Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Fabled Afghan province of Nuristan keeps US at bay
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Australia
China
India
Indonesia
Japan
Malaysia
Philippines
Thailand
Vietnam
Fabled Afghan province of Nuristan keeps US at bay
AFP - Thursday, March 4
Send
IM Story
Print
Fabled Afghan province of Nuristan keeps US at bay
KALAGUSH, Afghanistan (AFP) - – A region of soaring mountains, rare languages and isolated tribes, Nuristan in northeastern Afghanistan has long held a special fascination for writers and hardy travellers.
A British colonel in 1910 described it as "more impracticable than either of the poles," and in recent years the United States army has learnt that the area's formidable reputation is well-deserved.
Just 12 kilometres (7.5 miles) inside the provincial border, a convoy of US military vehicles comes to a halt on a rocky, winding track.
"It takes an act of God to get us to go further," says Captain Matthew Frye.
Any advance into Nuristan beyond the Gondalabuk bridge brings guaranteed rocket and gun attacks from insurgents who use the rugged terrain and their local knowledge to keep the US soldiers away.
The only permanent US military presence in Nuristan is now at Kalagush in the southwest corner of the province.
One US post, Camp Keating, was established in the mountains near the border with Pakistan in 2006 to disrupt insurgent safe havens and to tackle smuggling. Related article: India, Pakistan's 'proxy war' in Afghanistan
It was abandoned last October shortly after eight soldiers died when 300 militants nearly overran the camp -- though its closure was already scheduled as part of the US's "drawback" policy.
The military's bruising experience in Nuristan would have come as little surprise to the handful of Westerners who had previously ventured there.
Eric Newby's classic travel book "A Short Walk in the Hindu Kush" tells of his testing expedition to the region in 1956 when he had a chance meeting with legendary explorer and author Wilfred Thesiger.
Newby described a particular high ridge as "one of the lonely places of the earth with all the winds of Asia droning over it, where mountains seemed like the bones of the world breaking through".
Such awe-stuck sentiments are now shared by many in the US military.
They accept that it is impossible to ensure Nuristan is free of Taliban and Al-Qaeda militants, and they are implementing General Stanley McChrystal's new strategy of concentrating instead on population centres.
"It could appear to be a safe haven for the bad guys," admitted Major George Hammar, the acting commanding officer at Camp Kalagush.
"This is difficult country, with no roads, and it is back-breaking to patrol through on foot.
"Nuristani people are sceptical of outsiders. They haven't ever seen Americans, and no Westerners since they threw out the Soviets in the 1980s."
Nuristan is still celebrated for its fierce resistance to the Soviet occupation, and retains a strong identity separate from the rest of Afghanistan.
Rudyard Kipling, when looking for the ultimate remote and mysterious setting, used the region for his 1888 short story "The Man Who Would Be King," which was made into a film starring Sean Connery and Michael Caine.
Known as Kafiristan ('land of unbelievers'), it was renamed Nuristan ('land of light') when forcibly converted to Islam from paganism only in 1896.
Today, the US-led international coalition is trying -- as it is across war-torn Afghanistan -- to fund development schemes and promote local government structures in Nuristan through a Provincial Reconstruction Team (PRT).
But security is too dangerous and transport too difficult for the PRT to operate in most of the province.
Compounding their problems, several officials confirm that relations between the coalition and Nuristan's governor Jamaluddin Badar have completely broken down over allegations of corruption and months of unpaid police salaries.
"We withdraw investment in places we cannot go," said US Commander Russell McCormack, head of the PRT.
"In one month, we cancelled 3.5 million dollars in schools because we could not go to the sites to verify what was happening to the money, but I am passionate about helping the people who deserve help."
The US efforts will struggle to produce any results, according to Richard Strand, an American academic widely considered to be the world's leading expert on Nuristan culture and society.
"The Taliban frankly have taken over the eastern side," he told AFP from Arizona.
"My old Nuristani friends tell me it is real tough for people like them who don't agree with the Taliban. They are afraid to go out of their houses."
-- No easy answers in a land of myths and legends --
Strand, who lived in a village in east Nuristan in the late 1960s and has visited regularly since, is reputedly the only Westerner to have ever mastered the province's five distinct languages.
He speaks all of them to some extent and specialised in the Kamviri language of the Kom tribe, which numbers fewer than 10,000 people.
Strand also dashes one of Nuristan's most enduring legends: that its people -- some of whom have red hair and pale skin -- are descendants of Alexander the Great who conquered the region in 327 BC.
"Total bunk," Strand said, pointing out that the people now known as Nuristanis moved into the mountains several hundred years after Alexander's invasion.
"Their appearance is probably due to being an isolated strain of people who have not bred much with others," he said.
Strand's expertise in Nuristan is unique, and the US government has sought his advice in its search for a resolution to Afghanistan's turmoil.
But he says he can offer only realism, not answers.
"It's a joke, and I hate to say that because I really feel for these soldiers," he said.
"They control one stretch of road (at Kalagush) for a few miles up and down, and that's it. If they make a foray further, they get their teeth kicked in.
"The truth is that they can't get to where true Nuristanis live at all."
Strand has identified a long-term growth of Taliban and Al-Qaeda influence in the province -- which he blames on extremist Islamic leaders in Pakistan, where many Nuristanis fled during the 1979-1989 Soviet occupation.
"In the years since, a certain number of younger people were totally bamboozled by radical Pakistani mullahs," he said.
"My elderly Nuristani friends often use the term 'brain-washed'.
"I have visited these refugee camps in Pakistan where Nuristanis stayed, getting 15 hours a day of propaganda over the mosque loudspeaker telling them what rotten people we kafirs (non-believers) are."
Nuristan may be a romantic wilderness to outsiders, but it is a painful reflection of the human condition today, says Strand.
"It was never easy to live there, but it is gorgeous and I always loved the place," he said.
"Right now, their culture and society are being destroyed by the fundamentalists."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
UN envoy says it's 'time to talk' to the Taliban AP - 1 hour 55 minutes ago
Gang kidnaps British boy in Pakistan Reuters - 1 hour 58 minutes ago
Cambodia tests old rocket launchers amid tensions AP - 2 hours 16 minutes ago
Australian minister condemns attacks on Indians AP - 2 hours 36 minutes ago
Malaysia won't punish Muslims for taking Communion AP - 2 hours 55 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Greece issues bond, raises IMF appeal as strikes hit
Scientists find early dinosaur cousin
New weekly US jobless claims fall
ECB holds key rate at one percent
Europe's economic recovery stalls: EU
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Chile quake moved Earth's axis, shortened days: scientist
New weekly US jobless claims fall
Greece issues bond, raises IMF appeal as strikes hit
NASA radar finds ice on moon's north pole
ECB holds key rate at one percent
More Most Viewed »
Chile quake moved Earth's axis, shortened days: scientist
Florida killer whale to stay in park after deadly attack
DNA reveals some mystery on King Tut, raises questions
Scientists recreate Big Bang heat of 4 tln degrees C
First footage of clouded leopard captured in Borneo
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Thursday, 4 March 2010 Pennsylvania Man Admits To Running Through The Woods Shirtless Punching Trees
'Corrections Idol' Promotes Positivity, Creativity In Florida Jail
Angry Parents Allegedly Set Fire To Philippine School
Chinese University Student Says He Killed Roommate Over Snoring
Quadriplegic Accidentally Falls Into Mosh Pit At AC/DC Concert, Impales Eye
German Family Wins U.S. Asylum To Home-School Children
Madam In Eliot Spitzer Prostitution Scandal Running For Governor
Pennsylvania Man Killed By Pet Bull
Dad Beats, Binds, Gags Two Small Children
Pigs Pig Out In Plantation
"Provocative" Iran invites more sanctions
Ukraine PM Tymoshenko toppled in parliament vote
Fridges talk to washing machines at high-tech fair
Greece announces more cuts, EU welcomes steps
Spain smashes infected global computer network
Greece announces crisis budget cuts
Kagame calls for trial for accused Rwandan widow
Washington Post unveils paid news app for iPhone
Greece to make cuts of 4.8 billion euros: state TV
Skype comes to Nokia smartphones, companies say
Pope Benedict to make high-profile visit to Spain
Lenovo takes aim at mobile Internet, China market
Reluctant Pashtuns hamper Afghan recruitment drive
|
Israel silent on Dubai call for Netanyahu arrest
Arabs give Palestinian-Israeli indirect talks 'final' chance
US-TECH Summary
Kagame assures Rwanda safe after grenade blasts
|
Mobile transfers save money and lives in Somalia
Iran 'weapon traffickers' arrested in Italy
Skype comes to Nokia smartphones, companies say
US supports trade ban on tuna
Obama to launch final push for health overhaul
Microsoft COO sees gradual recovery, client caution
|
Viacom to drop Jon Stewart, Colbert Report from Hulu
|
Indonesia lawmakers back criminal probe on bailout
Ethiopia aid diverted for rebel arms in 1980s: BBC
South Korea to get 'homework' after Ivory Coast win
Australia, Japan win last Asian Cup qualifiers
Japan's prince regrets Masako can't join him on Africa trip
Obama calls for simple majority vote on healthcare
Philippines' Arroyo defends economic record
Malaysian woman meets royals over caning sentence
Three suspected Jemmah Islamiyah allies held in Philippines
China puts economy first as parliamentary season begins
US veterans return to Iwo Jima for 65th reunion
Stress on economy as China holds annual meetings
Asian newcomers take stage at Geneva Motor Show
Many nominees, new stars feed Oscar fashion frenzy
|
Naomi Campbell off the hook on assault accusation
|
Viacom to drop Jon Stewart, Colbert Report from Hulu
|
Sade leads pop chart for third week
|
India's Toonz Animation makes US push
Second gay marriage in Argentina
Slovak push to promote patriotism draws fire
Vietnam welcomes Buddha relics
Mohawks kick non-aboriginals off lands in Quebec
Spain smashes infected global computer network
30 Taliban, one Pakistani soldier killed in clash: military
British police arrest 3 for terror funding
Chile keeps shaking, rattling survivors
|
Haitian radio host honored for 'tweeting' on quake
Markets look to ECB to end easy money policies
Two killed as cruise ship hit by freak waves off Spain
Clinton fails to win over Brazil on Iran
US economy shows green shoots in winter
Suicide blasts kill 33 ahead of Iraq polls
Dutch anti-Islam leader is major winner in polls
|
Book to aid Haiti quake victims goes on sale
US, EU call for new nuclear sanctions against Iran
China says 2010 defense budget to rise 7.5 percent
|
Greece announces more cuts, EU welcomes steps
'I have nothing to explain', Chavez tells Spain
U.S. military questions Karzai's steps on corruption
|
Nortel gets U.S., Canadian court OK to sell unit
Europe seeks to outline common growth strategy
Google backs HTC in Apple patent suit
Haiti wants more information on foreign aid
|
EU envoy visits Haiti, defends lateness of trip
Spanish "botnet" potent enough to attack country: police
Chavez rejects Spanish claim of links to rebels
|
U.N.-backed mission launched against Congo rebels
|
Earthquake injures 11 in Taiwan; damage limited
|
Nobel winners push for Myanmar regime to face court
|
U.S. military questions Karzai's steps on corruption
Obama demands final vote on health care
14 suspected terrorists charged in Indonesian Aceh
Obama seeks to push healthcare to final vote
Obama: Congress must 'finish its work' on health overhaul
30 militants, 1 soldier killed in Pakistan battle
Ethiopia aid diverted for rebel arms in 1980s: BBC
Internet cafe ban call draws Chinese hacker wrath
Indonesia president to address nation on bank bailout
China's defence budget to rise 7.5 percent in 2010
Pakistan kills up to 30 militants near Afghan border
Thailand offers tourists free insurance
Pacquiao shoots for fireworks against Clottey
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
Nortel gets U.S., Canadian court OK to sell unit
|
SKorea: NKorea crossed border to hunt for defector
Size matters at Geneva Motor Show
S.Korea buys 3,000 T non-western aluminium
Movie milestone 'Avatar' eyes Oscars gold
NZ dollar slides further across the board
PAKISTAN
Toyota Prius tops Japan sales despite recall woes
Prius tops Japan February sales amid Toyota woes
Seoul shares edge up; securities firms weigh
Taiwan chip, LCD makers see no big quake damage
RPT-UPDATE 1-S.Korea bond prices rise on rumours -traders
Seoul shares open up on shipyards, autos
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
U.S. bomb expert says "Hurt Locker" stole his story
U.S. bomb expert says Hurt Locker stole his story
|
Jeff Bridges among Oscar gamblers' top picks
Movie milestone 'Avatar' eyes Oscars gold
Jeff Bridges among Oscar gamblers' top picks
|
Controversies big and small dog Oscars contenders
Israeli film Ajami gets real, aims for Oscar
|
Burt Reynolds recovering after heart surgery
|
Bullock on brink of bizarre double as Oscars loom
Israeli film "Ajami" gets real, aims for Oscar
Burt Reynolds recovering after heart surgery
Winter yet again, but designers upbeat
Many nominees, new stars feed Oscar fashion frenzy
Seven Iraqi soldiers killed as early voting starts
Far-right celebrates breakthrough in Dutch polls
Europe's economic recovery stalls: EU
Attacks kill 12 as Iraqi troops and police vote
|
Samsung unveils fridge with built-in Internet
UK resists S. Africa pressure on Zimbabwe sanctions
Egypt court orders retrial in diva murder case
Greek protestors occupy finance ministry
Israel, Palestinians set for indirect talks
Five killed in Baghdad attack as voting begins
Fabled Afghan province of Nuristan keeps US at bay
Israel, Palestinians set for indirect talks
|
Afghan army countering Taliban infiltration: spokesman
|
Attacks kill 12 as Iraqi troops and police vote
German court jails Islamists for foiled U.S. attacks
|
Early voting begins in Iraq general election
India temple stampede kills 63 people: police
|
Britain in law change bid after Israel warrant row
New woe for Vatican as usher linked to prostitution
|
Samsung unveils fridge with built-in Internet
Robbers kidnap 5 year-old British boy in Pakistan
NKorea pressures SKorea to restart joint tours
28K fake Louis Vuitton goods seized in Philippines
Pakistan PM to attend US nuclear summit
German court jails Islamists for anti-US plot
Katrina victims seek to sue greenhouse gas emitters
Thailand denies visa to Dalai Lama's sister
Facebook CEO in no rush for IPO
|
Olympus eyes 20 percent share in high-end digicam
|
US pledges to mend ties, China says
India: 63 dead, dozens injured in temple stampede
Strong earthquake hits Taiwan; 12 people injured
Afghanistan to block some Internet sites: minister
|
Morgan Stanley strikes deal to sell China bank stake: report
Pakistani stocks up; rupee firms; o/n rates down
Japan manufacturers' capital spending drops
Toyota Prius tops Japan sales for 10th month
S.Korea ex-fin min denies c.bank rumour -media
Pakistani c.bank sells 14.3 bln rupees of T-bills
Indonesia premier to address nation over bank deal
Georgia looks to bring unique cuisine to world's tables
Many nominees, new stars feed Oscar fashion frenzy
|
Cyprus Maronites battle to preserve ancestral language
"Korean Wave" is ebbing but new cultural surge expected
Burt Reynolds recovering after heart surgery
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights