systems. But no one knows how many actually exist.
Jeff Whitcomb of Keene, N.H., had no idea that public record databases show his Social Security number linked to someone in Micronesia, but he wasn't overly alarmed. As far as he knows, he hasn't been harmed by the connection.
"It seems to me it's likely an innocent mistake, but one that bears watching," he said. "It makes me want to most definitely do business with small, local financial institutions that know me, and not just my Social Security number."
Do other factors contribute to the identity sharing?
The region's major financial player _ the Bank of Guam _ says it differentiates between local Social Security numbers and U.S. numbers, but won't say how.
None of the three major credit reporting agencies has any way to distinguish between U.S. Social Security numbers and those issued in the three island nations, said industry spokesman Norm Magnuson, who answered questions on behalf of all three agencies.
Surely the four nations' Social Security administrations were aware of this, right? Not a one.
"I thought U.S. government agencies only accepted U.S.-assigned numbers," said Gregory Ngirmang, head of the Republic of Palau Social Security Administration.
The credit bureaus say call the Social Security Administration. But Social Security mainly cares about crediting wages earned by American workers to the right person. If that's not an issue, it's not their problem.
Social Security says try the credit bureaus, or the Federal Trade Commission. But the FTC investigates identity theft, and this isn't theft.
"This is the trouble consumers have. There are obvious questions that need answers, and they don't have to answer you," said Evan Hendricks, author of "Credit Scores and Credit Reports." "You're sort of highlighting how wrong things can go, and how powerless you are to do anything."
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: World
Hurricane Camille's fury remembered 40 years laterAP - Monday, August 17
Israeli soldier stole from military chief's officeAP - Monday, August 17
Tropical Storm Claudette threatens Fla. PanhandleAP - 1 hour 56 minutes ago
Iraq postpones census over fears of ethnic strifeAP - Monday, August 17
Gene variant predicts hepatitis treatment successAP - Monday, August 17
Most Popular – World
Viewed
Don't brush with baldness: put down that comb
In death, as in life, Jackson surrounded by wackiness
Singer George Michael arrested after car crash
Millions of salmon fail to turn up in Canada
Eternal resting spot next to Marilyn Monroe to be auctioned
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Monday, 17 August 2009 Israeli soldier stole from military chief's office
Iran releases French teacher on bail: Elysee
| International
|
IBM uses DNA to make next-gen microchips
North Korea to reopen border with South: report
| International
|
Bombs kill at least 8 people in Iraq market
Too gung-ho? Israel military rabbis draw criticism
At least 6 killed by bombs at Baghdad restaurant
| International
|
Afghan govt says over 30 rebels killed
Qaeda stronger as blasts feed Iraqi Kurd-Arab feud
Single exit compounded deaths in Kuwait wedding fire
Iraqi worries grow as blast walls vanish
IBM uses DNA to make next-gen microchips
| Technology
|
Hurricane Camille's fury remembered 40 years later
US condemns return of Afghan warlord as vote looms
Gene variant predicts hepatitis treatment success
Iran dispatches China 70-52 for Asian crown
Hawaii's marks 50th anniversary of statehood
Official: 13 die in floods in northwest Pakistan
Hawaii plans quiet, sobering 50th anniversary
Afghans told they can vote _ as mortar shells fly
How were Social Security numbers given away?
Karzai's image down as Afghan election approaches
GOP senator: People have lost confidence in gov't
NKorea says Kim Jong Il met Hyundai Group chief
Hat-trick man Lin makes badminton history
Congressman says Obama able to keep tax pledge
Thai elephant takes 1st steps with artificial leg
North Korea in nuclear threat, Kim meets Hyundai boss
NYC schools prepare for 2nd outbreak of swine flu
1,000 still stuck in Taiwan as foreign aid arrives
Gov't recommends child care plan if swine flu hits
Sebelius: Public insurance option not essential
North Korea's Kim Jong-il meets Hyundai chairwoman
'District 9' lifts off with No. 1 weekend at $37M
Alien action film District 9 tops box office
| Entertainment
|
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Alien action film "District 9" tops box office
'District 9' lifts off with No. 1 weekend at $37M
'Don't worry be curry': Germany celebrates currywurst
Carnival mood for Mumbai's gay Pride march
Russian punk rockers rage against the Putin machine
Turkmen join Arabs to stop vote on Iraq oil province
Rescue effort for stranded climber in Pakistan called off
Last hours of campaign, Karzai seeks warlord edge
| International
|
Smoke-spewing Trabant poised for rebirth as electric car
Tropical storms race toward the Caribbean
North Korea reopens to South as economy weakens
| International
|
Robots at war: will humans stay in the loop?
Obamas marvel at Grand Canyon
More British deaths as PM says Afghan mission 'vital'
Indian PM says Pakistan groups planning new attacks
| International
|
Ahmadinejad plans female ministers in Iran cabinet
Taiwan searches for blame, causes after deadly typhoon
| International
|
Peres poems turned to song for his 86th birthday
Leader of banned Pakistan militant group shot dead
| International
|
Iran could release French researcher within hours: French FM
At least 11 dead in bombing in Russia's Ingushetia
| International
|
Taliban directly threaten Afghan polls
Thai red shirts rally, seek pardon for Thaksin
| International
|
Bombs kill at least 8 people in Iraq market
Suspected rebels attack U.N. compound in Somalia
| International
|
At least 6 killed by bombs at Baghdad restaurant
Pakistani troops hurt in suicide bombing
UK pilot 'killed' in Malaysia testing new plane
Taiwan must airlift many typhoon victims: govt
Man stabs himself outside Japan parliament: police
SKorean golfers celebrate Yang's historic PGA win
AP IMPACT: Banks added 10,000 branches in boom
UN probes Aboriginal discrimination allegations
North Korea, its economy weaker, reopens to South
Police: NY man beaten in racially charged robbery
Strong quake rattles southern Japan, Taiwan
Late deal averts crippling Bay Area rail strike
Pro wrestler Angle charged with HGH possession
China's nuclear envoy to visit North Korea: report
Earthquake rattles Taiwan, no reports of damage
Obama birthplace flap evokes Chester Arthur debate
Go West, Mr. President, to America's wilderness
Scars linger from killer Montana earthquake of '59
Obama softens on 'public option' in health care debate
China must adapt to EU rules on fishing: study
RPT-NZ services sector in first expansion in 16 months
20 years on, East Germans relive flight to freedom
Alien action film District 9 tops box office
| Entertainment
|
Jay Farrar, Ben Gibbard pay tribute to Kerouac
| Entertainment
|
Weinstein Co in dire need of a hit: NY Times
| Entertainment
|
Jay Farrar, Ben Gibbard pay tribute to Kerouac
Multi-pronged career keeps guitarist Haynes busy
Ex-Disney chief's series proves desperately unfunny
| Entertainment
|
Ex-Disney chief's series proves desperately unfunny
Rotterdam: cyclists' haven in Europe's largest port
Multi-pronged career keeps guitarist Haynes busy
| Entertainment
|
Alien thriller 'District 9' lands at box office top spot
With Obama in office, Fox News finds its stride
Iraq cabinet approves vote on U.S. security pact
Russia truck bomb attack 'kills 20'
US-TECH Summary
Eurozone trade surplus doubles in June
Pandas could be extinct in 2-3 generations: report
Palestinian leader stresses talks, not "resistance"
Struggling Sony Ericsson taps new head
Dozens missing after accident at Siberia power station
Karroubi 'should be lashed' over rape claims: Iran cleric
Reformist Iran newspaper shut down
Spanair crash result of human, technical error
| International
|
Mubarak says peace first, normalisation with Israel second
Russia says finds missing ship, crew alive
| International
|
Mass rally on last Afghan campaign day
Iran police clash with protesters over daily
| International
|
Israeli troops shoot Egyptian policeman at border
Human Rights Watch: Iraqi gays tortured and killed
US soldier killed in Afghanistan
Iraq cabinet approves vote on U.S. security pact
| International
|
US-TECH Summary
Struggling Sony Ericsson taps Nordberg as new head
IBM uses DNA to make next-gen microchips
| Technology
|
Telecom operators hurt selling iPhones
| Technology
|
Struggling Sony Ericsson taps Nordberg as new head
| Technology
|
U.S. videogame sales down 29 percent in July
| Technology
|
Republican Huckabee supports Israeli settlements
Bird's Nest, SARS enter Chinese dictionary
US senators talk terrorism, Gitmo issues in Yemen
N.Korea restarts S.Korea tours in conciliatory gesture
Dean: Public option a must for health care reform
NKorea agrees to resume tours, family reunions
Obama to update veterans on Iraq, Afghanistan
First hurricane of Atlantic season gains strength
Strong quake hits off Japan, tsunami advisory issued
Dell developing mobile devices for China Mobile
| Technology
|
Immigration trial for Egyptian student to begin
Supporters seek pardon for fugitive former Thai PM
Program cut to hurt NV, nation's driest state
Obama to address VFW on Monday
US relief team arrives in Taiwan to transport aid
Hundreds allowed to go home amid Calif. wildfires
Suu Kyi's US 'guest' receives medical treatment
Australian inquiry slams wildfire failures
US civilian killed in eastern Afghanistan
China sends envoy to Washington on tire case
Pakistani stocks end lower, rupee flat after rate cut
Taiwan dollar hit over 1-mth low on fund outflows
Pakistan's foreign investment falls to $195.6 mln
Q+A-What can be done to fire up Pakistan's power sector?
Moody's ups Pakistan outlook on IMF loan increase
Japan limps out of recession
China announces iron ore deal with Australia miner
Japan's economy rebounds in 2Q on export growth
Seoul shares fall on exporters;Hyundai Merchant up =2
Widow selling husband's tomb above Marilyn Monroe
| Entertainment
|
Kiss to release new album at Wal-Mart, Sam's Club
Sundance Channel launches video-on-demand service
| Entertainment
|
Waltz crafts linguistic magic for `Basterds'
Widow selling husband's tomb above Marilyn Monroe
Record mass dive in Indonesia: Guinness
Lebanon Jewish community rebuilds ornate synagogue
Time no barrier as Cropredy Fest rocks on and on
| Entertainment
|
US troops go back to basics with Iraq forces
Soap operas spark Arab tourist boom in Turkey
Cautionary tale for Philippines boxers
'G.I. Joe' continues overseas box-office domination
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights