Forum Views () 
Forum Replies ()  
 
 
Read more with google mobile :
U.S. senators voice doubts on Afghanistan plan
|  
 
 
 
 
	
	
		
Edition:
		
U.S.
		
		
	
	
		
			
				
					
					
						
					
				
				
					
					
						
					
				
				
					
					
						
					
				
			
		
	
	
	
		
			
				
				
			
		
	
 
	
 
	
 
 
	
		 
		
		 
		
		
		
	
	
    	
		 
		
		 
		
		
		
 
	
 
	
		
Article
    
Comments (1)
               
      
	
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
 
      
	
	
    	
		 
		
		 
		
		
		
 
	
		 
		
		 
		
		
		
	  
 
 
 
 
				
				
					
					
Most Popular
					
Most Shared
					
				 
			
			
	
               
      
		
		
		
Tired Gay succumbs to Dix in 200 meters
	03 Jul 2010 
	
Election looms for Democrats: How bad can it be?
	14 Jul 2010 
	
Iran nuclear scientist returns home from U.S.
| Video
		
	3:08am EDT 
	
CORRECTED - WRAPUP 1-BP runs crucial test on Gulf oil leak
	1:29am EDT 
	
More than 1,000 exposed to dengue in Florida: CDC
	13 Jul 2010 
	
CORRECTED - WRAPUP 1-BP runs crucial test on Gulf oil leak
	1:29am EDT 
	
Apple to hold iPhone press conference Friday
	14 Jul 2010 
	
BP runs crucial test on Gulf oil leak
| Video
		
	2:19am EDT 
	
UK Stocks -- Factors to watch on Thursday July 15
	2:05am EDT 
	
Asian stocks under pressure but China data helps
| Video
		
	3:00am EDT 
	
	
		
		
      
               
      
		
		
		
More than 1,000 exposed to dengue in Florida: CDC
	13 Jul 2010 
	
Tired Gay succumbs to Dix in 200 meters
	03 Jul 2010 
	
Russia curators plan appeal against art conviction
	13 Jul 2010 
	
US seeks homes tied to Taiwan ex-president's family
	14 Jul 2010 
	
PersonalFinance: The lure of low mortgage rates
	14 Jul 2010 
	
Analysis: P&G's Pampers leak market share
	02 Jul 2010 
	
Obama takes aim at Republicans on healthcare
	13 Jun 2010 
	
Drug war hits Mexico's richest city
	08 Jul 2010 
	
U.S. advisers say keep Glaxo's Avandia on the market
	14 Jul 2010 
	
Billboard's one-hit wonders of the decade
	09 Dec 2009 
	
	
		
		
      
	
	
	
    	
		 
		
		 
		
		
		
 
	
	
		
	
U.S. senators voice doubts on Afghanistan plan
	
     
        
            
          		
                 
            
 Digg This
            
 Tweet This
            
Share on LinkedIn
            
 Share on Facebook
            
    
               
      
 
      
               
      
	
Related News
	
		
		
Holbrooke: Afghan peace outreach to gain steam
Tue, Jul 13 2010
Karzai to ask U.N. to trim Taliban blacklist: report
Mon, Jul 12 2010
U.S. lawmakers press Afghanistan's Karzai on graft
Tue, Jul 6 2010
Afghan war at critical stage, says Petraeus
Sun, Jul 4 2010
Gen. Petraeus confirmed as new U.S. Afghan commander
Wed, Jun 30 2010
	
      
    
Related Topics
        
            
                
World »
                
Afghanistan »
                
        
    
               
      
 
      
               
      
 
                        
      
 
        
By Andrew Quinn
        
        WASHINGTON | 
        Wed Jul 14, 2010 6:05pm EDT
        
    
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The Obama administration has not done enough to explain its goals for the war in Afghanistan, including what its exit strategy will be, U.S. senators said on Wednesday.
Members of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee told Richard Holbrooke, the U.S. special representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan, that the American public needs better answers as the nine-year-old U.S.-led war shows few immediate signs of success against the resurgent Taliban.
"There are a lot of people in this country who are very confused. ... There's a real need here in my view for clarity in terms of what actually can be accomplished," Democratic Senator Jim Webb said at the committee hearing.
Holbrooke defended the administration's approach, noting that President Barack Obama's decision to send 30,000 more U.S. troops into the fight, for total troop levels approaching 100,000 this summer, was mirrored by a three-fold increase in civilian aid workers helping Afghanistan improve governance and its own security forces.
"I do not want to give an optimism/pessimism report to you ... I think there are significant elements of movement forward in many areas but I do not yet see a definitive turning point in any direction," Holbrooke said.
The sharpening U.S. debate over the Afghan war comes as Obama's Democratic Party gears up for tough congressional elections in November amid public frustration over the slow economic recovery and seemingly intractable Afghan conflict.
The United States has lost more than 1,000 soldiers in the war and casualties are mounting. More than 100 U.S. and other NATO-led troops were killed in Afghanistan in June, the bloodiest month of the war.
The Senate hearing came as Secretary of State Hillary Clinton prepares to lead a U.S. team to a conference in Kabul next week aimed at putting more detail on plans to gradually shift more responsibility to the government of President Hamid Karzai, who critics have called an unreliable partner in the fight to defeat the Taliban.
LOST CAUSE?
Committee Chairman Senator John Kerry, noting that Afghanistan last month surpassed Vietnam as the longest military campaign in U.S. history, said civilian reconstruction efforts in the south and east of the country where off to a slow start while corruption appeared to be growing.
"Many people are asking whether we have the right strategy. Some suggest this is a lost cause," Kerry, a Democrat, said in his opening statement.
"This is the time to ask hard questions about the progress we are making toward our objectives of defeating al Qaeda and bringing a measure of stability to Afghanistan."
Holbrooke noted several areas of progress such as agriculture and boosting the power grid. And he suggested Karzai's efforts to woo Taliban soldiers off the battlefield could carry the seeds of an eventual political solution to the conflict.
Republican Senator Jim DeMint joined several other senators from both political parties voicing concern over Obama's goal to begin withdrawing U.S. troops in July 2011 -- a target date DeMint said signaled the United States was not committed to victory in Afghanistan.
"The deadline is defeating us. People know we're leaving," DeMint said.
Holbrooke stressed that Obama's July 2011 target date was merely to begin withdrawals and that any reduction in forces would be dictated by the conditions on the ground.
"It's quite clear he did not say we're withdrawing in July 2011. He said we're beginning withdrawing," Holbrooke said. adding that this was key to "incentivize" the Kabul government to take charge of its own security.
"An endpoint for combat troop presence has not been decided upon," Holbrooke said, saying that the Taliban's links to al Qaeda made it a direct security threat to the United States.
"If we walk away from Afghanistan the way we did 21 years ago, the results will be similarly catastrophic," he said.
(Editing by Eric Beech)
			
World
			
Afghanistan
			
 
	 
     
    
Comments
    
See All Comments (1)  |  Post Comment
 
    
    
        
Jul 14, 2010 7:17pm EDT
        
In truth, winning in Afghanistan has a very precise meaning. No one suggests that winning will be easy, but it is achievable, as I explain in this brief post @NewsReal Blog.
http://bit.ly/bD1n2k
        JohnGuardiano
        Report As Abusive
        
 
        
 
 
        
 
    
    
 
See All Comments (1)
    
    
 
 
     
    
 
       
Add a Comment
       
       
        
     
    
*We welcome comments that advance the story directly or with relevant tangential information. We try to block comments that use offensive language or appear to be spam and review comments frequently to ensure they meet our standards. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters.
   
 
 
		
	
 
 
	
	
	
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
  
	
	
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
 
Reuters
	
Contact Us
	
Advertise With Us
	
Help
	
Journalism Handbook
	
Archive
	
Site Index
	
Video Index
	
Reader Feedback
 
	
Analyst Research
	
Mobile
	
Newsletters
	
RSS
	
Podcasts
	
Widgets
	
Your View
	
Labs
Thomson Reuters
	
Copyright
	
Disclaimer
	
Privacy
	
Professional Products
	
Professional Products Support
	
Financial Products
	
About Thomson Reuters
	
Careers
Online Products
	
Acquisitions Monthly
	
Buyouts
	
Venture Capital Journal
	
International Financing Review
	
Project Finance International
	
PEhub.com
	
PE Week
	
FindLaw
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
 
	
 
 
 
 
 
 
    
 
 
 
 
Other News on Thursday, 15 July 2010 EU says Iran talks must focus on nuclear programme  
Two more Cuban dissidents arrive in Spain: ministry  
Yamaha unveils zero-emission electric motor scooter  
Libyan Gaza-bound aid ship heads towards Egypt  
U.S. hands over prisons and prisoners to Iraq
|  
Fresh claims hit scandal-tainted French minister  
US Fed weighs new measures as recovery falters  
Nokia Siemens Networks eyes Motorola telecom: report  
Iranian scientist heads home to official welcome  
Medvedev tells Russians to stop 'everyday' bribery  
Avandia increases risk of heart problems: panel  
Crackdown fears after Chinese micro-blogs disrupted  
Bungled cases show weakness in Mexican judiciary
|  
Ailing Merkel bloc loses upper house with state vote  
U.S. hands over prisons and prisoners to Iraq  
Libyan aid ship set to dock at Egyptian port  
U.S. envoy says Uganda-type attacks hard to prevent
|  
Rapid weight loss best way to slim down: studies  
Prices soar as sanctions hit ordinary Iranians  
Indonesia to ask internet providers to block porn  
African troops parade in Paris amid rain, rights row  
Afghan attacks kill 8 US troops in 24 hours  
Kremlin says Russia losing battle on corruption
|  
Afghan gov't says OK to local defense forces  
U.S. and South Korea to stage military drills after ship sunk
|  
Nokia Siemens Networks eyes Motorola telecom: report  
Afghan attacks kill 8 US soldiers in 24 hours  
India sets up unified command to tackle Maoists
|  
EU says Iran talks must focus on nuclear programme
|  
U.S. envoy says Uganda-type attacks hard to prevent  
US, S.Korea to hold military drills after ship sunk  
'Barefoot Bandit' vows to reform his ways: attorney  
Indian FM brings 'peace message' to Pakistan: report  
Hague says new govt to build on China ties  
Hong Kong police raid developer behind record flat sale  
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary  
Bristol Palin engaged to Levi Johnston  
US author journeys from Twitter to print  
BSkyB says in talks to set up 24-hour Arabic news channel  
China accepts WTO ruling on entertainment goods  
First flight lands at showcase Delhi terminal  
Novelist reinvents Robin Hood as medieval gangster  
Thailand hikes interest rates for first time since 2008  
Britain the best place to die: global study  
Pakistani FY09/10 foreign investment falls 19.7 pct  
Polanski to film 'God of Carnage' in 2011: co-writer  
Geldof's Live Aid story to be made into a film  
Lion, wolves and bears draw the crowds at Baghdad pet shop  
Inception gives fans a movie to think about
|  
Bristol Palin engaged to Levi Johnston
|  
Movie on Joaquin Phoenix's lost year gets September debut
|  
Eminem leads pop chart for third week
|  
Reggae's Chaka Demus & Pliers sue for royalties
|  
Geldof's Live Aid story to be made into a film
|  
AT&T slams Cablevision for unfair Mad Men talks
|  
Toronto film festival opener flaunts Canadian roots
|  
Novelist reinvents Robin Hood as medieval gangster
|  
Iran nuclear scientist returns home from U.S.  
India, Pakistan open key talks in Islamabad  
Iran nuclear scientist returns home from U.S.
|  
Holbrooke paints mixed Afghan war picture  
US-TECH Summary  
N.Korea, UN Command in key talks  
New strike hits Honda parts supplier in China
|  
'Significant advances' made towards AIDS vaccine  
Israeli attack on Iran would start long war  
Apple to hold iPhone press conference Friday  
Amiable mood for N.Korea-U.N. military talks: officials
|  
'Facebook fugitive' taunts Bermuda police  
Experts urge US to restrict drug Avandia  
China faces worst floods in 12 years  
Google to scan Dutch library collection  
Hong Kong property giant 'welcomes' police probe  
EU tells Iran ready to resume nuclear talks  
U.S. senators voice doubts on Afghanistan plan
|  
'Paul the Octopus' now an iPhone app  
Pakistan and India seek to revive peace talks
|  
One dead, over 100 ill in China from malaria pills  
Afghan attacks kill 8 US troops in 24 hours  
Israeli attack on Iran would start long war: report
|  
Pakistan and India seek to revive peace talks  
Hunt for Philippine fishermen after killer typhoon  
Heavy rains in Japan kill two, three missing  
Torture victim's saga mirrors Iran's history
|  
China jet makes emergency landing after bomb scare  
N.Korea, US-led UN Command talks end: spokesman  
China faces worst floods in years
|  
Writer claims Hollywood agents stole TV show ideas  
Apple to hold iPhone press conference Friday
|  
Angelina Jolie jolts a man's world: action films  
Rivalries and economy cloud Google expectations
|  
Beekeepers add buzz to Japan urban jungle  
Abu Dhabi preserves Muslim musical heritage  
Nissan suspends output in US plants  
Willy Wizard takes on Harry Potter in U.S. court  
Formosa to restart No.1 naphtha unit in 2-3 mths  
Writer claims Hollywood agents stole TV show ideas  
Apple on the defensive as earnings approach
|  
Piers Morgan could earn $18 million at CNN  
Taiwan stocks flat; focus moves from China to earnings  
Jeff Goldblum miscast in London "Prisoner" revival  
Seoul shares slip 0.4 pct on recovery worries  
Betty White to guest star on TV's "Community"  
BoJ keeps interest rate, boosts growth forecast  
Gong, Lau to star in 'What Women Want' remake  
Taiwan sells T$40 bln bonds at 1.0110 pct yield  
China's economic growth slows in second quarter  
PAKISTAN  
S.Korea June LNG imports soar y/y; H2 growth may slow  
China's economy grows 11.1 percent in first half  
Angelina Jolie jolts a man's world: action films
|  
Piers Morgan could earn $18 million at CNN
|  
Betty White to guest star on TV's Community
|  
New Orleans Saints march off with top Espys
|  
Writer claims Hollywood agents stole TV show ideas
|  
Willy Wizard takes on Harry Potter in U.S. court
|  
Hockey Musical to open Toronto Film Fest
|  
Russia tells Iran to come clean over weapons work  
Russia has identified Estemirova's killer: Medvedev  
Facebook names India management, eyeing top spot  
BP lobbied UK over Libyan prisoner transfer case
|  
Car bomb kills six in Iraqi city of Tikrit  
Russia seeks German help to modernise economy  
JPMorgan profit leaps nearly 80%  
Tokyo trials digital billboards that scan passers-by  
Medvedev eyes German help to modernise Russia economy  
Philadelphia sign NBA number two draft pick Turner  
China's online population jumps to 420 mln  
Fresh unrest flares in N.Ireland  
British major killed in Afghan attack: ministry  
New car sales fall for third month in Europe  
Google Earth map showing temperature rises unveiled  
Afghan health team abducted; local official killed  
U.S. hands over last Iraq jail but keeps 200 inmates
|  
5 Afghan health workers kidnapped in Afghanistan  
Karzai approves plan for new Afghan police force
|  
5 Afghan health workers kidnapped in Kandahar  
Vatican toughens rules on sexual abuse of children
|  
Malaysia makes 1st military Afghanistan deployment  
Argentina approves landmark gay marriage bill
|  
Sudan expels two aid workers
|  
Five killed in suicide bombing in NW Pakistan
|  
Suicide attack kills five in Pakistan's Swat valley  
'Abducted' scientist arrives back in Iran  
Five killed in suicide bombing in NW Pakistan  
'Abducted' Iran nuclear expert arrives in Tehran  
Vaseline skin-whitening Facebook app sparks debtae  
Amiable mood for North Korea-U.N. military talks  
Bomb attack kills 2 in Pakistan's Swat valley: police  
U.S. senators voice doubts on Afghanistan plan  
BSkyB in talks over 24-hour Arabic news channel  
Myanmar dissident takes struggle to ballot box  
'Democratised web' helps Malaysian's life quality  
"Hockey Musical" to open Toronto Film Fest  
North Korea's health system seen in dire state  
Amazon accused of infringing patents with Kindle
|  
Wild tiger kills man in Indonesia's Aceh  
Pakistan's forex reserves ease to $16.63 bln  
China to keep managed floating exchange rate regime  
China may shut websites with pornographic writing
|  
Pakistani stocks fall on profit selling; rupee eases  
Seoul shares slip 0.4 pct on recovery worries  
Japan's NTT to buy S.Africa IT firm Dimension Data  
China merges steelmakers to create top 10 producer  
Spies uncloaked in new film and no, it's not Salt
|  
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro  
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found  
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever  
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production  
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time  
AMD to Start Production of piledriver  
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs  
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia  
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air  
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch  
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent  
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up  
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform  
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis  
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets  
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights