Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Rules on Wilson's outburst open to interpretation
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Search
Search:
Rules on Wilson's outburst open to interpretation
By BEN EVANS,Associated Press Writer AP - Tuesday, September 15
WASHINGTON - Republican Rep. Joe Wilson may have violated good taste when he yelled "You lie!" at President Barack Obama last week, and Democrats are moving forward with a resolution scolding him for it. But did he break any specific House rules?
ADVERTISEMENT
The answer is more complicated than it seems, and the rules that some initially cited don't appear to apply.
The House generally requires its members to abstain from personal insults during debate. Over the years, the institution has developed a long list of precedents deemed out of order, including insults directed at the president.
Some are downright odd: You can't call the president "a little bugger" or refer to any alleged sexual misconduct, for example. Others are more predictable: Don't call the president a liar or accuse him of lying.
Democrats initially cited the latter precedent in saying Wilson's outburst was a violation.
But Wilson, R-S.C., could get off on a technicality on that score because Congress was meeting in a special joint session for Obama's speech on Wednesday, not under the House's normal rules of debate.
"It doesn't violate House rules because the House wasn't in (normal) session," said Donald Wolfensberger, director of the Congress Project at the Woodrow Wilson Center in Washington.
Wolfensberger noted that under regular rules, House lawmakers wouldn't be allowed to stand and cheer as they frequently do at presidential speeches before Congress.
House Parliamentarian John Sullivan agreed that the House's rules on debate probably don't apply to the incident. But he and others said the House has wide latitude in interpreting its general code of conduct that says "a lawmaker shall conduct himself at all times in a manner which shall reflect creditably on the House of Representatives."
A lawmaker doesn't have to violate a specific rule to get scolded.
"This probably is not a question of decorum in debate as much as a question of decorum generally," Sullivan said.
Wilson, a conservative who won a 2001 special election to earn his seat in Congress, apologized to the White House and in a written public statement shortly after hurling the insult last week. But he has refused to apologize on the House floor.
At first, Obama and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi suggested that everyone just move on. But Pelosi changed her mind after many Democrats insisted that Wilson apologize directly to the House, saying the outburst was at least a general breach of decorum. They argued that allowing it to stand without some formal rebuke would create a bad precedent.
Pelosi and other party leaders confirmed Monday night that they would proceed with a resolution. Democratic aides said it probably would be introduced Tuesday afternoon, with a vote later in the day. Aides initially said it would be introduced by fellow South Carolinian Rep. James Clyburn, the third-ranking Democrat in the House, but officials said later Monday it was undecided who would introduce the measure.
The aides said the resolution would focus broadly on Wilson's conduct. The aides spoke anonymously because no public announcement had been made.
Wilson meanwhile, has accused Democrats of playing politics with the incident, and House GOP leaders are backing him. Minority Leader John Boehner, R-Ohio, said he would vote against the measure.
Wilson's unusual outburst came as Obama said illegal immigrants would not be eligible for low-cost health care.
The Democratic proposals on health explicitly prohibit spending any federal money to help illegal immigrants get health care. Still, Republicans say the legislation needs stronger citizenship verification to ensure illegal immigrants are excluded.
After the uproar, Senate Democrats said last week they were negotiating stronger verification requirements to be included in the bill, and the White House said it was also strengthening its position against health care coverage for illegal immigrants.
Wilson and his likely 2010 Democratic opponent, Rob Miller, have raked in donations since the incident.
Miller has raised more than $1.5 million, more than twice what he spent in his 2008 challenge to Wilson, according to campaign officials. Wilson was raising money at a similar pace, taking in more than $700,000 as of Friday. His latest tally was not available Monday.
___
Associated Press writer David Espo contributed to this report.
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: World
Former Carter press secretary Jody Powell diesAP - Tuesday, September 15
US military deaths in Iraq war at 4,344AP - Tuesday, September 15
US military deaths in Afghanistan region at 752AP - Tuesday, September 15
Calif. judge gives ex assistant sheriff 27 monthsAP - Tuesday, September 15
DC subway worker dies after hit by train last weekAP - Tuesday, September 15
Most Popular – World
Viewed
Nestle warns of possible exit from Switzerland
Remains of Jesus-era synagogue found in Israel
Study explains bacteria's resistance to antibiotics
Depression harms cancer survival rates: study
Britain apologises to WWII code-breaker hero
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Tuesday, 15 September 2009 Bagram inmates can challenge detention: Pentagon
Europe to emerge from recession in 3rd qtr, says EU
US-TECH Summary
Intel restructures, senior exec leaves for EMC
Netanyahu: no complete West Bank building freeze
sells stake in Alibaba.com for 150 mln dlrs
Venezuela inks $2.2 bln weapons deal with Russia
Intuit buying Mint.com for 170 mln dlrs
Kissing quest makes Taiwan woman a web sensation
Norway left wins rare re-election: exit polls
| International
|
Iraqi court orders the release of Bush shoe thrower
Public trust in US media eroding: Pew study
U.S. behind attack on militant in Somalia: U.S. sources
| International
|
Web TV firm Joost ousts Chairman Mike Volpi
Student leader in dock as Iran resumes protesters' trial
Top U.N official to visit Sri Lanka, discuss refugees
| International
|
Dalai Lama briefed about US approach to Tibet
Obama touts Wall St. changes on Lehman anniversary
U.S. NATO envoy says Europeans firm on Afghanistan
Dalai Lama hopes to meet Obama in Nov: statement
Harkin: `Silent majority' back health care reform
Myanmar politicians' kin set to join new party
Obama urges financial industry to rebuild trust
Taiwan coast guard alerted after Japan nabs skipper
US joins UN rights council as member for 1st time
Outgoing Japan PM bids successor 'good luck'
Inspiration for movie 'Norma Rae' dies at 68
Regulators: accounting changes need global reach
New Islamic law in Indonesia's Aceh province
Obama: Some Wall St. firms ignoring Lehman lessons
Classes resume in riot-turn city of Urumqi, China
Indonesia's Aceh passes law on stoning to death
Tenn. ash spill community getting $40M from TVA
China lodges complaint at WTO over US tyre tariffs
Man accused of attacking mayor pleads insanity
Japanese high-tech giants in cellphone merger
Turkmenistan, Russia's Itera sign energy deal
New film Precious gets big push from Oprah
| Entertainment
|
Whitney Houston says mom rescued her from drugs
| Entertainment
|
Correction: Oprah Winfrey story
Winfrey, Tyler Perry push new film `Precious'
'Big Brother' reunion won't have booted contestant
Rocker Juanes' wife gives birth to son in Miami
Apocalypse now? Dark visions at Toronto film festival
| Entertainment
|
'Shakespeare in Love' set to be reborn as theater
World celebrities sing to stop global warming
Intel restructures, senior exec leaves for EMC
Mafia sank boat with radioactive waste: official
Iran agrees date for nuclear talks in move welcomed by US
Top al Qaeda militant killed in Somalia
| International
|
Europe to emerge from recession in 3rd qtr, says EU
U.S. senator promises look into cellphone-cancer link
Iran agrees date for nuclear talks in move welcomed by US
Magna says to cut 10,500 jobs at Opel
Iranian conservative harshly criticises regime
U.S. envoy meets Netanyahu over settlement freeze
| International
|
Broadcom files patent infringement suit against Emulex
Iran's talks with world powers to start next month
Chile to adopt Japanese digital TV standard: Bachelet
Netanyahu says won't freeze building in settlements
Microsoft testing 'Visual Search'
Obama lashes out at Wall Street
Japan cabinet takes shape, Fujii for finance: media
| International
|
New York Times warns readers of website virus
Norway's Stoltenberg set to stay in power
| International
|
UK's Conservatives have 14 point lead: poll
| International
|
U.S. concerned over Venezuela-Russia arms deal
| International
|
U.N. assembly votes for more powerful women's agency
| International
|
Swiss watchdog threatens to sue Google over Street View
US military deaths in Iraq war at 4,344
US military deaths in Afghanistan region at 752
HP shows off new ultra-thin PCs, stylish netbook
| Technology
|
Calif. judge gives ex assistant sheriff 27 months
DC subway worker dies after hit by train last week
3 New York residences raided in terrorism probe
Obama admin fights Bagram detainee court access
Rules on Wilson's outburst open to interpretation
U of Illinois faculty back leaders' ouster
Koreas exchange lists of families separated by war
U.S. senator promises look into cellphone-cancer link
| Technology
|
APNewsBreak: Report says punishment led to killing
Japan cabinet takes shape, Fujii for finance
Defense: Brooke Astor was lucid when changing will
Taiwan sub skipper falls overboard during training
Conservationists say 70 dolphins in Japan released
Classes resume after China syringe attacks
4th Guantanamo detainee agrees to move to Palau
Indonesia's Aceh to allow stoning for adulterers
Malaysian judge hands out 2nd caning for alcohol
Missile kills 4 in Pakistan; 18 die in stampede
US turns over seized prehistoric relics to China
Offshore holdings of NZ govt rise in August
S.Korea T-bonds inch up; eyes on jobs data
Actor Patrick Swayze dead at 57
Seoul shares gain as shipbuilders rally;techs down
S.Korea regulator calls for careful exit
Patrick Swayze dead at 57: report
US seeks fresh look at SKorea auto imports
Lowe, Garner blast Kanye West and 'You lie!' lawmaker
Dirty Dancing star Patrick Swayze dead at 57
| Entertainment
|
Leno launches U.S. prime-time television experiment
| Entertainment
|
Toyota says European demand won't recover till mid-2010
Venice Fest short on prizes for local fare
| Entertainment
|
AES shares rise on report of China interest
Whitney Houston says husband painted evil eyes in house
| Entertainment
|
Lame? Seinfeld stars reunite after 11 years
| Entertainment
|
Kanye West taking time off after debacle
| Entertainment
|
Keanu Reeves hams it up as webisode star
| Entertainment
|
Quentin Tarantino to open Mexican film festival
Actor Patrick Swayze dead at 57
Kiefer Sutherland to head new acting school
| Entertainment
|
New suspect emerges in possible Brian Jones murder
New suspect emerges in possible Brian Jones murder
| Entertainment
|
Marc Jacobs leads pack at NY Fashion Week
New suspect emerges in possible Brian Jones murder
| Entertainment
|
Neil Young taps No Doubt, Chris Martin for benefit
Film star Patrick Swayze dead at 57: reports
Whitney Houston says husband painted evil eyes in house
Lowe, Garner blast Kanye West and 'You lie!' lawmaker
Music world slams Kanye West over awards outburst
Rapper Kanye West taking time off after debacle
Recounts due at 10% of Afghan polling stations
Brown seeks to reassure unions before election
Google launches online news reader 'Fast Flip'
Obama lashes out at Wall Street
Iraqi who threw shoes at Bush released from jail
| International
|
Iraqi shoe thrower released; says he was tortured
Iran says lays ground for more cooperation with IAEA
| International
|
'Dirty Dancing' star Patrick Swayze dead at 57
Afghan recount to cover 10 percent of polling stations
| International
|
Iran nuclear talks probably in Turkey: Solana
One in six Mediterranean mammals face extinction
China says 75 suspects held over far-west needle scare
| International
|
Recounts at 10 percent of Afghan polling stations
Russia's Medvedev says may run in 2012 vote: reports
| International
|
Iran talks likely in Turkey
Chinese schools quietly discard controversial Web filter
| International
|
US lawmakers to quiz military chief on Afghan war
Bagram inmates win right to challenge detention
No more reckless behavior: Obama warns Wall Street
Chinese schools quietly discard controversial Web filter
| Technology
|
Scientists find virtual reality helps relieve pain
| Technology
|
Police: College student kills intruder with sword
Plane crash plotter to appear in Indiana court
A paw and a prayer: Pilots save shelter animals
Obama back on the economy
The Nation's weather
Rights group suspends analyst over Nazi collection
Philippine July remittances surge to 9.3 percent
Iraq shoe-thrower freed, accuses guards of torture
China wants action on IMF at G-20 summit
Pakistan foreign investment falls 36 pct in July-Aug
Taiwan dollar rises on stocks, c.bank caps gains
Japan airline to cut 6,800 jobs and seek tie-up
WRAPUP 2-South Korea says economic support has to stay
San Miguel seeks new business opportunities
SLanka foreign reserves record high: central bank
Seoul shares hit 14-mth closing high; banks gain =2
Prince Harry turns 25
Taiwan's Formosa Plastics plans huge Vietnam port
Dan Brown returns after 6 year wait
Aussie rocker Garrett won't join climate change song
Ukraine dismisses Elton John's adoption bid
Marvel vs. Disney: Two very different Americas
Rightwing Czech hate groups target Roma: report
Indonesia flash floods kill 38: official
No drugs please, we're Singaporean goths
Indonesian rights groups condemn new stoning law
Freemasons hail Dan Brown's latest novel as good fun
| Entertainment
|
Leno launches U.S. prime-time television experiment
Flash floods hit Indonesian village, 25 missing
'Dirty Dancing' star Patrick Swayze dies at 57
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights