Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Egypt move revives US 'kill switch' debate
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Egypt move revives US 'kill switch' debate
AFP - Monday, February 7
Send
IM Story
Print
Egypt move revives US 'kill switch' debate
Slideshow: Full Photo Coverage: Internet Portals & Search Engines
WASHINGTON (AFP) - – Egypt's five-day shutdown of the Internet has revived debate in the United States over how much authority the president should have over the Web in the event of a crisis.
Some opponents of cybersecurity legislation wending its way through the US Congress have condemned the bill as a danger to free speech and civil liberties that would equip the White House with an Internet "kill switch."
Supporters deny it would confer any such power on the president.
As Hosni Mubarak cut his 80 million people off from the Web, the US senators behind the legislation denounced the move by the Egyptian president as "totally wrong" and leapt to the defense of their bill.
"(Mubarak's) actions were clearly designed to limit internal criticisms of his government," said Joe Lieberman, an independent from Connecticut, Susan Collins, a Republican from Maine, and Tom Carper, a Democrat from Delaware.
"Our cybersecurity legislation is intended to protect the US from external cyberattacks," Lieberman, chairman of the Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee, Collins and Carper said in a joint statement.
"We would never sign on to legislation that authorized the president, or anyone else, to shut down the Internet," they said. "Emergency or no, the exercise of such broad authority would be an affront to our Constitution."
At the same time, the senators continued, "our current laws do give us reason to be concerned" and their bill, which has yet to reach the Senate floor, was designed to replace "broad and ambiguous" presidential authority with "precise and targeted" powers to be used only in a national emergency.
In June, the Electronic Frontier Foundation, American Civil Liberties Union and some two dozen other privacy, civil liberties and civil rights groups wrote a letter to Lieberman, Collins and Carper to express concern about the bill.
"Changes are needed to ensure that cybersecurity measures do not unnecessarily infringe on free speech, privacy, and other civil liberties interests," they said.
"The Internet is vital to free speech and free inquiry, and Americans rely on it every day to access and to convey information," the groups said. "It is imperative that cybersecurity legislation not erode our rights."
Taking note of the concerns, Lieberman, Collins and Carper said "we will ensure that any legislation that moves in this Congress contains explicit language prohibiting the president from doing what President Mubarak did."
"Our bill already contains protections to prevent the president from denying Americans access to the Internet -- even as it provides ample authority to ensure that those most critical services that rely on the Internet are protected," they said.
Cindy Cohn, the EFF's legal director and general counsel, said the latest version of the cybersecurity legislation was an improvement on its "draconian predecessors" but remained wary.
"The Egyptian regime's shutdown of the Internet in an attempt to preserve its political power highlights the dangers of any government having unchecked power over our Internet infrastructure," Cohn said in a blog post.
"The lesson of Egypt is that no one, not even the President of the United States, should be given the power to turn off the Internet.
"(Egypt's move) puts a fine point on the risks to democracy posed by recent Congressional proposals to give the president a broad mandate to dictate how our Internet service providers respond to cyber-emergencies," she said.
"Any proposal to give the president the ability to interfere with Internet access of Americans -- whether to address cyberattacks or for any other reason -- must be tightly circumscribed," she said.
"It must be limited to situations where there are serious and demonstrable external security threats and must be strongly checked by both Congressional and court review."
James Lewis, a cybersecurity expert at the Washington-based Center for Strategic and International Studies, said the cybersecurity bill sets the threshold for invoking the presidential powers "very, very high."
"It's not some arbitrary power to turn off the Internet," Lewis told AFP. "It's an authority consistent with other wartime authorities to act in an emergency.
"It's not an Internet kill switch," he said. "That's just insane. How do you kill a globally distributed network with millions of devices?
"The answer is you don't," Lewis continued. "But you can think about isolating certain domains or certain enterprises.
"Say a big power company gets infected," Lewis said. "You say to them 'Disconnect yourself before you infect other power companies.' It's like an avian flu quarantine for the Internet.
"It's not like Egypt where the dictator wakes up in a bad mood and does it," he said. "It would be a legitimate process. It would have to be the threshold of an act of war or a major terrorist event."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
US-TECH Summary Reuters - 52 minutes ago
Google CEO says wants to avoid long EU probe: report Reuters - 53 minutes ago
Russian faithful to get 'sacred texts' on mobiles AFP - 2 hours 56 minutes ago
Egypt move revives US 'kill switch' debate AFP - Monday, February 7
Nasdaq hit by hackers AFP - Sunday, February 6
News Search
Top Stories
Citi to call the tune on EMI future
'Inception,' 'The Social Network' win WGA awards
Four dead in fresh Tunisia unrest
Are brains shrinking to make us smarter?
Egypt ruling party executive committee resigns: TV
More Top Stories »
Related Full Coverage
Internet Portals & Search EnginesLatest development in the online world
All Full Coverage »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
US golfer Woods finds old habits hard to shake
Russia loses military satellite: reports
US auto sales jump 17 percent in January
Dow closes over 12,000 for first time since June 2008
Egypt's Mubarak to step down at September election
More Most Viewed »
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2011 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Sunday, 6 February 2011 Iraqi premier says will give up half his salary
Intellectuals join anti-Berlusconi rally
Sicily couple murdered man with butter
China's Tencent buys US Riot Games majority stake
Ahmadinejad chides parliament for sacking minister
Obama urges entrepreneurial focus on America
Two dead after Tunisian police fire at protesters
|
US, Russia launch nuclear arms reduction pact
Israel, Jordan gas cut after Egypt pipeline attack
Ivory Coast Gbagbo backers protest against African Union
|
Hitler aide Bormann 'escaped to Latin America'
Two soldiers killed in Afghanistan bombings
Music Manager Johnny Wright debuts online star search "On the Spot"
Sudan's Bashir vows freedoms and open government
|
Bruno Mars' "Grenade" edges out Pink for another week at #1 on Billboard Hot 100
Sudan shootout kills 20, army warns of more clashes
Amos Lee earns first ever #1 album on Billboard with "Mission Blues"
Saboteurs attack Egypt-Israel gas pipeline
Bombs kill 2 NATO troops in southern Afghanistan
Intellectuals lead Milan rally against Berlusconi
|
U.S. and Russia cap 'reset' in ties with START treaty
Pennetta keeps Italy in Fed Cup tie
Kazakhstan secure top place in Asiad medal table
Pakistan trio handed lengthy corruption bans
Three Pakistan cricketers banned for 5 to 10 years
Obama joins protesters in calling for Mubarak's resignation
Indian students fiasco in the U.S.: Present Imperfect, Future Indefinite
Customs searches flower imports for insects and cocaine
Conservationists seek to stop slaughter of Yellowstone bison
Verizon stops iPhone sales after supply bought out
Clorox 2Q profit down 80 percent as germ-killer demand drops post-H1N1
Arctic air visits Deep South, brings more bad weather
Gunman in custody after hijacking Greyhound bus with 34 passengers
U.S. employment figures inch up in January as Bernanke hopeful
Pamela Anderson auctions off herself at this year's SuperBash
Yemen denies cyber-attacks on Saleh website
Facebook photos swiped for dating website
WikiLeaks bares smuggling of U.S. uranium bricks in Philippines
News Corp. launches iPad-only newspaper app
Flickr staff accidentally deletes subscribers account, 4,000 photos
Israeli or Palestinian? Umm Al-Faham Residents Are Divided
U.K. immigration officer fired after putting wife's name on terror watch list
Mubarak forms new government as protesters plan bigger rally, strike
Government aims to get Egyptians back to work
Govt. mulls new tax on non-domiciles: report
Nasdaq hit by hackers
Egyptian government in talks with Muslim Brotherhood
Four dead in fresh Tunisia unrest
US-TECH Summary
Government aims to get Egyptians back to work
|
Opposition divided over Egypt's power shift plan
Are brains shrinking to make us smarter?
Two dead as Tunisian police fires on protesters
|
Egypt gas pipeline attacked, Israel, Jordan flow hit
Egypt ruling party executive committee resigns: TV
Iraq PM pledges not to seek third term
Sudan's Bashir vows freedoms and open government
|
Israel, Jordan gas cut after Egypt pipeline attack
Rival Koreas gear up for talks this week to ease tension
|
Top leadership quits Egypt ruling party
Saudi women protest, web activists call for reform
Business executives killed in Iraq plane crash
Sudan's Bashir vows freedoms and open government
Tongan ferry deaths trial moved to parliament
Rival Koreas gear up for talks this week to ease tension
'Inception,' 'The Social Network' win WGA awards
Italy cruise to Fed Cup victory over Australia
Fires and floods hammer Australia
US 'spies' go on trial in Iran
Despite China, US violin-makers second fiddle to none
Chinese vessel 'not hijacked': state media
Global minimum and maximum temperatures
'Inception,' 'The Social Network' win WGA awards
Sumo spring tournament cancelled in corruption crisis
Coal stoves coat Mongolian capital in smog
Cyclone adds to Barrier Reef's flood woes
New approach brings US homeless in from the cold
Ex-leader of brutal Japan far-left group dies: reports
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Philippines 'seriously concerned' over rebel split
Writers Guild honors "Social Network," "Inception"
Higher food prices here to stay: analysts
Internet helps museums net new art lovers
Fast-growing India facing unemployment 'bomb'
Lindsay Lohan denies jewelry theft, her lawyer says
China, Japan, S. Korea to sign investment accord
Bottle of 1773 French wine fetches record price
Famous faces lend voice to Egypt's protests
Italian maestro Muti broke jaw at Chicago rehearsal
Writers Guild honors Social Network, Inception
|
Lindsay Lohan denies jewelry theft, her lawyer says
|
Famous faces lend voice to Egypt's protests
|
Moscow police comb train stations after bomb threat
Citi to call the tune on EMI future
Two Americans deny spy charges in Iranian court
|
'Inception,' 'The Social Network' win WGA awards
Kuwait accepts interior minister resignation: report
|
Karzai to announce Afghan handover start March 21
|
Russian airport bomber named
|
U.N., West warn rushed Egypt change a risk to Mideast
|
Man tries to set himself on fire at Algeria protest
|
Indonesia mob attacks 'heretic' Muslims, kills 3
Thai and Cambodia troops clash again on disputed border
|
Cheney calls Mubarak a good friend, US ally
Iraqis demonstrate over lack of basic services
|
Renewed Thai-Cambodian border fighting: army
Religious clash in Indonesia kills up to six: report
Record lotto sales and jackpot to be set soon
Thousands of persecuted Indians illegally entering into US: Report
Where som tum gets sensational
Google CEO says wants to avoid long EU probe: report
|
Indonesia appoints noted lawyer to defend Komodo against New7Wonders
Bunnies face uncertain future as pets in Year of Rabbit
Egypt move revives US 'kill switch' debate
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights