Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Decades-old dioxins pollute river, divide US community
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Decades-old dioxins pollute river, divide US community
AFP - Monday, December 14
Send
IM Story
Print
The signs posted along the Tittabawassee River warning of dangerous dioxin levels do not keep away fisherman David Mitchell, seen here in November 2009 near Saginaw, Michigan. He caught a walleye a migratory fish with lower dioxin levels - and planned to take it home for dinner.
MIDLAND, Michigan (AFP) - – The signs posted along Michigan's Tittabawassee River warning of dangerous dioxin levels don't really worry fisherman David Mitchell.
If he catches a fish that swims here year round he tosses it back. But if he hooks a walleye -- only an occasional visitor to the river and has lower dioxin levels than the year-rounders -- then it's time for dinner.
"I don't think it's as big a concern as what people are saying it is," said Mitchell, 51, as he sat on a pail on the muddy bank and cast his line out into the water.
"I can remember when the rivers never froze in the winters and now they're freezing over, so the pollution in the rivers has got to be a lot less than it was."
The Tittabawassee may be clean enough to freeze now, but it remains one of the most contaminated waterways in the United States and a key example of the nation's struggle to deal with its industrial past.
President Barack Obama's administration has vowed to take tougher action against polluters and has invested nearly a billion dollars of stimulus funds to spur cleanup efforts.
But the decades-long conflict over this one watershed underscores the complexities of trying to force companies into environmental action.
It also foreshadows the bitter battle the White House will face when it comes to implementing the emissions cuts needed to address climate change -- the focus of talks in Copenhagen to thrash out a deal for the global warming summit there on Dec 17 and 18.
Dioxins are chemicals so toxic they get measured in trillionths of a gram. They linger for years in both the environment and the body and pose a host of health risks from cancer to birth defects.
For most of the last century, Dow Chemical Company dumped waste from the sprawling complex near its Midland, Michigan headquarters right into the Tittabawassee and burned it in unfiltered incinerators.
Among that waste were dioxins created during the production of herbicides like the Vietnam-era Agent Orange and other chemicals which were carried downstream into the Saginaw River and Lake Huron.
Such dumping was standard industrial practice until the environmental movement -- horrified by the sight of rivers and lakes so polluted they would catch on fire -- succeeded in pressing the federal government to start regulating air, water and ground pollution in 1970.
Since then, Dow -- one of the world's biggest chemical companies with 2008 sales of 57.4 billion dollars -- has invested millions in sophisticated pollution controls which carefully manage the toxic waste it produces.
Dow estimates its total accrued liability for the Midland-area cleanup is 312 million dollars and concluded in its 2008 annual report that "the possibility is remote" that the cleanup costs will have an "adverse impact" on its balance sheet.
Yet little has been done to clean up the dioxins which spread for more than 50 miles (80 kilometers) downstream and downwind of the Midland plant.
"Dow wrote the book, they wrote the book on how to delay things," said environmental activist Michelle Hurd Riddick of the Saginaw-based Lone Tree Council who has spent years fighting for a comprehensive cleanup.
"This is a 30 year-old-issue and no one has yet to have the political will to move that company."
There are a lot of different reasons why the cleanup has taken so long.
Much of the 1980's were spent on figuring out how to prevent further pollution from the chemical complex.
Much of the 1990's were spent trying to understand the extent of the contamination.
Dow has spent much of the past decade fighting with the state of Michigan about what needs to be done about it and insisting that the dioxins do not pose a significant health risk to residents.
A series of scandals have engendered a great deal of mistrust.
A 1983 congressional investigation found that the Environmental Protection Agency allowed Dow to cut critical passages from a report so it would not conclude that Dow was responsible for the bulk of the contamination in the Tittabawassee.
The head of the state regulatory agency was accused in 2002 of covering up evidence of contamination in the area and blocking further investigations.
And just last year the regional EPA administrator accused the Bush administration of forcing her out of her job by for being too tough on Dow.
Amid pressure from the Obama administration, Dow agreed in September to accept responsibility for the contamination and get to work on a comprehensive cleanup plan under the EPA's Superfund program.
"We think that we have a really solid tool in place with this proposed settlement to really move the process forward quickly," said Wendy Carney, the regional Superfund manager who is overseeing the project.
Dow has kept its public comments on the issue to the absolute minimum.
"We're focused right now on moving this agreement forward and focused on the implementation of that agreement so we can move towards resolution," Dow spokeswoman Mary Draves told AFP.
Critics say the deal is little different from one Dow reached with the state of Michigan in 2003 which has never been fully implemented.
Even if the EPA exerts more pressure than the state, it will be several years until the actual cleanup work begins and at least a decade for it to be completed.
The issue has divided the community, said Ralph Wirtz, managing editor of the Midland Daily News.
Many here are not sure if the benefit outweighs the cost. They worry about the impact on their property values or simply don't believe the dioxins are actually that dangerous.
Others call the river a chemical soup which threatens the health of thousands of people and hampers future economic development.
The real question, Wirtz said, is "how do you go about cleaning this up, setting this straight without bankrupting an entire community?"
At a public meeting held downriver at Saginaw Valley State University, the desire to just get this over with was palpable. So was the fear of what would happen next.
Ron Thurlow, who owns a riverfront house in nearby Freeland, was worried about the cottonwood trees after seeing how Dow had stripped the banks bare at a test site.
"Some of us have concerns that the river's going to end up looking like a ditch in Kansas, no trees for as far as you can see," he told EPA officials.
"Or it's the old Vietnam analogy we had to destroy the village to save it and I hope we're not going to end up destroying this river to save it."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
News Search
Top Stories
Dubai to pay debt with $10 billion aid from Abu Dhabi
Fed likely to dampen speculation on early exit
Greece waits for its financial medicine
Nanomaterial used in cancer tests, medicine delivery
Decades-old dioxins pollute river, divide US community
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Top British banker admits 'mistakes' on bonuses
Tiger Woods' girlfriend apologizes in TV interview
'Whack A Banker' game proving a hit in Britain
Dubai stocks maintain profits after break
Fed likely to dampen speculation on early exit
More Most Viewed »
Global stocks mixed amid Dubai debt crisis
Tiny magnetic discs could kill cancer cells: study
Virgin unveils spaceship to offer space tourism
Tiger Woods' girlfriend apologizes in TV interview
Dubai blackout over debt plans to hit Gulf markets
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Monday, 14 December 2009 Israel funnels millions of dollars to settlements
Catalans vote in symbolic independence referendum
Campaign mocks treatment of Iran student leader
Leaders strike deal on Sudan democratic reforms
Berlusconi bloodied by hit to face, says he's fine
|
Supreme leader says Iran's opposition violates law
US jobless rate 'could rise further'
Greek economy minister urges immediate reforms
With Gaza cease-fire, south Israel blossoms
Israel expels Jewish seminary from army deal
|
Houston is first major US city to elect gay mayor
Iran's Khamenei issues stern warning to opposition
Iran's president pledges support to Hamas leader
PLO set to extend Abbas term as Palestinian leader
300 stuck temporarily on Disney World monorail
Turkmenistan-China pipeline to start Monday
`Princess and the Frog' hops to No. 1 with $25M
Nobel-winning economist dead at 94
NKorean weapons seizure could affect nuke talks
S Philippines grapples with crisis after crisis
Politics dominate Calif education reform effort
Turkmenistan-China gas pipeline to open Monday
Authorities: Rottweiler mauls, kills Fla. toddler
Thaksin back in Cambodia as Thai "spy" to be freed
Senator says opposition grows to Medicare buy-in
Taiwan fishermen 'fall victim to climate change'
Houston biggest US city to elect openly gay mayor
Senate to vote on $1.1 trillion spending bill
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Disney's Princess charms weekend moviegoers
|
Disney's "Princess" charms weekend moviegoers
Reggae star Buju Banton facing drug charge in Fla.
`Princess and the Frog' hops to No. 1 with $25M
Gunmen storm Afghan police post, kill 8: governor
Italian protester breaks Berlusconi's nose
|
Italy's Berlusconi in hospital after attack
2009: the Year of Twitter and Facebook
Afghan war decision toughest of presidency: Obama
Fed likely to dampen speculation on early exit
Russia cuts gas to Armenia after bomb found: report
|
Greece waits for its financial medicine
Accenture ends relationship with Tiger Woods
Afghan air strike wreaks more havoc in Germany
Nanomaterial used in cancer tests, medicine delivery
Conservative favored in Chile presidential run-off
|
Mobile phone English lessons a hit in Bangladesh
Timeline of Iranian, North Korean nuclear programs
Decades-old dioxins pollute river, divide US community
Israel votes new funding for settlements
Democracy referendum plan heats up Hong Kong politics
|
Kurds, Turkish nationalists clash in Istanbul
Low turnout in Catalan independence referendum
|
Myanmar rebels grow more opium to buy arms: report
|
Brown in Afghanistan vows new push to defeat Taliban
Iraq: No time to act after US tip before blasts
Kurds, Turkish nationalists clash in Istanbul
|
Saudi opposition petitions for vote after floods
China blocks Sun TV signal in content crackdown
|
Israel okays millions of dollars in aid to settlements
Highlights of UN resolution against NKorea
Thais extend North Korean arms cargo crew's detention
AP INVESTIGATION: Monsanto seed biz role revealed
Google to produce, sell own Nexus One phones: report
|
US mulls Predator strikes in Pakistani cities: report
Kidney donor's night-before-surgery poem
Accenture ends relationship with Tiger Woods
|
Nurses are key to matchmaking in kidney swap
Hardline Pakistani schools a draw for foreigners
Apple fires back at Nokia in patents battle
|
Avalanche fears, clouds hamper search for climbers
Cambodia frees convicted Thai spy
Lieberman resists Medicare buy-in plan
Crew of NKorean weapons plane in Thai court
Venezuela's Chavez sees U.S. 'threat' over Iran ties
Plane crew held for 12 more days over weapons haul
Obamas join stars for Christmas benefit concert
Obama: Expect no more White House gate-crashers
Woman executed in China over child prostitution
China might not take climate change funding: FT
UN: 2 UN hostages freed from Darfur
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
46 injured in pileup of about 50 cars in Conn.
Johnny Depp can't get used to winning awards
Seoul shares turn up on Dubai news; builders rise
Toyota to start selling plug-in hybrids in 2011
Mercedes-Benz sees China sales up 15 pct in 2010
Korea Hot Stocks
Confidence up at Japanese manufacturers
Obama's brother turns down film role
Pakistan
Johnny Depp can't get used to winning awards
Japan's business confidence grows: central bank
Seoul shares turn lower; KOPEC jumps on debut
History miniseries takes on the Kennedys
|
Taiwan dollar near flat in thin trade, eyes stocks
`Precious,' `Up,' `Hangover' make AFI top-10 list
Downey's Sherlock Holmes an action hero
|
S.Korea Nov ind power demand growth at 8-yr high
L.A. critics honor Iraq war movie Hurt Locker
|
Luxury travel business bounces back
NBC launching Chuck game
|
`Hurt Locker' wins LA Critics' best-picture prize
Hundreds of Indian languages struggle to survive
Big US box office kiss for Disney's 'Frog Princess'
US-TECH Summary
EU warms to Oracle-Sun deal
Detained Americans to be tried in Iran: minister
|
Insurgent foe's slaying shows cracks near Baghdad
Koalas, penguins at risk of extinction: study
Hi-tech, eco-friendly dream home takes shape in Japan
U.S. forces chief warns of Afghanistan fight
|
Gunmen kill 16 police in Afghan ambushes
Jackson, Boyle and Tiger transfix in 2009
Cadbury says rejects 'inadequate' Kraft takeover bid
Bin Laden: symbolic icon in impenetrable fortress
Dubai to pay debt with $10 billion Abu Dhabi fund
Turk PM calls for unity after Kurdish party ban
|
Pakistan seeks clues on jailed Americans
|
Iran says makes arrests over torn Khomeini picture
|
Will Ecuador drought dry up Correa's popularity?
|
Motorized bar stool from DUI case fetches $1,125
DNA map shows pandas may lack meat taste buds
Katrina recovery was test of ability to adapt
Beijing cuts broadcaster's signal amid media crackdown
EU warms to Oracle-Sun deal
|
Iran to put three US hikers on trial
Accenture ends relationship with Tiger Woods
|
Democracy "referendum" plan heats up HK politics
Boxer's opponents capitalize on 'ma'am' exchange
U.S. envoy says no timetable yet for North Korea talks
Gaps in DNA databanks have led to tragedy
NBA launches Web, mobile sites for fans in India
|
Pakistan police probe Americans in terror case
NATO: Top US defense official visits Afghanistan
Accenture marks 1st sponsor to cut ties with Woods
Protest widens against creation of new Indian state
Clinics help people represent themselves in court
Philippine troops kill one militant after jailbreak
Obama to meet with bankers, then Lebanon's leader
Cambodia frees Thai 'spy' after pardon by king
26 operations, 13 kidneys: hope to few with little
16 policemen killed in 2 attacks in Afghanistan
Korean derivative funds rebound sharply; risks eyed
Toyota aims to roll out plug-in Prius in two years
`Avatar' joins tradition of the Hollywood colossus
China unveils landmark Turkmenistan pipeline
Coal still king in China, despite climate pledge
India inflation hit 4.8 percent in November
S.Lanka set for record current account surplus
Confidence grows at Japanese manufacturers
Golden Globes nominations launch Oscars race
India's gold retailers jump on the 'brandwagon'
History miniseries takes on the Kennedys
Downey's "Sherlock Holmes" an action hero
NBC launching "Chuck" game
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights