Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Website's instant posts of Wall Street research banned
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (0)
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
Polar bear, bluefin tuna trade bans rejected
| Video
18 Mar 2010
New password-stealing virus targets Facebook
17 Mar 2010
Viacom, Google accuse other of YouTube hypocrisy
18 Mar 2010
Once bitten by Apple, telcos warier with iPad
18 Mar 2010
The "Oscar curse," real or Hollywood invention?
18 Mar 2010
New password-stealing virus targets Facebook
17 Mar 2010
Netanyahu, Clinton talk after settlement crisis
18 Mar 2010
Female porn director swaps sex for British politics
15 Mar 2010
Polar bear, bluefin tuna trade bans rejected
| Video
18 Mar 2010
Indonesian Bumi-linked group lifts stake in Newmont jv
18 Mar 2010
Website's instant posts of Wall Street research banned
Jonathan Stempel and Grant McCool
NEW YORK
Thu Mar 18, 2010 9:38pm EDT
Related News
Website's instant posts of Wall Street research banned
Thu, Mar 18 2010
UPDATE 4-Website's instant posts of Wall St research banned
Thu, Mar 18 2010
AIG's Greenberg to testify Wednesday on Gen Re
Mon, Mar 8 2010
NEW YORK (Reuters) - A Manhattan federal judge on Thursday barred the financial news service Theflyonthewall.com from issuing immediate news about analyst research from several Wall Street banks, often before recommendations are shared with clients.
Technology | Media
Ruling in favor of Bank of America Corp's Merrill Lynch unit, Barclays Plc and Morgan Stanley, U.S. District Judge Denise Cote said Theflyonthewall.com engaged in "systematic misappropriation," essentially getting a "free ride" from its quick publication of upgrades and downgrades that can move stocks higher and lower.
Cote issued a permanent injunction requiring the Summit, New Jersey-based company to wait until 10 a.m. to report research from the three banks that was issued before the market opens, and at least two hours for research issued thereafter. The bulk of research is typically issued before the open.
While the banks had sought longer delays, Cote said: "This time frame preserves incentives for the firms to create and disseminate research reports to their investor clients, while still recognizing the inevitable, fast-moving, and widespread informal communication of recommendation on Wall Street."
Cote added she could not excuse Theflyonthewall.com's activities simply because recommendations are also reported by many rivals, or are otherwise leaked or rumored.
"The legally salient fact ... is that Fly is exploiting its self-described 'hefty relationships with people in the know,'" she wrote.
The judge said Theflyonthewall.com may apply in one year to lift the injunction if the banks do not take reasonable steps to halt the unauthorized distribution of research.
According to the opinion, Theflyonthewall.com said the lawsuit has forced it to ritualistically engage in "confirming" the substance of research with two or three sources before publishing -- still, typically, before the market opens.
The company has about 30 employees. It charges $50 a month, or $480 annually, for its services, its website shows.
Glenn Ostrager, a lawyer representing Theflyonthewall.com, said the ruling is "at variance with existing law." He said his client will appeal to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, and expects the financial press to "vigorously support" an appeal.
WIDER IMPACT?
Like many rivals, Theflyonthewall.com typically posts headlines from research reports and press releases, and longer summaries when available.
It was not immediately clear how the 89-page ruling might affect the ability of real-time financial news providers such as Thomson Reuters, Bloomberg LP and News Corp's Dow Jones Newswires to tell clients of potentially market-moving research.
Thomson Reuters spokeswoman Erin Kurtz and Bloomberg spokeswoman Judith Czelusniak declined to comment. A Dow Jones representative had no immediate comment.
The banks welcomed the ruling. Merrill spokesman Bill Halldin called it a "milestone in regaining control over the distribution of our proprietary research and preserving the value of our investment ideas for our clients."
Barclays spokesman Mark Lane and Morgan Stanley spokeswoman Carissa Ramirez said the ruling shows the importance of protecting intellectual property.
Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc had been one of the plaintiffs when the lawsuit was filed in 2006. Barclays took its place when it bought much of that bank's operations.
The judge noted that Merrill Lynch and Morgan Stanley have already taken steps to limit or delay the media's ability to obtain analyst research. Other banks have acted similarly.
EXCLUSIVITY MATTERS
In her opinion, Cote said the value of analyst research derives not just from its quality, but also from its "exclusivity and timeliness."
She said Theflyonthewall.com "free-rides" on banks' research efforts because it make no effort to produce the recommendations or contribute to the underlying analyses.
The judge also said such "illegal conduct" cannot be excused because rivals might also engage in unlawful behavior.
"While it may be true that Fly is a news aggregator and is in direct competition with other financial news aggregators, both large and small, each of these news aggregators is in direct competition with the firms when they report the firms' recommendations in a timely and systematic manner such that the firms are deprived of the opportunity to communicate them first-hand to their clients," she wrote.
While noting the 2003 global research analyst settlement, the availability of discount electronic trading platforms, and the financial crisis might have hurt the banks, resulting in reduced staff, Cote said "these other events aside, the misappropriation of their recommendations by Fly and others has also had a profound effect on their business model."
She also advanced a public policy argument for her ruling.
"A balance must be struck between establishing rewards to stimulate socially useful efforts on the one hand, and permitting maximum access to the fruits of those efforts to facilitate still further innovation and progress," she wrote.
The case is Barclays Capital et al v Theflyonthewall.com, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York, No. 06-04908.
(Reporting by Jonathan Stempel and Grant McCool; editing by Leslie Gevirtz, Richard Chang, Andre Grenon and Carol Bishopric)
Technology
Media
Add a Comment
More from Reuters
Special Report: Tea Partiers vs. Republicans
Tea Partiers want it known that they are not Republican Party lapdogs, but are they a fringe movement or a sleeping giant, awakened? Full Article
Organic a tough slog in China
After incidents of melamine-tainted milk to toxic cowpeas, selling organic food to the Chinese is not an easy business. Full Article
Organic foods finding a niche
China food security depends on policy
Food execs won't give up fried chicken
Food and Agriculture Summit
Once bitten, twice shy of Apple
European carriers sacrificed profits to carry the iPhone. They won't make that same mistake with the iPad. Full Article
Advertising and the iPad
Apple director Jerry York dies
technology
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts
Venture Capital Journal
International Financing Review
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Friday, 19 March 2010 Maliki holds narrow lead in latest Iraq vote count
Greece urges EU aid, but Germany 'open' to IMF appeal
Apple director Jerry York dies at 71
Iraq PM, ex-premier in tight race for parliament
Bullock cancels London trip, film premiere called off
Amazon unveils application to read Kindle e-books on Macs
Obama signs multibillion-dollar bill to create jobs
Creditors want Sex.com in bankruptcy, halt auction
Gaza rocket kills one in Israel, clouds Mideast peace moves
Poll: Three-Term Sen. Barbara Boxer Vulnerable In November
Obama calls for more job creation
London hospital to treat Internet-addicted teens
Myanmar deports jailed Burmese-American activist
|
Blagojevich Denied Request To Delay Corruption Trial
Amazon allows Kindle application for Mac computers
Turkey detains 20 people in coup plot case
Israel attack on Iran could ignite Middle East: Hezbollah
|
'Mr Microchips' proves popular in S.Korean schools
Mya Joins Cedric Gervais For NOH8 Campaign Theme Song
FedEx Q3 Profit Jumps On Volume Growth, Boosts Outlook
Ladies in White march on Cuba crackdown anniversary
|
New Cycling Policy From Transportation Department Earns Praise, Ridicule
Kremlin picks site for Russian "Silicon Valley"
BREAKING NEWS: Obama Postpones Trip Abroad To Concentrate On Healthcare Bill
Cybersecurity needs global rules: British lawmakers
U.S. Leading Indicators Rise Modestly On Manufacturing Gains
Phone Call To Mom Brings Drug Trafficking Charge For Inmate
British youngsters prefer online advice to parents
New Jillian Michaels Series "Losing It With Jillian" Premieres In June
American Known As "Jihad Jane" Pleads Not Guilty To Terrorism Charges
Obama scraps Asia-Pacific trip for healthcare
Junta frees Myanmar-American, deports him
Obama ditches Indonesia, Australia trip over health care
Thai Red Shirts declare 'class war'
Japan, France call on Iran to resolve nuclear crisis now
France rules out opening embassy in N.Korea
US, Russia see disarmament deal clinched soon
Reports: N.Korea executes official over currency chaos
Google slams Viacom for secret YouTube uploads
|
Clinton, Russia at odds over Iranian nuclear plant
N.Zealand's 'Madoff' fraudster spent millions on prostitutes
Website's instant posts of Wall St research banned
|
Myanmar releases jailed US activist: officials
Soyuz spacecraft lands safely on Kazakh steppe
Amazon allows Kindle application for Mac computers
|
FCC plans to announce broadband agenda
|
Apple director Jerry York dies at 71
|
Creditors want Sex.com in bankruptcy, halt auction
|
'JihadJane' pleads not guilty in domestic terror case
US operations already started in Kandahar: commanders
Obama health plan 'will cut deficit': US Congress
'JihadJane' pleads not guilty in terrorism case
France in big culture push to arts-repressed Saudis
15 years on, Japan film recalls doomsday cult sarin attacks
British hospital to treat Internet-addicted teens
Universal Studios Singapore courts 8 for lucky launch
Singer's musical journey reshaping Portugal's fado
HTC to 'fully defend' itself against Apple patent suit
Kia to build 100-million-euro engine plant in Slovakia
Palestinians struggle to impose settlements boycott
Nestle drops Indonesian company after Greenpeace demos
Japanese land prices fall at fastest pace in five years
Hollywood and Bollywood join arms to fight piracy
Davy Crockett star Fess Parker dies at 85
|
Pakistan aims to raise $500 mln with OGDCL bonds
Pakistan appoints economist Shaikh as finance chief
Pakistan's forex reserves rise to $14.85 bln
Pakistani stocks end up on finance adviser report
Nissan to make Leaf electric cars in Britain
Pakistan arrests ended UN talks with Taliban: ex-envoy
Argentina claims progress for Falkands talks with Britain
Israel strikes in Gaza after deadly rocket
|
Deadly Gaza rocket, air strikes cloud peace talks
US-TECH Summary
Taliban arrests thwart Afghan talks: ex-U.N. envoy
|
British boy arrives home after Pakistan kidnap ordeal
Israel strikes in Gaza after deadly rocket
Google adword win in Europe wouldn't end battles
Chileans' quake knowledge saved thousands of lives
|
Netanyahu, Clinton talk after settlement crisis
Nasty Google-Viacom billion-dollar battle goes public
Israel attack on Iran could ignite Middle East
World Bank OKs record $1.05 billion for Indian schools
|
Palm shares plunge on weak quarterly forecast
Creditors get turned off by sex.com auction
New Zealand's Madoff jailed for $13 million fraud
|
Bomb damages right-wing group's Athens office
|
Google slams Viacom for secret YouTube uploads
Economist not distributed in Thailand over royalty story
|
Desktop computer sales soared in February: NPD Group
Japan to boost Haiti aid to $100 mln: report
Drug Arrest Connected To "Lost Boy's" Death
Rihanna Hits #1 On Billboard Hot 100 With "Rude Boy"
Ludacris Comes Out On Top With "Battle Of The Sexes" On Billboard
US rep: Pa. Jihad Jane terror suspect cooperated
U.S. says driver error possible in NY Prius crash
Beyoncé Joins Alicia Keys On Stage For Special Performance At New York Tour Date
Website's instant posts of Wall Street research banned
|
China official warns of risk from yuan rise
The "Oscar curse," real or Hollywood invention?
China orders crackdown on cooking oil over cancer link
Japan celebrates defeat of bluefin tuna trade ban
Asian countries understanding of Obama trip delay
Alcohol 'worse than drugs' in Pacific: report
Study: Ancient Croc Dined On Dinosaurs
Pakistan arrests halt UN contacts with Taliban
FAA Proposes $300,000 In Additional Penalties Against American Airlines For Poor Maintenance
Google adword win in Europe wouldn't end battles
|
Congress Frustrated by "Virtual Fence" Problems Along Mexican Border
Tryptophan Shown To Reduce Aggression In Pigs
Taylor Swift's "Fearless" Named Most Awarded Album In Country Music History
Jennifer Lopez goes "Overboard"
Sandra Bullock's husband seeks forgiveness
|
Despite ratings wins, Leno still faces hurdles
Cable networks eye Sarah Palin reality show
|
Jennifer Lopez goes Overboard
|
Lady Gaga sued for $30 million by jilted producer
|
Beau Bridges joins Rockford revamp
|
"Life" breathes new vitality into nature series
No deal for Paula Abdul at ABC
|
Graco Recalls 1.2 Million Unstable High Chairs
Public Access To Court Documents Set To Open Up
Polanski lawyers appeal, demand sentencing in absence
|
'Hobbit' filming to start in July: Ian McKellen
British boy arrives home after Pakistan kidnap ordeal
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
UN wildlife body rejects bluefin trade ban
Obama scraps Asia-Pacific trip for healthcare push
Amid Afghan surge, disputed base becomes indispensable
McLaren launches new supercar
India's Bharti says to sell Apple's iPhone 3GS
Thai protesters target hearts and minds of Bangkok
|
Quartet urges Israel to freeze settlement activity
China quality watchdog says some HP laptops faulty
Armenian migrants dragged into politics in Turkey
Quartet hopes package will unlock Middle East talks
|
Iran jails top reformist: opposition website
Russia says Iran letting chances for dialogue slip
|
Democratic Donor Admits To $292 Million Bank Fraud
Losing the battle to keep female flesh off Afghan TV
|
"Barefoot Burglar" Once Again Eludes Authorities
China quality watchdog says some HP laptops faulty
Gay Advocates Detained After White House Rally Against "Don't Ask, Don't Tell"
Pakistan denies arrests thwarted Taliban talks
|
Second Teen Arrested In Florida School Beating Over Text Message Taunt
Rescuers End Search For Pacifica Swimmer
Syrian murder, Israeli planes not linked: official
|
Killer Who Wrote Taunting Letter Executed
Cambodian bans women from marrying South Koreans
UK anti-militant project stirs Muslim unease
|
Rice regrets how US prioritized rebuilding in Iraq
School Officials Condemn Obama Effigy In Classroom
Dutch lash out at gay link in Srebrenica massacre
|
South Carolina Governor Agrees To Pay Fines For Ethics Charges
Thai protesters target "hearts and minds" of Bangkok
Paula Abdul Not Joining "Star Search" Remake
UN issues travel restrictions for staffers to Aceh
Virgin America Eyes Flights To Toronto By Summer
Japan celebrates defeat of bluefin tuna trade ban
Cambodia set to renovate genocide museum
Ore. lawsuit claims Boy Scouts sex abuse coverup
US may extend tanker deadline to allow EADS bid
India seeks to question US terror convict
Calif police department on alert for deadly traps
China imposing financial rules on religious groups
Mideast Quartet meets in Moscow
Obama legacy at stake as health vote looms
Protesters smash, paint Myanmar Embassy in India
Japanese fish dealers welcome tuna ban rejection
Palm's survival questioned
|
China quality watchdog says some HP laptops faulty
|
Deal near for Guantanamo closure, trials: report
Samsung, LG see growth, but know rivals are catching
|
Google may announce China plans next Monday: report
|
China tells Washington to cool yuan pressure
India's Bharti says to sell Apple's iPhone 3GS
|
S.Korean bonds mixed, caution grows after rally
China says HP violated customer rights rules
S.Korea rejects N.Korea threat to seize assets
Middle East Quartet opens Moscow meeting
Taiwan stocks at 8-wk closing high; upside seen limited
Japanese fish dealers welcome tuna ban rejection
New Zealand's 'Madoff' jailed for $13 mln fraud
US leaves open option for more arms sales to Taiwan
China calls on Washington cool yuan pressure
Japan police seek criminal charges in Prius crash
Google to leave China April 10: state media
'Fantasies are real' says director Tim Burton
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Behind "Runaways" film, legal battle simmers
Uruguay is wine world's rising star
No death in the afternoon at S.Korea bullfight
Cable networks eye Sarah Palin reality show
Beau Bridges joins "Rockford" revamp
"South Park" season opener a strong performer
Behind Runaways film, legal battle simmers
|
The Oscar curse, real or Hollywood invention?
|
Despite ratings wins, Leno still faces hurdles
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights