Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Afghans do not expect change from U.S. shake-up
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (3)
Slideshow
Video
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
Australia gets first woman PM
| Video
8:44am EDT
Disease risk higher for swingers than prostitutes
23 Jun 2010
U.S. scores dead last again in healthcare study
23 Jun 2010
Spill hurts Obama rating as storm season starts
9:26am EDT
Methane in Gulf "astonishingly high": U.S. scientist
22 Jun 2010
Venezuela to nationalize U.S. firm's oil rigs
8:36am EDT
Miley Cyrus "no underwear" photo is fake, blogger says
15 Jun 2010
Toronto's downtown banks empty out ahead of G20
23 Jun 2010
Wall Street dragged by economic jitters
10:28am EDT
WRAPUP 3-Spill hurts Obama rating as storm season starts
9:16am EDT
U.S. scores dead last again in healthcare study
23 Jun 2010
Disease risk higher for swingers than prostitutes
23 Jun 2010
Australia gets first woman PM
| Video
8:44am EDT
Methane in Gulf "astonishingly high": U.S. scientist
22 Jun 2010
Consumers say: "In tweets we trust"
23 Jun 2010
Venezuela to nationalize U.S. firm's oil rigs
8:36am EDT
Trapped drunk driver opens another beer as awaits rescue
23 Jun 2010
Now scientists read your mind better than you can
22 Jun 2010
Toronto's downtown banks empty out ahead of G20
23 Jun 2010
French unions strike over pension reform
8:11am EDT
Commentary
Bernd Debusmann:
George W. Obama and immigration fantasies
The tone of the immigration debate is even more rancorous now than it was during George W. Bush's presidency and it features the same arguments, including the illusion that you can fully control the frontier between the U.S. and Mexico. Commentary
In Mexico, a drug war of choice?
In praise of Latin American immigrants
Afghans do not expect change from U.S. shake-up
Sayed Salahuddin
KABUL
Thu Jun 24, 2010 9:41am EDT
Factboxes
Factbox: Key quotes on Obama decision on McChrystal
7:38am EDT
Factbox: Security developments in Afghanistan
7:38am EDT
Related News
Petraeus a tough chief, say U.S. troops in Afghanistan
7:58am EDT
Top U.S. military official warns of Afghan challenges
9:29am EDT
Q+A: What is happening in Afghanistan right now?
9:40am EDT
Q+A: What does Petraeus bring to Afghan war effort?
7:38am EDT
Five facts about General David Petraeus
7:38am EDT
Related Video
Conduct unbecoming?
Tue, Jun 22 2010
1 / 6
President Barack Obama is followed by General David Petraeus, the head of the U.S. Central Command, as they arrive in the Rose Garden of the White House, in Washington, June 23, 2010. Obama has chosen Petraeus to replace Stanley McChrystal as the top U.S. general in Afghanistan, an Obama said on Wednesday.
Credit: Reuters/Jason Reed
KABUL (Reuters) - Afghanistan expressed regret on Thursday at the removal of the U.S. commander credited with reducing civilian casualties in the war against the Taliban but said it did not expect the shake-up to bring strategic changes.
World | Politics
President Barack Obama recalled General Stanley McChrystal, commander of U.S. and NATO forces in Afghanistan, and replaced him on Wednesday with McChrystal's boss, General David Petraeus, architect of the Iraq war turnaround.
McChrystal resigned after comments, mostly attributed to aides, appeared in a magazine profile that criticized some of Obama's closest advisers. The profile portrayed him as a derring-do soldier sometimes exasperated by politicians.
"We wish he hadn't gone, but this is America's internal issue," said General Zaher Azimi, a spokesman for the Afghan defense ministry.
"We expect him to follow McChrystal's assessment, which has reduced civilian casualties, brought down arrests and house searches and involved coordination on operations," he said.
DEADLY MONTH
The war has reached a critical stage in Afghanistan, despite the presence of around 150,000 foreign troops, with the Taliban at their strongest since being overthrown in 2001.
June has already been the costliest month in casualties for foreign forces, with the deaths of four service members in a vehicle accident late on Wednesday bringing the toll to 79.
More than 300 foreign troops have died in Afghanistan this year, compared with 521 for all of last year, according to icasualties.org. Scores more insurgents have died, but hundreds of civilians have also been killed -- most in Taliban bombings, but many too in crossfire or misdirected air strikes.
With the Taliban virtually bringing tens of thousands of foreign troops to a bloody stalemate, Afghanistan has been seeking ways to bring an end to nearly nine years of fighting.
Earlier this month, some 1,600 elders and religious leaders met in Kabul for a peace "jirga," or conference, where participants agreed the only way to end bloodshed was to reach out to the insurgents.
Apart from agreeing to start negotiations with the militants, the jirga also recommended a review of the cases of all prisoners in Afghanistan, including suspected insurgents, and a removal of Taliban figures from a U.N. sanctions list.
Completing a four-day visit to the country, ambassadors from the 15-nation U.N. Security Council said they were reviewing the 137-name U.N. blacklist case by case.
At least five of those named are former Taliban officials who serve in parliament or privately mediate between the government and insurgents battling NATO-led forces and their Afghan partners.
"TRICKY"
The Taliban said Obama had sacked McChrystal in order to shift blame for policy failures.
"Obama's strategy is a failure but he is tricky by washing his hands on McChrystal in order to maintain his own image and that of his party in America and the world," a spokesman said in a statement.
Afghanistan's conflict cannot be resolved by a shake-up of generals, the statement said, adding Petraeus was not as smart as McChrystal and even questioning his physical strength, noting his collapse during a congressional hearing last week.
McChrystal's counter-insurgency strategy aims to take on the Taliban where they are strongest, in their Kandahar spiritual homeland in the south, and boost security simultaneously with a push for improved civilian governance and development.
Petraeus, as commander of U.S. forces in Iraq, was widely credited with turning the tide there with a similar strategy when sectarian violence verged on civil war.
While he has a strong following on Capitol Hill and swift Senate confirmation is expected, a key first task will be forging a good relationship with Afghan President Hamid Karzai.
Since McChrystal took over as commander in June last year, he has formed a strong relationship with the Afghan president, accompanying him on several tours of the country in a bid to show support for the government.
The Afghan president expressed regret at McChrystal's departure, a spokesman said.
"We had hoped this would not have happened, but the decision has been made and we respect it," said spokesman Waheed Omer. "He looks forward to working with his replacement."
Obama said McChrystal's dismissal was needed to safeguard the unity of the war effort but insisted the switch in generals was a "change in personnel but it is not a change in policy."
In the field, some U.S. troops said they expected business as usual.
"General Petraeus is of the mind if something is not broken don't fix it," said First Sergeant Todd Sullivan in a mess hall at a camp in Gurgan, Kandahar.
(Writing by David Fox; Additional reporting by Jonathon Burch and Michael Georgy in GURGAN, Afghanistan; Editing by Paul Tait)
World
Politics
Comments
See All Comments (3) | Post Comment
Jun 24, 2010 6:59am EDT
The only person on this planet who still thinks we can win the Afghan war is Obama
STORYBURNcool
Report As Abusive
Jun 24, 2010 8:19am EDT
Now McChrystal
….from WW2 to Korea, to Vietnam, to Bosnia, to Iraq and now, but not finally to Afghanistan. Each Administration got us into an armed Conflict, but always wanted to fight it politically – whatever that means (maybe with Ballpens?).Yesterday McChrystal had to follow Douglas MacArthur: Reason keep the Prez and his Gang from getting a complete laughing stock.
Anyone remember General Grant refusing to fight an armed conflict but with military means!
This approach would have saved million of lives, maybe that of your fathers, brothers and sisters, not to count the billions of $ saved for extended campaigns. Just waiting to see Obama passing Jimmy Carter on the open Richterscale.
(Or could it just be that the Democrats just don’t like people with Mc/Mac in their respective names)
bluewin2008
Report As Abusive
Jun 24, 2010 11:37am EDT
@bluewin:
How is this situation in any way related to General Grant’s refusal?
“President Andrew Johnson tried to harness Grant’s popularity in an effort to restore Southern statehood at the expense of the freed slaves. Grant’s refusal to abandon his soldiers or his black veterans frustrated Johnson’s attempt to replace Secretary of War Edwin M. Stanton with Grant and drove him to support the Republican Party.”
(from http://www.answers.com/topic/ulysses-s-grant)
The President is the Commander-in-Chief of the American armed forces: a general publicly criticizing him is insubordination, an offense for which a court martial is the standard response. General McChrystal was free to voice his concerns PRIVATELY — it was enormously unprofessional for him to present his views in such a public forum.
This is why he offered his resignation; this is why Obama accepted it. I’m not sure why you’re mentioning MacArthur, a general who wanted to EXPAND the Korean war into Chinese territory, or Grant who has an entirely different set of circumstances.
sylvtrav
Report As Abusive
See All Comments (3)
Add a Comment
*We welcome comments that advance the story directly or with relevant tangential information. We try to block comments that use offensive language or appear to be spam and review comments frequently to ensure they meet our standards. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters.
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Reader Feedback
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts
Venture Capital Journal
International Financing Review
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
FindLaw
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Thursday, 24 June 2010 Obama fires McChrystal, picks Petraeus to head Afghan war
Balkan leaders discuss ties, EU prospects at Istanbul summit
US-TECH Summary
NATO chief says strategy for Afghanistan unchanged
|
Obama fires Afghan war commander McChrystal: report
Fed holds low rates, says economic recovery continues
Belarus says Russia gas debt paid, threatens transit cut
White Apple iPhone 4s sold out on eve of launch
Iran must respond to nuclear concerns: Brazil
'French Hannibal Lecter' tells how he ate lung
Quantum control: New step forward for supercomputers
Iraqi Islamist militants claim latest bank attack
Fed Continues Pledge To Keep Rates At Record Low
US new-home sales plunge to record low in May
Japanese fans queue up for Apple's new iPhone
French bank seeks 4.9 bln euros from Kerviel
Senate Seeks To Punish Gulf Oil Rig Safety Inspectors
Quake rattles Ottawa, other Canada cities
|
Good Tech software may aid corporate iPhone sales
Arizona Restaurant Serves Lion Meat To Mark World Cup
McChrystal says he resigned for good of mission
Obama Relieves McChrystal, Taps Petraeus As New Afghanistan Commander
Afghan leaders warn against firing Gen. McChrystal
BP Containment Cap Removed After Submarine Glitch
Council of Europe opposes bans on Muslim face veils
|
Americans Expect Jesus By 2050
Opera widens lead over iPhone in mobile browsers
GM Plans IPO To Sell Portion Of Treasury's Stake
Drake Earns #1 Debut With "Thank Me Later" On Billboard Albums Chart
New Home Sales Tumble To Record Low In May
Dreamworks Animation To Bring Troll Dolls To The Big Screen
Obama relieves McChrystal of Afghan command
Deadlocked global whaling talks run aground
Toronto man charged in G20 bomb plot
Taiwan's Lu keeps focus to go through
Court urged to jail N.Koreans over bid to kill defector
Indonesian police catch key terror suspect
Pakistan can help broker Afghan talks
Indonesia to protect 'sex clip' stars from Islamists
Verizon, Motorola to battle iPhone with Droid X
|
Taiwan, China expect to sign trade pact next week: source
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Pakistan court again orders websites blocked
Dancing, exhibits, specials mark Michael Jackson anniversary
Young Frenchmen spend as much on clothes as women
Disney and IMAX sign three-picture 3D deal
Midsummer festival gives Latvians a break from slump
Buzz is back in Singapore convention and expo business
Dancing, exhibits, specials mark Michael Jackson anniversary
|
Disney and IMAX sign three-picture 3D deal
|
12 killed as train hits revelers in Spain
NATO chief says strategy for Afghanistan unchanged
|
Sleep-deprived Apple fans brave rain for iPhone 4
OSCE calls for international police force in Kyrgyz south
|
Verizon and Motorola to battle iPhone with Droid X
Australia gets first woman PM
|
Drake Earns #1 Debut With "Thank Me Later" On Billboard Albums Chart
Google examining impact of new China laws on products
June deadliest month for troops in Afghan war
Canada police make explosives arrest before G8/G20
|
Swype hits Droid, eyes iPhones for future
Disgraced millionaire lobbyist takes pizza job
Venezuela to nationalize U.S. firm's oil rigs
|
Russian president downloads Silicon Valley success
Dismay in Kabul over McChrystal sacking
Guilty verdict in Toronto 18 bomb plot trial
|
Over 160,000 Android devices sold every day: Google CEO
Obama dumps McChrystal over magazine tirade
Nurse in iconic World War II kiss photograph dies
Rescuers rush aid to Brazil flood towns; 44 dead
|
Gulf containment cap reattached, collecting oil: BP
Taiwan and China to sign landmark trade deal on June 29
|
U.N.'s Ban criticizes East Jerusalem housing plan
Google and YouTube defeat Viacom in copyright lawsuit
Fed maintains record-low rates
China says breaks up terrorist cell in Xinjiang
|
Celia upgraded to major hurricane, new Pacific storm forms
US judge tosses out Viacom copyright suit against YouTube
Afghans relieved at choice of Gen. Petraeus
'Tweeting' Medvedev tours Silicon Valley
Auto accident kills 4 NATO troops in Afghanistan
Verizon and Motorola to battle iPhone with Droid X
17 kg of 20 pct enriched uranium ready: Iran
Over 160,000 Android devices sold every day: Google CEO
Disney To Release "Pirates," "Cars" Sequels In IMAX 3D
China busts Xinjiang 'terror cell'
Second Season Of ABC Family's "Make It Or Break It" To Premiere June 28
Sleep-deprived Apple fans brave rain for iPhone 4
|
U.S. Markets Finish Mixed On Fed, Housing Data
Verizon and Motorola to battle iPhone with Droid X
|
Google and YouTube defeat Viacom in copyright lawsuit
|
Witness in Philippine massacre trial killed
Google examining impact of new China laws on products
|
Google and YouTube defeat Viacom in copyright lawsuit
|
Flood-hit south China braces for more rains
Australia gets first woman PM
Swype hits Droid, eyes iPhones for future
|
Toyota's top test driver killed in German road crash
China says breaks up "terrorist" cell in Xinjiang
Russian president downloads Silicon Valley success
|
Quake near Ottawa, rattles Canada and U.S.
Hong Kong lawmakers set to adopt political reforms
What Viacom's loss to YouTube means for Hollywood
Oscar organizers consider moving up award show date
Japan finance minister to push for tax on rich
Taiwan stocks end slightly up before cbank meeting
Blast wounds nine in Sri Lanka capital
N.Korea economy shrinks in 2009: bank
Former China PM's Tiananmen diary on sale in US
Seoul shares gain on banks, builders; retail down
Xinjiang 'terror cell' busted, says China
Unicom in talks to launch iPhone 4, iPad in China
Japan export growth slows as Eurozone fears weigh
WRAPUP 1-S.Korea upgrades outlook, moves closer to rate rise
Toyota China plant idle as Honda resumes work
Drake and Tom Petty lead U.S. album charts
PAKISTAN
What Viacom's loss to YouTube means for Hollywood
New Zealand growth slows but rates still to rise
"Twilight" fans gear up for "Eclipse" premiere
Holding Oscars earlier would be tricky
Bin Laden Hunter Returning To U.S.
Rocker Gregg Allman has liver transplant
4-Year-Old Indian Boy Does 1,500 Push-Ups In 40 Minutes
The Offspring to unveil new song on summer tour
Obama Relieves McChrystal, Taps Petraeus As New Afghanistan Commander
"Twilight"s Robert Pattinson related to Dracula
Picasso work top sale at record-breaking British auction
Americans Expect Jesus By 2050
LA cemetery welcomes Michael Jackson fans, bans doves
|
Twilights Robert Pattinson related to Dracula
|
Mexico seeks extradition of Survivor ex-producer
|
What Viacom's loss to YouTube means for Hollywood
|
Oscar organizers consider moving up award show date
|
Former manager sues Joan Rivers, claims defamation
|
Twilight fans gear up for Eclipse premiere
|
Drake and Tom Petty lead U.S. album charts
|
Holding Oscars earlier would be tricky
|
Suicide bombers target Iraq troops and police
Apple's iPhone 4 makes world debut
Germany fires pre-G20 broadside at US criticism
Pakistani court sentences Americans for terrorism
|
French 'Hannibal Lecter' trial heads for verdict
7 Afghan construction workers killed in bombing
Paraguay want to end New Zealand's W.Cup fairytale
Afghans do not expect change from U.S. shake-up
|
Nokia to use Linux for flagship N-series phones
Mass strike against pension reform hits France
Fish out of water: Gene clue to evolutionary step
Relief greets Obama pick for new war commander
Families Return Home As Coconino Forest Fire Contained
Gameworld: Video gamers can now play for more than high scores
German finance minister warns of debt addictions
Target Recalls Childrens Belts Made In China Due to Violation of Lead Paint Standard
Pakistan court wants Google, Yahoo, YouTube blocked
Flood-hit China battles rain, 365 dead so far
|
Millions Of Cribs Recalled As Seven Manufacturers Address Entrapment, Suffocation and Fall Hazards
McDonalds Faced With Lawsuit Over Toys In Happy Meals
Russian Billionaire Reportedly Paid $1 Million To Appear In Lady Gaga's Video
Report Gives U.S. Health Care System A Failing Grade
Nokia to use Linux for flagship N-series phones
Google Wins YouTube Copyright Infringement Case Against Viacom
Hurricane Darby forms in Pacific off Mexico
|
In Prison, Kilpatrick Indicted On 19 Counts Of Fraud, Tax Evasion
Study Sugggests Warm, Yet Firm Parenting Style Best Bet To Keep Kids Off Booze
High Blood Pressure Drug May Benefit Alzheimer's Patients
Witness in Philippine massacre case shot dead
|
N.Korea threatens harsher punishment for US detainee
Pakistan court jails five Americans for terrorism
Pakistan court jails five Americans for terrorism
Five killed as suicide bombers target Iraq troops and police
|
S.Lanka to block UN visits to probe war crimes
Minimum and maximum temperatures in Celsius
Taiwan and China agree terms of landmark trade deal
|
Indonesia's top terror suspect behind bars
New Japan PM to make global debut at Canada summits
Pakistani court sentences Americans for terrorism
Emergency rule to be lifted in much of Thailand
Pakistan's forex reserves rise to $15.78 bln
China warns against US retaliation over yuan
India's Reliance completes new US shale gas deal
How (Not) To End An Office Romance
False-Alarm Medical Tests
Bollywood makes Osama bin Laden spoof
Twitter settles privacy charges with U.S.
|
Taiwan surprises with first rate rise after crisis
The World's Most Beautiful Sunsets
Tech companies seeking business in Syria
|
Pakistan stocks see another dull day, index inches up
Sri Lanka soldiers adapt to post-war pastimes
Gameworld: Video gamers can now play for more than high scores
|
Bulgaria strives to end plight of abandoned children
Asian stocks end mostly lower on poor US outlook
Nokia to use Linux for flagship N-series phones
|
Toyota boss feared having to resign over recalls
Top Five Scams in the Middle East
Taiwan, China talks set stage for trade pact
Noordin's father-in-law on trial over Jakarta bombs
S.Korea won turns down on importers, dlr short covers
Glastonbury readies for music, mud and Gorillaz
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights