Home
U.S.
World
Entertainment
Sports
Business
Health
Science
Technology
Politics
Offbeat
Environment
Travel
News
Articles
Iraq Urged to Lift Media Restrictions
Email
Facebook
Digg
Twitter
Buzz Up!
ShareThis
April 12, 2010 11:28 a.m. EST
Topics: freedom of the press, politics, news media, mass media, unrest, conflicts and war, arts, culture and entertainment, United States
The Media Line Staff
United States Rachelle Kliger - Media restrictions imposed by the Iraqi government have come under fire, with human rights groups calling for them to be lifted.
Human Rights Watch said the regulations should be revised to comply with international standards.
Iraq’s official Communication and Media Commission (CMC) began enforcing the regulations ahead of the parliamentary elections on March 7. The government’s stated aim was to silence broadcasters who encourage sectarian violence. But Human Rights Watch says the restrictions were unclear and susceptible to abuse.
“The main problem is that they’re extremely vague,” Joe Stork, deputy director of the Middle East and North Africa Division at Human Rights Watch told The Media Line.
“They’re ostensibly designed to allow the government to restrict broadcasting that they consider to be incitement, in particular incitement to violence. This is all well and good, but we think these restrictions should be spelled out in more detail. As it is now, it’s left pretty much to the discretion of the officials to determine what is suspicious or not.”
The government restricted media in a number of ways in the months leading up to the parliamentary elections, including denying media accreditation and suing news outlets that criticized government officials.
The main issue at hand, Stork said, was drawing the line between fair criticism and incitement to violence.
“The fact is, if the regulations are left standing as they are written, they give officials complete discretion to shut down broadcasters who would not at all be crossing that line, but may be critical of government policies. They shouldn’t be closed down for that reason alone and that’s what our concern is,” he said.
A letter sent by HRW to the CMC said the regulations suffered from several drafting defects that could inhibit their effectiveness and encroach on the freedoms of Iraq's broadcast media.
“In particular, the regulations impose inadequate licensing standards and underdeveloped content restrictions,” it said.
“Human Rights Watch's review of the regulations finds that they fall short of international standards for freedom of expression and we urge you to suspend them until necessary amendments are made.”
Stork also claimed the criteria governing the issuance of licenses were also not clear. They also failed to include criteria designed for fostering diversity and provisions for appeals were inadequate.
“The regulations give the CMC the power to cancel licenses after certain first-time minor violations of the licensing terms. Sanctions directed at broadcast media outlets should be proportionate to the offense and should be graduated in response to the repetition and number of committed offenses,” he said. According to the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ), 140 journalists have been killed in Iraq since the U.S.-led invasion in 2003 and at least 89 of those cases were defined as murder. However, the situation is improving - four journalists were killed in connection to their work in Iraq in 2009, the lowest death toll since 2003.
Analysts have attributed this reduction in the death tally to increasing participation of Sunni groups and other sectarian elements in the political process and the shift in security responsibilities from the U.S. military to Iraqi forces.
A requirement that broadcast organizations submit lists of their employees to the CMC represents “an unacceptable security threat to media workers,” HRW said.
“Journalists who wish to stay anonymous must be allowed to do so,” Stork wrote.
“Additionally, the new Iraqi parliament should take all feasible steps to stem acts of violence, intimidation and abuse aimed at muzzling members of the media who have written or broadcast information about governmental corruption or criticized government policies or officials,” he said. “The CMC should ensure that its regulations do not give Iraqi officials the authority to silence voices that speak contrary to the will of the ruling government.”
The CPJ was also critical of the new regulations and called it an “alarming return to authoritarianism.”
The organization said the regulations fell short of international standards for freedom of expression and appeared to contravene the Iraqi constitution.
“Such broad and unspecified standards are often used by repressive governments to silence critical coverage,” CPJ said.
Copyright © 2003 - 2010 AHN - All rights reserved.Redistribution, republication. syndication, rewriting or broadcast is prohibited without the prior written consent of AHN.License AHN news for your website, business, digital signage network or publication.
Most Popular Stories
Romney Wins Presidential Straw Poll By A Hair
20 People Killed In Thailand Protests
U.S. Navy Captures Six Somali Pirates
Seven Wounded In New Orleans Shooting
UFC President Dana White: Silva Fight Was a Disgrace
Report Reveals Nuclear Sub Navigator Listening To iPod During Collision With Ship
Bomb Explodes At U.S. Consulate In Mexico
Tell-All Book Claims Oprah Dumped By John Tesh In Middle Of The Night
Recent Posts
Most Popular Comments
Recent Comments
Popular Threads
Home | U.S. | World | Entertainment | Sports | Business | Health | Sci / Tech | Politics | Weird / Offbeat
Follow AHN on Twitter
AHN Social News connects you with friends and the news
Client Login | Submit News | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Contact | Content Services © 2010 AHN All Rights Reserved
Other News on Monday, 12 April 2010 Israeli groups decry army West Bank deportation rules
Europe agrees $40 bln Greece rescue deal
News
Iran's Khamenei slams Obama over 'nuclear threat'
Iraq PM's bloc says fraud may have cost it 750,000 votes
Hungary's Fidesz wins election with strong mandate
|
British campaigners threaten pope with arrest
|
Greek police arrest suspected leftist guerrillas
|
Brazil flood death toll rises to 224: officials
|
Drug gangs kill nine in Honduras as violence grows
|
Ousted Kyrgyz leader: I'm not to blame for deaths
Security blankets Washington as nuclear summit looms
Ousted Kyrgyz leader: not to blame for bloodshed
'All bets are off' if US under WMD attack: Clinton
News
Iran is not yet 'nuclear capable': US defense chief
Afghan president urges Taliban to air grievances
Thai protesters reject talks after deadly clashes
Kyrgyz leader: no guarantees for ousted ruler
News
Airstrikes kill 10 militants in NW Pakistan
Australian officials seek to protect reef
Colorado Sheriff's Deputy Tazes 30 Students; Gets Suspended
Date Night ekes out disputed box office win
|
News
Polish president's coffin returns home to Warsaw
|
News
Thai protesters gather after clashes hit markets
|
Kyrgyz interim government says to move against Bakiyev
|
Yemen says seeks cleric, yet to get U.S. intelligence
|
Pakistani forces kill up to 40 militants in Orakzai
|
NATO troops kill 4 Afghans on bus: provincial official
|
Fidesz wins Hungary election with strong mandate
|
Russia cast as nuclear security leader despite flaws
|
US-TECH Summary
Euro rises as markets back Greek rescue deal
Obama Meets India's Singh; Headley Issue Raises Controversy
China 3G standard phone sales to surge
|
Obama Cites Al Qaeda With Nuclear Weapons As Biggest Threat
Sharp to launch 3D TVs this summer
|
Google CEO: Tech silence in China spat no shock
|
Ex-Obama adviser calls on FCC to reclassify Web access: report
|
Google CEO says Apple helped AdMob deal
|
Smartphone maker Palm is seeking a buyer: report
|
News
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
News
Hollywood gripped by baby fever
|
Titans tops foreign box office again
|
Conan begins comedy tour as Fox talks drag on
|
ESPN's Allen Iverson documentary holds few surprises
|
Pop star Shakira prepares to build school in Haiti
|
News
New Zealand house prices rise in March
Top anti-racism judge shot dead in Moscow
Nine dead after landslide derails Italian train
Nine dead after Italian train derailment
Sudan extends voting for two days after delays
|
Afghan fury after US troops kill four civilians
Bomb explodes outside MI5 headquarters in Northern Ireland
|
Polish relatives seek to identify Russia crash victims
Attacks in Kandahar; NATO fires on Afghan bus
|
Moscow judge who sentenced neo-fascists shot dead
|
Greece charges six over guerrilla attacks
|
Sudanese opposition urge elections cancelled
Nine dead as landslide derails Italian train
|
Thai poll body says ruling party must be dissolved
200,000 civilians flee Pakistan military offensive
UBS reports 2.5 bln francs in quarterly pre-tax profit
Greek debt plan boosts euro, most Asian shares
Al-Qaeda would use nuclear bomb on US: Obama
China's Geely Auto 2009 net profit up 35%
China's foreign reserves hit new high
Paramount offers movies on Seagate hard drives
|
Obama to open landmark nuclear summit
Best Buy to sell Barnes & Noble's Nook e-reader
|
Bangladesh sentences 50 guards over 2009 mutiny
Kyrgyzstan's deposed president gathers supporters
Sharp to join 3D TV battle with advanced display
|
Pressure mounts on Thai PM after election body call
Global IT spending to rise
|
Afghan official says NATO gunfire kills 4 on bus
Australia refloats Barrier Reef oil spill ship
Ship that leaked oil on Great Barrier Reef removed
Australian in Bali prison applies for clemency
Thai stocks sink after deadly Bangkok clashes
Afghan official: 4 civilians killed by NATO troops
Rusal reports $821 million profit
China bank lending down 43 percent in 1st quarter
China says forex reserves hit record $2.447 trln
India's industrial output sees double-digit growth
Sharp to launch 3D televisions by summer
Iraq Urged to Lift Media Restrictions
IATA chief urges Japan to be China travel gateway
Romney Wins Presidential Straw Poll By A Hair
Mandy Moore To Check In To Greys Anatomy Finale
GM China: Sales by 2015 may exceed 3M units
Motorcyclist Flees Police, Crashes Into Ambulance Crew That Treats Him
Teen Birth Rates Down In U.S.
Researchers Say Hispanics Live In Areas With Limited Ability To Screen For Colon Cancer
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Dozens Hurt In 7-Alarm Manhattan Fire
President Obama Meets Kazak President Nazarbayev
President Obama Meets Pakistani PM Gilani, Mentions His Trip Sans Secret Service
British band Supergrass announces split
|
Tenor Domingo speaks of cancer fear ahead of return
|
Date Night ekes out disputed box office win
|
Russell Crowe drops tights for Robin Hood
|
DreamWorks rolls out Kung Fu Panda virtual world
|
Taiwan's 'Susan Boyle' voted off talent show
India hopes mud-pit wrestling can lead to gold
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Russell Crowe drops tights for "Robin Hood"
DreamWorks rolls out "Kung Fu Panda" virtual world
Hollywood gripped by baby fever
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights